HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

swishercutter

78 karma · joined April 25, 2011

submissionscomments
swishercutter··on What I Learned From Fixing my Laptop's Motherboard
Good work. You should do an instructable if you have not already.

People who share their work make the internet (and the world) great.

Always remember your maker rules: http://wondermark.com/tink8/

swishercutter··on What I Learned From Fixing my Laptop's Motherboard
A trick I sometimes use on cars is that when you take each part off you put all the bolts in a ziploc and mark it, then put the bags in series in a cardboard box or whatever...then you just take each bag out of the box in reverse during assembly since typically the same parts go back in the same way...helps avoid the extra screw (or the dreaded short one screw/nut/bolt which is usually more puzzling for me).

I always want to do photos but I am usually too dirty and/or lazy.

swishercutter··on What I Learned From Fixing my Laptop's Motherboard
Nice, we had a 2 year old range stop working in our condo...it wouldn't heat. So since we were upgrading appliances one at a time that was obviously next (it sucked anyways). So I traced the problem back to the control board...$500+ online, so I ripped into it, found the burned solder connection (admittedly very simple fix, but still a very simple circuit otherwise), resoldered the connection and now we have a working stove to sell/trade/donate. Total cost: 2 hrs and less than a penny worth of solder.

BTW, I am jealous of the stereo microscope and hot air rework station...those are on my list for my shop (Just got a Rigol oscope to hack a few months back)...Sometimes, I miss working in production and having access to all that..although I have better handtools now.

swishercutter··on What I Learned From Fixing my Laptop's Motherboard
He could have found the same SMT diode as he was replacing had he tried...he rigged it because it was the same part (electrically) just a Through-hole part.

Just because a device is "dense" or heavily populated does not mean it cannot be repaired if done properly, if the schematic is provided (and accurate per revision) and you can still source the part it can be repaired. Even IC's can be removed it just takes different tools (i.e. solder pot, hot air pen, hot plate, etc).

I assure you there is no difference between troubleshooting old tech and newer stuff its just different. An IC is just that an "integrated circuit", meaning they just took what used to be an entire daughter board and made it on a silicon chip. I would actually argue that it could be easier in some cases to find an issue on newer stuff since if a chip is failed you just replace it (if you can get it, which is the real problem).

It's just like he said in the article use the datasheets if you don't have a schematic typically they are just using some circuit that someone designed 20 years ago and put in the datasheet as an example.

I understand the labor cost involved in fixing an item but I would argue the long term cost of replacement/improper disposal (even recycling...have you seen the little kids with the campfires of circuit boards in india/africa that are trying to reclaim the valuable metals...that is the cost I am talking about).

As an electronics tech I can tell you that I have worked on many complex circuits in the field and in production and I have never had a problem with the complexity...but I have had many issues with finding "one off" IC's and schematics.

Things are not always about money...sometimes its best to fix things just to fix them (and hopefully learn something at the same time).

Also, consumer electronics are built to fail. If they were not the manufacturers would require some IPC class, nobody wants quality though...they want cheap.

swishercutter··on What I Learned From Fixing my Laptop's Motherboard
My electronics instructor still uses his amplifier from the 70's because he can rebuild it with common parts...nowadays if an amplifier section breaks chances are that it is a chip which may or may not be available (many manufacturers keep no backstock of one off chips, therefore there is no way to get replacements).

One of the things I really took with me from his instruction is a disgust at the "Death of the TV repairman". People would rather throw something in the garbage instead of having it fixed...not that it is always their fault. It has become cheaper to purchase an item than to have it fixed, that combined with the fact that most manufacturers typically do not release schematics until the item is out of production (if they do at all) and an increased effort by manufacturers to not allow anyone other than their techs to work on things (i.e. special Iphone screws, warranty voiding tape, part numbers removed from chips).

Remember, just because it is small and complex does not mean it cannot be fixed. If it was built it can be rebuilt (or unbuilt, see ifixit).

swishercutter··on What I Learned From Fixing my Laptop's Motherboard
Always remember the Maker rule..."If it is broken it is fair game..". Open it up, do your best, if you don't fix it but you learn something then its time well spent.

If you are like me you also salvage as many parts from what cannot be (or is not worth) fixing there is always something else to use the parts on.

swishercutter··on Creator of "Dirty Jobs" Mike Rowe testifies to Congress
The tools are there for the properly motivated like they have never been in our entire history. The internet and social networking have made it so there is a forum for every trade, interest, or fetish. It is time to use it for more than just porn and gaming...not that there is anything right or wrong about either.

I try to force myself to learn something new before I go do something for entertainment. I will watch one MIT video lecture on physics or something to that effect, or research something that I am curious about. Then when I am done I can go game or watch something mindless if I choose so.

It makes it hard when I have to explain to people that I am self employed and I do about 5-10 different things...just depends on what is paying...most people just don't understand.

swishercutter··on Creator of "Dirty Jobs" Mike Rowe testifies to Congress
I believe that the main problem is we have spent the last 20 years "training our replacements" (i.e. selling off semiconductor tech, outsourcing) and not enough time training our children. Maybe if we spent a bit more time teaching our children instead of depending on the schools to do it for us things might be better.

Make time to make things with your children. Life is about more than money, your grandfather knew that.

swishercutter··on Creator of "Dirty Jobs" Mike Rowe testifies to Congress
You just need a diagram...I replaced all the wiring on a 1993 Mazda 626 from the front bumper to the dash. 4 big looms. If you have the "real" shop manual tracing problems is easy...not the Haynes or Chiltons (I have the original shop manuals for 2 of my 4 cars, including the electrical supplements, all wire color codings and methods to test every sensor are in the books.

I will not argue that fixing the main relay on my father's 1962 Thunderbird was way easier (I won't even get into the difference between dropping the fuel tank vs. a newer car) I believe for the most part newer cars are not much harder to work on. I really like what Volkswagen did with their VAG-Com stuff, really makes troubleshooting easy...like stupid easy, plus it interfaces with the laptop for datalogging.

swishercutter··on Creator of "Dirty Jobs" Mike Rowe testifies to Congress
"I mean, most of my experience is working on fuel-injected stuff... but have you ever tried to rebuild a carb? it's damn difficult to get right, and there's no computer telling you when it's correct; you have to essentially guess."

I tell mechanics around me this all the time (North Idaho)...I personally can rebuild and troubleshoot fuel injection with no issues, I have no idea how to tune a carb. Why? Simply because I haven't had to do that yet. People seem to be scared of anything with a computer, its always the ECU they replace first for some reason...usually the problem is a sensor or vacuum leak (from my experience with things).

Older cars are easier to work on because you typically have more room and fewer custom tools, plus you need very little electronics knowledge. I was an electronics tech before I started working on my own cars so I guess that helps.

swishercutter··on Any Americans using the metric system in daily life?
Working on sourcing parts for Reprap's and I was shocked to find out that the metalworkers in the area had to convert all my numbers to standard. In electronics manufacturing we used whatever the print had so I just assumed everyone did. I stick with the standard I am used to which is use whatever the print has on it...if its standard I use standard, if its metric I use metric.

I still prefer miles and gallons to km and liters but if I am doing a precise measurement I will use mm. In electronics everything is metric so that is what I use.

Conversion errors kill spacecraft...right?

← PreviousPage 2 of 2