1,877 karma · joined January 21, 2009
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/textfiles; my proof: https://keybase.io/textfiles/sigs/3suXIN5AXKLC-jqt-_mr7ovc-jYpj6fH8vrIZOJNXdM ]
But one of the reasons that I chose to use the feed scanner that I do is that I get 600 dots per inch on these scans of these massive tabloids.
Going back on again.
Anyway, you nailed it. If you walk into Internet Archive Headquarters and go over to the Jason Scott statue and click his little top hat, a door opens in the floor and you're immediately lifted down 40 stories to a glowing LED-and-pulsating techno music lair containing dozens of Archive Team members, desperately gathering all the data they can from the world because [fill in the blank here, I'm sure you've got something].
Basically, Men in Black but more awesome and with more red bull.
Never change, Hackernews
You wrote, essentially:
Why not train a LLM AI on the magazines, newsletters, documentation, etc, and have it generate the descriptions based on prompts?
...and I call this an "unfunded mandate", which is where someone comes along to a project, and tells them a bunch of things they should take on and do, instead of either offering to do something themselves, or pointing to a resource or project that fulfils the need that is being asked for.
The article is about me finding out that certain kinds of activities are jammed in a Catch-22 of necessity but lack of potential funding (time or money). Your idea shifts no needle and makes things more complicated, to no greater chance of success, but plenty of chance (contemporarily) of hallucination and misleading results.
Feel free to delete, I guess, even more.
I'll just say that I'm not seeking a glorped together description of the games in question, but a semantic listing of the contents of original articles, ads, discussions and mentions related to the titles. LLMs do not do this, and if you're training the LLMs (at cost) to do this, you're already having to do the very same searching out of materials within the corpus related to what you want. It'd be like gathering every TV guide in a stack to then ask it to describe things that are like All in the Family, instead of just going through them as you gather them to indicate what each issue has information about.
My response was tepid because I don't like telling someone stuck in a little tiny fishbowl going "the fishbowl is perfectly adequate" and dissuading them that the fishbowl is not adequate. Not that Discord is "the ocean" but it's a cruise ship and it's expensive, and a very nice ride comparatively.
My weblog entry describes a situation beyond Discord, and that of knowledge, and is at best a framing of the problem in a static area, because I believe this is the year Twitter closes down, closes up, or dies.
Your pal, Jason