HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tarakat

1,065 karma · joined July 8, 2022

submissionscomments
tarakat··on Spotify acquired a company that detects harmful content in podcasts
Harmful and false, I assume? Surely harmful but truthful content wouldn't be censored.

Conversely, will beneficial but false content also be taken down, or will that be allowed to stand?

And we're all working with same definitions of "harmful" and "beneficial", right?

tarakat··on A tiny elections company became a conspiracy theory target
Archive in case of paywall: https://archive.ph/boUFQ

The day after the NYT article, the baseless, unfounded conspiracy theory was confirmed, as the Konnech CEO was arrested for storing election worker data on servers in China, contrary to his claims in the NYT article and the conditions of his government contract:

https://da.lacounty.gov/media/news/head-election-worker-mana...

The followup article:

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/04/technology/election-softw...

https://archive.ph/GPC9N

tarakat··on Hollywood: Unmasking informant T-10 (1985)
You are comparing the mildest version of the stated beliefs of one ideology, to the actions of another (actions that, by the way, were kept hidden from the German people, who for most of the war believed the Jews were merely being, or going to be, expelled. There would be no need for a coverup if gassing was a widely-shared, open belief). Try:

"Believing that the economically well-off and those professing contrary politics should be starved to death imprisoned in their own country or in Siberia is the same as believing the German people should prosper in their ancestral lands and be free of foreign exploitation."

Present-day communists still proudly proclaim "eat the rich", so the hate is not limited to some distant time and place. And please spare me the excuses of how "eat" doesn't mean "eat", but a peaceful and gradual economic transition where resources are more fairly reallocated. Such charitable interpretations are never extended to disfavored movements.

tarakat··on For personal reasons, I do not browse the web from my computer. (2007)
> Theo de Raadt, now there's a paranoid man

Can someone elaborate what makes de Raadt so paranoid?

tarakat··on Brazilian vote counting (real time)
Of all the problems you listed, only the "colonel" is ~unique to Brazil. Every single one of the others is something a country of any size has also faced, and solved, without introducing black boxes into the system.
tarakat··on Brazilian vote counting (real time)
Can you be more specific? I know that population or geographic size alone has no effect on counting complexity - the number of people counting is proportional to the number of votes to be counted. Communicating the vote totals from electoral districts can be done through the same medium as the voting machines would use, and producing final sums takes only O(log n) parallel steps.

So where does the terror, confusion, and rampant fraud come from, and what is it about Brazil that causes them, when so many other countries manage to avoid them?

tarakat··on Apple disables screenshots when playing Top Gun Maverick
With DRM, you have to pay extra for what used to be your rights. There are people right now thinking of ways to further restrict what we may do, so they can sell permission to do it back to us.
tarakat··on Brazilian vote counting (real time)
VW was able to detect when an emissions test was being done, so there may be ways to detect this as well. E.g. by the unusually fast rate at which votes are being cast, or if this "seizure" involves moving the machine, reconnecting power to it, or any other kind of abnormal interaction.

Why make things so complicated when manual counting works perfectly well??

With auditing being so difficult, you're not even saving any labor.

tarakat··on Brazilian vote counting (real time)
Or the compromise (or cooperation) of a few of the software supply chain components used to program the chipset of the voting machines. Or the development machines used to write and upload the voting software. Or the foundry used to cast the chips. You think if e.g. China devoted ~5 years of their best hacking group's time to this, they couldn't do it? Because that's a very low price to pay to sway the election of a country such as Brazil.

> They are audited by members of parties and the civil society.

Audited how? Do they plug in a USB, download the software, and verify that it matches the (hopefully open-source, ideally formally verified) code it's supposed to be running?

Let's say it matches - how can they trust that the code the USB port emitted, is what is actually running?

tarakat··on You weren’t supposed to see that
It is exactly the same. Natural selection only cares about reproduction rate. It doesn't matter if we consider a trait "bad" (such as lower education or intelligence) - if it results in more offspring, it is what evolution will select. Conversely, if it results in fewer offspring, it will slowly be weeded out, even if we'd rather keep it.
tarakat··on You weren’t supposed to see that
What makes you think we don't have natural selection? Most economically advanced countries have below-replacement fertility. Being eaten by a leopard or failing to have enough children are the same from the point of view of natural selection.
tarakat··on Brazilian vote counting (real time)
Sounds easy to evade. Once a machine has recorded 10+ votes since the last time it outputted a count, it could start giving a small probabilistic advantage to a preferred candidate, at the expense of other candidates. There would be no bumps, and the results would never differ by more than, say, relative 20% from the real count. E.g. if preferred candidate got 10% on one voting machine, it would give him 12%, taking the other 2% from all other candidates.

No bumps or disproportionate popularity in traditionally unpopular regions to raise suspicion.

tarakat··on Brazilian vote counting (real time)
> Each party has delegates present during vote counting [..] the system would be better if physical counting could be performed as well

If there's no physical counting, then what are the delegates observing? If the machines were compromised, how could they tell?

tarakat··on Why isn't the Holodomor taught in schools?
> Some famines are caused by misguided collectivization / socialism enforced by the state

This looks deliberate, not misguided: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor#Causes

regions with higher Ukrainian population shares were struck harder with centrally planned policies corresponding to famine, and Ukrainian populated areas were given lower amounts of tractors which were correlated to a reduction in famine mortality, ultimately concluding that 92% of famine deaths in Ukraine alone along with 77% of famine deaths in Ukraine, Russia, and Belarus combined can be explained by systematic bias against Ukrainians

[..]

Under the collectivism policy, for example, farmers were not only deprived of their properties but a large swath of these were also exiled in Siberia with no means of survival. Those who were left behind and attempted to escape the zones of famine were ordered to be shot.

> If you’re going to teach things, you need to find patterns and try to discern the root causes. Otherwise you’re just imparting biased propaganda to students.

This implies that history currently is taught so as to find patterns and causes, and that teaching the Holodomor for some reason wouldn't entail patterns and causes. It is a fully general answer that could excuse any event from being taught. A non-answer.

And to answer your question, yes, I knew about all of them.

tarakat··on Why isn't the Holodomor taught in schools?
History is full of any kind of event that may be taught, so that is a fully general answer: it can explain why anything isn't taught, and applies equally to things that are taught.

And the part of Andrew Tanner's Quora answer (top answer at submission time) that says it's because "it had relatively little impact on other historical events" is tautological - it would have had more impact if it was taught and publicized more.

So neither is a satisfying explanation.

tarakat··on Immigration accounts for over 94% of Canada’s population growth in Q2 of 2022
> Canada has an immigration rate 10x the rate of the US

I assume you mean per-capita? Because legal immigration alone into the US is about 1.8 million/year and has been for almost a decade, excluding one or two pandemic years.

tarakat··on Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Female Incoming PM Meloni
I'm just repeating the words of the current President of the United States (though he was not yet President when speaking them):

https://www.c-span.org/video/?c4926142/user-clip-joe-biden-u...

tarakat··on Trans-men asked to stop testosterone during pregnancy – but evidence is murky
"Not evidence based" is the impression the motivated author aims for, but if read carefully, is not supported by the text of the article. E.g. the link in While testosterone is widely considered a “male hormone,” all people produce testosterone. is to a study [1] showing an average 10x difference in testosterone levels between men and women.

Later, talking about polycystic ovary syndrome, it tacitly admits excess testosterone is likely to cause:

developing intersex conditions, or having biological traits that do not fit binary definitions of male or female characteristics; [..] metabolic and cardiovascular dysfunction, such as obesity; and neuropsychiatric disorders, such as autism and attention-deficit disorder

This is excused by equating the desire for "normal" children with eugenics:

I became increasingly concerned that this focus on producing “normal” children fails to attend to both natural human diversity in cognitive processing, bodies and identities, and the mental health of trans and nonbinary parents. It may also echo eugenicist policies that attempt to eliminate human characteristics and communities that society deems inferior or bad.

[1] https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/323085

tarakat··on Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Female Incoming PM Meloni
And maybe von der Leyen will lobby for a stricter reading of those treaties if the wrong party gets elected, which is the subtext of her words, obvious to all but the most willfully obtuse.
tarakat··on Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Female Incoming PM Meloni
Results are different between your link and https://twitter.com/search?q=Giorgia%20Meloni&src=typed_quer... (i.e. the "videos" tab, and a normal search with "filter:videos" appended)

The article is referring to the former (as can be seen from the screenshot).

And the results seem to be changing - when before I got zero results for the video tab search, I now get exactly one - a video posted 3 hours ago.

tarakat··on Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Female Incoming PM Meloni
That's the same trick used on the great replacement. Pick the most conspiratorial, unlikely version of it (evil Jews meeting in secret, plotting to cause immigration to turn whites into an oppressed minority in their own lands, and for no other reason), show that there is no evidence of that, the apply the label of "debunked" to anything that can be vaguely called replacement (relative demographic reduction of white population due to immigration policies enacted since the 1960s).

In other words, an offensive motte and bailey strategy. Attack the motte, then claim you've destroyed the bailey.

tarakat··on Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Female Incoming PM Meloni
During a conference on Thursday at Princeton University, an attendant pointed out to von der Leyen that “figures close to Putin” were among candidates for the upcoming legislative election on Sunday. “We’ll see,” she replied. “If things go in a difficult direction — and I’ve spoken about Hungary and Poland — we have the tools.” - https://www.politico.eu/article/italy-election-candidate-war...
tarakat··on Twitter Appears to Shadowban Videos of Italy’s First Female Incoming PM Meloni
I can confirm I get the same results. Testing for other leaders, I get plenty of results for e.g. Emanuel Macron. Ironically, the first result is a speech of Meloni addressing Macron.

By the time they fix the "accidental bug triggered by anomalously high search volume" (or some similar excuse), the interest spike in Meloni will have passed, and her videos' reach will have been successfully stifled.

And they'll learn their lesson, and next time will just reduce the visibility of her and her associates' posts. Assuming they haven't already also done that.

tarakat··on Facebook’s Systems Promoted Violence Against Rohingya in Myanmar
> Alright, it's a censorship issue. Censorship on one side; genocide on the other. Ideology or pragmatism.

Should we abandon honesty and accuracy if one side of an issue is genocide? Let me rephrase that: should I assume anyone speaking out against genocide is twisting words to their breaking point, and I shouldn't believe a word they're saying? Do you see the problem with this approach?

I find it incredibly dishonest to use spam-filters as a cheap trap that every non-spam message is "promoted", so that any usable messaging platform can be accused of "promoting" messages someone wants censored.

I propose the following: since opinion is split on this issue, using the (apparently incredibly broad) "promoting" will mislead a large segment of readers. And even those that won't be misled won't be any wiser, since to them, not having messages dropped as spam and algorithmically boosting a story so 90% of all Facebook users see it are both "promotion".

So instead of saying "promotion", say "treated the same as any other non-spam message". Unless you were in fact trying to mislead your readers, you would welcome this chance to be more accurate and descriptive.

tarakat··on Meta has banned the personal Facebook accounts for everyone on our team
The kind that realizes that government is not the only threat to a functional free market, that does not devolve into feudalism. I am pointing out the failure of lack of antitrust enforcement, not claiming that an unrestricted free market is the ideal, no matter where it leads.
tarakat··on Meta has banned the personal Facebook accounts for everyone on our team
> I agree it’s petty

The pettiness isn't the problem, the extra-legal power that consolidation of capital and media enables is. Competition in the market ceases to be about the best product at the best price, and becomes a game of strategic alliances and power abuse instead.

Edit: To clarify once more: Facebook may have a legitimate interest in keeping this company off Instagram. What it does not have is a moral right to use unrelated properties for retaliation. This is what I meant by "extra-legal" - it's using its market power to punish a company, instead of the courts. If Instagram was independent, it could not engage in this sort of business-warfare.

tarakat··on Meta has banned the personal Facebook accounts for everyone on our team
The company retaliated against their employees through unrelated services it happens to also own? Is this the kind of free market we want? Turf wars?
tarakat··on Instagram permanently disables Pornhub account
I'm not saying it doesn't have effects, or that it was good. But calling it "violence" dilutes the meaning of that word into nothing, as the threshold is so low almost anything qualifies as "violent".
tarakat··on Instagram permanently disables Pornhub account
And there's no difference between this 2nd order effect that may harm porn producers (or maybe consumers will find other channels besides Instagram to get porn, and overall porn consumption won't decrease), and hiring goons with baseball bats to assault prostitutes.

Or if there's a difference, it's so small that we can call both "violence", and insisting on some kind of categorical distinction between the two is pedantic nit-picking.

tarakat··on I spent $3k on a Samsung Smart TV and all I got were ads and unwanted content
> It's customers who have shown they prefer those cheaper on the face of it options rather than those with much bigger up-front cost

I question the "much" - I'm sure the price difference isn't as big as those who are spying on us would have us believe (and coincidentally they are also keeping their costs secret).

But more importantly, how can you attribute this to "preference", when the hypothetical price difference is front and center, while the ads and spying are hidden, and there is not an equivalent TV without the ads and spying being sold next to the ad-infested one at an unsubsidized price?

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →