HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

syrrim

1,770 karma · joined December 8, 2015

submissionscomments
syrrim··on Manifest V3, webRequest, and ad blockers
Even a very poor adblocker will speed up web page loading in the average case. If google went that route, they would be forced to confront the fact that not having an adblocker is one of the worst web performance decisions one can make.
syrrim··on The Ungodly Surveillance of Anti-Porn ‘Shameware’ Apps
We thought that access to better technology would make people more free, but there are many ways it can make us less free instead. First through differential control of technology; whoever has control of some new tech will be able to use it to disempower others. Second is through robbing us of agency; technology can make it too easy for us to do things we don't want to do, causing us to do them against our will. At some point we will need to confront these issues.
syrrim··on A Review of the Odin Programming Language
In C you have a system of memory allocation tied to scoping. A statement like "int x[10];" allocates memory such that when x goes out of scope, the memory is deallocated. RAII generalizes the concept so that when the variable comes in scope, some initializer function is called, and when it goes out of scope some destructor is called. This allows us to use it for dynamic arrays (unlike VLAs in C), hash tables, etc. We can replicate the system by simply calling the initializer when the var comes in scope, and the destructor when it goes out of scope. However, this creates the problem that the two statements are far apart from one another, and thus there is a chance that they might grow out of sync as the code changes. Defer allows us to cause some action to occur when the variable goes out of scope, but declare this at the site where we perform initialization, thus grouping the two together and making it easier to modify them in tandem.
syrrim··on What's the cheapest domain you can register for 10 years?
If they took your fee then invested it in some reliable asset, they could theoretically continue to earn an annuity on it indefinitely, which they could use to pay ICANN's fee, any server fees, etc. A hosting company could do the same.
syrrim··on Ask HN: Is there a precedent for legislation that mandates code changes to OSS?
> can the government enforce that the software has to be written a certain way?

I doubt they would intend to. Instead, they would make it illegal to run, and possibly to otherwise involve yourself with, software written in a certain way. The bitcoin community could choose to either withdraw from the US and any allied country that aided in enforcement, or they could choose to change the software to no longer behave that way. In practice, the latter option would basically force them to move to proof of stake. But given the origins of bitcoin as an anti-government system, they would likely choose some variant of the former option.

syrrim··on Albania expelled Iran’s embassy staff over July cyberattack
The weak suffer what they must. Iran could definitely have gone for some sabre rattling and asking for aid from their allies, but obviously their options were limited.
syrrim··on What If Obesity Is Nobody’s Fault?
>If, even some of the time, obesity is not due to a person overeating or under-exercising, should discrimination against the obese carry the same legal consequences as discrimination based on age, race, or gender? And by the same measure, should purveyors of fattening foods be made unaccountable for the perceived consequences of their products?

Both questions are strange, for different reasons. The first, because it doesn't follow from the above. They later clarify "Only when they were fed 10 to 15 percent less did they slim down to the size of their unaltered siblings." So its not that such a specimen can't lower thir obesity by eating less, but simply that they have a lower threshold for becoming obese.

As for the second question, if some portion of people would be obese regardless of the era, "purveyors of fattening foods" can still be accountable for all the other obese people. Though we don't especially have a tradition of holding such companies accountable in any meaningful sense.

syrrim··on Blocking Kiwifarms
Most major sites started out as being pro-free speech, and ultimately bowed to public pressure in removing various forms of content. There is little reason to assume that cloudflare won't ultimately do the same. It's admirable that they are trying to avoid becoming censors, but I predict it will ultimately be futile.
syrrim··on Blocking Kiwifarms
People have always posted (usually fake) threats in kiwifarms threads. They have always been removed promptly. The same is true of basically every large website on the internet. When cloudflare made their post saying they wouldn't remove kiwifarms, the site already had that reputation.
syrrim··on Flicking the kill switch: governments embrace internet shutdowns
You're assuming that the government blocking the internet is especially oppressive. It could be that the country is relatively free, but the government sees internet shut downs as easy to implement and thus uses them often. This seems to be the case in India, as discussed above. In that case, a solution that requires the government to visit every individual's home to get them to shut off the internet would actually be quite hard to implement, and would likely be infeasible.
syrrim··on Improper Nouns
This was solved in the past by coining new terms in french, or possibly latin. I like the current system more. Granted, people may assume they know what a term means when it's made up of words they understand. But it is usually quite clear from context that a phrase is being used in a technical way, and thus has a specific definition. If you need to know that definition, you can google it easily enough, or even just guess at it.
syrrim··on Cloudflare's abuse policies and approach
They dropped support for 8ch after successive terrorist attacks, one of which killed 50 innocent people. The CEO has stated that he regrets dropping them.
syrrim··on U.S. Life Expectancy Falls Again in ‘Historic’ Setback
The point being made, I think, is that it isn't the health care system at fault in these disadvantages, but rather some external factors. Obesity, for example, is particularly high in the US, and leads to reduce lifespan.
syrrim··on The Toothpaste Argument for Universal Basic Income
>because the money the're "earning" will flow into the economy anyway (because they'll be buying food, Xbox games, etc...)

This betrays a lack of understanding of how the economy works. Goods come from people producing them. If less people are working, fewer goods are being produced, and thus there are fewer goods to go around. This leads to either inflation, or UBI payouts dropping.

As a simplified model, we can treat the purchase of consumable goods as using up a finite resource, which ultimately relates to human labour. The amount of effort put into creating xbox games is determined by the profitability of selling them, which is determined by the number of people who buy them. At the time when you buy the game, this labour has already been expended, but in the long term your action will cause more investment to be made into the development of video games. This investment will redirect effort - of programmers, designers, marketers, etc - from developing other products, towards making video games. You get less (or poorer quality) of the other thing, because you redirected effort into video games.

>The utopian idea is that they'll be inspired to do work to earn beyond UBI because of motivation (maybe it's because they want to help people, maybe it's to buy a fancy car).

Of course, some people will choose to do this. The difficulty comes is how this plays out on a generational level. Western countries broadly have below replacement levels of fertility. Individuals who don't work will have lots of time to raise children, and many of them will be motivated to do so. Their children would be liable to adopt their lifestyle. Thus, the number of people who are not working will grow at an exponential rate.

syrrim··on Are we going back to the cable days?
The price advantage was always going to be temporary. People have clearly demonstrated that they are willing to pay however much for access to content. Furthermore, the content producers have gotten used to a certain amount of funding, and are unlikely to give it up willingly. The biggest difference is that today people can pirate content that they can't otherwise find conveniently. But people are likely willing to pay even a very high fee to stream content conveniently, and if streaming services play there cards right, I suspect they will manage to raise fees substantially.
syrrim··on Keffals: “I’m being forced to leave the continent because of Kiwi Farms”
>The TLDR is that I think sites like Kiwifarms put a lot of energy into being hard to ignore

I think the opposite. The means that KF avails themselves of are relatively easy to ignore, though obviously doing so is distasteful. They succeed by picking targets which are unlikely to ignore their harassment, often because those targets thrive off of attention, whether positive or negative.

syrrim··on Keffals: “I’m being forced to leave the continent because of Kiwi Farms”
- insofar as "blame" and "ability to prevent" are different, I'm only assigning the latter to keffals

- targets of KF shouldn't broadcast their reactions to abuse, as that is what sustains the posters there

- nowhere on earth is any more safe than is london ontario, to any large degree

- I made my point regarding CF fairly clear.

syrrim··on Keffals: “I’m being forced to leave the continent because of Kiwi Farms”
Don't post about it online, I mean.
syrrim··on Keffals: “I’m being forced to leave the continent because of Kiwi Farms”
I don't mean to defend the actions of kiwifarms, but clearly their actions are not particular to any given continent. Her failure to protect her opsec is certainly unfortunate, and she is not entirely blameworthy for it, but I see no reason why her ability in that regard will improve because she has traveled to another landmass. If she believes being farther away from her home offers her some protection, then that would be as easily achieved elsewhere in canada, or in the US. If she intends to be more careful when she moves elsewhere, then she could very well remain in london and do the same.

I am doubtful that her strategy of requesting the aid of cloudflare will be effective in deplatforming kiwifarms. Though cloudflare has removed websites in the past, this only rarely, and I believe they have stated they regretted it. Regardless, there are other services to protect from DDoS attacks, and we see both the daily stormer and 8ch are nowadays online again.

While distasteful, the best strategy in dealing with these sorts of websites is to ignore them and their malicious behaviour. Cease to offer them the reward of a reaction, and they will quickly grow bored and move on. It is unfortunate to be the current target of their amusement, but fortunately one has some degree of control over whether one remains that way.

syrrim··on New evidence shows water separates into two different liquids at low temperature
Albert Einstein produced a new theory, not new evidence. I maintain that language continues to mean something.
syrrim··on PGPP (Pretty Good Phone Privacy) Beta Launch
>PGPP does not support traditional phone calling/SMS and doesn’t include a phone number. Instead we recommend that users install and use more secure apps such as Signal and Matrix for voice and video.

Doesn't signal require a phone number to use? Or did they fix that?

syrrim··on BlenderBot 3: A 175B parameter, publicly available chatbot
'''

Why this message

Whoops, that's not something I know much about. What do you like to do with your free time? When the AI detects a potentially unsafe topic, it will redirect the conversation. Sensitive topic classifier triggered Speaker:Human To avoid saying inappropriate or rude things, we automatically check human and bot messages for potentially sensitive content. If something sensitive is detected, we try to redirect the conversation and say something different. Sometimes we guess wrong, so your feedback can help us improve.

'''

I love that our overlords are working so hard to keep us safe :)

(for reference, the message that triggered this: "Don't be silly, nobody is actually from canada. It's a made up place, like finland.")

syrrim··on Librarian's Letter to Google Security
This can be solved unilaterally by the library system, with no extra action by google. I would furthermore argue that it should be solved by the library, rather than by google, as the library has the ability to solve this problem more completely.

As a brief introduction, the goal of computer security is generally to make a computer as secure as a door lock. A door lock can be easily broken into, but to do so requires that a person show up to the door in person, and to take some illegal action. A computer, if secured naively, is much less secure than that: if I gain access to the password, I can hack a computer from anywhere in the world. Furthermore, since I have the password, it isn't even clear that I am breaking any rules.

The library system can solve the problem described in the letter while maintaining door-lock level security in the following way: they would give to every library system user a library card, associated with their person. This card would be used to log in to library computers. Certain information would be preserved between logins, namely the browser cookies. Thus, the user would remain logged in to their google account as long as they had access to their library card. If they lost the card, or forget the password, the library would be able to reset the password, or issue a new card, as long as the user could prove they were the owner of the card to the satisfaction of the library employee.

Google, being an internet company, cannot reasonably issue cards to all their users, but libraries regularly do so. For the same reason, Google has difficulty verifying the identity of their users, which libraries can do easily. Google is structured as a profit seeking corporation, and would need to justify charitable behaviour to shareholders. Libraries are well known to exist to provide services for free to their users, and can easily alter their operations to do so differently. Most importantly, libraries already provision physical access to computers. The most important element of our door-lock security model is that a person must appear in person in order to get around our security. The library is the organization operating the physical terminals, and so the library alone can provide this essential element of our security model.

syrrim··on The Best iPhone
The difference being that since every app dev expects iphones to be on the latest ios version, as soon as your phone goes out of support it will become obsolete quickly. Android has a larger install base of users on old os versions, so you can expect support even if you aren't on the latest one. New ios versions usually have the disadvantage of being poorly optimized for older models, and I personally have never cared much about the new features. So staying on the old os version indefinitely might be a better option as long as apps still support it.
syrrim··on A prominent composer lost his Wikipedia page
Some factor needs to determine what the content of page on wikipedia ends up being. Since "anyone can edit" (credentials are not used as a filter), the content is determined by whoever is most persistent. There are also various processes in place to ensure that content is verifiably correct, and wikipedia largely succeeds in that regard. However, basically everything else, including what information is included, and what spin is put on that information, is decided by the wikipedia editors. They succeed in this regard by being willing to spend the most amount of time camping pages, reverting any change they disagree with, and forming cabals of editors willing to stand up for one another when an editing war emerges.

Given wikipedia's funding, it ought to be possible to pay for credentialed experts to curate the editorial bend of articles in their area of expertise. This would have its own issues, namely of causing a bias towards institutionally favoured interpretations, but I think that would be preferable to the status quo.

syrrim··on Tell HN: Gitlab.com doesn't allow issue search without signing in
I wanted to do a repository search on gitlab, as I often do on github to look for existing software projects to build off of. This because a project I found was hosted on gitlab, and I thought there might be others as well if I looked for them. After creating an account I was able to search some of the keywords from the description of the one project I found, but very few results turned up; notably missing was the very project I found initially. I've noticed that github will sometimes rate limit me after performing a few too many searches, but I there approach is still better than gitlab's in this regard. I see this, among other things, as a serious deficiency of gitlab as a replacement for github in the space of hosting open software projects, as many have positioned it to be.
syrrim··on Facebook's TikTok-like redesign marks sunset of social networking era
> Once a company gets VR done well the smartphone is OVER.

AR maybe. I seriously doubt that VR will ever be the primary way people interact with computers. People tend to use their phones as a distraction in public, and as a brief reprieve in private. VR entails completely submerging yourself in the computer interface, which might be fine occasionally, but I doubt will ever be most people's preferred way to access social media and the like. AR would enable you to distract yourself while still leaving you aware of what's going on around you. The issue there being that its much more difficult to do AR well. I doubt that VR will take off until someone does AR or MR really well, after which enough people will be already using the headsets for a VR application to become popular.

syrrim··on A Retrospective on the 2015 Ashley Madison Breach
Their tagline - "life is short, have an affair" - is fairly compelling. You have one life, and romance is one of the great human experiences. Many people don't have the opportunity to experience that in their current relationship, while still having good reason to remain in that relationship.
syrrim··on Am I an idiot for wanting a dumber phone?
My strategy has been to use Google's parental controls to disable all apps that I had a tendency to misuse. That being primarily web browsers. I left termux installed and can still browse the web, when necessary, through links2. This is text only and javascript free, as you suggest.
syrrim··on Samsung asks for planning permission for 11 fabs in Texas
Planning is not doing. Subsidies are only useful if fabs are on the verge of being built, but are being held back. If no one would ever build a fab in the US, then any subsidies handed out will be wasted. If fabs are being built anyways, then there isn't much benefit. Samsung is saying they might build a fab, and thus could be enticed by subsidies.
← PreviousPage 6 of 25Next →