HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

tehchromic

210 karma · joined June 18, 2014

art in theory, in practice beekeeping and UIX
submissionscomments
tehchromic··on The Great A.I. Awakening
The author gets it close to right when he talks about Google Maps as a form of AI, and the notion of raising the bar.

What's missing in this article as well as most reporting on AI is the differentiation between artificial intelligence and artificial consciousness, otherwise known as individuality or self awareness.

To me there's a whole smoke and mirrors phenomenon going on in the AI topic, especially the idea of "emerging AI", and the supposed potential danger that poses, and it's tied to the tendency we have as humans to anthropomorphize inanimate objects, and to believe in supernatural effects.

That tendency allows the idea of artificial self awareness to always float behind the scenes in these conversations, and let's normal reporting on AI be magically conflated with a different topic.

It's important to realize that AI is nowhere near self awareness, or conscious, or "awake" and won't be no matter how far the field and implementation goes. No matter how many Turing Test they pass, intelligent machines will be no more conscious or self-aware than the Mechanical Turk!

That's because solving the problem of self-awareness, or consciousness is a different engineering challenge than solving problems of AI. Consciousness is a more complicated, and specialized a thing.

Were we to build an artificial self-awarene machine we would not expect it to pass a Turing Test. Instead we might expect different things of it and ask different questions to determine if it is self aware: can it adapt and survive without human help, ie can it trap and store energy and reproduce itself, and what purpose does it find for itself is what objective does it pursue ...

These are things machines are capable of as well, but as I said: it's a different engineering challenge than producing information that is organized to be sensible to human mind, which is the AI challenge, and the Turing Test.

That isn't to say machine learning isn't potentially dangerous, on the scale of atomic weapons or greater, especially in conjunction with automation, however the idea of an artificially emergent consciousness wth intelligence greater than our own is hogwash: we would do better to pay attention to our own emergent lack-of-intelligence systems and worry about them taking over first.

tehchromic··on The sad truth about depressive realism (2006) [pdf]
So it's hopeless afterall
tehchromic··on Let's Colonize Titan
I actually agree with you. I think that chasing dreams and visions, ie "the afterlife" is a better motivator than scolding and regulating ourselves. Even so, I think at the level of intellect and organizational administration, it's important to have the line between reality and fiction extremely clear, so I don't mind saying so.
tehchromic··on Let's Colonize Titan
I find the "colonize other planets" dream of the secular/scientific community to be most like the "you'll go to heaven when you die" idea in religious paradoxy. You would think we might have experimented with teraforming uninhabitable place here on earth - the bottom of the Mariana, or Death Valley. If that was a snap, then we might contemplate Moon or Mars or Titan.

But in fact we are systematically rendering our own planet uninhabitable. Our planet is the product of billions of years of biological teraformation that has created the narrow and extremely specialized spectrum of environmental factors in which we live comfortably. It is far easier to eat that up than it is to replicate it.

The answer is to drop our extreme hubris and misguided religious style escapism and instead develop some respect for planet e, and proceed with extreme caution moving forward, or we will find our own planet unfit for living on.

Not saying interplanetary travel isn't possible, however I strongly disagree with the statement in the article that 'humanity will remain the same' and adapt our environment to suit us. If we make it to other planets we will be so altered we will not recognize ourselves. IMO that's a long loooong way off and requires that we don't extinct ourselves in the meantime.

tehchromic··on My observations during the explosion at Trinity (1945)
Once had a job working in the basement of a building in Los Alamos NM operating a digital scanner to digitize various documents from the lab archives. I encountered a few boxes of photos of various atomic tests - beautiful and spooky.
tehchromic··on Brutalism is Back
I couldn't be happier in the context of permacultural revolution, it make sense. Art povera will make a comeback next mark these words!
tehchromic··on Yarn – A new package manager for JavaScript
It's a great read and feels good to know FB is solving problems that we all run into!
tehchromic··on Yarn – A new package manager for JavaScript
It's a great read and feels good to know FB is solving problems that we all run into
tehchromic··on RethinkDB is shutting down
Ok I'm going to go with: Rethink is dead, long live Rethink!
tehchromic··on Elon Musk on How to Build the Future
More to the point: if I had Elon's advantages and talent, I would have begun with a more humble product and system, and taken on trains - not hyperloop, but freight and communter. Our trains are a system that's ripe for a revolution, and really potentially paradigm shifting.

However none of what I say makes sense if you've been stuffed with all the typical narratives and have not developed your imagination or your sense of history.

tehchromic··on Elon Musk on How to Build the Future
A perfect example of unsustainable European cultural paradigm!
tehchromic··on Elon Musk on How to Build the Future
I am not sure that all European cultural paradigms are unsustainable, but I said that the one Elon is working under seems to me to be. I think Elon is doing the best he can working on the problems that are available for him to work on.

To me, one wrong problem is anything that perpetuates the automobile/road system as is. I think the whole thing needs to be completely rebuilt.

To me the enormity of our problems from a sustainability standpoint are so great that anything but a massive mobilization and shift in our way of life is arranging deck chairs on the titanic.

I think that religion was a science of mobilizing public opinion, and I think science has replaced it, and has yet to do as good a job, and has yet to recognize that fact.

I think the right problem is how to manage mass social/cultural change in a very brief period of time.

I'll say again, Elon is doing a fantastic job within the paradigm of our current industrialized cultural norms, which says that we can keep on with business as usual and make some adjustments to our systems ... but I think it's not enough by an order of magnitude, and so that's why I think minds like Elon's should be working on manufacturing a social/cultural reality that prepares us for a huge change in lifestyle.

To me that's a problem of social engineering, same as religion, and same as building a company, and Elon excels at it.

tehchromic··on Elon Musk on How to Build the Future
What's interesting about a savant is how they can end up defined by what they don't see. I have nothing but respect for Elon, however I think he is working on the wrong problems. That's not his fault and he is most definitely making his best effort. However he's the paragon of a paradigm of a European culture which is as unsustainable as it is powerful.
tehchromic··on Gravitational pull 'has role in quakes'
Queue the fracking-causes-quakes deniers! I can hear the floor speeches already.
tehchromic··on Ask HN: What was your “why didn't I start doing this sooner” moment?
Beekeeping. I go to sleep thinking about the little bugs, and wake up with them on my mind. When I'm bothered by work or life I think about the colony doing it's thing and feel better. They're awesome.
tehchromic··on Why I'll never abbreviate a variable as long as I live
It's the quality of engaging posts like this one that draws me here on a Friday night.
tehchromic··on Airbnb's impact on cities
Long term the impact I see is better tourists and better cities.
tehchromic··on Keep your identity small (2009)
can you give me specific examples of how tho?
tehchromic··on Moving Forward on Basic Income
One important component that should not be overlooked is how BI is tied to basic occupation. People do need something to do, no matter how automated the future becomes, and that thing ought to be something they are well adapted to do.

It should not be entirely left to chance. Unoccupied people will find every avenue for their unspent energy, and too easily this becomes competition, and conflict.

Farming is a good example of a pastime that is historically maligned yet immensely rewarding and pleasurable when done right.

Along with BI ought to be a very carefully structured form of basic income that allows people cultural engagement that is productive and sustainable.

tehchromic··on 85 percent of Facebook video is watched without sound
or eyes! lol
tehchromic··on Keep your identity small (2009)
"I think what religion and politics have in common is that they become part of people's identity"

You might also say that people have identity and religion and politics use those to advantage. But is it wrong to have identity? I'd argue it as a basic human requirement.

Religion can be considered a technology of group identity which was refined over millennium to be most effective at generating a unified form. Like all technology it was disrupted by something better and more efficient at transmitting shared consciousness.

That definition also fits the web which is the most powerful method of transmission yet invented, and is the fruit of the science religion.

tehchromic··on Chrome removes Backspace to go back
Hip hip hooray!!!
tehchromic··on Ask HN: Which people and groups are researching new approaches to programming?
Don't forget the ether! I hear the ether is posed to make a comeback, big time!!
tehchromic··on Guns are now killing as many people as cars in the U.S
It sounds wrong to say so but that is as it should be!
tehchromic··on The Marshall Islands Are Disappearing
No one could have predicted this based on any kind of evidence tho so we best go about business as usual without making any changes to our way of life.
tehchromic··on Local and organic is a romantic myth
well i agree with you, and I wouldn't knock food transport and scale provided it is done in a sustainable and non toxic way.

but i definitely take issue with the "weird pleasure" comment, as there is nothing weird about the pleasure of farming in the city and growing your own food. It's about one of the most engaging cultural practices in existence, and it's as old as people. But it takes learning and practice, and awareness of that value, which is clearly missing in modern culture which views farming as some sort of weird thing. A weird peasure indeed!

tehchromic··on Local and organic is a romantic myth
yeah, well I think the mega-farm outputting tons of food for cities across state lines has it's place, however I think, and a lot of research as well as the direction of industry backs me up, that the conventional farming techniques on mega-farms need an upgrade. That is, fewer toxic chemicals, more organic practices, less monocropping, more automation, more high technology, more holistic, integrated, organic solutions to pests, etc.

And, on top of all that, local food sources are extremely valuable to a large scale sustainable food system. They're a buffer, and a cultural benefit, as agrarian pursuit is a truly healthy way for society to form its social engagement - it's called deep ecology and it's a human need to be engaged and invested with the cycles of life. It's much better than sequestering behind walls in front of TV's as we do now. So, true that it can't provide all our food, but it can provide a damn good buffer, and a lot more value aside from just calories. Don't buy the myth that farm life is slavery - that's an invention of the last century. Generally farm life, when it is done right, is extremely fulfilling. They even had a word for it: bucolic!

tehchromic··on Local and organic is a romantic myth
not quite, since that one trip produced many pounds of fresh healthy food over many weeks, whereas a comparable amount of fresh produce from the grocery store takes many trips.

That said, it's a culture of food production that's really where the efficiency lies. That's people saving and trading seeds, helping each other farm and harvest, and bottling and canning for winter.

That's not only tremendously efficient if it's done locally, it's also fun.

tehchromic··on Local and organic is a romantic myth
local, organic, small-scale farming is certainly practical, and it's also imperative for a sustainable model to support our immense population. So is automation, and greenhouses, and transporting food from far away places. What is incompatible with a sustainable future is conventional, factory farming, where the fields are awash in toxic chemicals, pesticides, herbicides, fungicides, and supplemented with bare fertilizers manufactured using toxic processes out of fossil fuels or harvested from unsustainable sources. That can't go on. Fortunately organic holistic farming methods produce higher yield and healthier foods, and are compatible with the best and highest tech in automation, greenhouses, and etc, and increasingly the old and new tech is coming together on the small scale, local farm.
tehchromic··on Local and organic is a romantic myth
"do more damage"

sorry, that's the claim that is not substantiated by evidence and it isn't close to being accurate. Conventional farming is a toxic mess, and it's heavily subsidized by unsustainable resources and practices at every level. It may be the case that the cost of doing farming right is high (and that is not necessarily meeting the "organic" standards which are themselves heavily biased by conventional interests, but by farming using truly organic methods) but that's because it tends to include costs to the planet, or not include cost savings that are causing extinction level changes to the planetary chemistry. There are people who will tell you that sustaining our population is not possible and that we are headed for an extinction event, however other people say that it is possible to live within our means, if we start factoring in the real cost of things like conventional farming, and therefore change our practice.

And technology is definitely a factor in that transition, so if you buy the phony trolling argument going on here that greenhouses, and automation is incompatible with sustainable, organic, local farming practice, then you are being sold a bill o' goods!

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →