HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tarakat

1,065 karma · joined July 8, 2022

submissionscomments
tarakat··on Key EU Policymakers Want Netflix to Pay More for Infrastructure
The conglomerate can do this even if the EU makes Netflix pay twice for bandwidth.

And calling it unlimited vs. metered is deceptive. ISPs can (and do) offer lower bandwidths (usually called "unlimited") instead of metering.

tarakat··on ‘That was our beach’: Notes on Fred Conrad’s Iconic 1977 Photograph
> Economic stagnation combined with plummeting tax revenue resulting from an exodus of wealthy (and largely white) residents left New York in an intractable financial crisis.

For context, in the 1970s the US was ~83% white (57% today) [1], and New York was ~62% white (30% today) [2]. So you could append "largely white" to most things at the time.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_racial_and_ethnic_d...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_history_of_New_Yor...

tarakat··on Key EU Policymakers Want Netflix to Pay More for Infrastructure
"The price I am charging for my services is not enough to cover my costs! Government, help!"

Or they could, you know, offer smaller speeds or higher prices.

tarakat··on Key EU Policymakers Want Netflix to Pay More for Infrastructure
They're already charging both sides - the consumer streaming a movie has to pay for his bandwidth, and Netflix's server uploading the movie stream pays for its bandwidth. Now the ISPs want to be paid a 3rd time??
tarakat··on Oberlin College to pay $36M to bakery owners who were falsely accused of racism
> Like me, the majority of the campus was not here at the beginning of this matter in 2016.

But they still benefit from the inherited privilege born of these systemic injustices that the bakery case exemplifies.

tarakat··on Oberlin College to pay $36M to bakery owners who were falsely accused of racism
She should remove testimony of what happened by the alleged victim's mother, because the accusation did not result in a conviction? It is also immediately followed by

> David was afraid the incident would blow up, since the students claimed to the police that my son had assaulted them—not the other way around.

giving the reader testimony of all parties involved. But by your logic, the media could report only on court decisions.

tarakat··on Simulated Growing Plants
ML systems are more difficult to tweak. E.g. if you want to adjust parameters such as growth speed, branching factor, sunlight attraction, etc., and see how the resulting plant changes.
tarakat··on Computer experts urge Georgia to replace voting machines
If being exposed to the "wrong" people for a few hours is all it takes to make the voting machines unsafe, isn't that an admission that they weren't remotely safe to begin with?

I argue this holds for any black box that requires an army of computer experts and electron microscopes to truly verify... and that verification only lasts until the next time the wrong person is in the same room as the black box.

tarakat··on It seems that the good times for online Minecraft play are over
Liability? Has a game developer ever been held legally liable for not policing their community hard enough?
tarakat··on It seems that the good times for online Minecraft play are over
And who has been the greatest cheerleader of this totalitarian corporate control, where nothing happens on a platform without the blessing of its corporate master? MS have only themselves to blame, for they did everything in their power to erase that distinction.

Maybe in addition to educating users on inclusive language in MS Word [1], they could educate users about the very basics of how computers work. But that would go against MS's interests.

[1] https://www.windowscentral.com/new-microsoft-word-feature-wi...

tarakat··on Google's Project Nimbus is the future of evil
Yes, being constantly surveilled by AI-enhanced telescreens when in public is so very complex and nuanced, that we need security and geopolitics experts to tell us if that's the kind of society we want to live in. A lay person is simply not educated enough to judge whether having his every move and expression logged and analyzed by some government or corporate entity is a good thing or not.
tarakat··on Ask HN: Location based pay is killing my motivation, how do others handle it?
The reasons they gave are lies. They're paying you less because (they think) they can. That's all there is to it.

Another reason is because they know where you live, and the salaries in that location. Keep that in mind when someone says they have "nothing to hide" - this is how companies use such information. To better determine the absolute minimum they can offer you (or maximum they can sell you).

tarakat··on [dead]
Actions of individuals are representative of and inherent to a website/movement/ideology when it is useful, and at most incidentally connected otherwise.

It's the same reason the media always mentions the Charlottesville rally killing in the same breath as the alt-right, but never connects the Waukesha Christmas parade killings to BLM.

tarakat··on [dead]
As a [flagged] [dead] comment noted, that doxxing dates to 5 days after its "victim" shot up a school, then killed himself:

https://www.newsweek.com/william-atchison-led-double-life-on...

tarakat··on Chile Constitution Vote a Big Loss for CIA and “Chicago Boys”
> A new, lower voting age of 16. Moreover, voting “constitutes a right and a civic duty,” and so voting would become compulsory for everyone 18 and over.

This keeps popping up. Whose interests does it serve to make those who vote, on average, less informed, experienced, and interested in politics? People readily decry how stupid they were when the were teenagers, so why then turn around and give them the vote? And how can one simultaneously decry disinformation, while adding those most vulnerable to it to the voting body?

tarakat··on The Sick Society
Those Europeans were themselves on the receiving end of foreign disease when the Black Death was brought to Europe from somewhere in Asia. Strange how for some plagues, their foreign origin is emphasized, while for others it is ignored, despite how neither were introduced deliberately.
tarakat··on Blocking Kiwifarms
But it should do something about how 2-3 giant corporations have become effective arbiters of online speech.
tarakat··on Bank of America to offer zero-down mortgages in Black and Hispanic communities
We'll see if this runs afoul of disparate impact [1], or even the narrower disparate treatment, since it was their declared intention to choose neighborhoods based on race.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disparate_impact

tarakat··on Breaking the silence around academic bullying
So if an article casually threw in some disparaging remarks about Blacks, Asians, or Jews (or, as was the case here, implied the entire problem the article was talking about was disproportionately their fault), they'd be expect to let the accusations stand unchallenged, because they should only address more interesting parts of the article?
tarakat··on Breaking the silence around academic bullying
That sounds rather Euro-centric. Non-majority-white countries are also heavily represented in academia - China, India (and most of Asia, really), and the Middle East pop to mind - whites don't enjoy "intersectional privilege" there.

In fact, at most scientific conferences, Antarctica is usually the only continent not represented, so it's doubly unusual for academics to suddenly become so blinkered.

tarakat··on Israeli rules say West Bank visitors must declare love interest
It's largely due to that alliance that ISIS even cares about Europe. The "alliance" itself is largely one-way - the US and Europe topple the government of any country that looks at Israel funny, and in return they get.. what?

The usual answer is oil, but the cost of the Iraq war is estimated at $1.9 trillion [1]. Even if all of Iraq's oil industry was taken by the US, and its revenue was 100% profit that went entirely to the US, at the current record-high export of $11 billion/month [2], it would take 15 years to break even.

But neither of those assumptions hold - oil industry profit margins vary between 5% and 30% [3,4], and the media seems shockingly disinterested in reporting how oil company ownership or profit flow changed following the war, but let's be generous and say it resulted in half of their total profits being diverted to the US (that weren't already diverted before).

Under these more realistic but still very generous assumptions (using the 30% high-water mark for profit margin), it would take 97 years to break-even. That is also assuming Iraq would remain a stable pawn to US interests for that entire time, and it wouldn't take more military spending to keep them in line.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_cost_of_the_Iraq_War

[2] https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/4/2/iraq-oil-exports-11-...

[3] https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/012015/what-average...

[4] https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/oil-industry-ranks-60-by-prof...

tarakat··on IMDB deleted all negative user reviews for The Rings of Power
A better comparison would be Black Panther or Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon - fictional stories and worlds loosely inspired by real places, just like Middle Earth.
tarakat··on Amazon Halts LOTR: Rings of Power Ratings to Combat Review-Bombing
> Amazon says that intentionally bad reviews shall not pass

Will "intentionally good" reviews also be banned? For example if they like the show for the "wrong" reasons?

tarakat··on Bank of America just launched a zero down payment mortgage in 21 cities
Those sound like problems with the pupils, not the school. This is not semantics - it affects how to solve the problem, and informs what consequences various solutions may have.
tarakat··on Poland plans to seek $1.3T in reparations from Germany for WWII
How does one decide which countries owe reparations? Poland could equally demand reparations from Russia [1], as could most of Eastern Europe, while South-Eastern Europe could demand reparations from Turkey. Yet one never sees headlines about those.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territories_of_Poland_annexed_...

tarakat··on Bank of America just launched a zero down payment mortgage in 21 cities
> But generally, this is simply because of crime and bad schools due to the cycle of poverty.

What makes the schools bad, if they receive on-average marginally higher per-pupil funding than mostly-white schools [1]?

[1] on average, both Black and Latinx total per pupil expenditures exceed White total per pupil expenditures by $229.53 and $126.15 - https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/23328584198724... - I can't find a source now, but the average per-pupil funding is around $20,000, so a difference of $200 is negligible.

If you're surprised that the funding is almost the same, despite schools being funded by property taxes, which are much higher in whiter neighborhoods, that's because you were hoodwinked by the media. Schools are funded by local property taxes and state taxes, with the latter distributed to even-out the funding. For some mysterious reason, the latter funding source receives much less coverage than the former.

tarakat··on Bank of America just launched a zero down payment mortgage in 21 cities
> this story says that this program is in historically Black and Latino neighborhoods. Kind of a difference if it's open to all people or not.

Even if open to all people, this is a clear case of disparate impact [1], which runs afoul of the Civil Rights act. But I wouldn't hold my breath for an even application of the law.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disparate_impact

tarakat··on The Portuguese can no longer afford to live in Portugal
> The only way your comment makes sense is if you're suggesting it's a problem that white British being a minority is a problem.

Why don't you tell me - do ethnic minorities without a country of their own face any challenges or dangers due to that? Is there reason to believe that native Britons won't face those same dangers? Perhaps because they are so beloved by other nations they now share their country with, there are yearly riots of gratitude held in their honor?

They're not even a minority yet, and we already have a preview of what's to come:

RAF ‘Pauses Job Offers for White Men’ to Meet ‘Impossible’ Diversity Targets - https://news.sky.com/story/raf-pauses-job-offers-for-white-m...

BBC bans white people from job - but workforce already reflects country's ethnic make-up - https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/670266/BBC-advert-white-pe...

tarakat··on The Portuguese can no longer afford to live in Portugal
Salami slicing. No single step will ever make much difference for the majority of Portuguese, until they suddenly find themselves a minority in their own capital, as happened to the English.
tarakat··on The Portuguese can no longer afford to live in Portugal
If a nation cannot give preference to its own people, then that nation effectively does not exist. As for "established rules", the idea that nations should be reduced to economic zones is relatively novel, and not something most voters (i.e. the people nominally deciding on those rules) agree with.
← PreviousPage 6 of 8Next →