HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

taywrobel

1,318 karma · joined November 6, 2016

I’m not a writer, I just type a lot.

Formerly at Palantir, Apple, and co-founder at Symbolica AI. Currently at GitHub.

submissionscomments
taywrobel··on What is ranked-choice voting and why is New York using it?
Can you summarize or provide a non-paywall link?

It’s frustrating that they claim RCV is second best but (presumably) put what they argue is best below the fold.

taywrobel··on Nobody has found a use case for blockchain
The risk isn't the price drop, it's China deciding that it wants to own the bitcoin market one day, seizing control of the hashers, and then doing whatever they want with the network. For instance, refusing to process transactions from American IPs.

Would love to see how BTC's price holds up to a state sponsored hijacking of the network using raw compute power.

taywrobel··on Nobody has found a use case for blockchain
In April a power outage in China caused Bitcoin hash rate to drop by 45% - https://news.bitcoin.com/bitcoin-hashrate-drops-xinjiang-bla...

In the idealized little crypto world no one person has control, sure, but we have one country with the majority of the raw compute power on the earth and a government that has no problem seizing control over that compute power when it suits them.

One of the many reasons I am bearish on crypto and have been since 2014.

taywrobel··on Go 1.17 Beta
Especially when tossed in a container for most workloads nowadays. You can have a full go binary statically linked and copied into a FROM SCRATCH docker image and it just works, and is miniscule.

For example, that's all that the production image of NATS Streaming is - https://github.com/nats-io/nats-streaming-docker/blob/024b04...

taywrobel··on How I, as someone who is visually impaired, use my iPhone (2020)
If it’s something that makes someone understand and enjoy their chosen wallpaper preference better is it really useless?

I guess it comes down to your personal interpretation of “usefulness”, but frankly I think you take for granted the amount of detail that you’re able to ascertain from being (presumably) fully sighted.

There’s no reason that someone with any visual disability can’t appreciate a scene with as much detail and intricacy as you can, if it’s adequately conveyed to them.

Words and grammar can be learned and expounded upon, but the description of a scene as “a tree on top of a hill” cannot, so why not err on the side of being overly descriptive for those that can understand, and leave the door open for those that can learn more?

taywrobel··on How I, as someone who is visually impaired, use my iPhone (2020)
Having several friends on the Apple a11y team, they really do work tirelessly to make the accessibility experience amazing. A lot of the engineers on that team have visual, audiotory, or other physical impairment as well, which is really cool to see and as a result they’re all really invested in making the product accessibility awesome.

Personal favorite “Easter egg” in their accessibility utilities is the baroque voiceover descriptions for the built-in wallpapers. A current colleague of mine shared it last week as part of Global Accessibility Awareness Day - https://twitter.com/mattt/status/1395439320652148736?s=21

taywrobel··on Kafka without ZooKeeper
StreamNative doesn’t lock critical functionality behind enterprise agreements while still advertising the software as open source, and doesn’t openly lie about what the system capabilities are.

Not saying that they won’t turn evil at some point, but so far they’re leagues ahead of Confluent in terms of earning developer trust. At a minimum this developer, but also others that I’ve worked with.

Maybe I’m the minority opinion here and that’s fine, but confluent has been far too shady for me to ever consider contracting with them.

taywrobel··on Kafka without ZooKeeper
> The broader Kafka ecosystem has features like exactly-once support

No. No it doesn’t. It has at-least-once delivery with client-side deduplication. That’s not new, it’s what TCP does FFS. Why would you lie to people about supporting something long established at best and demonstrably impossible at worst?

> Finally, I work at Confluent....

Oh, that’s why. Never mind then. Continue selling digital snake oil.

taywrobel··on Kafka without ZooKeeper
Fair enough, not hijacking. Just presenting the software as open source then requiring you to pay substantially for features that it’d be irresponsible to use the software in production without (e.g. geo replication via mirror maker).

Add to that their insistence in claiming “exactly once delivery semantics” from Kafka despite that being provably impossible and I don’t see any reason to trust them as a company or pay for their software.

I’ve been sticking to pulsar for all new projects and have yet to hit a single drawback. It scales better, has less fiddly knobs needing adjusting, has cluster management already built in, and supports traditional pub/suv as well as worker queue semantics. It even has Kafka compatible adapters so it’s relatively easy to migrate existing systems.

Kafka played an important role in the history of distributed system design but it’s time to move to something better built and better managed IMO.

taywrobel··on Kafka without ZooKeeper
If designing a new system is there any reason to choose Kafka over Pulsar at this point?

Apart from Confluent wanting you to use Kafka so they can keep leeching money off you by hijacking de facto ownership of an open source project, of course.

taywrobel··on Kafka without ZooKeeper
NATS by itself doesn’t handle the persistence side at all (by design). It’s at most once delivery, not at least once.

That being said, have you checked out NATS Streaming Server? It’s effectively a first party client for NATS that gives it at least once semantics and persistence, and makes it much more applicable to use cases that are currently on Kafka.

Docs here if you’re curious - https://docs.nats.io/nats-streaming-concepts/intro

taywrobel··on Adobe will end support for Brackets on September 1, 2021
Not the right forum for this type of shallow dismissal. Please be more substantive with comments or don’t comment at all.
taywrobel··on Plain Text Protocols
There’s a difference between the transport and the protocol. For instance I’ve used Redis fronted by TLS in the past. Initial connection did get more tricky for sure, needing to have the certs in place to first connect.

However after the connection was established with OpenSSL I was able to run all the usual commands in plain text and read all the responses in plain text. Having transport layer encryption on the TCP connection didn’t effect the protocol itself at all.

taywrobel··on Palantir’s God’s-Eye View of Afghanistan
Thanks, dang, you do a great job moderating discussion on HN.

FWIW I don’t feel personally attacked here, and I accept that this is a contentious issue where hyperbole is likely to happen, but I really appreciate you being a mediating voice advocating for positive discourse rather than just shutting down all discussion that becomes contentious.

taywrobel··on Palantir’s God’s-Eye View of Afghanistan
I’m not a fan of invoking Godwin’s law, I only mentioned the nazis because the commenter I responded to make the allusion.

And you’re entitled to your opinion, of course, but I wouldn’t recommend trying to presume anyone’s intentions.

taywrobel··on Palantir’s God’s-Eye View of Afghanistan
Good news/bad news.

Good news is that I was one of those people that had a clearance, so can confirm that those individuals exist at least.

Bad news is because I had a clearance, I can’t say anything more than that. Way too much liability to even speak vaguely about it, even tho I no longer have it. The US government doesn’t play around with that type of stuff.

taywrobel··on Palantir’s God’s-Eye View of Afghanistan
Disclaimer that I left in 2014, but at that time they didn’t lean into their reputation at all. With that said, <speculation>I’d guess that they’re leaning into it and capitalizing on it because any press is good press. </speculation>

They were actually incredibly open with what they did technically, and a lot of who they worked with it’s just that nobody seemed to care at the time. They had tech talks showing the full system architecture on YouTube that didn’t get more than 10k or so views. A quick search indicates that a lot of those are gone now (maybe just outdated) and the channel is more marketing heavy now, but just as low trafficed.

They also open source a lot of their core technologies. The main database they used was “AtlasDB”, a relational layer on top of Cassandra. It’s open sourced and actively developed, and again, nobody seems to care, with it at a measly 700ish stars - https://github.com/palantir/atlasdb

People just like a good boogie man story, and after 2 decades of being labeled as such eventually you just stop trying to fight it I guess.

taywrobel··on Palantir’s God’s-Eye View of Afghanistan
It’s okay, I’ve tried to explain what Palantir does on a few threads and always get a decent amount of pushback. So it goes with politicized issues.

So I get a lot of downvotes and lose some imaginary internet points; that’s fine. I’m not attacking anyone, and for the most part nobody is attacking me, so I’d still call this healthy if contentious debate.

taywrobel··on Palantir’s God’s-Eye View of Afghanistan
Maybe I’m old fashioned, but I’d rather address the nazis themselves than the tools they use. People still drive Volkswagens and wear Hugo Boss.

Edit: A bit surprised to see this comment flagged. What about HN's guidelines were violated by this response to the parent comment's allusion to Nazis?

taywrobel··on Palantir’s God’s-Eye View of Afghanistan
I get that opinions differ on how to handle situations like these, and I respect that disagreement, but I’m personally of the opinion that if you don’t like what government does, vote to stop them from doing it.

Don’t blame those that build the software they use. To me that makes every open source project a potential ethical minefield since they could all be getting used to do immoral acts without even knowing about it.

As a concrete example, most of Palantir’s indexing and searching back when I was there was done using lucene. Should the lucene authors feel some moral conflict over this? If we’re shifting blame/responsibility down the tech stack why stop at the productized form? Why not the libraries? Why not the language?

I understand that the case is different since Palantir is more purpose built for this type of work, but you have to admit the lines get blurry pretty quickly.

taywrobel··on Palantir’s God’s-Eye View of Afghanistan
Having worked at Palantir in the past, I’d like to again take the opportunity to let everyone know what it is they actually do, because they really aren’t this all-seeing boogeyman of tech that everyone enjoys making them out to be (such rumors do bolster their reputation, however, so they aren’t likely to correct them, and paranoid responses like some here just lend them more credence).

They build a federated search engine with a simple UI to make it accessible to a non-technical audience. That’s it. Have a whole lot of data in different databases/data lakes? Palantir will let you search across all of it quickly and simply. They don’t source the data, they even hold the data, they install their servers on premise with where the data is already being stored, and import it.

It’s a specialized Google with very robust and configurable access controls that you can buy and run because you’ve collected more data than you know what to do with.

Now you may still be legitimately unhappy with them because of who they work with or the implication of making those entities more efficient in processing data, but given that HN is a technical audience I’d really hope that we can get over this trend of thinking Palantir has some magical data summoning abilities.

taywrobel··on Why CockroachDB and PostgreSQL Are Compatible
While that's technically true, it isn't in any practical way. What K/V API does CockroachDB offer you as a user? The closest you can get is:

CREATE TABLE kv (key STRING PRIMARY KEY, value STRING);

But calling that a "key-value" store is disingenuous at best.

taywrobel··on Anathem
Anathem is great, but I'd call it the "hard mode" of Neal Stephenson's work. If anyone is wanting some easier to follow books by him to get started with, I highly recommend Seveneves (personal favorite) or Snow Crash (modern classic).
taywrobel··on Hexagonal Grids (2013)
I almost never use bookmarks any more, but I’ve had this page bookmarked for the better part of a decade now and still refer to it at least once a year, and I don’t even work in game development.
taywrobel··on Show HN: Weird JSON superset with BigInt, Infinity, TypedArray etc
Like JSON5?
taywrobel··on What's so great about Go?
That’s more a side effect of the tooling than the language itself tho.

“ Gofmt's style is no one's favorite, yet gofmt is everyone's favorite.”

https://go-proverbs.github.io/

taywrobel··on What's so great about Go?
TLDR;

- Simplified, familiar syntax for those who already know a C variant

- Concurrency model (CSP) which works nicely with the request/response paradigm of server communication

- Performance comparable to other statically compiled languages.

taywrobel··on NoisePage – Self-Driving Database Management System
Looks like Peloton finally got too popular for Andy Pavlo to keep using their name for the project.

Sort of a shame, I thought the old name was a more apt analogy for the goals of the system.

taywrobel··on A 20kg hybrid drone that can fly at 50kmh for 4 hours
Seems to be in a similar product category as Anduril’s Ghost sUAS - https://www.anduril.com/ghost

Less capacity, but longer flight time. Seems similarly marketed towards industrial/military use tho.

taywrobel··on Don't contribute anything relevant in web forums
Probably wouldn’t have crashed if it was contributed to a web forum instead of a personal site...
← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →