2,108 karma · joined December 13, 2018
When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."Great movie overall.
He is like that in interviews, but it's worth noting that a lot of care is put into making great digital versions of his movies too. I'm not familiar with how involved he is in that process, but I would hazard a guess he's pretty involved.
The Oppenheimer site mentions this:
The Digital Cinema presentation of OPPENHEIMER has been created from 8k scans of the photochemically color-graded film elements, scaled to 4K, fine-tuned in the digital realm to maximize the color and contrast attributes of digital projectors, and dust-busted to achieve the cleanest and most stable image presentation possible. The film was finished in 4k for the highest digital resolution currently available.
1. IMAX 70mm
2. 70mm (non-IMAX, 2.2/1 aspect ratio)
3. Dual Laser IMAX (4K, can show the full 1.43/1 picture instead of just 1.9/1)
4. Single laser IMAX (4K, shows 1.9/1)
5. Dolby Cinema (4K, aspect ratio probably 2.39/1, not sure)
6. 35mm film
7. Non-laser IMAX
8. Regular theater
(1) is the most special, (2) is still quite special as only every few years do these theaters typically bring out 70mm projectors, (3) is also pretty special because rarely do movies return to IMAX where you can see the full uncropped image. (4) and (5) will still have great picture and sound quality compared to almost any home setup (OLED has contrast advantage always). (6) is pretty special, as [0] says: The 35mm prints have been made photochemically, preserving all the rich analog color of the original 65mm photography. (7) will have a big screen and good sound. (8) regular theaters are still good too. The value of the movie-going experience is not insignificant, which you get at any theater.
Well, aside from a few small projects, he only made four movies and one show, and in my estimation they're all excellent. Paranoia Agent I would say is deliberately uneven, being assembled from various unused ideas from past projects, and is quite effective in that way.
“The thing that hath been, it is that which shall be; and that which is done is that which shall be done: and there is no new thing under the sun.”
I noted that when I posted the link. But at least half are saying it is uplifting.
I obviously can't argue further as I haven't read it. I will remark that different people will react to the same material variously uplifted or beaten-down, and neither reaction is less valid (unless they just misunderstood the plot). Personally, I tend to find depictions of nobility and perseverance in the face of imminent doom interesting and moving if not uplifting.
Here are some people using the word uplift in their review on Amazon: [0]. There are some negations though ("this book is not uplifting").
[0]: https://www.amazon.com/Road-Vintage-International-Cormac-McC...