HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

szemet

1,146 karma · joined October 20, 2015

submissionscomments
szemet··on Oh My Gosh, It’s Covered in Rule 30s
So is it a hack? Simply: a Shakespeare festival with T.S. Eliot can get much more press coverage?

People like "alternative facts" - both on the believer and the debater side, so give em' what they want for fun and profit? :) That is a fine point, but I simply do not like the value system behind it: to be ignorant or pretend to be ignorant because that's what people like

szemet··on Oh My Gosh, It’s Covered in Rule 30s
Ok but anyway, either they were ignorant or they simply lied in the press release. Choose freely what shows the project members in a better light! (Neither? ;)

My initial quotation was this from the press release:

The architects said the aluminium design is derived from John Conway's Game of Life 'cellular automaton',

http://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/news/cambridge-news/could-ca...

You can't protect this with some kind of "we all come from gogol's overcoat", mentality. If it is true then they should have put a Gogol image there! ;)

szemet··on Oh My Gosh, It’s Covered in Rule 30s
Ok. So they are not ignorant or stupid, but have a twisted value system?

Imagine that you go to a Shakespeare festival but they only recite T. S. Eliot. When you are disappointed, they say:

"Look these are all poems. They are very similar on the surface, but Eliot somehow sounds better to the modern ear. Long live Shakespeare!"

szemet··on Oh My Gosh, It’s Covered in Rule 30s
Like what?

They decided meanwhile that they would like to celebrate Wolfram instead?

Or is there any artistic value to celebrate someone with other persons achievements? Some kind of twisted post-modern artistic message about authorship?

Or it looks better for them? For example: lets pay tribute to Amundsen reaching the South pole with polar bear images (because they are so cute)?

By Occam razor: ignorance is the best explanation. ;)

szemet··on Oh My Gosh, It’s Covered in Rule 30s
cladding which is derived from John Horton Conway's 'Game of Life'

Strange that no one was there to tell them they are wrong. Anyway, how could they get it wrong in the age of Internet? Every bit of information about 'Game of Life' is one click away... :( Agree - that's sad...

szemet··on Quantum Approaches to Consciousness (2015)
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/other-minds/
szemet··on Diet Drinks are not killing you
A causal relation definitely exists in the other way around: people with diabetes are encouraged to consume less sugar... This may explain large part of the correlation.
szemet··on How We Realized Putting Radium in Everything Was Not the Answer (2013)
I not understand what you mean by this. We always had those. Do you believe in the existence of:

- computers solving the generic halting problem

- perpetual motion devices

- faster than light communication

I guess no, because based upon our current knowledge of physical/logical laws these are nonexistent (impossible) things. And there are many existence proof with the same confidence level. So science have both positive and negative proofs (actually verification is a better term) with similar confidence.

szemet··on What to look for when buying knives (2007)
I use ceramic knives for the very same reason. Guess it doesn't cut it for you if you insist on this: "made out of a really strong metal"
szemet··on At Scale, Rare Events Aren’t Rare
And this is the generalization: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisson_limit_theorem
szemet··on Clr-boot-manager now available in Solus
I've not used it, but afaik Suse linux default install have btrfs+snapper (http://snapper.io) It snapshots before every install and yast configuraton step and have a boot to snapshot feature..
szemet··on Your yearly dose of is-the-universe-a-simulation
That's also means they may have to alter our minds sometimes to avoid expensive computations:

For example a bit contrived example: if we try to find the next Mersenne prime (or something similar, computationally hard but easy to check thing (e.g. anything NP complete)), and we use millions of computers to do that, and the simulators do not have it precomputed already - then the simulators either have to compute it too to provide the proper sensory input (the mersenne prime found) or alter our mind not to do this...

szemet··on Why Complexity is Different
I come up with one for you:

The clear separation of microstates and macrostates in software, through proper abstractions is a key to good software quality.

Unfortunately the lack of abstractions or the prevalence of leaky abstractions, due to bad design and software management practices (e.g. monkey patching) eventually leads many codebases into its critical point. In this critical state small perturbations of microstates (either at development or at runtime) causes unpredictable behavior changes at macroscale level.

So if you ever have wondered why our software quality is worse than the laws of thermodynamics would justify:

Our best physicists are now working on theories based on renormalization groups to exactly describe the expected distribution of blue screens of deaths: To have much better models of how bad our applications are! ;)

szemet··on “Eurocentric modernist” thinking is exploding
Similar propaganda was in my country: the capitalist/imperialist West is falling apart.

Actualy they became rich, and the eastern block falled. 28 years later I still earn one fifth as a western european.

(guess I should be as happy as a Bushman - until those filthy selfish scientist materialist people send modern medicine to my people - and be greatful to God! ;)

szemet··on Go 2016 Survey Results
I guess many people don't have problem with the 'errors are values' concept, just would like to handle them with much less boilerplate: like in Rust or Haskell...
szemet··on “When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.”
"It would take an infinite amount of power to calculate every digit in pi"

Representation by digits is just one representation. We have plenty of finite representations: http://mathworld.wolfram.com/PiFormulas.html

Base 10 notation also requires a calculation to get the concrete number: You have to sum and multiply and power a lot

(Imagine whole numbers described in base 10, now how you get that number of something?)

szemet··on “When we do mathematics, we touch immortality.”
Yes, if you take something like "Minimum Description Length principle", there may exists circles in physical world that are best (most economically) described with a perfect circle + some noise.
szemet··on People who eat 10 portions of fruit and vegetables a day
That's my experience too. When I was a student I have made a linear programming excercise just for fun: to find foodsets with all the required daily nutritions at cheapest price

Basically chicken liver was IT, just a few hundred gramms per day and nearly all requirements are fulfilled. When I've disabled liver, then came some diets much harder to realize: with elements such as 4 kg of oranges a day :)

szemet··on Cheating on a string theory exam
6 bit to win 12 question from the first 18 (group by 3) 5 bit for the remaining 5

17 answer and one bit remained

szemet··on Cheating on a string theory exam
Using this on only 3 questions, you get 2/3 success rate:

000,001,010,100,000 -> buddy signals 0, I write 000

111,110,101,011,111 -> buddy signals 1, I write 111

with 7 bit you definitely win 14 questions from 21

szemet··on Cheating on a string theory exam
Reed Solomon for example? Or anything to increase Hamming distance between legal codes.
szemet··on How the Anti-Vaxxers Are Winning
In my country vaccination rules are rather strict!

But: I've heard many stories about anti-vaxxer parents who managed to bribe doctors to throw out the vaccination but then do the bookkeeping as the if the child were vaccinated.

And this is the worst imaginable setup... :(

Maybe in richer countries, where the doctors are well payed (by the state or whoever enforces the vaccination rules), this would not be a problem...

szemet··on On Loneliness
It is a cultural thing / mentality coming from the enlightenment (in the western sense;) (and for me this is one of the most important legacy of enlightenment): EVERY ideology is (should be) open for criticism

More criticism, more open discussion leads to more (or at least more educated) freedom of choice.

This, of course, may cause bad feelings in the devoted adherents, but that's a price I happily pay! This critical - "no sacred cow" - mentality have done a lot good to the society, and I definitely would not like to live in pre-enlightment times/places.

szemet··on A first look at WebAssembly performance
'the overhead of profiling and applying optimizations has always been greater than any efficiency gains.'

Not necessarily, especially if you explicitly rely on them.

For example in C++ you deliberately have to avoid overusing virtual functions if you don't want the overhead. In Java, virtual functions are the default, and you usually don't care: if you call them a lot (e.g. in a tight loop) JVM will adaptively give you the proper implementation - without per call indirection - or may even inline it.

If you code C++ in Java style then JVM will win - so the overhead of (runtime) profiling and applying optimizations not always greater

szemet··on Grappling with Go
'Put Rust and Go in front of a python coder who wrote dozens of web services using flask - and I am pretty sure I can predict what tool he'll pick'

It depends what part you show. For example Rust has an experimental flask/sinatra/... inspired library (https://rocket.rs/overview/), and although Go has similar things you can't cut boilerplate that much:

So in the end it may depend why someone likes python in the first place: because of the concise high level constructs or because of ease of use.

szemet··on One in five of us may 'hear' flashes of light
Oh, Thanks. When I was a child I asked all the adults around about this, but they looked at me like I were a lunatic, so eventually I just stopped talking about it.... :) Glad to have an answer now.
szemet··on Go and Dogma
Name a language having a compiler that most similar to Go in the threading domain, e.g.:

compiles to machine code

have green threads

use non-blocking IO in the background

have parallel runtime

Haskell is the first that comes to my mind. (I guess that Common Lisp is a safe bet too, as it had everything for ages before it was cool;), but I'm not familiar with that domain to be sure) Erlang have everything except machine code compilation.

What else? I guess the rest is from the newer, lesser known or experimental languages. So is there anything more popular than Haskell?

szemet··on Derek Parfit has died
> That's what Nagel is disputing

We have many many evidence that random mutation is enough for describing the biological evolution on Earth. If the mutation is controlled by someone than it is done according to random distributions as far as we currently know. He should provide evidence if he thinks otherwise but he is not doing it and not qualified for it, thats only what I see.

szemet··on Derek Parfit has died
Ah we don't need this discussion. The rigth answer is in The Library of Babel of Borges.

Guess you can find it easily without much thinking, and then you will see I was right! ;)

szemet··on Derek Parfit has died
> I didn't see any misunderstandings of evolution in the book

The greatest feature of evolution that it makes teleology unnecessary. It can operate as a mindless/goalless algorithm. Of course evolution may be operated by someone/something with specific goals instead of pure chances, but thats just an unnecessary assumption until it proved - so we may employ Occam razor here until someone proves it. The possibility of design without a designer is one of the main point and contribution of the theory and it should be fully understood - even if if later turns out (which have not happened yet, and no sign for that happening beside metaphysical opinions...) that there was a designer.

> of actually existing computers is also extremely complex, and not obviously any less complex than the mapping from these states to physical states of rocks

You can't be serious: First map a Computer chess program states to human interpretable visualization to play chess against it And then do this with your rock.

First is mainly one-to-one mapping of digital signs to pixels by using a static table, the second is..., I'm not even sure how to inject my move into the states of the rock, but no idea either how to extract its response. You know why? There is simply no one to one mapping there. The states of a rock is a large bundle of everything without interpretation, the states of the chess program is CLEARLY more constrained - the proof is empirical: it CAN be implemented.

Like if you say that the set of all positive integers contains the solution of factorizing any large number. Of course it does: you just have to point to those numbers. ;) But how? All states are not the solution - selecting the proper states is the computation, and if those selection mechanism is in the mapping process then the mapping IS the computer.

← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →