HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tarakat

1,065 karma · joined July 8, 2022

submissionscomments
tarakat··on Civil rights groups are calling on Amazon and MGM to cancel Ring Nation show
> Cancel Ring Nation’s letter emphasizes how, in a post-Roe world especially, people should understand how Ring cameras can be weaponized against them

And Ring Nation will help them understand. Surveillance should not be discreet. Unless people are aware, they won't try to stop it. I can think of no better way to raise awareness than a reality show hosted by an ex-NSA agent.

tarakat··on Video shows GOP fake elector giving 'unauthorized access' to voting equipment
At my (non-US) voting location, we put marked ballots into big plastic boxes. After the polls closed, the ballots were counted by volunteers, and the counting was supervised by other people to make sure it was done correctly.

Nobody had to worry about the boxes being tampered with, or about "unauthorized" people gaining access to them before or after the election, because they're just boxes.

If your election can be trusted only if only "authorized" people interact with voting equipment, then it can't be trusted at all. Obscurity has no place in elections.

tarakat··on America’s Open Wound
The US invasion of Iraq that the CIA helped start [1] resulted in about 200k civilian deaths [2]. I don't feel like tallying the deaths from all of CIA's projects (or deciding how to split responsibility between the CIA and the USA as a whole), and I'm inclined to agree that Russia did worse, even much worse, but not incomparably worse, as subjective as that term is.

Regardless, my statement holds - there are plenty of people that justifiably hate the CIA. It wouldn't surprise me if plenty of proud Americans hated it - it has dragged their country into unnecessary wars, and subverted their democracy. Why this desire to protect a rogue agency that seems hostile even to the US itself, just because Russia is bad?

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2004/jul/09/usa.iraq2

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_Body_Count_project

tarakat··on Germany's blanket data retention law is illegal, EU top court says
We've seen where this leads to in the US, where the federal government financially extorts states to fall in line on issues that are supposed to be up to the states, such as what happened with speed limits:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_limits_in_the_United_Sta...

tarakat··on You don’t want to be on Cloudflare’s naughty list
You're looking at it all wrong. From Cloudflare's point of view, this kind of blocking is a feature. Anyone doing legitimate web crawling, or offering alternative web services such as Starlink, now needs Cloudflare's permission.

Essentially, for a broad class of web-based businesses, they have made themselves gatekeepers. I'm sure they'll find a profitable use for this position. Charging outright would look bad, but investing in businesses that just happen to not run into Cloudflare-based trouble, but whose competitors do...

tarakat··on America’s Open Wound
> A bit hypocritical of Snowden to criticize the USA while holed up in Russia.

So you have no problem with the substance of the article, only with the author's place of residence?

The article itself references several instances of the CIA toppling governments and starting wars - those are not invalidated because Russia also did similar or and worse things. Plenty of people in the Middle East and Central America could justifiably feel the same about the CIA as you do about Russia.

tarakat··on America’s Open Wound
> Why is it such a long shot to believe they don't interfere locally?

> Because this goes strongly against the culture of the organization?

No it doesn't, and I'm curious where you got that impression:

A Brief History of the CIA's Unpunished Spying on the Senate - https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/12/a-brief...

Through these programs, the CIA's Office of Security received information from US based informants regarding individuals and groups with anti-war views. [..] According to a 1977 New York Times article, the CIA conducted a covert propaganda campaign to squelch criticism of the Warren Report. The CIA urged its field stations to use their "propaganda assets" to attack those who didn't agree with the Warren Report. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIA_activities_in_the_United_S...

In 1975, Church Committee Congressional investigations revealed Agency connections with journalists and civic groups. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird

At various times, under its own initiative or in accordance with directives from the President of the United States or the National Security Council staff, the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) has attempted to influence public opinion both in the United States and abroad. [..] Ralph McGehee, a former CIA officer, stated that the CIA often placed news stories anonymously in news publications to spread false ideas favorable to CIA goals. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIA_influence_on_public_opinio...

And that's only what we know about.

tarakat··on Public buses across country adding microphones to record conversations (2012)
> In Baltimore, wiretap laws only apply where there is a 'reasonable expectation of privacy' (https://cite.case.law/a3d/197/27/#p685) per Fourth Amendment standards (which would suggest that any recordings made in a public place would be lawful).

It is absolutely insane that not assuming a computerized private investigator is following your every step and listening to your every word as soon as you step through your front door is considered 'unreasonable'.

> It's therefore likely that a simple sign saying 'recording in progress' or something similar would be adequate.

It's even more insane that a simple "conversations may be recorded" sticker is all it takes to nullify the 4th Amendment in public.

tarakat··on Public buses across country adding microphones to record conversations (2012)
Plus it's no longer relevant since this program, and mass surveillance in general, are slowly being phased out /s
tarakat··on Public buses across country adding microphones to record conversations (2012)
I wonder if that means they've since stopped.
tarakat··on Gaming companies get DHS to combat radicalization of online gamers
> “the development of a set of best practices and centralized resources for monitoring and evaluation of extremist activities as well as a series of training workshops for the monitoring, detection, and prevention of extremist exploitation in gaming spaces for community managers, multiplayer designers, lore developers, mechanics designers, and trust and safety professionals.”

It is only the stigma around surveillance that's keeping them from expanding these efforts (faster) to phone networks, public transport, chain restaurants, and eventually all public spaces.

In fact it's already starting:

https://www.theverge.com/2012/12/10/3752318/microphone-surve...

https://www.wired.com/2012/12/public-bus-audio-surveillance/

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2016/03/24/seen-and-hear...

tarakat··on Tik Tok is a national security threat
"A foreign country is amassing spies and rumour-spreaders on our streets!"

"So? Our country also has such agents on our streets. Worrying about these others is xenophobic. Besides, our country is just as corrupt, we are in no position to judge."

But what should we non-Americans make of this? Depends on your relationship with China vs. US. Personally, I view FB/Google/Twitter with less, but still plenty, of mistrust. US govt influence is a big factor, but not the only one.

tarakat··on Pentagon opens sweeping review of clandestine psychological operations
There's a corruption problem, and the US will use it as an excuse to target politicians unfriendly to their interests, and divert scrutiny away from those that play ball with Washington.
tarakat··on Viral “racism in academia” story deleted when I started asking questions
> I like to ask myself, what if the result were reversed? Would it be reported?

Ask and you will be answered:

The authors also submitted different test studies to different peer-review boards. The methodology was identical, and the variable was that the purported findings either went for, or against, the liberal worldview (for example, one found evidence of discrimination against minority groups, and another found evidence of "reverse discrimination" against straight white males). Despite equal methodological strengths, the studies that went against the liberal worldview were criticized and rejected, and those that went with it were not.

Source: https://theweek.com/articles/441474/how-academias-liberal-bi... summarizing the following paper: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/behavioral-and-brain...

tarakat··on Republicans in key battleground races refuse to say they will accept results
And blind acceptance? I haven't been paying attention to whether the Republican doubts over the election are justified, so don't interpret this as endorsement, but in principle, elections should be scrutinized by all parties.
tarakat··on Republicans in key battleground races refuse to say they will accept results
> Acceptance of an electoral outcome — win or lose — was once a virtual certainty in American politics, although there have been exceptions.

A 10 minute montage of those exceptions: https://twitter.com/_/status/1565480585715408896

tarakat··on ‘The Rings of Power’ has inexplicably terrible writing
I don't mind a slow pace. It's when the humans (unusually pale compared to the rest of the show's diversity) started complaining about elves taking their jobs that I checked out.
tarakat··on Crackdowns and Censorship in the UK
Which alleged viewpoints of mine conflict? And is that what we're calling drawing attention to relevant but ignored facts? Trolling? And to not troll, I would have to accept journalist's framing and cherry-picking of stories without complaint?
tarakat··on Is It Illegal to Transport an Undocumented Immigrant Within the U.S.?
It will be interesting to see how this develops. Afaik the federal government refuses to secure the border, despite the pleas of some border states, and does not allow those states to secure it on their own, since they claim it is a federal matter.

It would be very hypocritical to enforce immigration law so selectively - prosecuting inter-state transport, while turning a blind eye to the border.

tarakat··on The curious afterlife of a brain trauma survivor
Disable javascript if you encounter the paywall.
tarakat··on Ask HN: Have you commented on HN about a court decision without reading it? Why?
I didn't mean to imply that was the only thing it was based on. But it is the main thing placing limits on laws such as this.
tarakat··on Crackdowns and Censorship in the UK
State intimidation for things that are explicitly legal in the UK is also nothing new - see their police logging of "non-crime hate incidents", even for schoolchildren:

https://reclaimthenet.org/the-uks-chilling-non-crime-hate-in...

tarakat··on Crackdowns and Censorship in the UK
> The police crackdown on such protests has raised questions about freedom of speech during this fraught period for the United Kingdom.

Those questions were answered years ago when mean tweets [1] and nazi pugs [2] resulted in arrests. Those were not isolated cases [3]. Let's not act surprised now.

[1] https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2019/09/05/trolling-malicious-com...

[2] https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-43478925

[3] Two-and-a-half thousand Londoners have been arrested over the past five years for allegedly sending “offensive” messages - https://www.theregister.com/2016/06/02/social_media_arrests_...

tarakat··on Ask HN: Have you commented on HN about a court decision without reading it? Why?
Perhaps they've read a summary of the decision that they trust?

Also, the decision is based on a single-paragraph long part of the constitution. I tentatively disagree with the decision*, consider this hypothetical: a one-thousand page long decision that ruled the government was allowed to censor all anti-war speech, based on the 1st Amendment.

It would be bizarre to expect only people that read through the whole thousand pages to comment on such an on-it's-face misguided decision.

*But I don't consider it entirely unreasonable, and I think the law behind it addresses a very real problem that we shouldn't ignore by sticking our heads in the sand and yelling "1st amendment".

tarakat··on 5th Circuit Rules Internet Companies Have No Right to Moderate
1. As I understand it, state constitutions are subordinate to the US constitution. In case of a conflict, the US constitution prevails.

2. "Disruption" is highly subjective. On one end of the scale is spam, on the other end is political speech that platforms declare is "harmful". Do you think the mall in question could get away with booting the petitioners, as long as they could provide some vague reasoning to how their stated politics lead to "harm"?

3. You move from "endorsement" to "tone", I suspect because you realize no-one in their right mind believes Meta "endorses" every post on Facebook. But the point is valid - the tone of social media is more central to their business than the tone of a shopping mall. But what tone can a platform's billion+ users claim to share? And should their desire to shape a tone, at that scale, supersede their users free speech interest?

tarakat··on 5th Circuit Rules Internet Companies Have No Right to Moderate
"People" like banks, phone companies, ISPs, software vendors (suppose MS decides not to support your speech and prevents you from using any of their products), multinational taxi (Uber) and rental (AirB&B) companies, utilities (water, gas, electricity), or retail chains (Walmart)?

Calling such entities "people" is at best misleading.

tarakat··on 5th Circuit Rules Internet Companies Have No Right to Moderate
SCOTUS also ruled that the 1st Amendment allows compelling a mall (a private entity) to host petitioners, which is strikingly similar to this case: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruneyard_Shopping_Center_v._R...

And we were happy to throw freedom of association under the bus to enforce civil rights.

tarakat··on 5th Circuit Rejects First Amdt. Challenge to TX Social Media Common Carrier Law
> they want citizen’s united to hold so right wing candidates can be funded with unlimited corporate funds but don’t want the woke tech world to police speech

The situation is not nearly so clear-cut. Both parties seem to get about equal amounts of corporate donations, while individual contributions vary. Currently, Democrats get slightly more than Republicans from billionaire donors. From <$200 donors, Republicans got more for the 2016 elections, but now Democrats seem to be taking the lead there too. Sources:

If you sum the donations from https://www.opensecrets.org/elections-overview/biggest-donor..., Democrats get 20% more donations from ultra-rich individuals (not corporations) than Republicans, in absolute terms.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2014/07/16/th... shows that the Republican Governor's Association raised $11 million from corporate and $13 million from individuals (mostly the ultra-rich), while the Democrat counterpart raised $12.8 million from corporate and only $1 million from individuals.

On the other hand, the 2012 Trump campaign got more funds from small (<$200) contributions than Hillary's - $239 million, which amounted to 69% of his individual contributions, compared to Hillary's $137 million, which amounted to 22% of her individual contributions: https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2017/nov/13/kayleigh-m...

And many corporations have cut ties with election objector Republicans: https://fortune.com/2022/02/15/political-donations-corporate...

For actual corporate donations, those go through PACs. https://www.opensecrets.org/political-action-committees-pacs... shows the split by party and year.

tarakat··on California sues Amazon for preventing 3rd-party sellers being cheaper elsewhere
> being yanked from a good location

"Reducing the listing" can potentially mean being pushed to page 23 of search results. In retail, that would be equivalent to never leaving the warehouse, available only upon specific request by a customer.

tarakat··on California sues Amazon for preventing 3rd-party sellers being cheaper elsewhere
No business is happy with competition. That doesn't make contractual collusion any less anti-competitive. If it is, as you allege, the norm, that only makes dealing with it more urgent.
← PreviousPage 4 of 8Next →