HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

szemet

1,146 karma · joined October 20, 2015

submissionscomments
szemet··on Universal Basic Income
1. Then you may limit the economical benefit of the whole thing: people may not just consume using free money but may use it to small investments, produce something etc... Creative usage of money requires flexibility.

2. Secondary market will come: You either criminalize it then it will cost a lot, or not and you just give part of the money to the money changers for a service that could have been easily avoided.

szemet··on Derek Parfit has died
I feel a lot of times that many modern philosophers simply not qualified enough in natural sciences. I've read Mind & Cosmos but gave up halfway: Nagel simply does not get evolution.

Contemporary philosophical discussion many times is like typical forum debates on the Internet about basic science - someone says something stupid and the others try to educate him, he don't get it and write his same stupidity again and again until everybody is tired to reply.

In the academic world this is called publish or perish: if you are a philosopher you should fear more from being forgotten than from proper and decisive falsification - so you just have to be loud, even if you are wrong. If you defend your wrongness skilfully you will have your followers anyway.

But I'm just simply don't interested in whether Nagel will get evolution eventually, or Putnam & Searle get computation sometime in the future* (just to provide another example)

* I thinking about their theory that a rock can implement any computation - if we provide proper mapping between the states, without taking into consideration the complexity of the mapping as part of the "computer" here. It is ok if someone doesn't get Kolmogorov but not clear why they should make a living from it, or at least why should I support it by buying and reading their books. ;)

szemet··on Rust is more than safety
Does the standard force it to be safe? If not, then the parent comment is true: "the same code in C ... can lead to memory unsafety"
szemet··on Pyret – A language exploring scripting and functional programming
Usually when one starts to learn to program already have learned some math. So knows only this notation for funcions: square(x) = x*x

"Return" seems meaningless.

So that is the "real world" function declaration (if this phrase makes any sense for a math notation convention) for a nonprogrammer.

Is that what you mean? Because then I agree...

szemet··on H.264 is Magic
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MPEG-1#B-frames

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MPEG-1#Macroblocks

szemet··on H.264 is Magic
I thought I'll learn something special about H.264, but all information here is high level and generic.

For example if you replace H.264 with a much older technology like mpeg-1 (from 1993) every sentence stays correct, except this:

"It is the result of 30+ years of work" :)

szemet··on Engines of Evidence – A Conversation with Judea Pearl
A good link maybe: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/causation-mani/

Pearl's theory summarized in chapter 5, but it is put into context: related work, criticism, etc...

szemet··on Introducing Rust Language Server
I agree. At least for me it was a common pattern that by fixing a bug I've introduced another (sometimes suprising one), and by fixing that I've introduced another and so on. I would have given it up without strong editor support giving hints on the fly.

(I don't remember similar experiences learning other languages even with strong static checks (e.g. haskell). Either my errors were 1 level deep there, or the propagation of errors (like changing a type somewhere) was easier to follow/predict to me)

szemet··on How fear of nuclear power is hurting the environment
Here they calculate deaths due to maintanence: and it is around 0.02 death / Million MWh (= trillion), which is far far far from 150 deaths. So there may be some kind of iron mining fallacy here to, that I mentioned in my earlier comment... http://dailysignal.com/2010/06/26/wind-power-is-more-dangero...
szemet··on How fear of nuclear power is hurting the environment
Then they have to estimate how big is the market effect of the turbines on mining. It is very very hard, wonder can it be done well enough...

For example: It may even happen (logically possible at least) that stopping building turbines brings down the price but not the demand (others will buy it anyway), and the net effect will be that due to lower prices miners close safer but more expensive mines and reopens cheaper but more dangerous mines.

Once, I've read an estimation where they even calculated deaths due to iron mining, into wind energy deaths!!! They simply added the deaths that may occur mining the needed amount of iron.... Big big mistake, according to what I wrote earlier. Wing turbines hardly have that direct market effect on iron miners life. And because that study (I can't find it now) was sponsored by nuclear power organizations - guess the mistake was intentional - so it was not a "mistake" more like a disgusting ethical crime...

szemet··on How fear of nuclear power is hurting the environment
According to the article 150 people die / trillionWh due to wind power. According to wikipedia 269 birds die / trillionWh due to wind power. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_wind_p...

So the death rate for birds is nearly the same that for people? Seems strange. We can protect clueless birds better from the turbines, than the intelligent and educated working people up there??? Or something is wrong with either of the estimations...

szemet··on The Problem with Modern Romance Is Too Much Choice
Yes that's my point. But 80% below the average can be a valid/true valuation, no logical glitch here: If the "wisdom of the (female) crowd" says that's the case, then it may be true - so I don't see the issue here...

So to clarify - your data says nothing about whether women are judgemental - they may be just realistic ;) If beauty is in the eye of the beholder than how can we argue them?

szemet··on Image unshredding using a TSP solver
To me the whole experiment suggests otherwise:

it shows that naturally occurring images are organized by having similar rows and columns close to each other, which is - by default - good for most compression algorithms that prefer regularities/similarities to be as local as possible.

edit: but it can be good for other cases, where there are no good-enough default orders. For example "customer - product bought" matrix (binary matrix, customer rows, product columns: X customer bought Y product = 1, otherwise =0 ).

Here the order of rows/columns are not predefined, and ordering by similar customers and products the compression of the matrix could be improved. Finding these similarities also can be a good starting point for some recommendation/collaborative filtering engine.

szemet··on The Problem with Modern Romance Is Too Much Choice
Average? That's ok. If it were median there would be some problem here though... ;)

(e.g. If every men is the same, except one who is beautiful, than everybody is below the average but one.)

szemet··on The Limits of Machine Learning
I don't understand why it says "2 * (5 + 1) = 12" fits equally well as "x + 5 + 2 = 12" to the original pattern:

"5 + 2 = 12"

As it changes one of the terms of the original addition (2 to 1). The second solution fits better by my judgment. Changing the the puzzle, seems like a bit of cheating...

szemet··on Meet the Winners of This Year's Ig Nobel Prizes
I've read the commentery of the physics Ig winners (in Hungarian)

First they are happy because of the recognition. ;)

And the essence of their research is that dragonflies and horseflies are attracted to polarized light. Dragonflies mainly identifies water that way. Due to the "polarized light pollution" of black marble they tend to put their eggs on them instead of water which of course disadvantageous to their population.

On the other side, they designed a horsefly trap based on their findings. As horseflies may spread diseases, this can be a practical achievement (if it works).

So it is practical research to save one species and eradicate another one (classical human goals, I guess...) ;)

szemet··on Why I Majored in Philosophy Despite Everyone Telling Me Not To (2013)
Axioms are chosen so that they are evident a priori

Wonder why it took 2000 years to came up with alternatives to the 5th postulate, if all three variants (Euclidean, elliptic, hyperbolic) is so evident apriori?

szemet··on Logical Induction
Its too late, we already risk fortunes (and even lives) trusting in similar methods ;):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primality_test#Probabilistic_t...

(Primality is also a logical (analytic) truth and we are satisfied with probabilistic proofs - of course only because the risk is known and controllable.)

szemet··on Security experts have cloned all seven TSA master keys
Zip tie? Only a ballpoint pen is needed, and you will never know someone messed with your luggage. Definitely easier than any lock... https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wpIJVWXsBBI
szemet··on A Nihilist's Guide to Meaning
Yes. Science based on methodological naturalism (where one only assumes naturalism). But I guess the success of the scientific method may add some support for metaphysical naturalism (where one actually believes that naturalism is true) too.
szemet··on Has Physics Gotten Something Really Important Really Wrong?
What about the rules governing the position of the moon on the sky?

If we switch off all consciousness by giving strong sleeping pills to all humans (animals too? - or is it just you who matters (solipsism)?), will the moon change its position while we are sleeping?

So will your/the consciousness move the world while you/we are unconscious - using some simple and higly regular rules (called physics)?

But if you/we are unconscious, then why on earth should we call that unconscious mover of the world consciousness?

szemet··on Rudolf Kálmán Has Died
There were only a few times in history when it was good/safe to be hungarian - and this meme has a long tradition in hungarian thinking. Just read the national anthem. (It is written in 1823 but it could be easily extended with events from the last 190 years...) http://lyricstranslate.com/hu/himnusz-national-anthem-hungar...
szemet··on Advanced programming languages (2009)
It depends on the context. I guess rayiner has referred to "untyped lambda calculus".

Thats not a bad name as it is self consistent - there are no type expressions in that language. If you say that it is actally "unityped" it is (just) your (semantical) categorization looking at it from a higher level perspective.

Of course on the other side whole numbers were just "number"-s, before fractionals came, so in the end it may be ok to introduce higher level perspective in naming just to diferrentiate better. :)

szemet··on Is Functional Programming really slow?
Purely functional (persistent) data structures which are natural in GC-d functional languages are a research grade topic in C++/Rust. (Edit: AFAIK: It is due to the additional ownership management/bookkeeping required if there are concurrent access and modification.)
szemet··on Ask HN: Transpiling a dynamically typed language to a statically typed language
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HipHop_for_PHP https://www.call-cc.org
szemet··on Nim Programming Language 0.14.0 released
How do you debug ANY compiled language? Every compiler compiles to another language. ;)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compiler "A compiler is a computer program (or a set of programs) that transforms source code written in a programming language (the source language) into another computer language (the target language), with the latter often having a binary form known as object code."

szemet··on Provide Sharp Knives (DHH)
> I’ve yet to hear a single programmer put up their hand and say “I can’t trust myself with this power, please take it away from me!”

I'm not sure... I guess people who prefer static type systems (me included) often have these feelings working with dynamic languages. Or functional programmers using state in imperative languages... ;)

szemet··on The Relativity of Wrong by Isaac Asimov (1989)
If the universe cannot contain infinite amount of information then it follows that there are infinite knowledge we cannot know - simply because we cannot store it anywhere (in brains or computers or anywhere).

For example: exact prime factorization of all natural numbers, etc...

Of course this is true only if you accept induction. So you can still back off by declaring yourself finitist* ;)

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finitism

szemet··on Energy revolution? Grabat introduces its graphene batteries
If it does not heat when short-circuited (as stated), where does the energy go? Does it only change the chemical structure of the battery, or what?
szemet··on The Go binary diet
With UPX the shared page cache for the executable is lost too... So if more then one instance are started the executable have to be loaded multiple times into the memory.

Eg. running 10 instance of a 20Mb Go binary you save some cheap disk space (10Mb maybe?) and lose some expensive RAM space: the worst case if the whole binary is utilized 180Mb.

← PreviousPage 8 of 9Next →