HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sw104

139 karma · joined April 1, 2022

submissionscomments
sw104··on The Quest for a Dumber Phone
I honestly don't understand the point of people avoiding smartphones on principle. I'm not sure if it's a contrarian way of thinking, a way to stand out or what. Why not just dumb down a smartphone?

I have a Pixel 5 because it's the smallest form factor Android smartphone available. I never installed any entertainment (games, social media, video streaming) apps on it. Those that came pre-installed (ie. YouTube), I uninstalled or disabled.

After this, I disabled notifications for everything besides calls and messages (SMS, Signal, email). I cleaned my emails so only genuine stuff ever pops up, and I make it a point to not check my phone, except for set times throughout the day, unless I'm being bombarded by messages or calls (as would happen in an emergency).

The phone that is left sits in my pocket 99% of the day, but still has the tools that I may need (Maps, Uber) should my forward planning be thwarted by unexpected occurrences (lost my pre-planned route to a new place, a cancelled bus/train). My daily smartphone use is maybe 10 minutes. Some people have commented that they didn't think I had one, because I'm barely holding it.

I don't understand the need to get rid of tools which could help in an emergency or unexpected circumstances. I anecdotally had a friend who uses a dumbphone because he wanted to simplify things, and he ended up pestering the people he was around to check their maps or to look something up. In the end he went back to a smartphone.

You can do this with any smartphone, cheap or expensive. I did it with a Pixel 5 just because I liked the form factor of something that can easily slip into my running bag, pockets etc. Plus, as a bonus, the low usage of the device should keep it going for a couple of years until my next dumb smartphone.

sw104··on The Quest for a Dumber Phone
What did you find difficult in removing distractions on Android?

I got a Pixel 5 few years ago (seemingly the smallest form factor Android device), didn't install any apps, removed a bunch of stock apps I didn't need, and turned off notifications for everything beside incoming calls/messages. After that, I just trained myself to avoid using search/the browser unless necessary and to do something else when the itch arises to check the phone for something.

sw104··on Cruel optimism and lazy pessimism
The gym I go to has maybe 10 female regulars (including my wife). I think the reason it's so low is because of men advising other men to meet girls at the gym, or people going with that goal in-mind.

My wife has to put up with all sorts of weird behaviour (staring, unsolicited advice, chatting up, following around the gym, and occasionally somebody trying to leave with her, which cuts my workout short) just to get a workout. If we didn't live in such a small living space, we'd build a home gym to get away from public gyms.

I know you're not advising that, but I think more-or-less the gym isn't an environment for meeting people, unless it's truly a per-chance meeting where neither side is actively looking for anything.

sw104··on Sludge content is consuming TikTok. Why aren't we talking about it?
I always wondered what this was, and presumed it was just a fill-in for commentary videos where the commentator was a bit camera shy, despite being confident enough to post their political / social commentary.

The Grand Theft Auto footage of the car driving down a load of ramps has popped up so many times when I've been mindlessly browsing YouTube, that I never connected the dots that it was being used to reinforce (through the reward/satisfaction element of the video game footage) the commentary alongside it.

sw104··on Ask HN: How can I stop pulling my hair?
Thank you so much for this.

I'd never heard of stimming before, but your first paragraph was exactly what I feel that I have. I just couldn't write it as clearly.

It seems to be caused by all sorts, as you suggest:- stress, focus, boredom. Because of that it just makes it seem like a habit that I'm always practicing as somewhat opposing moods (focus and boredom) trigger it.

I've never been diagnosed, but I've always shown signs of autism in general and I believe other people view me that way even if unspoken. Regardless, I read a bit more after reading what you've written, and found it's common to a lesser degree even without autism, so whether I am autistic or not, it doesn't matter.

I'll try to replace the stim with something else less destructive, like squeezing my wrist/bicep as that's something to do "on the way" to my hands reaching my hair. I think when I started biting/chewing my inner lip, this was something like that (ie. getting the same feeling as the hair pulling stim without as much time to move my hands about).

Thank you again. I had no idea about this and it's given me a great starting point to find out more and try to work around it.

sw104··on Cruel optimism and lazy pessimism
It depends how much flow the escape valve controls.

Anecdotally, I used to have neighbours who would order food delivery religiously, multiple times per day, every day. It must have costed a small fortune. Not enough for buying a home, but enough to do something better with.

sw104··on Maximum two drinks a week, Canada advises
Being overweight and obese are alongside alcohol and tobacco in the biggest causes of ill health and misery. In the UK 64% of the adult population are overweight/obese, in the states it's over 70% (if I remember correctly).

Alongside a myriad of other issues, the state of my countries national health cripples the healthcare system we have, which obstructs healthcare access even for those who live a healthier lifestyle.

One McDonalds Happy Meal isn't the same as one cigarette, but the much greater abundance of people who eat junk food as opposed to those that smoke or drink (both rapidly diminishing statistics) makes the food industry just as responsible, if not moreso.

Fast food and junk food companies sit on the sidelines providing all of the ammunition, while taking none of the responsibility. They'll do everything to keep their prices as low as possible, weaving their products into traditional life (chocolate Easter eggs, the abundance of chocolate at Christmas, a pack of crisps being a typical component of an office workers lunch) and oppose any taxes and regulation to obstruct their profits.

The most they do is to tell people to eat moderately, and link to a website that nobody will ever visit, but then they make their packaging appealing to children, hold prices low and have their products featured in grabbing distance at supermarket checkouts.

I'll admit entertainment isn't really on the same scope directly, but you still have people wrecking their lives by prioritising it over education/work. That can provide a serious knock-on effect to poverty and ill-health etc. Many video games and social network products (ie. TikTok) are designed especially to be addictive. The creators know their products are addictive, and don't hold responsibility for the impact that may have on a good proportion of their customers.

sw104··on Google's Stadia Cloud Gaming Platform Shuts Down Today
I think they struggled with a very stubborn userbase.

I used it and thought it worked brilliantly.

sw104··on Maximum two drinks a week, Canada advises
The thing is, once you take away all the industries thriving on selling products that damage/ruin lives, there's not really much left is there?

It's legal to sell fast food and junk food (crisps, fizzy drinks, chocolate, even juice) which in large contributes to the obesity epidemic. It's legal to sell alcohol, cigarettes and other addiction forming substances. It's legal to sell media like video games and TV shows which waste people's time and potential.

I live a 5 minute walk from a city centre with all sorts of shops. I walk past and think most of them offer little to negative benefit to people's lives.

sw104··on Ask HN: Techwise, how did TikTok get so good?
YouTube Shorts don't seem to operate on the same level as TikTok. Maybe I have a unique experience but every time I look at YouTube Shorts, it's literally the same batch of videos in the same order, day-to-day.
sw104··on Why gyms don't work but Superhuman does
It's a terrible analogy really. Poor writing.

A gym is only unfamiliar if you've never been to a gym before. Almost any gym you go to has the same machines (cardio and weights), dumbbells, barbells, kettle bells etc. Most machines are understandable on first sight (maybe not good form), and even if somebody has never used one, the average person instinctively know how to use, let's say, a chest press machine because they've seen it in TV shows, movies, real life. You'd have to be almost alien to reach an age that would allow you to have a gym membership without having seen these machines used second-hand.

I'm sure Superhuman won't be the first email client somebody uses, so they'll likely pick up most of the features based on intuition. Based on that, the analogy doesn't hold up whether you've been to a gym before or not.

sw104··on Ask HN: How many of you are open to Piracy again?
I'm not the person you replied to, but have the same stance. I'd just not consume that content.

I don't deserve to have everything, even if I want it. At the end of the day, it's just a piece of media.

sw104··on Some UK hospitals with emergency services in complete state of crisis
The NHS isn't built to handle the modern British man/woman's health.

According to the ONS, 64% of adults are overweight and obese. To add to that, we have a more aged population than when the NHS was founded. Binge drinking and social drinking are the absolute norm, and smoking/vaping is on the increase (smoking increased during Covid because people were "bored", people take up vaping who never smoked).

People abandon the last bastions of basic daily exercise in walking and cycling, in preference of e-scooters.

A population with an apathetic view towards keeping fit and healthy. The NHS will only get better if a good proportion of the population decide to handle their own health. That seems unlikely to happen.

Go to any gym and see what the very few people who exercise constitute as a workout. Walking on a treadmill for 15 minutes or sat on machines reading their phones. However everybody seems to walk around in athletics / yoga clothing.

Go out for a run and see how many people you see running. Most people you meet do zero exercise beyond walking around.

All the while, every apartment block in our cities sees 20 Deliveroo/Just Eat takeaway deliveries per hour. Restaurant dining is a multiple-time-per-week activity. Salty and oily food dominates in fast food, takeaways, ready meals and restaurants.

This makes people angry because it's the truth.

If you want to see why the NHS will collapse, take a 5 minute walk around any built up area in the UK and look at people's (substantial) guts.

sw104··on UK PM wants all pupils to study maths to 18
Agreed. British education is upheld by a handful of universities with great research backgrounds. High school standards are slipping, and most universities are now just filler for 18-21 year olds.

I went to a Russell Group university which was operated like a crude joke.

sw104··on Ash HN: Any viable alternative device to a smartphone on the market today?
Could you advise what sort of data might be leaked? I'm curious, just not sure how to ask without it sounding antagonistic.

I use contacts, phone, SMS, and the odd search on Google Maps and Chrome (once a week or so). All I can imagine they're able to track is the time, date and recipient of calls, plus the message for SMS and search history.

Is there something I don't know about that Android records on top of that?

sw104··on Ash HN: Any viable alternative device to a smartphone on the market today?
I've been through this thought process myself and honestly, the best approach I've found is to use a cheap smartphone (Android in my case) and just use it minimally.

In my opinion, a lot of the complaints about attention are unfairly attributed to the device, when it's the rubbish installed on the device that causes these issues (social media, games, media streaming, news). This could also be extended to security and privacy.

As much as I'd love to go phoneless, I need it in case of emergencies (wife, kids, myself, a random stranger collapsing in the street). A dumbphone could provide that, but there's always going to be a bunch of one-off moments where some of the basic utilities of a smartphone are very useful.

I have a Pixel 5 (no third party apps, and small enough to slip into any pocket), with GPS turned off, battery saver on, very few apps installed (no games, streaming, social media, news), most of the default apps disabled, and notifications limited solely to calls and texts.

At home, the phone lives on its charging dock and acts as a home phone. When out and about, the phone sits in a pocket for 99% of the time I'm out. I only use utilities (like browser, maps) when it's necessary. I leave most thoughts until I get home, as anything important enough to want to check online is something that can wait a few minutes/hours.

According to the Google "Digital Wellbeing" app, which tracks phone/app usage, I spend less than 10 minutes each day on my phone, and unlock it 3/4 times each day (which is calls). I believe, due to my minimal use of the phone, Google collects very little of value about me. I just don't give it a chance to collect anything.

A lot of the alternatives to smartphones (eg. Lightphone, Librem 5, posted below) are very expensive ($300, $1300 respectively) and for that price, I feel you may as well buy a cheap smartphone and strip away all the excess or just buy a feature phone (Nokia 105 for $30). These companies are selling a lifestyle and talking piece.

You can buy a minimalistic phone like Lightphone, a feature phone, or some other workaround, but every now and then there'll be a situation where a quick check of Google Maps or some other mapping app would help. And that one check isn't going to tell Google all about your life. I'd rather have the utility there for those situations, than inconvenience a stranger in the street to use their phone.

sw104··on Using rats to clear land mines in Cambodia
I've owned multiple (fancy) rats as pets in my time. The species is somewhat split into domesticated and non-domesticated.

My rats would probably never have survived in the wild (due to their appearance, sand/tuxedo coloured, instead of just gray/brown), and likewise wild rats wouldn't be possible to domesticate.

There's quite a few videos on YouTube of the social skills they can develop. Quite amazing animals, but incredibly short lives. Most people who have them don't get new ones after the originals die because it can be so heartbreaking losing a pet every 2 years or so.

sw104··on How long would society last during a total grid collapse?
That sounds quite harsh. People that live in cities aren't stupid.
sw104··on The age of social media is ending
I think the jury is out on YouTube being social media. Like yourself I'd agree it's not social media based on the way I use it.

For people who just watch the videos it's purely a video streaming site. For other users it's social media because they use comments/messages (if it has this feature).

It ponders the question that if a website can be used in 2 ways (as a social network, or as an information/entertainment source, like when lurking anonymously), whether you should really call it by it's full-feature name.

For the most part, I rarely write on HN and I browse Reddit but don't have an account, so am I using them as social networks?

And if on a site like HN I can't add somebody as a friend, and always reply once or twice to a fresh user I've never met before, does that still count? Is it socialising or just taking part in a one-off conversation?

sw104··on Zuckerberg’s empire collapses
I think that's just you.

I was an early adopter of virtual reality (since sold it and moved on). Even the most energetic VR games pale in comparison to a typical gym workout, provided the person actually works out at the gym rather than practicing fuckarounditis

I find the gym/outdoor running is much more effective for both weight loss (running being the most effective way to burn energy) and muscle gain (which generally requires weight-based resistance training)

sw104··on Ask HN: How to deal with regret of not having kids
These reasons are entirely on a person-by-person basis. Sleeping and drug use isn't going to sway somebody away from wanting to start a family.

Many people have no kids and still can't simply change their job, location, travel or buy a home.

sw104··on Why aren't Russians protesting (more)?
I'm not certain social media is ever a good sample space for this sort of thing. We're all too aware that certain platforms lean certain directions and I believe VK is essentially owned and operated by the government, having been taken from it's original owner, Pavel Durov.

Posting anti-war, and therefore anti-government / anti-state sentiment on a platform essentially monitored and run by an authoritarian regime seems like the least likely form of protest you will see, as firstly it's most likely to be censored, secondly it's the easiest way to oust yourself to the authorities, and thirdly even if posted securely will be simply seen to be a weak protest/bot.

My wife is Russian and quite a lot of my friends and obviously relatives are Russian. All are against the war (that I know of), and were so before mobilisation.

It's true to say mobilisation has made people more concerned, but hardly fair to claim that people supported the war before. Of those who aren't anti-war, I'd take a guess that most fall into a neutral camp where they're trying to continue living their life as normally as possible knowing that realistically there isn't much they can do to stop the war that won't involve destroying the rest of their life with no impact on Putin's regime.

The consequences of opposing the war have always been abysmal in Russia. Anti-war sentiment online or in person can come with a 15 year prison sentence. Rape and assault are incredibly common in Russian prisons and the likelihood of returning to normal life is very slim as many Russian firms don't touch ex-convicts.

Quite often people quote a Levada Center poll suggesting 70% of Russians support the war/government position, but usually omits how many refused to answer the poll. These pollsters call you and ask if you'd like to answer questions about Putin / government / war, at which point most people hang up because in the moment they don't know if the Levada Center is independent/government controlled. The very few polls that are concluded will mostly lean to people that support (or outwardly pretend to support) the government, which is hardly a fair metric for judging opinion. The alleged 30% who went through with the poll and answered negatively about the government are braver than I'd ever be. I'd hang up.

The only real way to gauge Russian opinion is to befriend and converse with them behind a closed door. I know it's anecdotal again, but in my many travels to Russia, most people express anti-government views behind closed doors, and this most likely extends to the war.

I think in the West we're too quick to demand people in more repressed states do more to protest. A common statement I've heard the past few months (especially in relation to my wife, family and friends) is why they don't protest, why they don't overthrow Putin's regime. The consequences of doing any of that are so much higher, and if the positions were swapped I can hardly see Western citizens doing what they demand the Russians do.

sw104··on What If Obesity Is Nobody’s Fault?
Anecdotal but I've lost 10kg (from a healthy starting weight), across 3 months, with CICO. Sure it's not completely precise, but if you round down your energy expenditure estimates and round up your calorie intake estimates, it works.

The act of consistently observing one's own weight, what one eats, and what exercise one does, is a viable dating strategy, much more so than Paleo, Keto or some other named diet which can push book sales and courses.

To drop 100g of weight requires around a 700 calorie deficit (or 7000cal for 1kg). If you're rounding up your energy intake, rounding down your exercise/BMR estimates, and still staying clear 700 calories or more a day, you'll shift the weight.

I think the issue comes when people try to use CICO with precision, thinking that 50cal here, 100cal, 7cal there etc. will add up and help them lose weight. It's not big enough deficits and like you stated, they're probably actually in surplus from bad measuring/inaccurate figures at that point, so they'll likely maintain/gain weight.

Completely agree on the restaurant / self-prepared food. That's why you round it up. I round up everything to the next 50/100, even if the packaging states a figure.

sw104··on What If Obesity Is Nobody’s Fault?
Portion sizes are a really good point.

I'm British and my partner is Russian. Our first date was at an Italian restaurant and she ordered a pizza.

She was shocked to receive a full circle of pizza, as opposed to a slice.

I was shocked she was only expecting a slice.

That was quite eye-opening for me. I've never been overweight and growing up my parents brought me up on a good diet (albeit somewhat large portions). Looking around, many people weren't fortunate enough to have the same experience with food. Either because they grew up on fast food, or because their parents cooked large batches of rather beige British food.

(Practically) anybody being stubborn with themselves following a CICO diet will lose weight. But the portion sizes and types of food people eat have definitely been misunderstood as having less energy.

I've been confused for some time as to why our food packaging recommends 2500 calories for men and 2000 for women, when the basal metabolic rate (BMR), the amount of energy burnt daily by doing nothing is around 1500, and the extra 1000 calories would require a decent amount of exercise which most people simply don't do (akin to a daily 10 mile run). I have assumed it's food companies lobbying to increase it with a very optimistic view on people's daily energy expenditure.

sw104··on What If Obesity Is Nobody’s Fault?
While there may be an underlying cause exacerbating the issue, I still think most people's obesity (and being overweight) is almost entirely on poor lifestyle choices, and refuting this is mostly a coping mechanism.

I'd be willing to bet most people (even those in shape) underestimate their calorie intake and overestimate their energy expenditure, unless actively logging it, and these small differences gradually add up.

I've lost 10kg since June (starting from a healthy weight of 75kg), and my special method that doctors don't want you to know, is calories in, calories out. I track food in, and I track exercise.

Even if my weight is being influenced by microplastics or something else, I believe everything is still within my own control.

I do think that in an ideal world, junk food (including alcohol) would be treated akin to cigarettes, with bland packaging . featuring health warnings, and a carpet ban on being advertised.

sw104··on What I Miss About Working at Stripe
How does somebody work 15 hour days making blog posts (Stripe Press)?

Maybe I'm being elitist, but I pegged the long working hours and collaboration more with the engineering side of Stripe.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4