HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tclmeelmo

264 karma · joined February 19, 2016

I have donkey brains.
submissionscomments
tclmeelmo··on Ask HN: Moving Out of Silicon Valley because of housing? Where to?
Since you like Korean and BBQ, have you been to Heirloom Market? http://heirloommarketbbq.com
tclmeelmo··on Ask HN: Moving Out of Silicon Valley because of housing? Where to?
> (though I'll miss the Sushi and Korean food greatly)

Are you not taking advantage of the Buford corridor?

tclmeelmo··on Apple Gets Tech Industry Backing in iPhone Dispute, Despite Misgivings
> The 5th amendment guarantees that you can't be forced to incriminate yourself.

It does, and my example was hyperbolic to my detriment by bringing in the 5th. The point I was trying to make was that the act you described (a manual signature to enable a search) was equally transgressive in my eyes.

The 1st Amendment does prohibit government-compelled speech, of which the act of digitally signing is (by analogy to signing) expressive conduct that merits protection. That alone should be sufficient to stop this case.

Your example doesn't apply here. For one, as far as I can tell, being forced to reveal one's own encryption key remains an unsettled matter (I would argue 5th Amendment protections apply, were I before the court). Apple is not being asked to supply something that they possess, they are being asked to use something that they possess, to create something that doesn't exist, to give to the government in order to enable a search. The government hasn't established if they have exhausted their own resources, they haven't (to my knowledge) proposed payment for Apple's services (which would as I see it constitute taking), and they haven't established the probative value of what might be on the phone (probably zip). And, if the product of this search were to come up in court, Apple would have to testify to their methods and be subject to cross-examination.

This whole situation is a tire fire.

tclmeelmo··on Why I think Tesla is building throwaway cars
> What? Fast means fast. The Model S goes fast. It has better performance than cars it competes with, like BMW 5/7 series, etc.

It goes fast in a straight line, perhaps better than it's competitors. It's also portly compared to some of it's competitors, and not as nimble. Fast in a straight line is boring.

> It's an absolutely horrible standard and that entire ecosystem should die. Every car should have an open API that is easily accessible using any computer, rather than specialized equipment.

OBD-2 certainly has its warts, but it's an interoperable industry standard. I have a hard time believing that an OBD-3 or a legacy-free de novo interoperable standard would be any less wart-free. Some warts come from interoperability compromises, some from the industrial constraints, some from the bureaucracy. I'll take an interoperable standard over any proprietary API, no matter how nice that API might be.

> Has anyone actually ever died in a Tesla? I believe one person did.

Amazingly, this is not a unique feat! There's actually a growing list of cars that are without recorded deaths: http://www.iihs.org/iihs/sr/statusreport/article/50/1/1

> Yes. Because Elon Musk is pulling a Henry Ford. They're more vertically integrated than any other car company. I'm not sure that's a good thing ... but it does support my point.

I don't see any basis for your claim that Tesla is more vertically integrated than any other car company, and I don't buy it. A DDG search pulled up this short list of Tesla subsystem vendors, and there are plenty that are obviously not 'Murican: http://moneymorning.com/2014/05/08/tesla-suppliers-list-thes...

In fact, Monroney stickers I see online put the domestic parts content of a Tesla Model S at 50%, here's one: http://www.midway-group.com/inventory/2015-tesla-model-s-p85...

> Well, yeah. Someone has to pay for it to get built and to maintain it. It's free in the sense that I don't have to explicitly pay for it. It's just included and I can use it as much as I want.

A DDG search showed that some earlier Model S had a $2000 option to gain access to the Supercharger network, so that would seem to be a good estimate for the cost. The Monroney above shows it as "included", which I would say counts as explicit even though the price isn't transparent.

> The Model S and Model X are excellent cars. Not perfect, but excellent. There's a reason they're eating up the entire luxury market.

They certainly have a dedicated fanbase that should be the envy of any car company, and I understand why they are popular as peppy urban people movers. I personally find them soulless, but Tesla drivers would probably find the cars I enjoy to be vulgar and uncomfortable :)

As to the "eating up the entire market" article, my criticism there is that the other luxury marques have a more diverse product line with considerable overlap. Saying that the Model S is the single best selling car model in that grouping isn't informative if the cohort who would consider a Model S are buying a mixture of BMW models.

tclmeelmo··on Why I think Tesla is building throwaway cars
Hah, yeah, it's hard to draw deep inferences from that data. They (IIHS) do have limited death statistics broken down by model, and Porsche is never near the upper end. The data is actually pretty interesting to pour over: you see some obvious trends (do not drive a small car) and some weird outliers (Nissan Titan has an usually high death rate for a pickup).
tclmeelmo··on Apple Gets Tech Industry Backing in iPhone Dispute, Despite Misgivings
In my mind, that leads to scenarios where the government "asks" someone to sign a confession. That's been done before, and it doesn't end well.
tclmeelmo··on Why I think Tesla is building throwaway cars
> > trying to be a fast car but only really good for 0-60 in a straight line

> LOL. I sense hurt feelings.

A Model S weighs something like 4700lbs, depending on battery? I suppose it depends on one's definition of "fast car", but I personally consider more than straight line performance, and lighter cars have a distinct advantage. I agree with Lotus's Colin Chapman: "performance through low weight".

> > no OBD-2 port as another poster pointed out

> Why would it need an OBD-2 port when it has an API? http://docs.timdorr.apiary.io/#

Because OBD-2 is a standard with an entire ecosystem built around it.

> 2. Safety. It is the safest vehicle on the road. Period. Because there is no engine block slamming in your face during a front-end collision.

That is an advantage (also, it's on the heavy side and mass helps a lot) and it certainly tests well in crashes. IIHS statistics for injury and medical payments don't however support your statement that it is the "safest vehicle on the road". Porsche's 911 and Boxster have lower Personal Injury Claim frequencies (and the Boxster doesn't even have a roof!).

> 4. No oil changes. No transmission failures. Fewer moving parts = less maintenance needed.

There might be less maintenance needed on some of the drivetrain leading to a more convenient service interval, but there still is maintenance (tires, brakes, brake fluid, HVAC, battery, suspension, steering, etc.) to be done, and the longer service interval might make it more likely for problems to increase in severity before they're noticed. It's kind of a moot point, modern cars have overall excellent reliability on the drivetrain; luxury cars tend to have problems with the electrical system and associated accessories, especially after the lease period is up, and Tesla is no different.

> 5. American designed, American built, no $$$ going to questionable oil interests.

Overall design and final assembly, perhaps, but are you saying that the subsystem vendors are American too, to some degree larger than other manufacturers?

> 10. Supercharger network. Free juice all over the country and beyond. Fills up in 20-30 min.

It's not free, it's incorporated into the cost of the purchase.

tclmeelmo··on Why I think Tesla is building throwaway cars
From your first link: "Getting a driver's license after turning 16 years old has become a lengthier process in recent years, as regulators instituted more safety hurdles. That has also led to a sharp decline in teenagers who are driving."

That said, this is going sideways because I didn't make a complete and clear post originally. Never mind.

tclmeelmo··on Why I think Tesla is building throwaway cars
And the HVAC system. I don't know but wouldn't be surprised if the HVAC system on Teslas, in addition to the cabin environment, had some responsibility for the battery and motor thermal management too.
tclmeelmo··on Why I think Tesla is building throwaway cars
> The number of teenagers with driver's licenses is the lowest in history.

The value of such a statistic is questionable given that the minimum age for a license has increased of late.

tclmeelmo··on Biggest patent troll of 2014 gives up, drops appeal
The claims establish the legal bounds of a patent, however, they must be read in light of what is disclosed in the specifications. The enforceable scope of this patent is fairly limited.
tclmeelmo··on Apple Gets Tech Industry Backing in iPhone Dispute, Despite Misgivings
The whole point of a signature, handwritten or digital, is to act as proof of identity and intent. If the government can compel Apple to sign FBiOS (against Apple's stated intent of signing their OS), where do you propose the government's ability to coerce a signature stop?
tclmeelmo··on Etsy CTO: We Need Software Engineers, Not Developers
Unless those 14 years were under the supervision of a PE who was stamping your work, your work experience isn't meaningful for the purposes of licensure. Why would it be?

I view the PE in software as being for managers on software-intensive engineering projects, say for example, plant controls or electronic medical devices. If you look at the current licensing path, you'll see that it requires deep domain-specific engineering knowledge (e.g., mechanical engineering) or broad engineering knowledge (e.g., statics and dynamics + fluid dynamics + materials science + ...), neither of which are common among self-labeled software engineers: this is why I view a PE in software as being intended for a controls engineer who does a lot of software projects (as one example). It's not really relevant for most software domains, nor is it intended to be.

tclmeelmo··on Etsy CTO: We Need Software Engineers, Not Developers
> Well that's a start. They don't offer one in my state/country yet but I'll definitely take it when they do.

It's not that simple. The quickest path to licensure is to graduate from an ABET-accredited engineering program (4 years), pass the fundamentals of engineering exam (which, likely being the "other disciplines" exam, requires general knowledge of engineering and science), perform engineering work supervised by a licensed engineer (I think you typically need 3 references), document your engineering work time (4 years are needed with a BS), and then pass the principles and practice in engineering exam. There are alternative paths that differ on the state level, but they take years longer, e.g., lacking the accredited BS would require something like 8 years of experience before one could sit for the FE exam. I think there's also a plan to require an MS at minimum to sit for the PE exam.

Point being, licensure is far more involved than passing one exam.

tclmeelmo··on Apple Gets Tech Industry Backing in iPhone Dispute, Despite Misgivings
Consider however that Apple is being asked to digitally sign the modified FBiOS in order to load it onto the phone. The implications underlying the act of signing are the sort of speech that deserves the highest protection.
tclmeelmo··on Firearms vs. Intentional Homicide
> Has there been any significant effort to really comprehensively evaluate the data around gun violence and gun control?

The NRC did a review in 2004 that is probably the closest to what you're seeking: http://www.nap.edu/catalog/10881/firearms-and-violence-a-cri...

It's not the comprehensive review of the literature you're looking for, but more recently in 2011, the Justice Department put out a report that might also be of interest: http://bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/fv9311.pdf

← PreviousPage 3 of 3