HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

sytse

12,257 karma · joined December 15, 2009

I'm a co-founder and executive chair of GitLab https://about.gitlab.com/ and co-founder of Kilo Code. More information about me is on http://sytse.com/ I'm also a general partner at Open Core Ventures https://opencoreventures.com/ (portfolio companies are listed on the website)
submissionscomments
sytse··on GitHub’s new offer closely matches that from GitLab
I agree, thanks for the numbers. I'll suggest to incorporate this into our Q2 OKRs.

For our references please see https://storage.googleapis.com/sitespeed-results-gitlab/gitl... and https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/engineering/performance/

sytse··on GitHub’s new offer closely matches that from GitLab
That is a great suggestion. GitLab has burn-down charts https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/project/milestones/burndown_... that show that progress isn't linear.

What is small change we can make to stress planning has error bands without affecting the usability?

sytse··on GitHub’s new offer closely matches that from GitLab
Just making sure that you are aware that GitLab supports sizing and estimations via weights https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/project/issues/issue_weight....
sytse··on GitHub’s new offer closely matches that from GitLab
I was doing iteration office hours https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5e-6R5NWl0 :)
sytse··on GitHub’s new offer closely matches that from GitLab
For self-hosted instances you can use Advanced Global Search https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/search/advanced_global_searc... to do this. Please note that this requires installation of Elastic Search. It used to be a paid feature but I think we recently open sourced it.
sytse··on GitHub’s new offer closely matches that from GitLab
I think time tracking in GitLab originated as a way to track time if you're working for multiple clients, but I'm not sure.
sytse··on GitHub is now free for teams
Thanks, good point, we're looking at changing this.
sytse··on GitHub is now free for teams
Thanks for the kind words!

For developers everywhere competition is great. We recently made 18 new features free and open source https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2020/03/30/new-features-to-cor... and today Github with an improved free plan and their team plan came down to the exact same price as our most affordable plan. BTW Maybe an idea to rename their lowest tier from team, may we suggest bronze? :)

Since you mentioned contrasting here is a quick take on the features that you lose if you go from a GitHub Pro account to a Free account, I got the list from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22867974 :

    Protected branches in private repos => Free on GItLab
    Draft PRs in private repos => Free on GItLab
    GitHub Pages in private repos (using 1) => => Free on GItLab
    Wikis in private repos => Free on GItLab
    Code owners in private repos => Bronze on GItLab
    Multiple issue assignees in private repos => Bronze on GItLab
    Multiple PR assignees in private repos => Bronze on GItLab
    Code review automatic assignment in private repos => ?
    Scheduled reminders in private repos => TODOs are free on GitLab
    Standard support => Bronze on GitLab
For a complete comparison across all the stages (like monitor and defend) please see https://about.gitlab.com/devops-tools/github-vs-gitlab.html
sytse··on Honeypot as a Service
This is a great early detection mechanism for malware.

Providers like Crowdstrike https://www.crowdstrike.com/ already aggregate results of malware scans for customers.

This is different because it is National CSIRT of the Czech Republic and because it is a honeypot, it will let the attacker use more commands.

sytse··on Blohm and Voss BV 141
Wow, that is even better. Thanks!
sytse··on Blohm and Voss BV 141
And I assume it is safer because to distance between them engines is smaller than it would be if neither was mounted in front of the cockpit.
sytse··on Dragonfly, an Open-Source P2P-Based Image and File Distribution System
I agree a more prominently placed comparison with other P2P applications would be helpful.

BTW There is a comparison with Bit-Torrent in the FAQ https://github.com/dragonflyoss/Dragonfly/blob/master/FAQ.md...

sytse··on CDC Now Recommends “Use of Cloth Face Coverings” (DIY Masks)
https://www.cato.org/blog/against-noble-lie-covid-19-edition

"Research shows that during disasters, people can show strikingly altruistic behavior, but interventions by authorities can backfire if they fuel mistrust or treat the public as an adversary rather than people who will step up if treated with respect. Given that even homemade masks may work better than no masks, wearing them might be something to direct people to do while they stay at home more, as we all should."

sytse··on Dolt is Git for data
The article was published with https://www.dolthub.com/blog/2020-03-30-dolt-use-cases/ and here is the short HN thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22751209
sytse··on Gitlab features that are moving to open source
If people submit the code to do this I'm supportive. Feel free to ping me on Twitter when you have the code.
sytse··on Dolt is Git for data
Thanks for your answer!
sytse··on Gitlab features that are moving to open source
Thanks for asking. Right now we have one label accepting merge requests and then labels by tier. Does it work to filter on two labels? Or are we not consistent in labeling the tier? Another option would be to have an accepting merge request label per tier. But this might cause other problems, such as getting out of date when we change the tier before the feature is made.
sytse··on Gitlab features that are moving to open source
Awesome! Getting your support emails converted into issues so you can work on them as a team tends to make it much clearer who is handling what.
sytse··on Gitlab features that are moving to open source
Thanks for asking Drew and congrats the rapid progress on sourcehut.

Yes, we actually started by making making Enterprise Edition actually open source. When we announced there would be a proprietary part of GitLab people mentioned that Wordpress plugins where able to make it work with an open source license. It was a comment on https://about.gitlab.com/releases/2013/08/22/introducing-git... but the comments there seem to have disappeared. So instead of making it proprietary we licensed it with an open source license but without offering a download, you had to pay to get access to the source code (this is similar to the Wordpress plugins and also not unlike Red Hat Enterprise Linux updates).

We were afraid that people would put up a mirror with the paid code, this didn't happen. But our customers told us that it was hard to justify paying for open source code, they got lots of questions from their managers. So we switched to making the additional features proprietary.

We tried charging for support but it is hard to make enough margin to be able to invest in the things we wanted (scalability, security, library upgrades, easy of use, etc.). People tended to cancel after they didn't use support for a year. I believe that most companies charging only for support are tempted to make the product harder to use to increase the need for support. More about the business models we tried can be found on https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2018/11/09/monetizing-and-bein...

sytse··on Dolt is Git for data
Very cool! The world needs better version control for data.

How does this compare to something like Pachyderm?

How does it work under the covers? What is a splice and what does it mean when it overlaps? https://github.com/liquidata-inc/dolt/blob/84d9eded517167eb2...

Is it feasible to use Conflict-free Replicated Data Types (CRDT) for this?

sytse··on Gitlab features that are moving to open source
I totally agree we shouldn't call it open source if we mean proprietary and source available. We changed the classification of our company from open source to open core a while ago https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2016/07/20/gitlab-is-open-core... Sorry for the inconsistency in this thread.
sytse··on Gitlab features that are moving to open source
Yes, free users with private repos have the same functionality as is in the Core edition of GitLab self-managed, the open source feature set. Free users using a public repo additionally get all proprietary features.
sytse··on Maltego – open-source intelligence and graphical link analysis tool
It says it is open source but I have a hard time finding the code. https://github.com/paterva/maltego-trx looks like something much more basic.
sytse··on Zoom needs to clean up its privacy act
Zoom decided to remove the Facebook SDK in their iOS client https://blog.zoom.us/wordpress/2020/03/27/zoom-use-of-facebo... fixing this issue.
sytse··on Lasts Longer (2.0)
I made the same mistake. I insisted that a phone with 50% of the price had 80% of the functionality. That is true but you shouldn't see it relative to other phones but relative to other purchases. Since a smartphone is amazing value for money (low $ per hour used) the rational thing is to buy a top of line model.
sytse··on GitHub shuts off access to Aurelia repository, citing trade sanctions
GitLab CEO here, thanks Nat for doing everything you can do to keep open source accessible around the world. We have to comply with the same restrictions and respect greatly that GitHub is taking the broadest possible interpretation of US sanctions law to help users.
sytse··on NPM Is Joining GitHub
It is exciting to see that having everything in a single application is being validated by GitHub. Last year it was very clear they are switching from a marketplace model to a single application by including Verify (CI), Package, and Secure.

We think Git(Lab|Hub) will become the two most popular solutions and we look forward to this competition https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/leadership/biggest-risks/#...

I think the companies that should be nervous are ones that have only one stage or ones that have multiple stages but as a suite of applications instead of a single application https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/product/single-application... There are a lot of these https://about.gitlab.com/devops-tools/

sytse··on NPM Is Joining GitHub
Thanks for that clarification, I was not aware of that. Thanks RubyCentral!
sytse··on NPM Is Joining GitHub
Thanks to Microsoft/GitHub for this acquisition. NPM is essential to the Javascript eco-system and it is hard to have a business model for just a registry. In the ruby eco-system the awesome Ruby Together https://rubytogether.org/ was started to run the registry. In this case one of the worlds most valuable companies will run it, which means it doesn't need a not-for-profit.

Regarding "trace a change from a GitHub pull request to the npm package version that fixed it" will there be an API to add a source in case the change was made outside of GitHub? Although I recognize that the vast majority of changes to npm packages happen on GitHub.

sytse··on Cyclecar
A modern implement would be the Dutch Carver https://www.motorauthority.com/news/1029074_carver-one-tilt-...
← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →