HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

susan_hall

129 karma · joined December 22, 2014

submissionscomments
susan_hall··on When Will New York City Sink?
A lot of the articles that focus on rising oceans, and how they might effect the USA, seem to confuse the general issue of global warming with the specific issue of Florida. The situation in Florida might be hopeless, but why should that effect how we talk about other USA urban centers? This article is an example. It talks about New York as if the situation in New York is as hopeless as the situation in Florida.

It's important to remember that much of the USA coastline can be defended the same way that the Dutch defend their coastline: build a lot of dykes around any urban area that is of high value. This strategy would work just fine for much of the northern eastern coast of the USA.

The big exception is Florida. Because much of southern Florida sits on porous limestone, it is useless to build dykes for Florida. The ocean would simply go under the dyke. Figuring out how we might save Florida is a very difficult issue, and it might be impossible.

But figuring out how to save New York is straight forward. The techniques that the Dutch developed 500 years ago would work just fine for New York today. Yes, it would be very expensive, but the payments can be stretched out over 100 years -- the projects can be implemented gradually, as the oceans rise gradually. A staggering $1 trillion price tag is a trivial $10 billion a year, over 100 years.

One could reasonably argue that we can't build a dyke for the whole east coast. That is probably true. Some farmland will be sacrificed, some fishing villages will be sacrificed. But can we build enough dykes to protect New York? Obviously. If the Dutch could do this in the 1500s, why can't we do it now?

susan_hall··on A Design Defect Is Breaking iPhone 6 Pluses
You might be interested in a book called The European Revenge, written in 1973 by two writers from the Economist magazine. It made the argument that some day in the near future, European auto makers, such as Mercedes Benz and BMW, would be able to make automobiles that were as good as American automobiles.

And they were correct. Mercedes Benz and BMW did eventually catch up to the Americans. Nowadays, many people would argue that Mercedes Benz and BMW represent a level of quality that is much higher than what you can get from American automobiles.

If Europe hasn't yet caught up to the USA in consumer electronics, perhaps that is because Europe hasn't yet made the concerted effort to catch up.

susan_hall··on For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan
About this:

"Certain Manhattan neighborhoods (I live in one on the Upper West Side) have already achieved NORC (“naturally occurring retirement community”) status."

I also live on the Upper West Side. What surprises me is that everyone my building appears to be under 40, certainly everyone is under 50. It reminds me of when I lived in Brooklyn. But I expected it in Brooklyn. I didn't expect such a youthful building on the Upper West Side.

susan_hall··on The Idle Army: America’s Unworking Men
This is an interesting opening, coming from the Wall Street Journal:

"Millions of young males have left the workforce and civic life. Full employment? The U.S. isn’t even close."

If the USA is not close to full employment, then the USA does not have to work about inflation. And yet, in other commentary, the Wall Street Journal has been obsessed with the risk of inflation, for many years now. They have urged the Fed to raise rates to head off a surge in inflation. But if there is hidden unemployment, then rates can remain low longer, with little risk of inflation.

susan_hall··on When to Avoid JSONB in a PostgreSQL Schema
Space constraints can be a big problem with column keys, at sufficient scale.

Traditional SQL database have column names that are stored separately from the table data, but in JSON, the keys are in the data.

I've worked with MongoDB systems that held 100 terabytes of data. At that scale, we had to re-write all of the keys so they were only a single character. When JSON is small, it is pleasant to have keys that make sense, such as:

username : mary

but as JSON gets big, this needs to change to:

u : mary

If you have 10 million records, the difference (in this trivial example) is 70 million characters, and if you have 100 different collections with an average of 20 keys each, then you are talking about 140 billion characters saved.

Most of the companies that I know, if they work with JSON document stores at scale (such as MongoDB) eventually take steps to make the keys smaller.

susan_hall··on The king of smokers
Thank you for explaining why tobacco has such a powerful effect.
susan_hall··on The king of smokers
A dear friend of mine quit smoking, cold-turkey, and she went completely berserk for 3 months, with dangerous mood swings and outbursts of violence. She had previously suffered a mild depression, which now emerged as some kind of dark nightmare of rage and guilt and hatred and also self-hatred.

This is what struck me: of all the SSRIs she'd had ever tried, none had ever worked as well as tobacco. Tobacco moderated her depression and mood swings more effectively than any modern drug that her doctors had prescribed for her.

So I when I read this passage, what strikes me is how much truth there is still in this, even in the year 2016:

"its virtues rarely get a hearing, and yet the latter are many and great. To quiet nervous rest; to soothe a ruffled temper; to favour calm and partial thought; to steady and clear (not to cloud) a confused, overworked brain; "

susan_hall··on Don't Read the Comments
And it marks Sam Altman as living in the past. In terms of "why are comments mean?" we had that debate more than 10 years ago:

https://signalvnoise.com/posts/171-why-do-blog-comments-seem...

This seems to fit into the pattern where those who lead the transformation of people's social lives also seem to completely misunderstand that transformation. I'm thinking in particular of Mena Trott:

--------------------

"Trott has an interesting golden rule that she would like to see bloggers adopt. “If you aren’t going to say something directly to someone’s face, than don’t use online as an opportunity to say it,” she says. “It is this sense of bravery that people get when they are anonymous that gives the blogosphere a bad reputation.” "

susan_hall··on Companies Rethink Across-the-Board Pay Raises
"For most of us, yearly pay raises are a fixture of corporate life"

Was this article written in 1955 and then accidentally drawn out of the archives and posted in 2016? The annual pay raise died a few decades ago. There were countless articles about it. You can go back and re-read early issues of FastCompany, from the 1990s, where they talk about "you" the worker needs to make themselves essential to the company, because annual raises are dead and only real promotions bring real money any more.

And of course, at some point there emerged in the USA the odd habit of top managers, such that to get a pay increase an employee needs to quit and go elsewhere, or at least has to get a real offer from somewhere else, and only then will "your" company give you a pay increase, to match that competing offer.

susan_hall··on Fixing JSON
Dave Winer's remark from 2006 offers some historical perspective:

"I've been hearing, off in the distance, about something called JSON, that proposes to solve a problem that was neatly solved by XML-RPC in 1998, the encoding of arrays and structs in a format that could easily be processed by all programming languages. The advantage being that you could easily support the protocol in any language that supported XML and HTTP, which, at the time, was quickly becoming all languages."

http://scripting.com/2006/12/20.html

Then there was someone, much younger than Dave Winer, who wrote a response to this (during 2006), and who said (paraphrase) "When I'm older, I look forward to my XML moment; my horror at something that the young kids are doing."

I wish I could find that second quote, but I worry it is lost in the mists of time.

susan_hall··on This Is Your Life in Silicon Valley
I admire the fact that the author was able to add a humorous twist to almost every paragraph. However, to get the humor they indulge in a bit of exaggeration. That's fine, I have no problem with parody. I would find this style revolting if the article was longer, or if this was a book, but as a short blog post it reads fine.

I am curious if the emphasis on status symbols was meant to be so exaggerated? The first joke was funny, but there were several on the same theme. By the time he got home and was thinking about watching stuff on Netflix, only because other people were talking about it... by that point, either the joke is over-used, or if it's meant to represent "real life" then it is just sad.

susan_hall··on The Magic Bureaucrat and His Riverside Miracle
I am hoping the slow expansion of Social Security and Disability will eventually bring Universal Basic Income to the USA. This is the only likely route for the USA to get UBI, since the political forces opposing UBI are very strong. But if we can push to expand the definition of "disability" and if we can lower the age of Social Security, then eventually we can get close to something like UBI. And hopefully, once we've passed some critical threshold (which might be 30% of the population or 50% or 80% or some other number) then the public will see the need to reorganize the way these programs are run, and hopefully when that reform is enacted, we will get a real UBI, implemented in a clear and concise way.
susan_hall··on Notes on Distributed Systems for Young Bloods (2013)
On dealing with backpressure, I would recommend what Zach Tellman writes about in his video "Everything will flow":

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1bNOO3xxMc0

Tellman also tells his own adventure about a system something like this:

"a system that would latch up into an overload state because in overload it would log errors at a severity high enough to force the log file to be flushed on every line"

He talks about some problems he faced when writing to Amazon S3, when S3 stopped accepting requests. It's a fascinating talk.

susan_hall··on Notes on Distributed Systems for Young Bloods (2013)
Agreed. Anyone who wants to read some intelligent thoughts about the advantages of the Tandem system should read what Joe Armstrong wrote about it, in his own work developing Erlang:

http://erlang.org/download/armstrong_thesis_2003.pdf

susan_hall··on We’re in a Low-Growth World. How Did We Get Here?
I think "TV" is a stand-in for "watching TV". That is a common sense reading. And what do you watch on TV? Your statement is correct if you only watch broadcasts, but that is only 9% of the USA public. Almost 90% of USA households have cable. The cable is a monthly fee. That changes the economics that you suggested.

In the UK, the economics are slightly different, but recall that UK taxpayers pay a fee to the BBC.

susan_hall··on We’re in a Low-Growth World. How Did We Get Here?
This idea has been disproven hundreds of times. It is a zombie idea -- no matter how many times it is killed, it just keeps shambling along.

Also, the context here was helicopter money -- sending money to people, not banks.

susan_hall··on Volapük: A Cautionary Tale for Language Communities
This is certainly relevant for Lisp programmers:

"Contrarily, major schisms or breakdowns in the relationships and development of a language and its community are big warning signs that should make you think twice about the future of a language."

Related reading includes "The Lisp Curse":

http://www.winestockwebdesign.com/Essays/Lisp_Curse.html

And note that "Why Lisp Did Not and Never Will Gain Enough Traction" offers this alternative explanation:

"Since there is so little pre choice, the glue that is supposed to hold a community together is too weak to draw enough people that would build up a momentum."

http://kresimirbojcic.com/2012/08/14/why-lisp-did-not-and-ne...

susan_hall··on We’re in a Low-Growth World. How Did We Get Here?
jganetsk had already answered your question, you simply have to read what they wrote. Anticipating a question like "What insentive do they have to keep costs low?" they answered before you wrote, when they wrote: "And if you manage to hand people free money and yet the economy STILL doesn't grow, and inflation STILL doesn't rear it's head -- guess what? That's a GOOD thing."

Put differently, the government should print money until inflation appears. This is what Keynesian economists have been recommending since 2008, yet most Western governments went in the opposite direction and engaged in long bouts of austerity.

susan_hall··on Questions to Ask Before You Join a Startup
This is actually more an aspiration than a reality of startup life:

" Grownups do the difficult thing when it’s the right thing to do, with composure. This means giving peers and employees critical feedback. It means saying the unpopular things about your startup’s product or service offering and assuming responsibility for failures. It means being really honest about the strengths and weaknesses in the management team. This strength comes from surviving and overcoming difficult circumstances. Grownups can do this over and over without losing credibility or support of the team."

But I agree that I tend to find more of this kind of honesty in small startups than in big companies, and for this reason I prefer to work with startups.

susan_hall··on Not Saying Winter Is Coming, but Where’s Your Coat?
I have faced something similar. Though I have 14 years experience with technologies that are suppose to be in demand (Ruby On Rails, NodeJS) I have had a very difficult time finding work this year. It's certainly more difficult now than in 2012 or 2013.
susan_hall··on Just Deserts
I'd also recommend "Lucky Or Smart?" from Bo Peabody, who built Tripod in the mid 90s, one of the early successful web startups of the 90s.

https://www.amazon.com/Lucky-Smart-Fifty-First-Time-Entrepre...

susan_hall··on I Accidentally Some Machine Learning – My Story of a Month of Learning Elixir
All your base are belong to us.

Sometimes typos lead to memes.

susan_hall··on Visiting physician sheds new light on Lyme disease
There are certain bacteria that are known to require many years of antibiotics to resolve:

1.) tuberculosis

2.) Leprosy (Mycobacterium leprae)

For both of these it is normal to take antibiotics for many, many years.

Also, less seriously, ordinary acne is often treated with antibiotics for years. My sister took antibiotics for 5 years to deal with her acne.

It is possible that there is a tick borne bacteria that also falls into this category. Some of the stories of long-term Lyme would suggest this.

The 2 days of antibiotics for "prophylactic" protection makes sense only if the goal is to create antibiotic-resistant bacteria. 2 days of a relatively weak antibiotics is pure anti-science. She makes a good point here:

"She also said the two-day course of doxycycline, often prescribed for people who find a tick embedded on their body, has little or no prophylactic value."

susan_hall··on Ask HN: What's going on at IBM?
It's always been controversial whether a company should be allowed to invest in new fields. Over the last 100 years a few people have even made the argument that it is illegal for a company to invest in a new fields. There were some lawsuits about this in the 20th Century, though the courts always sided with the corporations.

Still, the argument is interesting to consider. Suppose it is 1995 and Microsoft it at the peak of its power, so you invest in Microsoft stock. Then 14 years go by. Now it is 2009. Google is rising in power. You want to get your money out of Microsoft, so you can invest it in Google. Does Microsoft have a legal obligation to give you all that it can? Or can Microsoft create Bing? Microsoft then creates Bing and loses more than $1 billion on it. You feel frustrated. Microsoft could have given that money to its shareholders, so you would have more money to invest in Google. But instead the money was wasted on Bing.

On the more general level, the question is, when one industry is in decline, and another industry is rising, who is responsible for shifting capital from the dying industry to the growing industry? Should individual investors do it, or should corporations do it?

You could argue that IBM is following the philosophy that all money should be given to the shareholders, so that the shareholders can reinvest the money wherever they feel best.

susan_hall··on Mistakes Reviewers Make
This part reminds of some of the job interviews I've gone to, as a software developer:

"Detail-oriented: New researchers are often immersed in the minutiae of research, such as building software, collecting data, and running experiments. This means that they tend to focus on details (which may or may not be significant) rather than the bigger picture."

I am in my 40s, yet when I go to a job interview I am often interviewed by people in their 20s. I have 20 years experience with dozens of technologies. And yet, just recently, I found myself facing a long list of questions about the details of specific technologies, for instance, NodeJS. While I may not know the details about NodeJS, I had no trouble learning Struts and then Spring and then Ruby On Rails. Is there any reason to think I can't pick up the details of NodeJS? I have done one major project with Node, is it really crucial that I know all the latest packages before I get a job at your company?

In these interviews I am often surprised by the focus on very specific aspects of particular technologies. Who really cares? We all need to learn some new technologies for any job, even if it is just the specifics of the software that the company has built.

I am often surprised at the extent to which my 20 years of experience is discounted. However, I run into this less often when I am interviewed by someone who is in their 30s or 40s or 50s -- they seem more willing to recognize that I've had a long career and I've learned a lot of tech.

susan_hall··on Is sound gradual typing dead?
This sentence deserves to be examined for alternatives:

"To make all this work, you have to insert runtime checks between the typed and untyped portions of the program."

That makes it sounds as if there are 2 choices:

1.) insert runtime checks

2.) don't insert runtime checks

I'll point out that many platforms (in particular, the JVM) allow us to pursue a 3rd option:

3.) insert runtime checks in development and whenever you are debugging, but strip them out when you are in production and things are going well

You can fill your code pre and post assertions on functions. These slow your software but they give you most of the benefits of gradual typing. You can run your code with these assertions whenever you need to debug. But if you ever want a speed boost, and you feel like your software is stable and bug-free, then you can simply pass a flag to the JVM compiler, and it will strip out the assertions for you.

susan_hall··on GitHub is undergoing a full-blown overhaul as execs and employees depart
Regarding diversity issues, it is interesting to go back and look at this interview with John Lennon and Yoko Ono, from 1972. What I find worrisome is that the conversation is still being discussed in 2016. For all the progress in technology, there are some social issues that change only very slowly.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S5lMxWWK218

What has changed is that some corporations now have formal programs in place to try to make progress on diversity issues. But the resistance to progress on this issue is remarkable.

susan_hall··on GitHub is undergoing a full-blown overhaul as execs and employees depart
Way back in 2005, Shelley Powers made the argument that a diverse workforce helped a company deal with crisis. The inverse was also implied, that a rejection of diversity was an indicator of some kind of resistance, which would make it difficult to deal with crisis.

Powers wrote:

"When jobs are plentiful, diversification within the job pool is not seen as a threat. In fact, diversification can be seen as a way of extending one’s power over a larger base of people. Book companies see more people buying books, conference organizers hope for more butts in seats, industries have less stressed and healthier, happier workers. However, when jobs are threatened, any change in the status quo will be seen as a risk–even those in an industry populated by people who consider themselves free of bias. It is a natural inclination to want to pull in, like the turtle into its shell, when threatened. Except in the tech industry, this ‘pulling in’ materializes as a resistance to difference."

http://weblog.burningbird.net/archives/2005/07/19/when-we-ar...

My interpretation of this is that the problems that Github has had with diversity in its teams was a leading indicator of the wider management problems that we now see.

susan_hall··on LinkedIn shares drop 40%, erasing $10B of company's value
For me, this is the most surprising missed opportunity:

"posting original stuff to groups with thousands of members and not receiving a single comment or click to some link"

LinkedIn had the chance to build some amazing forums. LinkedIn should be the place that you think about when you want to have a conversation about business. They clearly have the traffic. They could have done something amazing with their groups and discussions. They have wasted all of their chances.

susan_hall··on Google, Microsoft, Stall Points, and Growth
That is a good point. History is going to remember Ballmer as one of the worst CEOs in history, though, unlike Jeffrey Skilling or Bernard Ebbers, Ballmer will be remembered for mistakes of omission rather than commission. And the revival of Microsoft should be factored in to a full understanding of the situation.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →