HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

szemet

1,146 karma · joined October 20, 2015

submissionscomments
szemet··on What's the ultimate way to defy depression, disease and early death? Exercise
Ok, but if you plan to do something(not just excercise) regularly, maybe it is better not to calculate with the initial costs/benefits but with the long term averages...

There are plenty of activities in life that initially only have costs and zero benfits - excercise at least consumes calories from day 1...

szemet··on What's the ultimate way to defy depression, disease and early death? Exercise
https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=male+80+kg+1+hour+runn... = 1050 calories
szemet··on [dead]
How this related to the Universal quantum simulator of Feynman?

As I understood, it has been proved that it could simulate every quantum system with linear overhead...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_simulator

szemet··on Molinillo: a dependency resolution algorithm
Also there is zypper, the package manager of OpenSUSE and SLES. That's where I first heard about this usage of SAT, around 10 years ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZYpp
szemet··on Review of Jean Bricmont's book "Making Sense of Quantum Mechanics"
suitable as a visual aid

Especially the somewhat related silicon droplet videos on youtube, e.g.: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WIyTZDHuarQ

szemet··on Ask HN: What are some geeky wrist watches?
DIY? Found this: https://github.com/carrotIndustries/pluto

But they've made different design decision:

Q: Why is there no accelerometer? A: Accelerometers are the most useful when they're permanently active for applications like sleep trackers, pedometers or features like "shake to do something". Unfortunately, even accelerometers marketed as "ultralow power" draw approx 30 µA when running, draining the CR2016 coin cell in less than half a year. So we decided to dedicate the available space to a digital compass.

szemet··on Why religion is not going away and science will not destroy it
Science is based on "methodological naturalism" - assuming that everything in nature have natural causes.

This is the framework where science is made - it is not necessary to believe that it is true (that's called "metaphysical naturalism"), just work by the assumption.

That's why there can be religious scientists. They apply methodological naturalism at work (they explain everything without appealing to the supernatural), but they maybe believe in virgin birth / resurrection / other miracles, so they actually believe that naturalism in the metaphysical sense is false.

The successes of science may provide some confirmation that naturalism may be true in reality but of course can't prove it undoubtedly. But in practice it may work in this way: http://www.pewforum.org/2009/11/05/scientists-and-belief/

szemet··on People believe in evolution, just not for humans
It would be stupid not to believe evolution for humans but believe it for all other species. I'm not american but pretty sure that this can't be the standard liberal view.

What is my view (and perhaps many others share it), is that human life is simply lived in a different abstraction level. Like when you program, you work with numbers and text and logical values and usually you do not have to care that there are electrons down there. You can express things at this abstraction level, that could not be understand by any human using just the lower physical level. E.g. most of the time you just can't fix an operating system bug with a screwdriver...

Similarly, in my everyday personal life I usually work with my emotions, thoughts etc. For example if I have a desire for family or child, even if I know, that the physical implementation of this desire have an undoubtedly strong evolutionary origin, I don't work on that low level, why should I? I could decide what to do with my desire at the same high level where it appears to me (as I would would fix most OS bugs in the source code), even if I would never heard about evolution - as did many people before Darwin.

Of course every true fact can be useful sometimes, and social problems may be handled at the evolutionary level too. But I'm not sure how far it could get us. We may (should?) experiment, but social darwinism have a bad reputation since the WWII, and it is hard to do anything against this. (Maybe the large business behind genetic engineering will change the picture...)

szemet··on Don’t Fall for Babylonian Trigonometry Hype
He strongly objects to the use of infinity and proofs and mathematics that involve it, which includes real numbers

He is not alone, this is a known branch of mathematics called finitism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finitism

szemet··on Pakistani province plants one billion trees to slow down global warming effects
'according to a new study published in Nature, it turns out that the oldest trees are actually still growing rapidly, and storing increasing amounts of carbon as they age' http://science.time.com/2014/01/15/study-shows-older-trees-a...
szemet··on Brief thoughts on the “Google memo”
One part is ok. This is not mainly about facts but value systems:

For example we can decide as a society that everybody born with equal rights, and some rights are inalienable, and work out the logical consequences. On this level differences do not matter (this is exactly the content of our value proposition). But this value proposition is not against the knowledge of the differences.

Knowledge may matter:

Factual knowledge of differences can help towards your goals independently of the nature of these goals. If your goals are equal representation - facts help, if it is to suppress people than these facts also help. Facts do not have goals and can be equally useful for morally different goals.

szemet··on Not even wrong: Why does nobody like pilot-wave theory? [pdf]
On the other hand objective randomness is a black box. You can describe how it behaves at the surface level (so functionally it is usable), but by definition you can't have a finite model of it, so what is inside? No answer by definition - something infinite.

So why X happens instead of Y?

1. Let's propose an unexplainable, unmodellable infinite entropy source under everything

vs.

2. X happens and so do Y, and one is observed at a certain probability due to anthropic principle - like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9R5OWh7luL4

The first is somehow psychologically less satisfying answer for me, although - of course - I accept that calculation works either way. The second at least not an unimaginable infinite, and in the end leaves me with less "why?".

szemet··on 10 page anti-diversity screed circulating internally at Google
Yes. It is the is-ought [1] distinction. People differences may be a biological fact, but this factual knowledge does not informs us what to do with it. We can do then anything: amplify it, suppress it, or don't care

"Natural"[2] - if it has any meaningful definition at all - is not an ethical category. Evolution is not normative.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is–ought_problem

[2] For example for a naturalist everything is natural :)

szemet··on The case against Kotlin
"90% of the developers think that they're better than average"

Median. It can happen that 90% of programmers literally better than the average.

szemet··on American Runners Have Never Been Slower
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14862901
szemet··on American Runners Have Never Been Slower
'It has been a popular belief that the increase of the average marathon finish time is due to the fact that participating in running competitions is gaining popularity. With the popularity increase, the number of not so fit participants rises, and the average finish time increases.

This argument is not exhaustive.

Let alone that in the last two years (2015 and 2016) numbers of participants are declining and the finish time in all the four major race distances is still growing.'

This is a wrong argument. It is enough if just running in general gains popularity. If you take races as a sample from the running population the sample size does not mean that much - the average/median/percentile performance of the sample (if it is representative) may follow the performance of the whole running population!

This is the case for example if the racing population is a uniform random sample. But it may even happen that nowadays larger proportion of slower runners are going to races - because races are much more advertised/known for the hobby joggers than in the past, while elite runners were there always...

szemet··on Why I’m Learning Perl 6
"The concurrency stories for Erlang and Go are front and center, very well defined, and obvious."

GHC Haskell basically have the same concurrency story (since ghc 7.0.1 - 16 November 2010 [1]):

- You can start ten or even hundred thousands of threads

- Inside them you can program like having synchronous I/O

- And the runtime handles it efficiently (with epoll/kqueue/...)

The difference is that haskell is less opinionated on the high level concurrency primitives, so you have many choices (sometimes with multiple different library implementations) like: locking, explicit async code, transactional memory, channels... https://hackage.haskell.org/packages/#cat:Concurrency

[1] Release Notes: "On POSIX platforms, there is a new I/O manager based on epoll/kqueue/poll, which allows multithreaded I/O code to scale to a much larger number (100k+) of threads" https://downloads.haskell.org/~ghc/7.0.1/docs/html/users_gui...

szemet··on How Life and Death Spring from Disorder
A short summary as I understand:

Imagine you write a '1' bit to a memory location - now you know for sure that the location contains '1' now, as you can check it anytime. But now you have absolutely no information about the past, either it was '1' before or '0'. So the number of legal states (and entropy) seemingly have decreased if you are considering this bit level macrostate. But according to the 2nd law the global entropy never decreases, so at least an equal entropy increase eventually should be there somewhere in the system (in the microstates - the states you did not considered as logically separate) - for example as a small heat increase.

szemet··on How Life and Death Spring from Disorder
By overwriting old information it is still being erased and lost - so the Landaur's principle holds, some explanation is here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landauer%27s_principle
szemet··on Ask HN: What's the worst thing your code has done?
Maybe. It is also possible that better knifes cause less but more serious accidents, and then it is hard to compare the two. But I stop now, because what we have now are just plausible hypotheses without any real evidence - theoretical knife science waiting for confirmation... ;)
szemet··on Ask HN: What is preventing rust from replacing c/c++?
A big difference is that Rust has a zero overhead interop with C, so it it allows mixed projects or gradual porting.

So Scala or Kotlin replacing Java, or F# replacing C# may be a better analogy. What happens there, is that Java and C# are improving just enough that many people are simply not considering the change... And C++ are trying really hard nowadays too - new version with interesting features every few years etc...

(By the way - I'm a Rust fan, and also a functional programming fan, so I would be happy if C++, C#, Java would slow down a little to let the alternatives really catch up popularity;)

szemet··on Ask HN: What's the worst thing your code has done?
Then you did not want to hurt anyone.

Imagine someone who works as a knife grinder. If he do his job right the knifes will be much more dangerous, they may cause accidents or even some will be used intentionally as a deadly weapon.

Then considering these possibilities: an ethical knife grinder should do a shitty job, should quit, or should live in self-reproach?

It may be more complicated if you are a gunsmith. But those guns are used by your customers - so in what extent your ethical evaluation will depend on their actions in this case?

For example if your guns are used in an arming race, and eventually they help avoiding war then you are a saint? If your guns are used in a victorious war then you are a hero? And if they are used for killing innocents then you are an evil person? Or you should be judged by the average probabilities of the global gun usage? Or what?

szemet··on It’s Complicated: Unraveling the mystery of why people act as they do
Science needs only methodological naturalism not metaphysical naturalism.

There are religious scientists - they personally believe that miracles exist so they oppose the real methaphysical naturalism but they assume naturalism during work (that is the methodolical kind), and that is enough for progress, science doesn't care.

szemet··on Thermodynamic Asymmetry in Time (2016)
only in the same way, and to the same extent

Yes, but entropy can make it asymetrical - in practice past usually have less legal states (a lower entropy point) than the future.

Past and future can be completely encoded by the direction of entropy change, if we start from, or end in one legal state.

(You can exactly tell the past of the Logo turtle (or something similar physical thing) by following its trajectory line. You can have an inverse turtle that follows and erase an existing line, then you can tell its future, but not its past by looking only its present state)

This kind of entropy increase is very common in human life - like forming memories, filling empty screens and white papers with signs, leaving footsteps in the snow etc... So the subjective feeling of asymetry is not completely ungrounded.

szemet··on On C-optimizing compilers removing code that has undefined behavior
Here the first answer says (with some quotations) that it depends on, if the variable could be declared as register or not.

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/11962457/why-is-using-an...

edit: i recognised that it does not count as the original example is about an array element...

szemet··on On C-optimizing compilers removing code that has undefined behavior
Undefined behaviour was always there to make possible compilers to optimize as they like (nowadays usually for speed or to ease porting to specific architectures) - that is the essence of C "portable assembly" mentality and it always was. Am I wrong?

I tolally agree that this is a bad mentality for software developement in general, but at least it is the "authentic C way" so I feel that part of the critics ungrounded...

szemet··on A link between video games and unemployment
I don't agree. As I understand these things:

You are mindful and react on direct stimulus - while gaming, you do not think on future or past, you are immersed in your actual activity - it IS mindfulness.

BUT it does not improve mindfulness - it is easy to be mindful at interesting times - that's normal, but not so when nothing interesting is around, and you are just left alone with your own thoughts or problems. Thats what various mindfulness practices trying to improve - to be mindful in common "boring" or bad situations too.

And like for any improvements you usually have to make some effort - not just do something when it is natural.

szemet··on Oh My Gosh, It’s Covered in Rule 30s
There were multiple different assumptions why Rule 30 was used, if I think neither is a good reason to use it to tribute Conway, why couldn't I answer them one by one?

It is just my opinion - it is not hard science but art, so maybe no one can be right here: you can just choose not to read my comments if you anticipate in advance that you will disagree ;)

edit: By the way they not said "inspired" by GoL but that they derived the pattern from it. I admit I'm not a native english speaker but I feel some difference... For you if it is the same, or it is fine "pedagogically" then good for you.

szemet··on Oh My Gosh, It’s Covered in Rule 30s
https://www.quora.com/Why-do-post-modern-artists-question-au...
szemet··on Oh My Gosh, It’s Covered in Rule 30s
Yeah that's the problem with unconstrained things: http://dilbert.com/strip/2001-10-25

(Ok-ok, I know it is just a fun comment, but just to be serious anyway for the sake of truth:

you can think of how likely that this is a GoL pattern: take the set of all imaginable GoL patterns, at all timestep, and check how frequent is this subpattern then, compared to some combination of some common/well-know patterns, like these: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conway%27s_Game_of_Life#Exampl... )

← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →