HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tcarnell

269 karma · joined July 24, 2009

Tom Carnell - CTO & Co-founder ETFmatic Ltd - UK/EU robo-adviser

Tom Carnell

submissionscomments
tcarnell··on Businessweek Magazine's Classy Tribute to Steve Jobs
...and why couldn't all of that have been prepared in advance? I find it somewhat disturbing to have already prepared an obituary, but how do we know that there isn't a pile of similarly, very well produced and finished magazines waiting to go the press of other famous business figures?
tcarnell··on An Encrypted, Inherently Secure Social Network?
I think this is a very interesting idea and things like a 'group' or an 'event would simply have their own private/public key to allow subscribers etc. But two thoughts spring to mind:

1). Without the marketing/advertising opportunity, who will be prepared to pay for a facebook like IT infrastructure?

2). In some ways I quite like that criminal or otherwise sinistre behaviour/communications could potentially be intercepted and policed by some authority for the benefit of others - ie, the bad guys dont have anywhere to hide... (I'm expecting an onslought of critism from this comment!)

tcarnell··on UK government response to my letter about programming in schools
Well as nobody tought the founders to Google, Facebook or Microsoft to program a computer - especially at school, there is absolutely no logical reason to teach kids such a specific skill. The programmers I know, and notable the better ones are all self-taught (with the help of the astonishingly open and supportive IT community).

I think the author of the letter is somewhat confused as to Eric Schmidt's sentiment. I think schools could, or perhaps should provide better resources and encourage students to learn more about computer technology, but I agree with the other comments that core subjects like language, maths and science are far more important.

However, there is no reason why teachers could not discuss, when relevant the history, technology, people and science behind the British computer engineering legacy.

tcarnell··on What's wrong with this code, really?
If the code compiles and does what it is supposed to do, then the answer is that nothing is 'wrong' with it.

Writing code that does what it is supposed to do is often not the challenge of software engineering - but writing code that can be easily tested, refactored, altered and ultimately understood by other developers is the harder part.

The conditional statement used in the 'for' loop whose value can not easily be determined is not helpful and the i--; is 'unusual'.

In any case, it is more useful to code review the unit tests than the code itself.

tcarnell··on Break Google
I disagree! It does not make sense that submitting any text via a form input should in any way interfere with a templating engine, in the same way we dont expect to be able to affect a database by entering SQL into a form field.

The fact that Google brings back an empty result set to me indicates the problem is a bit deeper...

tcarnell··on Microsoft has Abandoned Silverlight and All Other Plugins
It wasn't necesarily a bad idea to compete with Flash, but SilverLight was about 10 years too late and offered no reason for the entire world to switch from Flash.

Thus, the end of SilverLight was just a question of 'when', not 'if'.

tcarnell··on If this then that
I'm not sure, but this is exactly what http://femtoo.com does. Femtoo allows you to select the exact part (or parts) of the page you wish to track.
tcarnell··on If this then that
Additionally, Femtoo stores every value of every change in content so you can see history data about flight prices with pretty graphs etc...oooohhh!
tcarnell··on If this then that
...yes you could - you can actually perform exactly those tasks using http://femtoo.com. Although IFTTT is great, Femtoo has the advantage that you can track changes and be notified, or fire events when content of ANY web page, not just those listed.

Femtoo also supports Notifo notifications (direct to your mobile) and optionally a URL callback, so you can even create your own event handlers.

For example, I have a Femtoo tracker that is monitoring the latest BBC news headline, whenever it changes, Femtoo calls the LiveDirectory.org API to update the BBC profile here: http://livedirectory.org/profile/bbc - as LiveDirectory.org is a pub/sub system, subscribers to the LiveDirectory BBC profile will recieve a webhook style callback.

tcarnell··on Freelance2 has launched - my lunchbreak project
I'll give you a point for that - my lunchtime project was beans on toast and a cup of tea.
tcarnell··on Google misspellings stats for "britney spears"
Yeah! I agree I think its a bit bold to say that Google 'corrected' "brandi spears" to "britney spears" - there almost certainly are numerous "brandi spears"...
tcarnell··on Google misspellings stats for "britney spears"
Actually, it seems these are only the spelling stats for misspelling 'britney' - every single 'spears' is spelt correctly. I was expecting to at least see 'britney speares' listed.
tcarnell··on People are biased against creative ideas, studies find
For me it is rewarding to here these findings written on paper. I am forever generating ideas and am continuously faced with awkard silences as people are not sure whether to laugh or congratulate me - it seems true, many people are unable to distinguish a good idea from a bad one (although the article talks specifically about 'creativity').

NB: In many occasions laughing maybe the most appropriate option!

tcarnell··on Show HN: weekend project, an attempt at a simple bed time calculator
I think finding your individual recipe for a good night sleep is really important. From what I have read people seem to have their own patterns etc. If the app also had some kind of feedback/tuning system so you could use it as a tool to find your perfect routine, this might be great...

TYPO: "try to get into bed around 15 before one of these times" - change to "15 mins"

tcarnell··on Does Google see UK developers as unimportant?
I think Berlin is a great choice - better than London. Berlin is developing and changing quickly and seems to be setting the scene for a perfect startup hub: lots of bright young people and cheap offices (cheap everything relative to the rest of europe) meanwhile London is primarily a financial district, not engineering.
tcarnell··on The Patent Pledge
Great stuff! I would add my company, but there is not point - I have no patents!

I think until we see Microsoft, Google, Oracle and Apple on that list it wont be worth much.... and if we do see Apple on that list, would be believe them? and would they care if we didn't believe them?

tcarnell··on Ask HN: Why don't we use subtitled films/tv to train speech recognition?
The problem with implementing this idea is which technology would actually have to be built, and in which technology the real value would lie. Once the technology is established, scanning videos, tv, radio etc for any source of spoken audio and building up a database of indexable dialogs would almost be the easy part.

Building a speech reconizer is not only difficult, it has also been attempted many times before and unless a speech recognition guru could bring something new to the world, the best we could do is what is already available - so probably best to use existing technology, which often is not cheap to get a license. This is also true with voice print technologies.

The key to getting this up and running lies in finding or building a really good speech recognizer and voice print generator/varifier...

Maybe this is something Y Combinator would be interested in funding? I am based in Europe (Spain at the moment) and I think it would be really hard to convince people to fund this type of technology over here.

If anybody is up for the challenge, I'd love to be involved!

tcarnell··on Ask HN: Why don't we use subtitled films/tv to train speech recognition?
I used to work for a company that built Speech Recognition systems and I came up with a similar/related idea - the idea being to take a load of videos of barack obama (for example), and create an accurate 'voice print'. Once done, any videos or speech could be scanned and if Barack Obama's voice print was recognized/detected, the recognizer could be tuned to his voice print AND could apply a set of appropriate grammars/vocabluary (for example the 'politics' grammar, or 'american' grammar or 'economics' grammar) - then you could very accurately perform speech recognition and automatically create text translations. Then when you google for text, you could actually retrieve videos whose content exactly matches the search terms and jump directly to that part of the video.

Over time you could build up a database of voice prints and grammars for not just celebrities, policitians, but also criminals (for automatic identification).

I had this idea almost 4 years ago, submitted it to the company, but it wasn't taken seriously.

If anybody is interested in this, let me know!

tcarnell··on Ask HN: Why don't we use subtitled films/tv to train speech recognition?
Very interesting. In a similar vein, automated language translation could be assisted too - beacuase a film DVD often has different audio and subtitle languages, so it would be possible to pair up semantically similar audio and written content... and put it all into a magic computer
tcarnell··on Ask HN: Any new HN Meetups globaly? Please update Google Doc...
I would be interesting in starting something in Madrid, Spain. If anybody else is interested, let me know...
tcarnell··on Poll: Do you use Google Reader on a daily basis?
If you are interested, feel free to get in touch - anything to help NewsBlur!
tcarnell··on Poll: Do you use Google Reader on a daily basis?
Very Impressive! I've been working on a number of 'content extraction' tools - cQuery.com and webXtract (experimental), but maybe you would find them a useful way to extract news and headlines from hundreds of online sources.

Here is an experiment that uses 'profiles' as a basis for content extraction:

http://webxtract.com/content-extractor

tcarnell··on VMWare Screw Customers
VMWare have started Screwing their Customers? Thats quite a diversion from virtualized operating systems. Does it scale?
tcarnell··on Play Button: a wearable, uneditable album
It would be really great if the buttons had two headphone jacks for sharing with somebody...
tcarnell··on Play Button: a wearable, uneditable album
That is a BRILLIANT IDEA! Such a great way to swap/share music with people too. I hope it takes off.
tcarnell··on Question for PG/HN: Where do you think we stand on your list of "ideas"?
I am currently building/have built a web-based spreadsheet with a really unique approach - something that Excel does not and can not do.

I will be presenting this at the Seedcamp in London later in the year. I am really exciting about the project, so I wont be giving anything away here! Unless PG wants to get in touch directly...

tcarnell··on Google just launched prizes.org
I dont believe this is from Google. Dishonest marketing from the real owner to post on HN that it is by Google...
tcarnell··on JQuery 1.6.2 released Or so says the front page...
...I'm using Femtoo to track when new JQuery releases are published - the front page of the website says 1.6.2, but the current release is still listed as 1.6.1 - I'm a bit too quick for them!
tcarnell··on ORM is an anti-pattern
I 100% completely agree with the article. ORM's are dangerous.

ORM's solve a problem we dont really have, but introduce a whole load of new problems we never had before (lazy loading does not work, object relations work completley different from table contraints, designing the domain layer to fit our persistance layer, learning new proprietary query languages, inability to control sql queries)

I am continuously amazed at how keen developers are to adopt them as a core part of a their product.

Thanks for the article - I feel relieved others feel the same way!

tcarnell··on My Email Canary
Following on from the idea of Google offering account access for different security levels, would also be great if you could label an email as 'bank', 'money' or 'personal' and these emails, photos and calendar items would only be visible with full account access - so effectively you could associate a particular email label to a 'security' or 'access' level.

I would DEFINATELY use a feature like this.

← PreviousPage 4 of 8Next →