HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tdb7893

4,493 karma · joined October 2, 2015

submissionscomments
tdb7893··on Work after work: Notes from an unemployed new grad watching the job market break
Yeah, I'm employed as a research assistant as part of the Master's program currently. There are jobs in government, non-profits, and academia potentially after. I've never loved money (except for the flexibility having it gives me) so I have several hundred thousand saved up after a decade of engineering so while grad school is an 82% cut in pre-tax pay I can withdraw 1% a year from my investments and live fine. Even once I'm out of school my pay will never as good as it was in engineering but I'll be happier presumably.

I'm still figuring out exactly what the research will be but the plan is essentially data science applied to bird migration patterns (lots of statistics and modelling currently). Overall if you like birds and don't like money apparently a strong math/tech background is potentially useful for ecology research with the idea that's it's easier to teach me about birds than teach an animal science person data science and programming (though I did take an undergrad ecology class before applying to ecology programs).

tdb7893··on Work after work: Notes from an unemployed new grad watching the job market break
I think a lot of tech people feel this way. The feeling of mismatch between my values and the values of leadership is why I left the industry. I'm starting a Master's degree studying birds and it feels like such a weight off of my shoulders to not have to justify corporate decisions to myself.
tdb7893··on US air traffic controllers start resigning as shutdown bites
I'm a Democrat (well, nominally at least) but they clearly need some people from both parties to fund the government. Democrats won't vote for a "clean" bill and Republicans won't negotiate. The crazy thing is people predicted the shutdown in the spring and the government still drove the boat straight into this iceberg.
tdb7893··on Denmark's government aims to ban access to social media for children under 15
I think this would be good for kids but also I want that sort of feed as an adult.
tdb7893··on Man who threw sandwich at US border agent not guilty of assault
People shouldn't be throwing sandwiches at people but it's wild in the US that the most minor stuff against the police and they try to charge you with a felony but police can commit pretty much any form of assault (even on camera) and often don't even lose their job unless there's a big outcry.
tdb7893··on End of Japanese community
In addition to not responding to any of the specifics that the poster clearly put time into, there's also a huge mismatch in tone. In general, do not act very corporate when people are personally pissed off, this has a tendency to just annoy most people further.
tdb7893··on Meta and TikTok are obstructing researchers' access to data, EU commission rules
One of my friends is a mechanical engineer doing the most standard "nuts and bolts" form of engineering and by these standards he isn't even an engineer. I don't think there are any reasonable English speakers who wouldn't say he's an engineer (if he wasn't you would need to rename the whole field of mechanical engineering). You can have an idiosyncratic definition for personal reasons but it's probably best to realize that it's not the general definition of the word.
tdb7893··on US declines to join more than 70 countries in signing UN cybercrime treaty
One of my family members was a research director at the UN and came from a middle class American family. It has its problems (he certainly has his share of complaints) but the idea that they are all nepo babies is incorrect and they do have serious researchers. Also, are we sure that the $10.5 trillion is a UN generated number? Other people in the comments seem to think it was made up by some other organization.
tdb7893··on Meta and TikTok are obstructing researchers' access to data, EU commission rules
Most of my friends are mechanical or aerospace engineers and it's all the same job in a different medium (many do a significant amount of software as part of their work). They don't have stamps and aren't any more legally liable than we are and staying we aren't engineers just seems to be a misunderstanding of what engineering is.
tdb7893··on Trump pardons convicted Binance founder
I was against the Biden pardons at the time but in hindsight with the current administration pushing poorly done prosecutions for political purposes I have changed my mind on them. Trump will say his pardons are similar but looking at the facts I don't find them comparable (I'm still livid that he pardoned Blagojevich, who was literally caught on tape talking about selling a US Senate seat).
tdb7893··on No science, no startups: The innovation engine we're switching off
I don't really understand how you come to the conclusion that the current system is non-functioning. There are tons of examples of it working (I even have members of my family who took their research to make products) and for the rocket example experts didn't think it was literally impossible, just not cost effective with the current technology (e.g. the space shuttle was reusable but very expensive). I don't think that's some huge failure given SpaceX had a lot of launch failures and went nearly bankrupt before the first launch (and even after that it was a long road to profitability, I thought it took 20 years to get to an operating profit). This is also ignoring how SpaceX is operating within the current system also.

It's not perfect but if you replace the system you're gonna find the same sorts or errors since it's impossible to accurately guess future value of uncertain engineering projects.

tdb7893··on Peter Thiel's antichrist lectures reveal more about him than Armageddon
I get this sense often when the "famous" tech CEOs talk, they sorta come across like that uncle that you humor at Thanksgiving dinner. My best guess is there's a selection bias in that the more grounded ones are less likely to speak publicly and be in the news.
tdb7893··on Google, Meta and Microsoft to stop showing political ads in the EU
Ignoring political implications here and just on a personal level I wish political ads were banned. Quite possibly my least favorite type of ad to see and I've never felt meaningfully informed by them (generally quite the opposite).
tdb7893··on Canadian bill would strip internet access from 'specified persons', no warrant
So it has been on the upswing recently but my understanding is that in the US we have been doing pretty much as much surveillance as technology (and also generally the 4th amendment) practically allows since at least WWII, and especially during the Cold War. Many law abiding people opposed to government policy (e.g. civil rights leaders or anti-war activists) have always been surveilled with dubious cause.

This isn't the best wiki article I've ever seen but it has some examples of the US surveillance over the last century. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_surveillance_in_the_Unite...

tdb7893··on New California law restricts HOA fines to $100 per violation
It wouldn't surprise me if it's still a net positive, even with the downsides. Also the article says there are carveouts for health and safety, I wonder if excessive noise at night counts as a health issue (there's more than enough research on how important sleep is where it wouldn't be absurd to have it as part of the health carveout).
tdb7893··on How Israeli actions caused famine in Gaza, visualized
For context these are the questions asked since obviously this claim will change a lot based on questions. I wouldn't say it's terribly surprising based on my experiences, I've met Republicans against a lot of these things. I'm also wondering a bit how they got their sample since they had way more Democrats than Republicans and how representative it is (it also didn't close to match the racial makeup of the US). Not hating on the study, I didn't spend enough time reading it to know it's effectiveness, mainly the actual questions seemed important.

Item 1) Abortion should be illegal.

Item 2) The government should take steps to make incomes more equal.

Item 3) All unauthorized immigrants should be sent back to their home country.

Item 4) The federal budget for welfare programs should be increased.

Item 5) Lesbian, gay and trans couples should be allowed to legally marry.

Item 6) The government should regulate business to protect the environment.

Item 7) The federal government should make it more difficult to buy a gun.

Item 8) The federal government should make a concerted effort to improve social and economic conditions for African Americans.

Edit: to be clear I read the study and they used Prolific (https://www.prolific.com/) to get the participants but that means nothing to me.

tdb7893··on US memo to colleges proposes terms on ideology, foreign enrollment for fed funds
I think framing this stuff as even a protection of conservative views is going to miss the point. They seem to want a hiring preference for conservative views and seem to want to punish non-conservative organizations at universities (e.g. LGBT organizations or views). This won't be the end to this push, it's just another step in a longer context.

Edit: with NSPM-7 you can sorta see the angle they are likely to push. With a lot of the oppositional views to the government being labelled as promoting terrorism and violence.

tdb7893··on Privacy Badger is a free browser extension made by EFF to stop spying
Look, none of these criticisms are novel or unknown in the industry and it's well known that measuring the exact impact of ads is impractical but we're not talking exact numbers here, just whether personalized ads are generally effective or not. This criticism effects how effective it is but not the fact that it's generally effective, unless you think all ads are doing is shifting sales forward in time (which doesn't really make sense to me).

I think this is more of an effect for things like search or ads on an e-commerce platform (somewhat ironically the contextual ads people here are advocating for are much more susceptible to this) but less so for a lot of the more random ads, especially for niche products.

Edit: For me they are obviously effective. I think the more interesting question is exactly what the return on ad spend generally is but that would take very specific data that I don't have access to.

tdb7893··on Privacy Badger is a free browser extension made by EFF to stop spying
Having worked for these companies some of the data is murky (e.g. did these ads they saw earlier lead to them buying the product later, perfect attribution is obviously impossible) but a lot of it is unambiguous where they tracked people straight from clicking on the ad directly to a purchase. People have their conspiracies but I've seen it in black and white, it's very very clear. The only way I could see the data not being clear is in the case of outright fraud, which I'm fairly certain wasn't happening within our own metrics (as it would not only lead to legal liability but even more importantly fuck up the machine learning models).

Edit: to be clear I would believe the effect of ads is overstated, it's just the idea they are ineffective is wrong and people claiming that you can get more effective ads without tracking people at all doesn't seem plausible based on what I know of the industry. I could see contextual ads working in niche use cases (which again we already see when searching for products. YouTubers have relevant sponsors all the time. We even have affiliate marketing, where it's not only contextual but part of the content).

tdb7893··on Privacy Badger is a free browser extension made by EFF to stop spying
Personalized ads are more effective than non-personalized ads, to try to argue that personalized ads are ineffective is incorrect and the "without any proof" claim is absurd seeing the amount of specific data they collect on effectiveness measures. I used to work for ad tech companies and while that led me to hate them more than most people I'm not gonna say the data isn't their supporting their effectiveness.

Edit: I'm not familiar with data on context based ads but I'm very skeptical they are significantly better in the general case. They are already used in things where it makes sense like when you're searching for something.

tdb7893··on Scientists say X has lost its professional edge and Bluesky is taking its place
So firstly most scientists already aren't really activists in any meaningful way, it seems like you're implying most are on twitter/bluesky doing activism and the vast majority aren't really. Secondly I'm confused who people think should be able to be activists in a democracy? Scientists seem like a good candidate for people that should do activism in a healthy democracy.
tdb7893··on Conspiracy content drives anti-establishment sentiment on TikTok, YouTube
Are those examples at all indicative of what conspiracy theories are anymore, they seem stuck in the last century? The only one of those I've literally ever seen, even online, is aliens (and just UFO videos). On the other hand I personally know a lot of people who consistently buy into medical and political misinformation (and social media pushes it to me at least weekly, no matter how much I try to say I'm not interested).

I know a lot of people who have had to cut off family members because they got too deep into conspiracy theories and it's pretty much always weird political ones.

tdb7893··on Conspiracy content drives anti-establishment sentiment on TikTok, YouTube
I wouldn't undersell the harms of general conspiracy theories. Most of them become more harmful the more people believe in them and the social media that I see has a tendency to spread the more harmful types of conspiracy theories (medical or political misinformation I see all the time on the internet now).
tdb7893··on DeepMind and OpenAI win gold at ICPC
As someone who has been to the ICPC finals around a decade ago I agree that the limited time is really the big problem that these machine learning models don't really experience in the same way. Though that being said these problems are hard, the actual coding of the algorithms is pretty easy (most of the questions use one of a handful of algorithms that you've implemented a hundred times by the time you're in the finals) but recognizing which one will actually solve the problem correctly is not obvious at all. I know a lot of people that struggled in their undergrad algorithms class and I think a lot of those people given the ICPC finals problems would struggle even with being able to research.
tdb7893··on The case against social media is stronger than you think
Echo chambers aren't good but the large scale social media I've tried has a tendency to put me in an echo chamber (specifically one trying to wring out all the engagement possible, often with stuff to make me angry) and also elevate low quality opinions (often factually incorrect or philosophically incoherent).

Smaller and more personally curated social media has been better for sourcing broad opinions actually if I put just a little work into it.

tdb7893··on Chicago has the most lead pipes in the nation
"disgusting level of violence in minority communities" -> this is so clearly an insulting way to refer to these communities it boggles the mind that someone would say it while accusing someone else of not being concerned enough. These communities have people I like and care about so I do care about these communities, which is exactly why I am careful about what I say and don't compare them to warzones or tell them about what violence is like in their communities (it reeks of the same condescension towards these communities that I grew up with in the suburbs).

If you're in these communities in Chicago then I'm sorry but judging from your general ignorance of Chicago it seems pretty clear that you are not.

tdb7893··on Chicago has the most lead pipes in the nation
Crime is down just based on the actual numbers (also anecdotally from someone who has spent the majority of their life in/around the city) and for most people the city is pretty safe right now. While there is violence this sort of pearl clutching historically hurts those exact communities you're talking about (and also is not how the people I've met from those communities described their experiences anyway).
tdb7893··on Data engineering and software engineering are converging
I mean this very sincerely but I'm a little lost how data engineering is distinct from software engineering. It seems like just a subset of it, my title was software engineer and I've done what sounds like very similar work.
tdb7893··on Tipping point in Gulf Stream may be reached as early as mid-century
We've already seen sea level rises make some islands unliveable, pretty large ecological damage, and many people dead from natural disasters from climate change and we are still in early stages of it (levels of greenhouse gases in the environment are still still not only rising but also accelerating in the wrong direction). You would need to be incredibly selective to the point of absurdity to say predictions have 100% failed.
tdb7893··on I forced every engineer to take sales calls and they rewrote our platform
Yeah I think having engineers understand product is important as I think it's the harder to get right than the basic engineering. Most of the products I've worked on have failed for product reasons so just from a logical standpoint it makes sense to focus on making sure that's a strength for a team.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →