HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

svieira

1,903 karma · joined August 24, 2010

Outline of the man: * Catholic, Virginian.

Outline of the programmer: * Python, JavaScript, Scala, C#, Java.

Ad Jesum per Mariam

submissionscomments
svieira··on Show HN: Tired of logic in useEffect, I built a class-based React state manager
Is this because Elm forces you to separate the model computations from the view computations, which then lets you compose the model shape in one place and the view shape in the other, or some other property of the framework that I'm not aware of?
svieira··on Medieval Monks Wrote over Ancient Star Catalog – Particle Accel Reveals Original
This was in 2006 - digging around, I find things like https://go.gale.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE%7CA452289555&sid=googleS...

> Abstract:

> Several Italian judges, including the members of the Supreme Court, have defined begging with children as a "Roma cultural practice". In response, the Italian Parliament enacted law no. 94/2009, which severely represses the practice. The article contests that begging is a Roma cultural practice and claims, instead, that it is an economic practice which may sometimes connect to other elements of Roma culture. The article critiques both the cultural argument put forward by Italian judges, and Italian law no. 94/2009, neither of which serves to defend the rights of Roma children. It concludes by suggesting a different kind of legal approach to child begging, more respectful of the constitutional duty of solidarity and protection of the family, and based on social policies rather then criminal repression.

and references to Article 669-bis C.P. talking about this 2018 law "re-introducing" limits to begging, so I suspect that the "impersonating a gypsy" bit was a mis-understanding and it was really "impersonating a person in need".

> If I’m wrong, a sum that doesn’t matter to me was grifted.

"Give to anyone who asks" is a fine approach, one that I follow too.

svieira··on Medieval Monks Wrote over Ancient Star Catalog – Particle Accel Reveals Original
> To me the difference is, there seems to have been way more freedom of thought in the pre christian societies.

I see you're one of today's lucky 10,000! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diocletianic_Persecution#Great...

svieira··on Medieval Monks Wrote over Ancient Star Catalog – Particle Accel Reveals Original
The beggars are professionals almost every single time. To the point where they have licenses from the state to beg (my friends were filming an amateur film in Rome and were stopped by the Guardia because they thought my friends were breaking the law by impersonating a Gypsy.)
svieira··on LLMs as the new high level language
Note that the prompt wasn't fed to another LLM, but to the same one. "I wrote a program in C and gave it to GCC. Then I gave the same program to GCC again and I got a different result" would be more like it.
svieira··on We tasked Opus 4.6 using agent teams to build a C Compiler
Enron
svieira··on A sane but bull case on Clawdbot / OpenClaw
ItisevenbetterwhenyoudropthespacesthatREALLYforcespeopletoengagewithyourcontent. FormaaimxlgarbteihratttenionandHLODitscrmblaetheintreiorofwrdos! /s
svieira··on I miss thinking hard
So today are you doing it again? Or did you compress a week's worth of work into a few hours and the rest of the week is shot because you don't expand?
svieira··on Deno Sandbox
Did the machine-bound Macaroons ever get written up publicly or is that proprietary?
svieira··on OracleGPT: Thought Experiment on an AI Powered Executive
What (or who) would have been responsible for the Holodomor if it had been caused by an automated system instead of deliberate human action?
svieira··on Claude's new constitution
> So yes, I think you can derive an ought from an is. But this belief is of my own invention and to my knowledge, novel. Happy to find out someone else believes this.

Plato, Aristotle, and the scholastics of the Middle Ages (Thomas Aquinas chief among them) and everyone who counts themselves in that same lineage (waves) including such easy reads as Peter Kreeft. You're in very good company, in my opinion.

svieira··on Ask HN: COBOL devs, how are AI coding affecting your work?
Would you consider Knight Capital Group[1] a banking context?

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knight_Capital_Group#2012_stoc...

svieira··on Show HN: I quit coding years ago. AI brought me back
> excel sheets

Funnily enough, Excel is the quintessential example of a fourth generation language, IDE, and database and it's the only one aside from SQL which actually succeeded from its time period. It's software, just like what you're building now, and just like what you're building now there are good points and bad points about it. The tradeoffs are different between the JS / Python code you're likely spinning up now vs. the Excel code that was being spun up before, but they rhyme.

svieira··on Cursor's latest “browser experiment” implied success without evidence
> What they all seem to be just glossing over is how the project unfolded: without human intervention, using computers, in an exceptionally accelerated time frame, working 24hr/day.

Correct, but Gas Town [1] already happened and what's more _actually worked_, so this experiment is both useless (because it doesn't demonstrate working software) _and_ derivative (because we've already seen that you can set up a project where with spend similar to the spend of a single developer you can churn out more code than any human could read in a week).

[1]: https://github.com/steveyegge/gastown

svieira··on Don't fall into the anti-AI hype
> My favorite definition of “legacy code” is “code that is not tested” because no matter who writes code, it turns into a minefield quickly if it doesn’t have tests.

Unfortunately, "tests" don't do it, they have to be "good tests". I know, because I work on a codebase that has a lot of tests and some modules have good tests and some might as well not have tests because the tests just tell you that you changed something.

svieira··on How will the miracle happen today?
If you haven't read C. S. Lewis' The Great Divorce you may like it.
svieira··on US will ban Wall Street investors from buying single-family homes
So when you build a sewage farm on your back 40 you should get wealthier (while your neighbors thank you because their land tax went down), but if someone snaps a photo of your area that goes viral on {THE PLATFORM DU JOUR} thus making your county more popular and driving up a bidding war for postage stamp sized lots of land (leading to the land being valued at a higher rate than it was a year before) you suddenly have a massive tax bill because "we noticed you are living in a popular county" and the benefits of living in a popular place should be taxed away? Or do we need some kind of a standard for "more valuable" that deals only with tangible things? And if so, which tangibles?
svieira··on Opus 4.5 is not the normal AI agent experience that I have had thus far
> just like anyone

Arthur Whitney?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Whitney_(computer_scien...

svieira··on CSS sucks because we don't bother learning it (2022)
> Why is it using an NIH format instead of using XML or INI or something?

The original suggestion was LISP-like or X.11 configuration file syntax (https://www.w3.org/Style/CSS20/history.html) - XML was still too new (but look at https://www.w3.org/wiki/Xsl-fo if you want to see what the W3C came up with for "styling, but in XML format for XML documents"). My guess is that the declarative shape imitates SGML with a C syntax to make it easier to understand.

> It's too global. This is good for consistent styling but bad for modularity.

Yeah, that was an explicit design choice - one that we're now asking for (and getting) more control over as the web continues to expand, but it's not like it wasn't considered, it was considered and rejected for MVP as it were.

> Pseudo-classes are ugly and weird and were a way-too-late NIH thing.

https://www.w3.org/TR/CSS1/#pseudo-classes-and-pseudo-elemen... were in CSS 1 released as a specification in 1998. Ugly-and-weird-and-special-cased ... sure, but what would you replace them with?

svieira··on CSS sucks because we don't bother learning it (2022)
Depends ... are you using `display: table` or are you literally using HTML instead of CSS? If you are doing the former, you know CSS. If you're doing the latter, then you haven't demonstrated that you know CSS and we'll have to talk to figure out if you know it and are avoiding it or if you just don't know it.
svieira··on 2025: The Year in LLMs
Does a prolog program think?
svieira··on 2025: The Year in LLMs
> Yes, in fact, it turns out that language encodes and embodies reasoning ... No one had the faintest clue

Funnily enough, they did, if you go back far enough. It's only the deconstructionists and the solipsists who had the audacity to think otherwise.

svieira··on Lottocracy: Democracy Without Elections
This is the premise of The Napoleon of Notting Hill by G. K. Chesterton. In 1984 (100 years after the writing of the book), the King of England is now selected by lottery. Much wildness ensues.

https://www.gutenberg.org/files/20058/20058-h/20058-h.htm

svieira··on I don't care how well your "AI" works
> After 6 months I let them go, the improvement was far too slow.

The bit that's missing from this story is the "why" the improvement was far too slow. Was it primarily a failure to hire the right people, a failure to teach them what you wanted them to learn, a failure to understand what you needed to teach, or a deliberate lie on the part of all three of them to steal from you?

svieira··on Americans no longer see four-year college degrees as worth the cost
> or at least a comfortable living

I know a farrier. The pay comes straight out of your body and cannot be called comfortable.

svieira··on Running a business means contact with reality
She objectively caused you to transition to an objective state which you both experienced subjectively!
svieira··on Show HN: Explore what the browser exposes about you
You mean something like https://consumer.risk.lexisnexis.com/request?

Or more like "on ad network X you match for keywords A, B, F, G"?

svieira··on Cloudflare outage should not have happened
Yes, but my point is that without a reasonable supervision tree and crash boundary the difference between a composition of Result-returning functions that bottoms out in main's implicit panic and an explicit panic is nil operationally.

While lexically the unwrap actually puts the unhandledness of the error case as close to the source of the issue's source as possible. In order to get that lexical goodness you'd need something much more fine grained than Result.

svieira··on Cloudflare outage should not have happened
All that means is that the `Failure` bubbles up to the very top of `main` (in this scenario) because we're only caring about the happy path (because we can't conceive of what the unhappy path should be other than "crash") and then hits the `panic("Well, that's unexpected")` explicitly in Place B rather than Place A (the `.unwrap`). I'm not sure how that's _better_.
svieira··on Mind-reading devices can now predict preconscious thoughts
I rather prefer the holistic take that we are our whole selves and not just the part that reflects on what we do or the part that reacts to external and internal material stimuli. We know we can change the instincts, emotions, and hormones when they conflict with what we know by reflection to be just and good. To put it another way, we know that we can do things "without thinking" that are either just or unjust and by reflection can achieve some level of mastery over the direction of our impetuses.
← PreviousPage 4 of 28Next →