HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tcarnell

269 karma · joined July 24, 2009

Tom Carnell - CTO & Co-founder ETFmatic Ltd - UK/EU robo-adviser

Tom Carnell

submissionscomments
tcarnell··on Idea of the day - CPU heated external keyboards
Yeah, you're probably right! Good thing I didn't call the patent lawyers just yet!
tcarnell··on What really happened aboard Air France 447
good point - but I think a 'dual input' mode is the wrong solution to that problem.
tcarnell··on What really happened aboard Air France 447
... so if there was a noise (intercom, radio, talking etc) and you didn't hear the announcement, that's it ,game over.
tcarnell··on What really happened aboard Air France 447
completely agree about this 'dual input' mode - crazy.

But also these modern planes seem to jump in and out of 'modes' without any warning or confirmation.

I believe the 2008 plane crash at Madrid (largely pilot error again) also suffered from some confusion about the plane 'mode'. It was set to 'normal flight mode' whilst attempting to take off (or something).

Again, both crashes largely due to 'usability' issues and cockpit design.

tcarnell··on What really happened aboard Air France 447
yes, and I'm not sure under what situation a 'democratic' dual-input mode is a good idea!

Maybe everyone on the plane could have one!

tcarnell··on What really happened aboard Air France 447
Presumably the stall warnings were ignored because in "normal law" even if you try to stall the plane, a). the plane will not allow itself to stall and b). the stall warning will still sound.

Hence the stall warning SHOULD NEVER SOUND in "normal law" mode.

Therefore, the only time a pilot should hear the stall warning is when they actually have to intervene.

Ultimately, if the plane was funcioning perfectly well and assuming the pilots weren't complete idiots, the problem was a 'usability' issue.

(think again everytime you see a bug logged as 'usability' and assume it is not important!)

tcarnell··on Show HN: 300x288 pixel clock using HTML5 canvas and Javascript
ooh - make a yearly one!!!

colours could be used to mean different things! day, night, summer, winter, full moons etc... cant think of a use for it right now, but I'm sure one will 'spring' to mind! ;-)

tcarnell··on Living Earth Simulator will simulate the entire world
...and its only a matter of time before the simulated world creates their own simulation...

But I wonder how many simulations deep we are now???

tcarnell··on Every death on every road in Great Britain 1999-2010
I'm quite surprised at the lack of 'hot spots' - areas of concentrated fatalities. Had a quick look at some areas I have lived in, including SE11 (south/central London), especially around Elephant & Castle am quite surprised that actually, there are generally fairly few fatalities when considering this spans a decade of data.

Obviously pedestrians and cyclists are far more at risk of being a fatality, so the stats certainly dont represent general accidents, even serious ones.

tcarnell··on Ask HN: How many of you built a profitable startup while having a day job?
thanks so much for the great feedback! I'll make the quick changes ASAP and start reworking the UI - again, thanks so much!
tcarnell··on Poll: HN readers, where's your residence?
ha ha ha ha !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
tcarnell··on Ask HN: How many of you built a profitable startup while having a day job?
I built Femtoo.com in my 'spare' time. It was built whilst working at a day job over the course of a year or so.

It brings in a small amount of money each month and it pretty much requires no maintenance. However I would not say that it is profitable (yet), there is a fair way to go before it brings in enough money to have justified the time.

I would spend more time implementing new features if I thought it would result in a significant increase in paying users.

...not sure what to do with it now really!?!? Suggestions welcome!!!

tcarnell··on Poll: HN readers, where's your residence?
yay! I'm based in Madrid! and am looking for new projects come the new year... feel free to get in touch (tomcarnell.com)
tcarnell··on Poll: HN readers, where's your residence?
Do people post this stuff just to earn karma points? What use would this half-thought through data set provide? and who would use it?

Can we NOT repeat the same polls again?

I suggest creating a Hacker News 'polls' section which lists a permanent list of polls ideally with a public data API and bonus points for a pub/sub mechanism to help 3rd party application developers build something that might actually be useful...

I'll even build it for you, but only if there is a purpose to it all.

tcarnell··on Poll: HN readers, where's your residence?
Cant HackerNews just publish the Google analytics stats for this?
tcarnell··on Fliers Must Turn Off Devices, but It’s Not Clear Why
Exactly.

In addition, keeping passengers calm and relaxed is also a key point of security - roudy/drunk/agressive or even violent passengers can cause a lot of trouble on a flight when there are relatively few, fairly untrained flight attendants on board. Thus, if everybody was chatting away on their phones with annoying ring-tones going off every 2 minutes this would probably start aggravating people, so its just easier to say 'no mobile phones' - and if people have the impression it is a point of safety then they are more likely to obey them.

tcarnell··on Go nuts with CSS3 hover effects
Very impressive - I thing I like #10 the most! thanks
tcarnell··on Vertical vs. grid product listings - a surprising AB test
Interesting - have you got any external links you can post about this 'F' behaviour? I'd be interesting in reading them!
tcarnell··on Vertical vs. grid product listings - a surprising AB test
exactly, I find navigating a vertical list much less 'stressful' than trying to understand the ordering of a matrix while trying to digest the actual product info.

Also the eye is attracted first to the product images then moves naturally to the right to read the description, with the matrix the eye has to move less naturally downward to read the related product info.

tcarnell··on A Brief Rant on the Future of Interaction Design
Fantastic article - thanks for writing this - it is exactly how I feel about UI and the dissapointment that generally follows anything these days that is claimed to be "innovative".
tcarnell··on Microsoft may halt development work on Silverlight plugin after next release
they should have probably made this decision before starting the first release!
tcarnell··on Yahoo releases nodejs framework
Not really sure what problem this solves.

I could imagine something like this from college students, but with the resources Yahoo has I expect bigger, game changing technologies.

The only Yahoo technology I use for web development is the YSlow Firebug plugin...which is itself infinately less useful than Firebug!

tcarnell··on And breakbeat was born in 1969, 1:27 seconds into this song...
...and check out 5:35 into this song: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dNP8tbDMZNE
tcarnell··on 24 year old student lights match: Europe versus Facebook
Regarding deleted data: there are clearly two concepts of 'deleted' a). deleted in terms of the application/user interface (ie, it is no longer visible) and b). deleted in terms of physical removal from all permenant storage. Clicking on a button labelled "delete" does not necesarily imply one or the other.

For example, if I "delete" an email in google it is not deleted, it goes to my 'trash/bin' folder - is this also a breach of the law? and are we sure which definition the "Delete Forever" button is using?

...I suppose its up to the terms and conditions to define this.

tcarnell··on 24 year old student lights match: Europe versus Facebook
Yes, I pretty much agree with this. I am sure many IT companies could technically be in trouble with the Data Protection Act in the UK alone for very similar breaches as Facebook and I am sure many companies would not even be able to provide a CD containing a nice break down of all data about a user (even though they are legally obliged to do so).

However, I find it interesting why people get paranoid about the mindless jibber-jabber on facebook compared to the immense and more presice data google stores about individuals... and I imagine getting a CD out of google would be far harder than from facebook (by the looks of things).

Google are clever by being 'open' and allowing people to download 'some' of the data they hold about peoeple, but I am sure they would be as reluctant as facebook to make everything accesible.

tcarnell··on What is wrong with GWT.
thanks!
tcarnell··on What is wrong with GWT.
Absolutely. I am at a loss as to why people use Java for Internet facing sites and apps. Of all the things Java 'should' be used for (embedded apps and desktop applications) it gets most used for the one thing it wasn't designed for - the web.

So...was GWT developed for Java web developers that didn't want to learn Javascript? Javascript is just one of the things you have to know how to use to build a modern web site or web application.

tcarnell··on What is wrong with GWT.
Actually, I think your last sentance exactly highlights my point (I dont know how to do that italicy/quote thing).

Whether you choose to write your code in Java or Javascript doesn't matter because it will HAVE to be run in a Javasript environment (browser) so you will always be limited to the target language - Java allows you to connect to databases with JDBC, read/write files and create rich user interfaces - none of these language features can be used by javascript in a browser.

So solving a problem that is more appropriate for Java can never be a problem that needs to be solved inside a browser by javascript...

tcarnell··on What is wrong with GWT.
Javascript is interpreted. Which actually highlights my point that languages (of any level) have usually been designed to solve a particular set of problems or targetted for a particular type of runtime environment.

Thus, the likelihood is that converting Java into Javascript or Pl/SQL into LISP or ActionScript into Python will provide no benefit but will almost certainly complicate the development process.

tcarnell··on What is wrong with GWT.
EVERYTHING is wrong with GWT - just dont use it.

Generally I believe the idea of writing code in one language to be converted into another is wrong. Languages are tools to do a job - pick the right one for the job or it will end in tears.

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →