HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

teachingassist

846 karma · joined April 7, 2021

submissionscomments
teachingassist··on Ask HN: Anybody Started a Research Institute?
I could alternatively assume that you time travelled with a copy of Grays Sports Almanac.
teachingassist··on Ask HN: Anybody Started a Research Institute?
> in 1 year and 2 months, we turned 40k of our own funds into [redacted].

This would be a challenge even if you had perfect foresight.

If you had gone all-in on Dogecoin, you would still only have ~5M.

teachingassist··on World Now Likely to Hit Watershed 1.5 °C Rise in Next 5 Years
Isn't this the canonical historical justification for colonialism?

That colonialist barons are helping the local population by improving infrastructure for them? (While massively enriching themselves)

I don't think that really worked out well. The exploited wealth (both from resources and labour) arguably contributed to our current position, where unlimited greed at others' expense and total exploitation and destruction of the planet's resources is seen as noble.

Continuing this theme with modern-day Western corporations seeking further profit extraction is a tragedy.

teachingassist··on Stanford Bunny
The Lindt bunny does look similar but I guess it's lower resolution ;-)
teachingassist··on Government fell disastrously short in dealing with Covid – Cummings
> None of these places ran out of hospital capacity.

You would know this to be nonsense if you knew almost anyone who works in healthcare.

I know retired health workers who were temporarily re-commissioned to deal with the total lack of staffing capacity.

teachingassist··on Our memory is better than experts thought
I wonder if chimps are also less butthurt than humans.
teachingassist··on How inevitable is the concept of numbers?
We agree that the difference between 2 and 20000 is significant, but I can easily observe this difference without counting all the way up to 20000.

Identifying the difference between 19,999 and 20,000 is certainly not significant in this way. 19,999 is already "too many" students; or, "plenty" of firewood. I don't need to count them to know this.

I'd say the difference between 5 and 6 is already relatively unimportant in these contexts.

teachingassist··on How inevitable is the concept of numbers?
> There's a tree, there are more trees. So now it's useful to count them...

It's not that useful to count them. My personal interactions with trees have likely never involved counting them; not even when I was involved in woodland management.

Trees control their numbers according to whether or not they can reasonably live in a particular density of tree coverage.

Only humans want to count trees, perhaps in general to claim (abstract) ownership of a particular large number.

teachingassist··on EU bans Belarusian airlines from European skies
Given that Minsk to London Gatwick is Belavia's furthest west flight (B2851, three times per week), this has limited effect.

Belavia has no reason to fly over UK airspace otherwise.

teachingassist··on EU bans Belarusian airlines from European skies
>these rules are there to protect the minority, not the majority.

That's not clear.

Democracy protects the majority (but not always the minority); in an absence of democracy, the majority are also vulnerable to breaches of human rights.

teachingassist··on U.S. Backs 15% Global Minimum Tax to Curb Profit Shifting Overseas
I get that corporations do lobby, but I was questioning whether they have an obligation to lobby.
teachingassist··on U.S. Backs 15% Global Minimum Tax to Curb Profit Shifting Overseas
> Corporations have a fiduciary obligation to maximize shareholder value.

I understand this statement to mean "Corporations have a fiduciary obligation to maximize shareholder value [within the law]".

Do corporations have a fiduciary obligation to change the law, as in your interpretation?

teachingassist··on U.S. Backs 15% Global Minimum Tax to Curb Profit Shifting Overseas
From a corporation's point of view, it's fine if your competitors are treated the same as you are (in a competitive market).

But, even if so, CEOs/board members are often those high net worth individuals. So there's a potential conflict of interest that isn't resolvable.

This explains why corporations will lobby against a minimum tax, even if the institution doesn't ultimately care.

teachingassist··on Ask HN: Engineering managers; what are the problems you face?
> but why would they?

They should, because they observe the parent's point:

The employee now has the potential to jump ship and re-start this process for a higher $x, meaning that the employer risks losing the institutional knowledge/institutional memory that this employee contributes, and the employer will suffer the cost and risk of hiring someone(s) new.

An employer declining to give a regular pay increase is depending on their employee's loyalty and kindness to remain in employment at lower than their market value, and/or that the average employee has very minimal capacity for risk, because they must constantly stay housed and fed.

That might work for the employer a while, but personally I don't find it a wise long-term strategy.

teachingassist··on Google Finds It’s Underpaying Many Men as It Addresses Wage Equity (2019)
> your 50/50 split of n is the most aggressive way to interpret that information.

I'm satisfied with that choice.

Given that Google are here quoting this stat in the press (with the 50/50 implication) to defend themselves against an inequality suit, without actually giving us the figures, I assume that this is the best spin that Google can put on it.

teachingassist··on Google Finds It’s Underpaying Many Men as It Addresses Wage Equity (2019)
What I said is mathematically correct.

For the sake of completion:

Suppose there are N employees.

76% = 0.76N are men; 24% = 0.24N are women.

Suppose also that n men being underpaid for their work.

The stat as quoted suggests there are n women being underpaid. (Or, sufficiently close to n, that a stronger stat can't be quoted)

Chance of men being underpaid: n/0.76N

Chance of women being underpaid: n/0.24N

Chance of women being underpaid is therefore (n/0.24N)/(n/0.76N) = 19/6 > 3.1 times higher.

I rounded conservatively to conclude "women are three times more likely to be underpaid".

teachingassist··on Google Finds It’s Underpaying Many Men as It Addresses Wage Equity (2019)
"...the results showed the company was underpaying more men than women for doing similar jobs in software engineering."

Google's tech jobs are 76% men (from their 2020 diversity report).

Saying "50% of those being underpaid for their work are men" is an interesting statistic then only because 50 is less than the expected 76.

This stat, taken on its own merit, illustrates that women are three times more likely to be underpaid.

teachingassist··on How to get rich without being lucky (2019)
I'm now imagining rich grey goo saying it'd rather be poor grey goo, than a rich human in 2021.

Even if we have 200 years of consistent economic growth and technological process, I doubt you would see rich people giving up their wealth to teleport themselves there.

teachingassist··on How to get rich without being lucky (2019)
> Today, I would rather be a poor person in a First World country, than be a rich person in Louis the XIV’s France. I’d rather be a poor person today than aristocrat back then.

A rich person also had access to near-unlimited amounts of human labour. Cleaning your house, cooking your meals, tailoring your clothes, nursing your children.

There is a limit to how much that has been replaced by technology.

An equivalent question is: Would you give up being a rich person in 2021, to become a poor person in 2200?

teachingassist··on My thoughts about the Principal role
> Am I a manager? No. [I] let the team self organize with my help

Isn't that what a manager is, or should be?

teachingassist··on Four years after a man was executed, someone else’s DNA found on murder weapon
The judge's job is to make a decision based on the evidence in front of them. The judge has to weigh the evidence based on their training and knowledge.

That decision might prove in hindsight to be incorrect, based on new information or a fresh perspective. The judge cannot be held accountable for that.

We accept this as part of the job, that difficult decisions cannot always be made perfectly within any legal framework, but still need to be decided.

If this results in disproportionate punishment, the system is at fault - the system of laws - not the judge, who was doing their job.

The judge's decision might alternatively prove to be corrupt, in that the judge has been influenced by something outside of their training, knowledge of the law, and the evidence. The judge should be held accountable for that.

teachingassist··on Rich people do have trouble understanding what it's like to be poor
Being able to repair things as needed also comes into this category.

If I can't immediately afford to send something for repair, then I keep using it until it completely wears out, have an ongoing worse experience, and ultimately a larger expense later on.

teachingassist··on Rich people do have trouble understanding what it's like to be poor
Where are you supposed to live meanwhile?
teachingassist··on Despite social pressure, boys and girls still prefer gender-typical toys
The article that I'm reading claims that boy chimps like to play with toy trucks: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/travel/article/101220-chi...

You're gonna therefore have to explain to me why you think this is natural behaviour. Since, as I understand, trucks were invented by humans.

Isn't it just that chimpanzees are social and have been cued by human expectations, their captors and immediate relatives?

teachingassist··on Despite social pressure, boys and girls still prefer gender-typical toys
If your claim is that gender differentiated behaviour in children is spontaneously observed due only to nature, why do you need to invent an example? You've never seen a girl play with a stick like it's a baby, because that's not a thing that girls typically do (I doubt you can find a single example of this).

Girls treat the outdoors generally the same as boys do, and iirc are recorded climbing trees in the same numbers.

teachingassist··on Despite social pressure, boys and girls still prefer gender-typical toys
Any two people will certainly attach different levels of importance to what they observe, I agree.

Given that this behaviour was learned by observation, society's existing gender norms - and specifically those around guns - would also have been observed and learned. We can't separate these, in this anecdote.

Would we not expect to observe the son to engage with more caring play if the stay-at-home parent (primary carer) had been the dad?

teachingassist··on Despite social pressure, boys and girls still prefer gender-typical toys
> He ran around the backyard using sticks as guns.

Since sticks (in nature) have none of the function of guns, this is certainly a learned behaviour from social observation.

teachingassist··on Counting the number of matching characters in two ASCII strings
Plenty of library functions are already going to be optimised in this type of way - just because they're not visible in your codebase doesn't mean they are not there.
teachingassist··on CRISPR Editing in Primates
I agree that suffering is a risk that we should balance.

Your point in the other comment was that you would cause suffering to and sacrifice "hundreds of billions" of primates for a small chance to heal yourself.

That's clearly not balanced. I personally don't think that animal testing as it exists today, and given the complete lack of direct results that it has to show us, is balanced either.

Do you really value yourself, as a human, trillions of times higher than a chimpanzee? I don't and won't respect that. You saying that, out loud, only makes me wonder how much you internally value other humans.

teachingassist··on CRISPR Editing in Primates
It's a matter of resources.

Animal testing has found hundreds of vaccines against HIV that work in primates, but none of them have worked in humans.

How is that a useful thing to spend time on? You have a model, and it's proven that your model doesn't work: I would expect you to throw away the model.

You could spend those excellent researchers and science budget on anything else, and expect better results.

(I get that all drugs have been tested on animals out of legislative requirement, but I hope it's clear we are talking about using animal models for de novo drug discovery).

For a business-oriented forum, I find it hard to understand why people see this as valuable.

← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →