HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

syndicatedjelly

868 karma · joined July 27, 2023

meet.hn/city/40.0149856,-105.270545/Boulder

Interests: computer history, guitar, cycling, running, film and darkroom photography

submissionscomments
syndicatedjelly··on Ask HN: What's the best thing you've watched this year?
Who did he try to assassinate?
syndicatedjelly··on Jimmy Carter has died
Why does being alive in the 1970s qualify someone to speak intelligently on that subject?
syndicatedjelly··on The paper passport's days are numbered
Correct answer
syndicatedjelly··on The paper passport's days are numbered
The EU has borders
syndicatedjelly··on Ask HN: What is your best devil's advocate argument against AI progress?
I think there is a lack of a consistent definition of AGI that everyone is speaking towards, so it's really hard to know what people mean when they simple say "AGI is/is not happening".

From Wikipedia:

    Artificial general intelligence (AGI) is a type of artificial intelligence (AI) that matches or surpasses human cognitive capabilities across a wide range of cognitive tasks. This contrasts with narrow AI, which is limited to specific tasks.[1] Artificial superintelligence (ASI), on the other hand, refers to AGI that greatly exceeds human cognitive capabilities. AGI is considered one of the definitions of strong AI.
"Human cognitive capabilities" is often misunderstood to just mean "thoughts", but this definition is a bit limiting and there seems to be some incentive for pro-AGI people to make everyone think that this is all the brain does. The brain also receives information from an enormous number of sensors throughout the body, such as proprioceptors and other afferents. It also commands an enormous number of muscles, down to the muscle fiber level - this is what allows fine motor control, and is something robots still cannot replicate very well even after over half a century of development. Beyond that, there is so much more going on at other levels..."Society of Mind" is a great book by Marvin Minsky that tries to attack this subject.

I also think AGI must be able to push knowledge in a way that the best humans have done as well. So by this definition, AGI would mean a computer which can not only think the advanced thoughts that humans think, but can also generate new, divergent insights of the sorts which visionaries have thought of (e.g. Shannon's theory of information, Einstein's relativity, Gandhi's application of ahimsa, Gautama's Buddhism etc...).

Put together, I would expect true AGI to not merely match an "average" human's capabilities, but also be capable of exceeding it in the way an Albert Einstein or a LeBron James can. I think we are still decades away from either of those things happening, if they happen at all.

Finally, this is by no means an anti-AI take. I use LLMs daily as part of my core workflow, and rely on them for other tasks that a few years ago I had no capability of doing. Rather, I define all these terms to cut through so much of the marketing jargon and BS that AI companies are flooding us with right now. Let's keep an eye on the correct target, and not just settle for whatever some company thinks AGI means and which will pad their wallets the best in the near term.

syndicatedjelly··on Ask HN: Resources for better understanding quantum computing
I think this site is fantastic: https://quantum.country/
syndicatedjelly··on FDA Finalizes Updated "Healthy" Nutrient Content Claim
The FDA is about 5 decades behind the curve here. Seriously? “Healthy foods” now just need to:

    - Contain a certain amount of food (food group equivalent) from at least one of the food groups or subgroups (such as fruits, vegetables, fat-free and low-fat dairy etc.) recommended by the Dietary Guidelines.  
    - Adhere to specified limits for the following nutrients: saturated fat, sodium, and added sugars. 

    Manufacturers who choose to use the “healthy” claim have three years to conform but can use the new criteria sooner.
Does this help anyone at all, other than the big food companies who can now advertise ultra-processed junk as “healthy”?
syndicatedjelly··on The True Cost of PMI: Why you should pay down your low-interest mortgage
There is some basic math literacy lacking in this article.

    For example, the return on paying down a mortgage with a 3% interest rate is 3%. If savings accounts are paying 4% interest, you’ll get a 1% better return by keeping your money in a savings account than by making extra payments on your mortgage.
No. If the two options are to place $1,200 in a interest account bearing 4% (compounded monthly), versus contributing an extra $100/month to a mortgage at 3%, the amount "earned" is different.

Assuming monthly compounding in both cases, in the 4% interest account case, the final balance is $1248.89, representing a net earning of $48.89 based on the compound interest formula. In the second case, one needs to use an amortization schedule and compare the difference in contributing an extra $100/month, versus not doing so. The difference isn't simply a 1% gain though, because one is paying slightly less interest on a shrinking principal over a 30 year period, versus earning 1% on a growing principal over a 30-year period.

syndicatedjelly··on Discover Your Accent Like Never Before
Seems like snake oil. I get 92% British even though I certainly do not have that kind of accent.

FTR, the "how it works" section just says "AI-powered analysis" which is effectively like saying, we have no idea how it works

syndicatedjelly··on Huge math error corrected in black plastic study; authors say it doesn't matter
On the one hand, making mistakes in basic math is reasonable cause for retraction; on the other hand, why are people defending the use of something with only 8% of the daily limit of a carcinogen? Is there some hidden benefit to using melty plastic utensils on a hot iron pan versus, say, wood or metal, both of which contribute closer to 0%?
syndicatedjelly··on Ask HN: With O3 progression, how should juniors plan our careers
Time to become the CEO then
syndicatedjelly··on Ask HN: What personal projects do you have planned for the holidays?
Got 8 days through AoC before giving up/leaving for the holidays

Finished a presentation on bash tools. Surprisingly, many devs seem to be allergic to using the shell as a default, instead preferring to thrash about in some sub-standard GUI that runs inside an Electron app. Trying to convince everyone to return to their roots

Finishing up a small business grant application that my co-founder and I have been working on for a couple months now. That's the big accomplishment I'd say

syndicatedjelly··on Arizona School's Curriculum Will Be Taught by AI, No Teachers
Why is this automatically a bad thing?
syndicatedjelly··on Ask HN: Do you use an ergonomic keyboard? If so, which one? Do you like it?
I switched to a ZSA Moonlander last year. The ortholinear layout (and my poor typing hygeine) meant I needed to relearn how to type over the course of about a month. keybr.io was very useful in this regard.

I love the keyboard now though, and don't really enjoy typing on standard membrane keyboards with staggered layouts anymore. I also went from having to take frequent breaks from typing (every 30 mins) due to wrist pain, to being able to type continuously for extended periods with no discomfort.

The price is the most painful part...but a keyboard is a tool of the trade, so I don't feel too bad splurging on it.

syndicatedjelly··on Updates to H-1B
For what?
syndicatedjelly··on What should I look for in my first SWE job?

    At some point if I transition to FAANG/something closer to my ideal, I'd definitely like to grind so I doubt I would have time for much outside of work.
If you want to make that transition, you're gonna be competing with people who work hard from day 1, and not just when it's time to make the jump to FAANG. It's really hard to beat people who put in the time for their craft, in the long-run

You don't have to work at a "name-brand" company to have an enjoyable, challenging and rewarding career. Most people don't. Ignore everyone who tells you that the name of the company you work for, or length of your title are what matter in life

    How does WLB change over time for most people?
I think for a lot of people, they tend to have the fewest commitments immediately out of college. Life responsibilities tend to pile up as you get older, which makes it nice to have "banked" a bunch of good will, hard work, and connections from earlier in your career
syndicatedjelly··on What should I look for in my first SWE job?
IMO, WLB is least valuable immediately after getting out of school. Now's the time to put your head down, get some work done, and advance your career. The difference is only 15 hours a week, but after a year or two you'll have put in several thousand more hours than the version of yourself with better WLB. Especially if your goal is to get into a major tech company or FAANG.

"Enjoy life after uni" - you've just started, welcome to the real grind. There are real rewards to be had out here, in any way you desire, if you "work" hard. The fun part is, you can define what "work" means if you play your cards right

This is probably one of the few comments you'll get like this, most people will tell you "enjoy life, etc", so just keep this in mind whatever you decide

syndicatedjelly··on FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices
"Darn, sorry we can't make a deal. Hey look at all the people who need cars that are waiting!"

This is not as much of an upper hand as you think it is, often these shenanigans happen after sitting at the dealer for a couple hours while they do whatever it is they do. Do you value your time so little that you'll just walk out of a transaction over less than a 1% difference in cost?

The dealer knows how to play this game way better than you, if you walk into a dealership without having a plan to score a deal then you already lost

syndicatedjelly··on FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices
The zip code I live in spans two different cities (as well as different counties in my state). It's stupid but also it's reality
syndicatedjelly··on Ask HN: Simplest, lightest way to sync a single file between Macs?
save it to a private github repo, pull periodically using a cron job
syndicatedjelly··on Before shooting, Brian Thompson worried about UnitedHealth's negative image
Is it possible to be concerned about multiple things as a CEO?
syndicatedjelly··on What Is Vim?
No one is trying to convince you to use Vim over Nano. Use whatever makes you productive
syndicatedjelly··on What Is Vim?
I recently gave up on VSCode because the Vim mode is still substandard, missing keybindings, and constantly glitches out in new and fun (read: not-fun) ways. I’m just gonna use NeoVim and program the IDE myself, in a true moment of going super-saiyan as a programmer
syndicatedjelly··on The 1955 Le Mans disaster changed motorsport
Was probably equally as informative as whatever you’re trying to say
syndicatedjelly··on Humans are unreliable models of mouse disease
Any thoughts as to why?
syndicatedjelly··on The 1955 Le Mans disaster changed motorsport
We should ban all activities that may cause human injury or death, regardless of participant consent
syndicatedjelly··on We all took the DVD boom era for granted
I considered Canonical to be canonical
syndicatedjelly··on Mouseless – fast mouse control with the keyboard
Just downloaded and installed, I already love this idea :) nice work!
syndicatedjelly··on Mouseless – fast mouse control with the keyboard
Not sure what alternate universe you got stuck in, but I'm using a Macbook Pro with all those features, plus some. OS accessibility has gotten better, not worse. Web design has gone the opposite direction unfortunately, which is ironic because the web community is the one berating everyone over a11y constantly
syndicatedjelly··on Software developer arrested in connection with murder of healthcare executive
What is the point of this hypothetical?
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →