HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tbrownaw

7,440 karma · joined December 21, 2009

Also tbrownaw@prjek.net on email. (Or @tbrownaw on Twitter, but I'm more likely to actually see an email.)

Whenever possible, teach the computer to do your work for you.

submissionscomments
tbrownaw··on Global review confirms mRNA vaccines are safe, effective and full of promise 
> Also, the manufacturers can never be held responsible, because they have legal immunity for the COVID vaccines.

Since there was basically a soft mandate for it, especially on top of some of the usual official red tape being cut, the manufacturers really wouldn't be the appropriate party to hold responsibility. That'd be the government.

tbrownaw··on Are readers generating fiction with AI models?
I suspect that those other groups are largely not trying to generate fiction.
tbrownaw··on Are readers generating fiction with AI models?
I've heard that word used to refer to (still) pictures, and in more casual/offhand use to refer to text. I don't understand it as being quite so restricted by media-type as you seem to.
tbrownaw··on Historical memory prices 1960-2026
> The unit needs to be tied to the relative usefulness for its time.

That requires baking in assumptions, and makes the data less general.

You can go from $/gb to $/usefulness fairly trivially by adding assumptions, but you can't go the other way.

tbrownaw··on Ford rehires 'gray beard' engineers after AI falls short
It could also be that business conditions provided a convenient opportunity to run some experiments.
tbrownaw··on Michigan bill would bar employers from requiring after-hours coms with workers
> If you've ever worked in hospitality or retail, you'll know that managers will call/contact you at all hours to make sure they have coverage. It's irritating.

I vaguely remember a few years ago there was some news pushing new scheduling software that was supposed to help make schedules more predictable, and how it wasn't working to full potential because store managers wouldn't trust it.

But I don't think the bill in question here would actually do anything to affect that issue?

tbrownaw··on Michigan bill would bar employers from requiring after-hours coms with workers
I don't really see any other interpretation of saying that if someone says you're wrong you should update your worldview. There isn't much that could be other than a call for unquestioning belief.
tbrownaw··on Michigan bill would bar employers from requiring after-hours coms with workers
The comment I was replying to appears to be a call for unquestioning belief. Which is the far extreme in the opposite direction.
tbrownaw··on Michigan bill would bar employers from requiring after-hours coms with workers
> Someone is telling you the world works differently for them than it does for you, which means you've got an opportunity to learn something new about the world and expand your model.

...than it does for you, which means there's an opportunity for someone to expend resources verifying and characterizing the claimed difference.

tbrownaw··on Michigan bill would bar employers from requiring after-hours coms with workers
> a lot of people who are victims of

Are there statistics somewhere about what percent of people in various roles get asked but know they're safe declining, or mistakenly think they can't decline, or correctly think they'd get in trouble for declining, or don't get asked but think they have to anyway?

tbrownaw··on Michigan bill would bar employers from requiring after-hours coms with workers
> Indeed. If $job is not willing to buy and hand me a "work phone" then they are out of luck

My employer has a BYOD program with a monthly stipend that is somewhat more than my phone provider (Fi) charges for an extra line. I think doing this with a non-flagship phone would probably pay for itself in a year or two.

tbrownaw··on Michigan bill would bar employers from requiring after-hours coms with workers
> Maybe I just have abnormal leverage

It could also be a personality thing or a worldview thing.

Some people just have a hard time saying "no" in general, or are constantly looking for reasons to jump at shadows.

Or there's people teaching that the world runs on class warfare and anyone with any amount of power is always looking for an excuse to abuse that power.

tbrownaw··on Michigan bill would bar employers from requiring after-hours coms with workers
How would this interact with existing rules around exempt / non-exempt (roughly, salaried vs hourly) employees?

I would think it would already be expensive to make someone paid by the hour do extra work stuff during time they're not already being paid for.

tbrownaw··on Prairieland defendants sentenced today to prison terms ranging from 30-100 years
> I’m unsure what you mean by gated free speech zones. Sometimes specific areas are closed to vehicle traffic for a protest, but that doesn’t mean those locations are exclusively for protesting. In general protest is allowed wherever, provided it’s not on private property.

There are occasionally attempts to keep protestors away from wahtever's being protested. They tend to not do well when challenged in court.

Here's a couple (opinionated, obviously) articles:

https://www.fire.org/research-learn/free-speech-zones

https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/free-speech-zones/

tbrownaw··on Why were Covid vaccine trials so fast?
Still doing what, flagging attempts to derail threads into off-topic flamefests?
tbrownaw··on Why were Covid vaccine trials so fast?
How so? I would think that "whose fault is it" and "what can be done about it" are independent questions.
tbrownaw··on Zero-Downtime Deployments with Docker Compose – No Kubernetes Required
Are you implying that leaning on standard tooling is more arrogant than "hold my beer"?
tbrownaw··on Zero-Downtime Deployments with Docker Compose – No Kubernetes Required
> The reason people reach for Kubernetes (and similar) is because they need to scale past that single host dependency.

I have some stuff on single-node k3s. Because it's standard so I don't have to care.

tbrownaw··on Texas man sentenced to 30 years for transporting pamphlets
Here's an older article, talking about how the reason the authorities found this person was because one of the other defendants called him from jail to ask him to remove things: https://www.foxnews.com/us/man-busted-anti-government-anti-t...

I would expect that at that point it ought to stop mattering whether the evidence being hidden actually would have been useful evidence.

tbrownaw··on Texas man sentenced to 30 years for transporting pamphlets
> would be explicit in the article.

This is blatantly an advocacy piece, so that's not a valid assumption.

tbrownaw··on Texas man sentenced to 30 years for transporting pamphlets
I would think that a coverup should always be treated as slightly worse than the thing being covered up. Because of general "don't design systems with perverse incentives" principles.
tbrownaw··on Prairieland defendants sentenced today to prison terms ranging from 30-100 years
Headline: "for Common Protest Activity"

Body: "material support for terrorists, attempted murder, possession and conspiracy to use explosives"

Um?

tbrownaw··on Prairieland defendants sentenced today to prison terms ranging from 30-100 years
Hiding evidence tends to be bad, even when that evidence wouldn't itself be a problem without a crime for it to be evidence of.
tbrownaw··on Algorithmic Monocultures in Hiring
I read that question as a suggestion that the claim is unfalsifiable (ie, bullshit, unscientific, etc).
tbrownaw··on Algorithmic Monocultures in Hiring
> * Bias is absolutely impossible to avoid, especially with how today's "AI" works.*

Unless you're taking the "there are multiple mathematically incompatible ways to define bias" view of the topic, just do what's already known best practice for high-bureaucracy human review. Which is too define an overly-pedantic standard rubric.

tbrownaw··on Algorithmic Monocultures in Hiring
> That's a pretty common sense legislation to me.

There's no reason to single out AI vs any other approach to the same topics.

tbrownaw··on Algorithmic Monocultures in Hiring
The paper with the non-algorithmic screening used synthetic resumes. I rather suspect that they didn't generate a realistic distribution of qualifications levels.
tbrownaw··on Algorithmic Monocultures in Hiring
> We need to be very careful when using AI systems to evaluate people in general -- not because they might be biased (which they might be), but because even a small bias, if used by virtually everyone, can be damning.

I don't think this even requires any bias.

Assume there's some loose ordering of who is or isn't a good hire, and every employer has their own fuzzy view of it. If you get slightly better or worse as a potential hire (pick up an extra degree, let your latest certification lapse, whatever), it gets somewhat easier or harder to get hired.

Now assume that same ordering, but all employers share the same view of it. I'd expect the divide between employable and not employable to be much sharper.

tbrownaw··on Algorithmic Monocultures in Hiring
> We find that people who submit multiple applications to positions screened by the same algorithmic hiring vendor are more likely to be rejected from every position to which they apply than would be true if the companies made decisions statistically independently from one another. Ten percent of applicants who submit four applications are rejected from all the places to which they apply.

> Our research also found that this pattern does not appear to be the case in other circumstances. We analyzed data from the largest prior study of hiring decisions, which sent 83,000 applications to 108 Fortune 500 firms during the same time period as our study and did not focus on whether AI was used to make decisions. We found that the rate at which applicants were rejected from every firm they applied to in this data was no higher than what you’d expect if each company decided independently of the others.

It sounds like this study was using real-world applicants, and the other study they're comparing against was using synthetic applicants.

Consider the chance of being accepted as being composed of signal+bias+noise. Noise is random. Signal is a per-applicant value, and what's meant to be measured. Bias is a per-group value, and an artifact of the measuring process.

If acceptance/rejection is independent between positions applied for (as in the synthetic applicant study), that suggests that it's random or composed entirely of noise; ie there is no signal; ie the applicants are all equally qualified.

If acceptance/rejection is correlated, that means there is some nonzero amount of (signal+bias). But real-world applicants are not all identical, so there should be some amount of signal. So you can't just assume zero signal in order to infer that there must be bias.

tbrownaw··on Health insurance claim denial rates range from 13% to 35% by insurer
4. It's something that might help a bit, but the patient would still be fine without. Ie, a disagreement over what "necessary" means.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →