HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tanker

102 karma · joined January 26, 2016

submissionscomments
tanker··on Confirmed: CMU Attacked Tor, Was Subpoenaed by Feds
I recognize the similarity between phone calls and Tor; however, I too think there is a difference in the expectation of privacy.

I like your analogy with aerial surveillance, but partially because I think you are wrong. It is my understanding that aerial views available to the public, such as those available to a commercial helicopter, do not require a warrant. However, if the police go beyond public capabilities with high zoom cameras it may require a warrant. Similarly, if the state goes beyond the capabilities of the public in obtaining my IP address, they should require a warrant. The question then becomes, "Does the CMU project constitute knowledge generally available to the public?" I would argue the negative, but I could see it answered either way.

tanker··on Fake girlfriend, revisited
You would likely enjoy Neal Stephenson's novels if you haven't already discovered him.
tanker··on Custom resume from someone who wanted to work at Airbnb (2015)
This seems like an instance of Job's "A players hire A players, B players hire C players." [1] Results will vary by who is hiring.

[1] http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&story...

tanker··on Which Type of Exercise Is Best for the Brain?
My takeaway is that different types of exercises might have different effects on the brain. Stronger claims must wait.

And I think that is all the study was meant to determine. Based on the findings, I would support more research on the brain's response to exercise.

tanker··on Feds nail webcam on utility pole for 10 weeks to spy on suspect
Courts have held that there is a height (not sure of specifics) above which aerial surveillance is legal without a warrant. The idea is that if it is the same height at which commercial aircraft (usually helicopters) fly, then it is a view available to the public.

See Examples & Explanation: Criminal Procedure Constitution & Police, Seventh Edition (Examples & Explanations) by Robert Bloom for a detailed analysis.

tanker··on The Most Elite, Stagnant Club for Old People: Corporate Boards
I've started checking the comments on HN before clicking on Bloomberg articles due to the low content value.
tanker··on On Google's self-driving car acident rates
In many cases, the manufacturer could include software that prevents the car from operating if maintenance is out of date.

There are a lot of ways the manufacturer can increase safety that might have negative consequences. For example, what happens if a manufacturer decides that all models over 10 years old are too risky? How do you separate their legitimate desire to ensure safety in their own self interest from their desire to sell more cars?

You might need to bring a lawyer when buying a car in the future.

tanker··on On Google's self-driving car acident rates
I think your logic is correct, but your implied outcome is probably wrong.

>"If you get in an accident and suffer damages and you allege that this is due to a manufacturer's defect, this is a basis for suit against the manufacturer."

Right now, this is an edge case. The self driving car may cause it to become common.

tanker··on American Students Know Almost Nothing About Their College Loans
Agreed. Private lenders wouldn't take the risk at a price most people would accept.

I believe this is the problem with getting the government involved in the loans. It obscures the true cost.

Who knows what the college system would look like today without federal funding? Maybe distance learning or a more focused associate degree would have developed.

tanker··on Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste Good Anymore
I enjoyed your phrase "often said to be unhealthy."

I'm glad the nutrition field is willing to admit errors and update guidance. I'm a little disappointed with the high frequency.

I did 30 seconds of research, and found out dietitian and nutritionist are not synonyms. Dietitians seem to use nutrition to achieve specific medical or performance outcomes. In that context, it makes sense to have lots of changes as the bleeding edge advances.

tanker··on MIT dean to start new university: “No majors, no lectures, no classrooms”
I too learn more deeply outside of the confines of a structured class. However, I find the structure of an OCW course nearly ideal for many subjects.

For me it seems to be at least partially a function of my ability in an area. The stronger I am in a subject, the less structure I need.

I suspect the optimal amount of structure varies from person to person and within a person from subject to subject. People learn differently.

tanker··on MIT dean to start new university: “No majors, no lectures, no classrooms”
I like the idea of project based learning. I think it will end up being a more lasting method of instruction.

I am interested in how they will still teach the breadth of the subject matter.

For example, you can get a lot of work done with linear algebra without really understanding vector spaces.

I assume this method of instruction would require more teacher-student interaction to be effective. The teacher could review the student progress on a project and make a note of where the application of a new technique would be helpful. Guiding the student towards a more complete understanding of a subject.

tanker··on Request For Research: Basic Income
> What can startups do to increase prosperity for everyone?

Make starting a business as easy as possible: 1) Have all the legal stuff taken care of through a web form that fills out all the paperwork in a standard way. When a business becomes sophisticated enough, they get a lawyer to customize their solution if necessary.

2) Provide simple business banking at the same time.

tanker··on Apple Reports Record First Quarter Results, Slowing Growth in iPhone Sales
I question your value definition. 1) Apple products work well together. 2) iOS doesn't always play well with others (I understand receiving texts on Android devices from Apple devices is annoying). 3) Apple as a brand has value. All of these may also contribute to a fourth consideration of resale value.

Jeep is a good comparison. Jeep's vehicles are probably not much different than other car makers, but there is a huge and well established aftermarket parts business. Jeeps hold value well in the used market.

I would be interested in the used value of Apple vs comparable Android products.

I find a dumb phone meets my personal needs, so I have little interaction with either product.

Edit: I agree that people in general upgrade their devices more often than they need to based on their use case. It would be interesting to know if Apple owners do so more often than Android owners.

tanker··on Marvin Minsky: What makes mathematics hard to learn? (2008)
I remember asking my 4th grade teacher what the difference between fractions and division. She clearly didn't understand what I was asking. That was the moment I started seeking my own answers and stopped trusting my teachers blindly.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2