HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

suthakamal

130 karma · joined September 17, 2009

submissionscomments
suthakamal··on Revisiting Minsky's Society of Mind in 2025
Rich Sutton's views are far less interesting than Minsky's IMO.
suthakamal··on Revisiting Minsky's Society of Mind in 2025
agree. A lot has changed in the last 20 years, which makes SoM much more applicable. I would've agreed in 2004 (and say as much in the essay).
suthakamal··on Revisiting Minsky's Society of Mind in 2025
I pretty clearly articulate the opposite. What's your evidence to support your claim?
suthakamal··on Revisiting Minsky's Society of Mind in 2025
I don't think we're talking about the same book. Society of Mind is definitely not an in-the weeds book that digs into things like lisp, etc. in any detail. Instead of changing your mind, I'd encourage you to re-read Minsky's book if you found my essay compelling, and ignore it if not.
suthakamal··on Revisiting Minsky's Society of Mind in 2025
amazing find. thank you for sharing this!
suthakamal··on Revisiting Minsky's Society of Mind in 2025
As a teen in the '90s, I dismissed Marvin Minsky’s 1986 classic, The Society of Mind, as outdated. But decades later, as monolithic large language models reach their limits, Minsky’s vision—intelligence emerging from modular "agents"—seems strikingly prescient. Today’s Mixture-of-Experts models, multi-agent architectures, and internal oversight mechanisms are effectively operationalizing his insights, reshaping how we think about building robust, scalable, and aligned AI systems.
suthakamal··on CLEAR led a flyer carrying ammo under a false name to TSA, sparking probe
The benefit is being able to leave your ID in your pocket/bag. It is not to be able to travel without ID. You are describing an edge case, not a reason a frequent traveller would opt to purchase Clear. (Fwiw, I understand this edge case, I’ve flown to Canada from the US w/o a passport because I could show the gate agents my Nexus card, but this is not a feature of having Nexus. The same logic holds for Clear.)
suthakamal··on CLEAR led a flyer carrying ammo under a false name to TSA, sparking probe
The author suggests that the program is sold on the basis of not requiring ID. This is untrue.
suthakamal··on CLEAR led a flyer carrying ammo under a false name to TSA, sparking probe
The author of this doesn’t fly much, and probably isn’t actually a clear member. Nobody who pays for clear uses it because they don’t want to show ID: any frequent traveller has ID (probably a Real ID, too) and uses Clear to jump to the front of the PRE line. Also, and frequent traveller probably encounters non-Clear airports so has yet another reason to ensure they’ve got ID.

As for one of the more bizarre comments here: No minorities are signing up for clear to skip TSA, it doesn’t do that… it merely puts you at the front of the TSA line.

This just seems like a rebel-without-a-clue ranting about … something?

suthakamal··on Bilingualism affords no general cognitive advantages: Study
Troglodyte research done at… lol… Western.
suthakamal··on Bilingualism affords no general cognitive advantages: Study
lol
suthakamal··on Standard Notes
Apps that advertise “good place to store your racy photos” without front-and centre profiles of their executives?

Seems like a ridiculous security risk.

suthakamal··on AI could end foreign-language subtitles
An idea only a single-language speaker could love.
suthakamal··on Apple sues NSO Group to curb the abuse of state-sponsored spyware
I think the most important part of this announcement (I cried genuine tears of joy when I read it) is that Apple is committing to give Citizen Lab whatever they need. That kind of internal access to Apple's people and infrastructure is tremendous.

I've never heard anyone but a despot (or vendor to despots) claim anything untoward about Citizen Lab, it sure seems like they're genuine "good" folks. They do great work, and they'll do better with support and access. The announcement makes it sound like Apple is willing to offer similar support to other good actors. I imagine Apple putting the word out will yield a few more.

It raises - again - the question of what we expect from big companies vs governments, and questions of sovereignty. Where's the line between supporting good work and cyber vigilantes (if it's not a thing today, it will be, and what will society's place be with respect to them)?

suthakamal··on New Relic to open-source Pixie’s eBPF observability platform
How helpful is this to some/any of hybrid/multi-cloud and serverless? Analysing most of the telemetry at the edge seems like it could be helpful there. Useful for instrumenting low-latency edge applications?
suthakamal··on New Relic to open-source Pixie’s eBPF observability platform
hadn't thought of this like DTrace. Thx for that!
suthakamal··on Internet mob justice can easily destroy innocent lives (2019)
One set of anecdotes after another. Easy to understand why PG acolytes might enjoy this piece.
suthakamal··on Response to Tim Bray's Departure
Gross.

The lack of empathy or recognition of the terrible conditions warehouse workers have complained of (and have been well documented by journalists) is pretty striking.

suthakamal··on Vitamin D Insufficiency is Prevalent in Severe Covid-19
Lots (most) people of colour are below their threshold of "VDI" (vitamin D insufficiency) and perfectly healthy.

The fact that the study doesn't talk about base rates for ethnicities is pretty "striking" (to use a word they breathlessly, and wrongly, use).

suthakamal··on Was there PTSD in the ancient or medieval world?
The mechanisation of war changed the very nature of war. In the first world war, row upon row upon row of men got off of landing boats, to be mowed down, row after row, by machine gun fire. It's not comparable to hundreds of soldiers going in to armed combat.

In earlier times, having a calvary was a strategic, forceful asset. It was, right up until mechanised warfare. Suddenly, there was no utility to a calvary.

It's impossible to talk about the human consequences of war without understanding how very different war was to a Roman soldier vs an American in Vietnam, or today's asymmetric battlefield.

suthakamal··on A Coronavirus Vaccine Is Coming, and It Will Work
What's the actual evidence presented here? He explains the problem space and technology, but that's not the same as evidence that we're certain a vaccine will work for SARS-CoV-2
suthakamal··on France and Germany Agree to Block Facebook's Libra
You speak as though corporations and democratic governments are the same thing. The government is (at least notionally) the will of the people. A corporation is unaccountable to anyone but it’s shareholders. It is folly to treat EU legislators the same as Zuck et al.
suthakamal··on Death Row – Last words of every Texas inmate executed since 1982
What a disgusting, morally bankrupt society that permits the state to take a life. And then to censor statements? Damn. Nobody is claiming these were good human beings, but disgust isn't nearly strong enough a word.
suthakamal··on Safe – EncFS-compatible encrypted filesystem for Windows and Mac
Not sure why Safe forcibly disables hibernation on Mac's with FileVault2: it encrypts the hibernated (is that a word) version of memory stored to disk.
suthakamal··on Immigration Issues for a Canadian working for Microsoft
One tip to make life easier after obtaining a visa to work in the US : Apply for Nexus as soon as you can.
suthakamal··on Go native, HTML5 is going to lag for a while
(I wrote the original article.)

These frameworks typically just allow you to wrap native methods with JavaScript... so you're not really writing to a single cross-platform code base. Morever, if you can build your app entirely in the HTML/JS/CSS side of things, you're golden... as soon as you start to bridge between the Native and JS layers, things get messy (and often very slow).

suthakamal··on Go native, HTML5 is going to lag for a while
(I wrote the original article.)

You're absolutely right about open platforms and protocols being about lots of people taking risks and building hugely valuable things. My point was that when the core OS is innovating like mad, you need to be close to those OS's to build the best apps... The innovation on the desktop slowed to a crawl years ago, and the majority of innovation has moved to the browser and web-app layer. In mobile, however, there's a LOT of innovation still happening right at the OS level w/ Android and iOS, and so all the frameworks that exist above the native SDK's are going to lag, and not take best advantage of the innovations being released at the OS layer.

The speed of mobile OS innovation will invariably slow (like it did on the desktop), but until then, philosophy about open platforms aside, iOS and Android show no signs of being displaced as the real mobile OS / platform drivers... and so, native's going to lead HTML5 / other "open" platforms for a while.

suthakamal··on Go native, HTML5 is going to lag for a while
(I wrote the original blog post.)

You're right that things like PhoneGap give access to native features. However, the Native-API-implementations in these frameworks are 1) typically significantly behind the native OS (release date) 2) tend to have less-than-feature-parity

So, often you're stuck writing your own native bridge, or tweaking the portability framework's version, which is time wasted (IMO) vs writing to the native framework. As an example, just try and write a PhoneGap app using Bluetooth: The Android implementation is incomplete, and the iOS version is non-existent.

Also, there are a tonne of performance issues you run into with the HTML/CSS/JS + Framework + Native solutions. As a thought experiment, consider how you'd build Instagram in one of these frameworks.

1) Image filters in HTML/CSS/JS land? Slow. 2) Thousands of images in a continuous virtual scrolling window in HTML land? Slow. 3) Fetching a binary blob (the image) from the OS, and throwing the resulting blob back-and-forth to web-land (for example, to use HTML5 offline storage) ... hellish slow.

Compare that to native... it's just one example of where the theory of HTML for UI and native for logic breaks down when you start to push the platform a little outside it's comfort zone.

suthakamal··on Nokia appoints Stephen Elop (President of Microsoft MBD) to President and CEO
UI: MeeGo is their first UI that doesn't have massive echo's of Symbian in it... and while it looks clean-ish, it's not necessarily any improvement over Android, which already has years of improvements, and 3rd party UI goodness (i.e. HTC Sense) built atop it.

Developer platforms: Nokia's owned QT for a while... what did they do? Nothing. Nokia had the WebKit WebRunTime years ago... what came of that? Nothing. Nokia actually enforced arcane third-party code signing/testing for apps on Symbian... who builds a developer platform and thinks that's a reasonable idea?

Ovi Store: Whereas RIM also does carrier-integrated billing for BlackBerry App World, RIM provides the developer with a consistent 70/30 split on app sales, and consistent payment intervals. With Nokia? Your split varies WILDLY from operator to operator, potentially being 35% of gross app price or lower on some operators, and you get paid depending on when those operators decide to remit payment. So, even with the most carrier relationships on earth, Nokia can't even do a decent job getting developers paid.

So, Nokia hasn't got an especially sexy UI w/ Meego, they've not got a great developer tools story (indeed with WRT and QT they have a history of screwing up even when they have a technology advantage), and they understand so little of the app developer needs that they can't even build a billing solution that competes with what RIM have built with App World.

suthakamal··on Nokia appoints Stephen Elop (President of Microsoft MBD) to President and CEO
Nokia's problem is that they don't understand: - Developer platforms - User experience - Levers to create an app ecosystem

Picking the guy who ran MSFT's business prodcuts division might help them compete with RIM in the enterprise, but it doesn't help them: - Sort out the Meego/Symbian mess, much less make it competitive with iOS/Xcode or Android

- Build the next-gen OS into something slick and sexy, instead of S60 reskinned time and time again

- Develop the kinds of tools, infrastructure and incentive Nokia needs to win developers.

All in all, I'm sure Stephen is a super smart guy, but he's not proven to have the domain expertise to solve Nokia's most pressing problems... which suggests that Nokia doesn't fully understand what their deepest problems are, meaning they really are finished.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →