HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tbrownaw

7,440 karma · joined December 21, 2009

Also tbrownaw@prjek.net on email. (Or @tbrownaw on Twitter, but I'm more likely to actually see an email.)

Whenever possible, teach the computer to do your work for you.

submissionscomments
tbrownaw··on Scott Adams has died
Ibram Kendi wrote about how the only way to not be racist is to deliberately treat people differently based on their race. He was quite popular for this for a while.

But also for the DEI thing specifically, what's going on is that objecting to the implementation details is proof that you oppose the stated goal. Even if what you're doing is pointing out that the implementation is counter-productive to the stated goal. I think it might be some sort of tribalism thing.

tbrownaw··on Scott Adams has died
> Maybe his corpse can identify as 'living'?

Kind of like the opposite of spending a year dead for tax purposes?

tbrownaw··on Scott Adams has died
> The latter are core moral views, and we should not be so quick to dismiss them as merely political.

Morality and politics and religion all have significant overlap.

tbrownaw··on Scott Adams has died
For example, the general attitude shift about Elon Musk following that cave rescue incident. Before that he could do no wrong, and after that he could do no right.
tbrownaw··on Scott Adams has died
It mocks diversity policies by presenting race as arbitrary and surface-level, rather than some deeply unchangeable thing that pervades every aspect of your being. Since diversity policies are a way to push back against judging people differently based on race (aka racism), mocking them is inherently supportive of racism.

And as the other commenter says, it also mocks trans people. By applying their language to something presented as arbitrary and surface-level.

tbrownaw··on Scott Adams has died
Huh. I would have thought something like that would be in response to Rachel Dolezal, but the Wikipedia page for "Transracial (identity)" says her fifteen minutes of fame was way back in 2015.
tbrownaw··on Scott Adams has died
It also doesn't allow for the whole affirmative action / disparate impact approach, yet that's how it got applied in practice for quite a while.
tbrownaw··on Is beef tallow making a comeback?
> [0] 80-90% of people describe themselves as an "above-average" driver.

What shape is the distribution of driving ability? It seems entirely plausible that most drivers are decent and a smaller population are bad enough to pull the mean down well below the median.

tbrownaw··on Is beef tallow making a comeback?
> As an outside observer of this beef tallow trend, it looks to me a lot like a fad driven by some internalized machismo: "It's not proper food if it's not from a dead animal."

Well, it's a response to the green/eco push for making do with protein from insects and plants only and that it's bad and wrong to have nice things because global warming and sustainability.

It's not a "something died for this so therefore it's better", it's "stop commanding me to not have nice things".

tbrownaw··on My Home Fibre Network Disintegrated
I kinda want some just 'cause it's cool, with the only problem being that I haven't been able to find an excuse to justify (to myself) needing it.
tbrownaw··on European Commission issues call for evidence on open source
> only Romance language

...But we're (mostly) not one?

tbrownaw··on European Commission issues call for evidence on open source
> That doesn’t mean “free as in beer,” but “free as in speech.”

It occurs to me that this is a rather US-centric analogy.

tbrownaw··on LMArena is a cancer on AI
From https://lmarena.ai/how-it-works:

> In battle mode, you'll be served 2 anonymous models. Dig into the responses and decide which answer best fits your needs.

It's not a given that someone's needs are "factual accuracy". Maybe they're after entertainment, or winning an argument.

tbrownaw··on LMArena is a cancer on AI
> Firstly, paying is not at all the correct incentive for the desired outcome. When the incentive is payment, people will optimize for maximum payout not for the quality goals of the system.

1. I would expect any paid arrangement to include a quality-control mechanism. With the possible exception of if it was designed from scratch by complete ignoramuses.

2. Do you have a proposal for a better incentive?

tbrownaw··on US will ban Wall Street investors from buying single-family homes
Not unless we decide that personal mobility is evil, and start just assigning people to plots of land when they reach adulthood.
tbrownaw··on US will ban Wall Street investors from buying single-family homes
I think the idea is that nobody would prefer to rent if given a choice, and that everybody could afford to own if not for the presence of landlords in the market.
tbrownaw··on US will ban Wall Street investors from buying single-family homes
When this doesn't make anything better, the conclusion won't be that it was a bad idea but that it somehow didn't go far enough.
tbrownaw··on US will ban Wall Street investors from buying single-family homes
Sure it can be an investment even with no capital gains, there's still income from charging rent.
tbrownaw··on US will ban Wall Street investors from buying single-family homes
> It's fine to ban big banks from buying homes and wont do damage to the nation

It makes things slightly worse for people who want a non-apartment house but think they might move soon.

tbrownaw··on US will ban Wall Street investors from buying single-family homes
> because there's one extremely obvious way to lower the price of building new housing: Reducing or eliminating tariffs on construction equipment and materials and ensuring a robust supply of low-cost labor.

Oh I thought the one extremely obvious way was to fix local policy roadblocks. After all, it's not like a lacking supply of housing is a new issue they suddenly appeared out of nowhere within the last dozen months.

tbrownaw··on US will ban Wall Street investors from buying single-family homes
So if you aren't staying long enough to want to deal with a mortgage, you'll be stuck with an apartment only?
tbrownaw··on On the slow death of scaling
> A pervasive belief in scaling has resulted in a massive windfall in capital for industry labs and fundamentally reshaped the culture of conducting science in our field.

People spend money on this because it works. It seems odd to call observable reality a "pervasive belief".

> Academia has been marginalized from meaningfully participating in AI progress and industry labs have stopped publishing.

Firstly, I still see news items about new models that are supposed to do more with less. If these are neither from academia nor industry, where are they coming from?

Secondly, "has been marginalized"? Really? Nobody's going to be uninterested in getting better results with less compute spend, attempts have just had limited effectiveness.

.

> However, it is unclear why we need so many additional weights. What is particularly puzzling is that we also observe that we can get rid of most of these weights after we reach the end of training with minimal loss

I thought the extra weights were because training takes advantage of high-dimensional bullshit to make the math tractable. And that there's some identifiable point where you have "enough" and more doesn't help.

I hadn't heard that anyone had a workable way to remove the extra ones after training, so that's cool.

.

.

The impression I had is that there's a somewhat-fuzzy "correct" number of weights and amount of training for any given architecture and data set / information content. And that when you reach that point is when you stop getting effort-free results by throwing hardware at the problem.

tbrownaw··on Why the trans flag emoji is the 5-codepoint sequence it is
One good way to make screen time (online; video games) slightly less unhealthy is a standing desk.
tbrownaw··on Why the trans flag emoji is the 5-codepoint sequence it is
> Note that I am not defending this decision (nor the usage of the glyph today). One could argue that historians should use a special font that can render these two glyphs, but the problem is likely a lot more subtle than I am thinking.

Having a deliberate policy of granting bad people permanent sole ownership of whatever symbols they use seems less than ideal.

tbrownaw··on Most websites don't need cookie consent banners
> the heuristic for whether you need the banner is essentially: is the user deriving the benefit, or just the operator?

This is just as bogus as the user vs developer distinction in copyleft world.

Of course users benefit from the operator knowing if their design decisions are actually on the right track.

tbrownaw··on Why Big Companies Keep Failing: The Stack Fallacy (2016)
> you don't eat a sandwich layer by layer

Some sandwiches naturally want to be eaten from the middle layer out.

tbrownaw··on AWS raises GPU prices 15% on a Saturday, hopes you weren't paying attention
> From a resource allocation perspective, this doesn't feel particularly undesirable, at least in terms of certain assets like vehicles. The current system of ownership is quite wasteful.

People are by and large not that dumb. If they consistently choose a more expensive alternative, it means the cheaper alternative is missing something that matters.

> I own a high end GPU that I use maybe 4 hours a week for gaming.

Why? Why currently prevents you from being more efficient and streaming your display from the cloud?

tbrownaw··on AWS raises GPU prices 15% on a Saturday, hopes you weren't paying attention
Headline: hopes you weren't paying attention

Body: The change had been telegraphed: AWS's pricing page noted (and bizarrely, still does) that "current prices are scheduled to be updated in January, 2026," though the company neglected to mention which direction.

These do not seem entirely consistent?

.

> This comes about seven months after AWS trumpeted "up to 45% price reductions" for GPU instances - though that announcement covered On-Demand and Savings Plans rather than Capacity Blocks. Funny how that works.

Assuming I found the right pricing page(s), this new increased price is still lower than those other prices that were lowered.

tbrownaw··on Anna's Archive loses .org domain after surprise suspension
> Also relays (not exit nodes) are pretty safe to operate and running them is a decent thing, supporting free internet instead of a corporate ads machine, let's not frame it as a "crime support".

Well the purpose of using Tor is to prevent any network operators from knowing who you're talking to. Which AIUI is primarily a concern if either you're not allowed to talk to whoever ("great firewall" type things), or you risk getting in trouble for talking to whoever (Silk Road etc, or disfavored politics).

I guess if you're worried about hacks and doxxing rather than LE? Or if you only call things crime when they should be illegal rather than when they formally are?

tbrownaw··on AGI Is Here
I want a thing that has a fuzzy capability <X>.

To make this easier to discuss and think about, here's a short name <Y> for that thing, and a longer definition <Z> that probably describes that thing.

.

Oh look, if I take the literal definitions of some words in <Y>, there's a thing that fits!

Therefore <X> is solved!

← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →