HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tbirrell

944 karma · joined August 25, 2016

submissionscomments
tbirrell··on Amazon announces candidate cities for HQ2
I would hate to have amazon here. I don't need my rent to go up or my commute to get longer.
tbirrell··on What really caused the Titanic tragedy
Anyone who has studied this event at any length will know it was a death by a thousand paper cuts. Trying to assign ultimate responsibility to Captain Smith is tenuous at best.

> 1. Why were the iceberg warnings ignored?

Its not the Captain's fault if information never reaches him. Trying to say Smith ran a sloppy ship or that was a "systemic failure of communications" is merely displaying ignorance.

> 2. Why was the iceberg not seen until too late?

The important phrase here is "The Titanic was going too fast for the crew to react because Captain Smith allowed his ship to exceed a safe speed for navigation conditions." And I'll grant this is fair. This was one of the situation where 4-5 unlikely things happened all at once. However, I will note that not all of this was on the Captain. Some of this is on the White Star Line and the macaroni operator. Without relevant info, Smith was justified in his expectation to not have to worry about iceburgs at that time of year.

> 3. Why was the Titanic traveling too fast for navigation conditions?

This is just a reiteration of point 2. Therefore I refer you to what I said there.

> 4. Why did the rivets fail?

"Captain Smith knew how dangerous an iceberg collision could be yet he still risked his ship being operated in unsafe conditions." I'm sure he also knew what would happen if a boiler exploded, yet he still allowed them to be fired on his ship. This article is just grasping at straws at this point. Captain Smith is in no way responsible of the construction of the ship and all accounts say he was not fully briefed on issues until _after_ the collision. And there was no reason to expect him to be! He was the Captain, not the architect. He had a reasonable expectation of quality of construction, just like when you buy a phone you expect it to function as advertised without having to be an expert on electrical and hardware engineering to make sure.

> 5. Why were there insufficient lifesaving equipment and procedures in place?

Again, this is the fault of the White Star Line. Blaming the captain for "allowing" the ship to be taken out of port shows a gross misunderstanding of the relationship between Captain and Company. A pilot expects the mechanics to make a plane airworth, and is not at fault for mechanical failure in flight. The captain is responsible for operation of the ship, not the construction or engineering or basic preparations of the ship. Are we going to blame him for lack of preparation if the bar ran out of martini olives?

This article is trying to bank on "TITANIC MYSTERY FINALLY SOLVED" and shows a fundamental lack of understanding. Which is quite shocking, to be honest, since they got a lot of the facts correct. The only thing I can guess is that they went into this article with an agenda and twisted interpretations until they got what they wanted.

As I said above, the Titanic was a death by a thousand paper cuts. Unfortunately, it was a necessary death to give us the marine safety regulations we have today. If any number of things had been just slightly different on the Titanic, it would be a footnote in history and we would be talking about a different ship that would have inexplicably had everything go wrong.

tbirrell··on The State of Atom's Performance
Okay... But can it handle mounted directories yet?
tbirrell··on Who owns the space between reclining airline seats?
Because humans, and by extension, airline seats, are primarily vertical in nature. Whereas cars are primarily horizontal in nature. So the elongated side is extending in a different direction.

In a parking lot, the shape, combined with the mechanics of parking, means that it helps to angle things. Though, you do lose one parking spot or so in the process.

In a plane, the sides of the object (in this case the upright coffin sized space you fit into) are roughly the same, so angling will do little to help and is largely unneeded to "park" yourself. Ultimately though, airlines are unwilling to lose that one row if they did compensate for the morphing a reclined seat does for the shape of things.

tbirrell··on Why Don’t Americans Understand How Poor Their Lives Are?
I think this is a result of never truly leaving a wartime economy. We had WWII, then the Korean War, then the Cold War (with Vietnam in the middle) all on top of each other and justifying the expense for almost 50 years. I don't think America knows how to cut defense without losing military dominance. As te_chris said, Defense spending might be a red herring, but I would say it is almost certainly the foundation of the problem.

The other major budget problem is welfare/comunal programs. These have been hyperinflated over the last 20-30 years or so. I personally believe one of the reasons it works so much better in Europe is the fact that any given program is orders of magnitude smaller than American attempts. To improve quality-of-life to the level the article wants, I think America need to trim (trim, not cut) military spending and stop welfare spending entirely and let the states handle it (with parameters of course, but it would be a far less unwieldy beast for them handle).

tbirrell··on Why Don’t Americans Understand How Poor Their Lives Are?
Because the money we put into Defense, Europe puts into the comunal programs that boost said quality-of-life indicators. Perks of being a superpower I guess. Love it or hate it, the argument could be made that without America choosing that path, Europe would not be able to enjoy the quality-of-life they have now.
tbirrell··on Design and Build Your Next Home in Minecraft
It feels like this article just kinda left off the end.
tbirrell··on Casualties of the Cashless Society: Those Who Get Seasonal Tips
$7.25 is not meant to be enough to live on. People were not meant to make a living flipping burgers. Its an entry level job. Minimum wage is where you start, not where you end.
tbirrell··on Ask HN: What do you do now that you'd pay 1000$ for?
One time fee: IDK. Probably nothing. Thats a hell of a lot of money. I only own two things worth more than that. A car and a computer.

Monthly: Definitely nothing. The only thing even remotely worth that amount that I absolutely need is housing. Odds are, the reason I'm doing "the thing" is to save that $1000. And if I'm not doing it, I obviously won't pay for it.

tbirrell··on Is Bitcoin a Bubble? Economists Say ‘Yes’
This sounds like the Joe Kennedy Shoe Shine story.
tbirrell··on Is Bitcoin a Bubble? Economists Say ‘Yes’
Fiat currencies are still reasonably stable compared to actual goods right now. I know that can and has changed in the past (pre/post WWII germany), but at the moment, they are not in a bubble. Not at the same level that bitcoin is, anyway.

How do I know this? Well, because I can still get a gallon of milk or loaf of bread for ~$3. If I put that $3 into bitcoin, I'd get some fraction of a coin (roughly 0.0001). Which is all well and good until the bubble bursts, and suddenly milk is worth 0.1 bitcoins. Did milk suddenly become 1000x more valuable? No, bitcoin lost value.

This is something I don't understand about people who say they "cashed out of fiat currency". Fiat currency is still what everything is valued by. The value of a gallon is milk is relatively stable. Compared to this, fiat fluctuates a little, and bitcoin is a drunk on a rollercoaster.

Which, if you consider fiat currencies to be a bubble, would make me even more concerned for bitcoin as it is a bubble within a bubble.

tbirrell··on How the US Pushed Sweden to Take Down the Pirate Bay
> I read a great article years ago where a Disney executive argued that they had to view pirating as a competing business model, and provide a better experience instead of just trying to shut it down.

This is exactly how Spotify get my money. It's so much easier than trying to manage a pirated collection.

tbirrell··on Bitcoin Is the Total Opposite of a Ponzi Scheme – Here’s Why
IDK about that. Perhaps its not a ponzi scheme, but it is still a remarkably bad idea (right now at least). From my perspective, it is not fiat currency that is massively devalued suddenly, its bitcoin being absurdly expensive. How do I know this? Well, because I can still get a gallon of milk or loaf of bread for ~$3. If I put that $3 into bitcoin, I'd get some fraction of a coin (roughly 0.0001). Which is all well and good until the bubble bursts, and suddenly milk is worth 0.1 bitcoins. Did milk suddenly become 1000x more valuable? No, bitcoin lost value.

This is something I don't understand about people who say they "cashed out of fiat currency". Fiat currency is still what everything is valued by. The value of a gallon is milk is relatively stable. Compared to this, fiat fluctuates a little, and bitcoin is a drunk on a rollercoaster.

Maybe bitcoin is not a ponzi scheme, but it can still bankrupt you. And when it is all said and done, what's the difference?

tbirrell··on IRC Netiquette and You
I found IRC through an online game many years ago in my teens. There are times I am amazed how much could be done with none of the bell and whistles chat platforms have today.

I'd agree with most of the rules, though I wonder how many more people will ever need to learn them. Unfortunately, IRC is a fading medium. There will be those who always stick with it, but they will be growing fewer in number every day.

tbirrell··on Show HN: Culture Queries – The best questions to ask during your job interview
CSS-Mastery FTW.

I did refresh the page, which was how I found the the input field again. Yep. Given the comments here on HN, it is fairly evident not many do.

tbirrell··on Show HN: Culture Queries – The best questions to ask during your job interview
That blur is clever. Kudous. One suggestion I have is to have another email submission field since I just got rid of the last one. I don't want to have to go looking for it. It actually took me a moment to remember where it was, since those pop ups are never something I pay attention to.
tbirrell··on Turbolinks: SPA-like Experience without the SPA-framework Hassle
Er... Yes. Its fairly easy. Granted I've never done anything on the scale of FB or Netflix, but SPAs are not as difficult as everyone likes to think they are.
tbirrell··on Meat tax ‘inevitable’ to beat climate and health crises, says report
> Furthermore, many people already eat far too much meat, seriously damaging their health and incurring huge costs.

What? I'm getting fat on pasta and breads. I need to actively eat more meat. And given the cost of meat compared to carbs, I'd bet dollars to donuts that the vast majority of people in the middle and lower class face the same problem. Meat is not the health problem here.

tbirrell··on The Cost Savings Of Netflix's Internal Spot Market
Can someone explain what a spot market is in this context?
tbirrell··on Ask HN: What tips do you have for weathering a recession?
What do you do for variety? If anything.
tbirrell··on Ask HN: Who's switched from Chrome to Firefox 57?
I tried to switch, but FF does not allow local files to be loaded. Since I use a bunch of Tampermonkey scripts (which I save and edit locally), it was a non-starter for me. Perhaps if they ever fix this issue, I might try again.
tbirrell··on A Beginner´s Guide to Getting Things Done
The first paragraph is a reference to this gem from the 80's called "Safety Dance"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjPau5QYtYs

tbirrell··on Ask HN: What do you care about most when looking for a new job?
A mix. I don't have an office/remote choice anymore, so flexibility manifests more along the lines of I chose which 40 hours I spend working. 4 long days and a half day are not uncommon.
tbirrell··on Ask HN: What do you care about most when looking for a new job?
In no particular order...

Flexibility. It is a hard 8-5? Or can I swing it either way an hour or two if need be?

Commute. It needs to be a reasonable drive in the morning. Work already takes enough of my day, I don't want to sacrifice the rest to the gods of traffic.

Pay. It needs to be reasonable. Obviously.

Benefits. This gets the honor of picking up any slack in the pay department.

tbirrell··on The Future of RethinkDB
Thats a lot of text...

Also https://xkcd.com/927/

tbirrell··on Against an Increasingly User-Hostile Web
I agree with much of this article, but at this point I'm dangerously close to falling into the camp of, "is it even worth it?" I have been using google accounts for almost 10 years, I'm very much locked into that ecosystem. Even if there was a privacy issue, I wonder if it is worth the monumental hassle to leave and spin up my own versions of everything I use.

Thanks to equifax, all my most important information is probably already out in the wild, and thanks to the US government (and how they deal with replacing identifying information) I'm likely screwed for the rest of my life. In the face of that, the harm that google or facebook (which I'll admit to using less and less of) can do to me seems trivial.

Yeah, as a user, I'm a commodity online. But I'll be damned if I'm not enjoying the bread and circuses they use to keep me there. There is little to nothing I can do to prevent anyone from doing anything with my information, so I might as well take advantage of what I've already "paid" for.

tbirrell··on Nativefier – Make any web page a desktop application
Yeah but see, the tabs share the browser environment. Each electron tries to run its own chromium instance. One of these is a memory hog and the other is a literal fire under your desk.
tbirrell··on Being less friendly to advertisers insulates Snapchat from viral hoaxes
This webpage is physically painful to read.
tbirrell··on Rising Rents Are Pushing More Tenants Past the Breaking Point
Google Cache Link to avoid paywall: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:-cyHPK...
tbirrell··on Show HN: Tello, a simple way to manage TV shows – built with React/Redux
I'll check this out when I get home, but what I'm wondering is if this supports rewatching a show. My current grievance with trakt.tv is that it'll track a show for you once, but the second time through, you either lose the history or have to keep track of which episode you are on somewhere else.
← PreviousPage 5 of 10Next →