HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tcarnell

269 karma · joined July 24, 2009

Tom Carnell - CTO & Co-founder ETFmatic Ltd - UK/EU robo-adviser

Tom Carnell

submissionscomments
tcarnell··on Chrome and misleading security information
I think I would be more relaxed if browsers used an additional icon to indicate if a site identity is verified or not.

And just because somebody has paid for a site certificate and gets a nice green padlock icon on the URL bar does not mean they wont misuse peoples personal information, does it?

tcarnell··on Do computers have a constitutional right to free speech?
First prove that a computer is capable of 'free speech' and forming opinions. And if, in the very unlikely case that a computer could form an opinion even slightly related to the human world, then the issue may become relevant.

However, it is extremely likely that a computer will never genuinely form its own opinion about human issues such as birth control or racism.

But what about animals? Just because we lack the ability to understand their communication (computers 'trick us' because they appear to communicate in human dialect) doesn't mean they aren't harbouring controversial or illegal views - should animals be condemned for theft and tax evasion?

tcarnell··on NASA successfully launches 5 Jet Stream monitoring rockets
I'm sure NASA just invent important sounding work so they can play with rockets.

...do the Jet Streams 'really' need monitoring? they have probably been doing fine for years!

tcarnell··on Ask HN: Anybody need a Contract Management System? I built one but...
It could be...

The application basically allows you to enter contracts you have - for example software licenses or contracts with suppliers and as those contracts change over time (ammendments and addendums), and contract terms come and go, the application will send alerts for when things need to get done. It also handles terms that automatically roll over etc and has quite a comprehensive import tool to allow you to import existing contract data into the system.

It was primarily design for companies that have many contracts with suppliers, re-sellers and licenses etc.

Let me know if you want more information. I really dont have any plans for the application, so I am just seeing if anybody else might find it useful, or is looking for something similar.

tcarnell··on A two column hacker news?
Yes, I've noticed this quite a lot recently, that somebody posts an article that become popular, soon after there appear 'secondary' articles which seem to be trying to ride the same wave. It could be genuine, but I also suspect people just quickly knock up 'follow up' articles to get the traffic. This almost always seems to happen when a new PG essay is posted.

How could the quality of HN be measured? (very Robert Persig!)

tcarnell··on A two column hacker news?
Perfect! good thinking and you read my mind!
tcarnell··on The Internet - and what it could be
Ok, apart from the 'plug' about LiveDirectory, I really wish there were some standard like the:

http://example.com/services.json http://example.com/data.json

as suggested in the article.

tcarnell··on JQuery 1.7.2 Released
And if you want your app to recieve a callback when jQuery is released, you can subscribe here:

http://livedirectory.org/profile/jquery/latest_version

To create the subscription, use the API call defined in the last text box on the page, under the section "API Access to create a subscription for this data item" API Access to create a subscription for this data item

tcarnell··on JQuery 1.7.2 Released
Although download link still points to 1.7.1 - Actually Femtoo.com has told me a few times that 1.7.2 has been 'released' when actually it hasn't!
tcarnell··on Fluid windows
I have also used keyboards that have extra buttons for things like this, but somehow I have felt reluctant to make the effort to use them because they are not standard and most other keyboards dont have them, which would frustrate me more!

Who is in charge of keyboard standards? If there isn't anybody, could we start a new keyboard layout organization!?!?

tcarnell··on Fluid windows
If keyboards had these button by default, this would actually allow the user interfaces to be cleaned up and have a lot of these 'non-metaphorical' UI componentes removed - "closing a window", what is this a metaphor of? When I close a real window, it doesn't vanish, it just stops air getting inside!
tcarnell··on Fluid windows
I am amazed at how poorly modern keyboards support our highly visual modern user interfaces. Wouldn't the following keyboard buttons be generally REALLY useful:

- Open

- Close/Exit

- Save

- Copy

- Paste

- Menu (to list available context options)

- Help (to show context help)

- Maximize/Restore (toggle mode)

- Info

And the potentially very useful directional arrows keys are almost completely useless except when editing text (although game developers use them meaningfully)

The keyboard is also littered with buttons whose function are designed specifically for text editing, not necesarily a bad thing, but when was the last time anybody actually reviewed the efficiency of the modern keyboard to discover if it is doing a good job or not!?!?!

tcarnell··on Fluid windows
great!
tcarnell··on Yahoo's 10 patents that it claims Facebook infringed
Here is a great response to the news (sorry if already posted somewhere on HN):

http://www.avc.com/a_vc/2012/03/yahoo-crosses-the-line.html

tcarnell··on Yahoo's 10 patents that it claims Facebook infringed
ah, thanks for clarifying.
tcarnell··on Yahoo's 10 patents that it claims Facebook infringed
...but aren't Yahoo in bed with Microsoft... who are one of the largest share holders of Facebook?
tcarnell··on Frighteningly Ambitious Startup Ideas
An obvious but scarey startup idea to me a a Skype competitor!
tcarnell··on Scraping Web Pages With jQuery, Node.js and Jsdom
Thanks for sharing. This is a bit off-topic, but if you are interested in Scraping Web Pages, you might find that http://cQuery.com is an interesting solution which uses CSS Selectors (much like jQuery) as its mechanism to extract content from live web pages.
tcarnell··on There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz format.
Is the 192 the bitrate or the frequency response? I thought 192 in MP3 was the bit rate, not the maximum frequency response...
tcarnell··on There is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz format.
Has anyone had a look at their hi-fi amp recently? If probably probably doesn't handle much more than 80 kHz and your speakers probably dont respond to anything over 20 kHz. So yes, 192 kHz is pointless UNLESS you intend using it for studio quality editing/mixing - and I'm sure Steve Jobs would not have encouraged this!
tcarnell··on Jobs made Apple great by ignoring profit
eh? they build phones in China - the other side of the world with a massive language and culture barrier with the sole purpose of saving money - how are they NOT thinking about profit !!!
tcarnell··on Look for opportunities rather than ideas
What the startup industry needs is for the business world to feel that they can pay a reasonable price and get a great bespoke software product built. In just the same way they pay for insurance, legal fees, IT, staff, they also pay for somebody to build them bespoke software for their company.

If the business world thought like this, then we (developers) would not have to 'guess' what would be a good or valuable idea, the business world would give it to us.

tcarnell··on Asciiflow - ASCII Flow Diagram Tool
I love it!
tcarnell··on What Would The End Of Football Look Like?
Well, for 99% of the world, the end of American Football would probably go unnoticed...
tcarnell··on You're Overthinking It
Exactly. Do something, lauch something, enjoy yourself, but dont call this a 'business' or yourself an 'entrepreneur'.
tcarnell··on You're Overthinking It
...so how would corporate banking systems get built?

Although I understand the sentiment, and have followed it with a number of my projects, an aweful lot of companies build and sell software that is not necesarily useful for their own purposes (banking, financial, retail etc).

A better and more general rule, and one that has been stated millions of times is simply its really REALLY important to known and understand your client*.

The client could be a 'normal' Internet user, or could be a multi-million dollar enterprise, but unless you understand them, you can forget trying to get money out of them! (and if they are a multi-million dollar enterprise, the people you need to sell to are very unlikely to be the people that actually use the system and you absolutely do need a mature product strategy and the necesary resources to even make a single sale).

tcarnell··on Desingineer – the mythical person every startup is looking for
(and no, I am not expecting and up-votes for that comment! - but just maybe something interesting will come my way...)
tcarnell··on Desingineer – the mythical person every startup is looking for
but I'm no myth! http://tomcarnell.com And as it happens, I'm looking for a new project for 2012... :-)
tcarnell··on Why apps are not the future
Yep, completely agree with the article. For me an important difference between the 'web' and 'apps' is that generally speaking nobody builds mobile apps out of generosity or egalitarianism, ie to give something to the world for free - mobile app developers are in it for the money.

However, the openness and non-proprietary nature of the web seems to encourage people to be generous and share content and services.

How many open source mobile apps are there compared to really great open source web/pc software?

tcarnell··on Apps are too much like 1990's CD-ROMs and not enough like the Web
Great insight, I mostly agree. And I am really crossing my fingers that HTML5 will quickly become a recognized app technology across all web platforms.
← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →