HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ta1243

4,223 karma · joined February 8, 2023

submissionscomments
ta1243··on Replacing a $3000/mo Heroku bill with a $55/mo server
The second by a long shot.

Detecting things are down is far easier than detecting things are slow.

I'd rather that oom started killing things though than a kernel panic or a slow system. Ideally the thing that is leaking, but if not the process using the most memory (and yes I know that "using" is tricky)

ta1243··on Greenland’s national telco, Tusass, signs new agreement with Eutelsat
There's a lot of ground between

Ally (which Greenland and the US were in 2024)

and

Active invasion

Starlink removing service is nowhere near as extreme as America jamming starlink (which would be a breach of international treaties)

ta1243··on Greenland’s national telco, Tusass, signs new agreement with Eutelsat
Starlink is run by a company based in a country which has threatened to invade Greenland, with a CEO who is aligned with the leadership of that country.
ta1243··on What do we do if SETI is successful?
Yes. There's nothing particularly special about visible light

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_radio_emission

ta1243··on Apple alerts exploit developer that his iPhone was targeted with gov spyware
Normally with crime we arrest people. Half the problems in the world seem to stem from the fact companies are unaccountable.
ta1243··on Apple alerts exploit developer that his iPhone was targeted with gov spyware
That gives positive outcomes.

People vote for "leopards eating face" party because they want leopards to eat other peoples faces. You're relying on that party to do something they didn't say (it's not "leopards eat everyone else's face but not yours" party)

If you vote for a party to build a monument, then they build a monument, that's reaping what you sow.

ta1243··on Wikipedia says traffic is falling due to AI search summaries and social video
> This would change if the government stopped taxing retained earnings.

No it wouldn't, because

> the money is still at risk (from a shareholder’s point of view) if something bad happens to the company (lawsuit or market problem).

ta1243··on Tesla is heading into multi-billion-dollar iceberg of its own making
Even in the best case scenario where they were a major global leader in EVs (difficult when you have an American mindset on what a car is), their valuation would still be less than 1/10th what it currently is.
ta1243··on Foreign hackers breached a US nuclear weapons plant via SharePoint flaws
Which really isn't a problem, unless you're being scanned so much your bandwidth is being overwhelmed. Certainly not the case for me, despite having port 80 and 443 open
ta1243··on Tesla is heading into multi-billion-dollar iceberg of its own making
Tesla had no option -- its valuation was based on some massive new gains in software/power/etc, not on being a great car company.
ta1243··on The longest baseball game took 33 innings to win
The rules aren't important. What's important is, it's linear. Every time I throw this ball, a hundred different things can happen in a game. He might swing and miss, he might hit it. The point is, you never know. You try to anticipate, set a strategy for all the possibilities as best you can, but in the end it comes down to throwing one pitch after another and seeing what happens. With each new consequence, the game begins to take shape.
ta1243··on AWS outage shows internet users 'at mercy' of too few providers, experts say
We could connect distributed computers on distributed networks together using some form of internetworking protocol.
ta1243··on AWS outage shows internet users 'at mercy' of too few providers, experts say
> Something like 30% of all internet traffic goes through CloudFront in one way or another. Pretty cool, huh?

No. No its not. But tech enthusiasts on HN and Reddit love it.

(Another 30% runs through cloudflare)

ta1243··on AWS multiple services outage in us-east-1
Relying on AWS is a single point of failure. Not as much as relying on a single AWS region, but it's still a single point.

It's fairly difficult to avoid single points of failure completely, and if you do it's likely your suppliers and customers haven't managed to.

It's about how much your risk level is.

AWS us-east-1 fails constantly, it has terrible uptime, and you should expect it to go. A cyberattack which destroyed AWSs entire infrastructure would be less likely. BGP hijacks across multiple AWS nodes are quite plausible though, but that can be mitigated to an extent with direct connects.

Sadly it seems people in charge of critical infrastructure don't even bother thinking about these things, because next quarters numbers are more important.

I can avoid London as a single point of failure, but the loss of Docklands would cause so much damage to the UK's infrastructure I can't confidently predict that my servers in Manchester connected to peering points such as IXman will be able to reach my customer in Norwich. I'm not even sure how much international connectivity I could rely on. In theory Starlink will continue to work, but in practice I'm not confident.

When we had power issues in Washington DC a couple of months ago, three of our four independent ISPS failed, as they all had undeclared requirements on active equipment in the area. That wasn't even a major outage, just a local substation failure. The one circuit which survived was clearly just fibre from our (UPS/generator backed) equipment room to a data centre towards Baltimore (not Ashburn).

ta1243··on Space Elevator
Zero. By the time you get to GEO your are connected to a station which is in Geostationary orbit. Your 35 hour ascent at say 1000km/h will have accelerated you sideways to the required 3km/second with a sidewards acceleration of 0.002g throughout the trip.

Of course you would be looking at a constant acceleration, not just a 1000km/hour trip. You'd probably be able to do the journey in a couple of hours with a reasonable acceleration and a rotating cabin (say 1.1g, meaning acceleration would slowly increase from about 0.1g at the surface, then after the flip point you'd decelerate at 1.1g). Even then sideways acceleration wouldn't be noticable (and your cabin could gimbal to just add it to vertical acceleration)

That's the other crazy thing. A space elevator takes forever at elevator, or car, or even plane speeds. But with constant acceleration/decelleration you can have a trip in airplane style seats with cabin crew serving you caviar // scratchcards (depending on class of cabin). Your peak vertical speed would be in the region of 8km/second - way above Earth's escape velocity, but you wouldn't even notice the acceleration/deceleration. You'd slow down in under 15 minutes.

Or you wouldn't and you'd depart Earth at 8km/s, twice the escape velocity.

(If you really wanted a fast departure you'd accelerate at say 1.2g and get upto 30km/s, twice the speed of New Horizons. 1.2g would probably mean you'd have the seatbelt on for the whole 40 minute trip)

You could launch cargo to Mars at say 5G, which would get it there in between 10 and 45 days depending where it is. Obviously you'd have a problem slowing down when you got there.

ta1243··on AWS multiple services outage in us-east-1
Fine, our overseas offices are different companies and bills are paid for by different people.

Not that "forgot to pay" is going to result in a cut off - that doesn't happen with the multi-megawatt supplies from multiple suppliers that go into a dedicated data centre. It's far more likely that the receivers will have taken over and will pay the bill by that point.

ta1243··on AWS multiple services outage in us-east-1
Paying for resilience is expensive. not as expensive as AWS, but it's not free.

Modern companies live life on the edge. Just in time, no resilience, no flexibility. We see the disaster this causes whenever something unexpected happens - the Evergiven blocking Suez for example, let alone something like Covid

However increasingly what should be minor loss of resilience, like an AWS outage or a Crowdstrike incident, turns into major failures.

This fragility is something government needs to legislate to prevent. When one supermarket is out that's fine - people can go elsewhere, the damage is contained. When all fail, that's a major problem.

On top of that, the attitude that the entire sector has is also bad. People thing IT should tail once or twice a year and it's not a problem. If that attitude affect truly important systems it will lead to major civil projects. Any civilitsation is 3 good meals away from anarchy.

There's no profit motive to avoid this, companies don't care about being offline for the day, as long as all their mates are also offline.

ta1243··on AWS multiple services outage in us-east-1
You could never run a site like hacker news on a single box somewhere with a backup box a couple of states away.

(/s, obviously)

ta1243··on AWS multiple services outage in us-east-1
> In the end, you live with the fact that your service might be down a day or two per year.

This is hilarious. In the 90s we used to have services which ran on machines in cupboards which would go down because the cleaner would unplug them. Even then a day or two per year would be unacceptable.

ta1243··on AWS multiple services outage in us-east-1
It took me so long to realise this is what's important in enterprise. Uptime isn't important, being able to blame someone else is what's important.

If you're down for 5 minutes a year because one of your employees broke something, that's your fault, and the blame passes down through the CTO.

If you're down for 5 hours a year but this affected other companies too, it's not your fault

From AWS to Crowdstrike - system resilience and uptime isn't the goal. Risk mitigation isn't the goal. Affordability isn't the goal.

When the CEO's buddies all suffer at the same time as he does, it's just an "act of god" and nothing can be done, it's such a complex outcome that even the amazing boffins at aws/google/microsoft/cloudflare/etc can't cope.

If the CEO is down at a different time than the CEO's buddies then it's that Dave/Charlie/Bertie/Alice can't cope and it's the CTO's fault for not outsourcing it.

As someone who likes to see things working, it pisses me off no end, but it's the way of the world, and likely has been whenever the owner and CTO are separate.

ta1243··on AWS multiple services outage in us-east-1
I'm a tech worker, and have been paid by a multi-billion dollar company to be a tech worker since 2003.

Aside from Teams and Outlook Web, I really don't interact with Microsoft at all, haven't done since the days of XP. I'm sure there is integration on our corporate backends with things like active directory, but personally I don't have to deal with that.

Teams is fine for person-person instant messaging and video calls. I find it terrible for most other functions, but fortunately I don't have to use it for anything other than instant messaging and video calls. The linux version of teams still works.

I still hold out a healthy suspicion of them from their behaviour when I started in the industry. I find it amusing the Microsoft fanboys of the 2000s with their "only needs to work in IE6" and "Silverlight is the future" are still having to maintain obsolete machines to access their obsolete systems.

Meanwhile the stuff I wrote to be platform-agnostic 20 years ago is still in daily use, still delivering business benefit, with the only update being a change from "<object" to "<video" on one internal system when flash retired.

ta1243··on AWS multiple services outage in us-east-1
I created a DNS record in route53 this morning with no issues

the Billing part of the console in eu-west-2 was down though, presumably because that uses us-east-1 dynamodb, but route53 doesn't.

ta1243··on Docker Systems Status: Full Service Disruption
More likely the outage reports for google and microsoft are based around systems which also include aws
ta1243··on Space Elevator
What's really interesting is that a space elevator goes to Geostationary orbit by necessity. Getting to 100km vertically doesn't save as much as you might think when it comes to getting into orbit.

To get into a very low earth orbit from an equatorial launch pad at sea level you need about 9.2km/s of Delta-V

To get there from a 100km tall tower, you need about 8km/s of delta-V - about 85%.

Think about how much scrolling there was to get to 100km.

To get to the ISS you'd need to scroll 4 times further. Starlink and Hubble are another 100km beyond that.

You start having radiation problems if you spend too much time above 600km.

Aside from Apollo, the highest a human has been is about 1400km - 14 times more scrolling than this page.

To get to GEO would require scrolling over 25 times further than even that.

ta1243··on Docker Systems Status: Full Service Disruption
Or they all rely on AWS, because over the last 15 years we've built an extremely fragile interconnected global system in the pursuit of profit, austerity, and efficiency
ta1243··on AWS multiple services outage in us-east-1
Never choose a single point of failure.

Or rather

Ensure your single point of failure risk is appropriate for your business. I don't have full resilience for my companies AS going down, but we do have limited DR capability. Same with the loss of a major city or two.

I'm not 100% confident in a Thames Barrier flood situation, as I suspect some of our providers don't have the resilience levels we do, but we'd still be able to provide some minimal capability.

ta1243··on AWS multiple services outage in us-east-1
Meanwhile my pair of 12 year old raspberry pi's hangling my home services like DNS survive their 3rd AWS us-east-1 outage.

"But you can't do webscale uptime on your own"

Sure. I suspect even a single pi with auto-updates on has less downtime.

ta1243··on Amazon’s Ring to partner with Flock
What worries me is how the HN groupthink mentions it at every possibility.

If people on HN aren't capable/willing to run their own kit there's no hope.

In the slashdot days you'd never get such worship of tailscale and cloudflare. Even in the early days of HN you'd have people suggesting a bit of rsync rather than using dropbox.

It feels like the modern tech zeitgest is either dripping in far-right memes, or it's "tech enthusiasts" from https://thecatholicdev.substack.com/p/tech-enthusiasts-vs-te...

It was probably ever so -- slashdot 20 year ago was full of Atlas Shrugged, Firefly, etc, I was just too young and naieve to understand it

ta1243··on Amazon’s Ring to partner with Flock
I can see benefits to a closed circuit camera. I've never felt the need personally.

If it's not running free software and treated in a secure fashion (camera can't talk to anything other than the server, enforced at the network level, etc) then it's not a risk per-se.

However people would rather pay up front and pay subscriptions to get outside companies to run it than run their own their own equipment. In the 90s when I was excited about tech I didn't even consider that aspect.

ta1243··on Amazon’s Ring to partner with Flock
The best time to not buy into all this non-free surveilence-as-a-service crap was a decade ago.

The second best time is today.

Unfortunately the public love this stuff, and are quite happy to have CCTV pointing at your house. Privacy never existed 300 years ago, it doesn't today. Accept your feudal masters and make peace with it, because they won years ago.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →