HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thaanpaa

94 karma · joined June 12, 2022

submissionscomments
thaanpaa··on Men and Women Can't Be "Just Friends" (2012)
The study was conducted on a small sample of people at a single public university in the US. Now, repeat the study with a random sample of people from a less conservative and sexually repressive culture, such as Sweden, Finland, etc., and the results will look very different.
thaanpaa··on Fastest rate of natural carbon dioxide rise over the last 50k years
Did you miss the climate agreement they committed to in November?
thaanpaa··on Global Firepower Index
Finland has spent the last 70 years strengthening its military to keep the Russians away, and they are well below Nigeria on the list. It is fairly safe to say that the list has absolutely nothing to do with reality.
thaanpaa··on Sampling: What Nyquist didn't say, and what to do about it (2018) [pdf]
With music, in particular, if you use any analog sources while recording, the signal will contain so much noise that any dithering signal will be far below the floor and will most likely be completely redundant. I know that people claim to hear a difference, but they also claim to hear a difference between gold and copper contacts.
thaanpaa··on The biggest losers: Metabolic damage or constrained energy?
If you deliberately misinterpret what I'm saying, I suppose I'm mistaken.

The majority of these studies consider a weight loss of 10 pounds over two years to be successful. If you start with 100 pounds or more, that is almost nothing.

Many of them consider anyone who starts at 300, loses 100, and gains 80 back in five years to be a huge success. Is it really?

In healthcare, an obese person is typically considered successful if they lose more than 30% of their body weight permanently. This is extremely unlikely to happen without surgery or medication.

thaanpaa··on The biggest losers: Metabolic damage or constrained energy?
Perhaps you didn't read what I wrote. You really need to look at the parameters (as well as the data).

A 5% weight loss for a 200-pound person equals 10 pounds. Anyone can achieve this by following a fad diet for a week or two.

thaanpaa··on The biggest losers: Metabolic damage or constrained energy?
The number one in a thousand is simply a ballpark figure that is frequently used in nutritional science. There are literally hundreds of papers, and not all of them are good (you should look at the parameters because many of them are quite lax), but here are a few examples easily found online.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/030646...

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/(SICI)1098-1...

https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/07315724.1999.10...

https://europepmc.org/article/med/2663745

thaanpaa··on The biggest losers: Metabolic damage or constrained energy?
It requires that complexity because a metric shit ton of scientific research shows that it is more complicated than that.

Permanent weight loss of more than ten pounds is nearly impossible from a scientific standpoint. The success rate after 5 years of weight loss is somewhere around 0.1%. You'd think that if it was as easy as everyone claims, more people would succeed. Heck, many people who have had gastric bypass surgery regain a significant amount of weight, even if their stomachs have been reduced to the size of a ping pong ball.

thaanpaa··on Databases and why their complexity is now unnecessary
Disk drives are also large global mutable states. So is RAM at the operating system level.

The article conflates the concept of data storage with best programming practices. Sure, you should not change the global state throughout your app because it becomes impossible to manage. The database is actually an answer to how to do it transactionally and centrally without messing up your data.

thaanpaa··on Fewer people are buying electric cars in the US
I suppose this could be the first "niche" in history where business demand did not drive up supply. But I wouldn't bet on it.
thaanpaa··on Fewer people are buying electric cars in the US
Yeah, it never ceases to amaze me that the fact that you need an extra coffee break whenever you drive for more than 4-5 hours at a time is ostensibly such a huge inconvenience, but somehow the fact that you never need to go to a gas station at any other time doesn't matter.

In the real world, I've never met an EV owner who didn't prefer it to a gas-guzzler, so I'm somewhat skeptical of the number of people on social media who claim to have returned theirs.

thaanpaa··on VMware is now part of Broadcom
I don't remember exactly, but there were some issues where a security update would remove support for certain common (HP?) RAID controllers or something to that effect. So, if you're not careful, a security patch could potentially brick a server.
thaanpaa··on Ask HN: What will you do when AGI's make you obselete?
The notion that everyone must work will eventually become obsolete. It will most likely be remembered as a brief and miserable but significant period in human history.
thaanpaa··on VMware is now part of Broadcom
That's an interesting development. Since the ransomware outbreak earlier this year, there has been an increase in security concerns about VMware. I've heard more complaints about the lateness of security patches and the difficulties people have had installing them, etc. I'm curious if this has anything to do with that.
thaanpaa··on Sam Altman exposes the charade of AI accountability
It's a marketing tactic in the case of artificial intelligence. AI promoters all want to make people believe that it is far more advanced than it actually is. Although, I'm sure that many people who work in the industry also fall for the hype, as many of them seem to exhibit cultish behavior.
thaanpaa··on I disagree with Geoff Hinton regarding "glorified autocomplete"
It's not magical; it's just agnostic. Some AI believers appear to be quite confident in their understanding of how the human brain works, despite the fact that those who have dedicated their entire lives to studying it will be the first to tell you that they ultimately have no idea.
thaanpaa··on OpenAI board in discussions with Sam Altman to return as CEO
The engineers are said to be relieved that Altman is gone, so it doesn't sound like they'd be following a "success story" (whatever that is supposed to mean).
thaanpaa··on A coder considers the waning days of the craft
I'll be concerned if I see an LLM create a secure, functional SQL schema and API with users, roles, subscriptions, products, MFA, and all the other basic requirements of modern-day apps. We're not even close to the required level of complexity yet, and I'm not holding my breath either.
thaanpaa··on GPU advancements in M3 and A17 Pro [video]
If the architecture is vastly different, these comparisons become sort of meaningless, though. The ultimate performance is determined by all the tiny little bottlenecks, like how quickly the architecture can move data between different types of cores, memory, cache, etc.

Apple has always been really good at parallelism, which is why they get so much performance from less power consumption.

thaanpaa··on GPT-4 vision prompt injection
Not really, I suppose; it's just a different type of prompt. The algorithm does not "know" what it is fed. Data is data.
thaanpaa··on GPT-4 vision prompt injection
I apologise, but I have no interest in any tech religion.
thaanpaa··on GPT-4 vision prompt injection
Isn't that just shifting the user's misunderstanding to whoever is developing the application?

I guess my argument is that if the type of behaviour described in the article causes problems, perhaps the technology was chosen incorrectly.

Edit: Or maybe I just have a problem with the vocabulary. Obviously, it's useful information.

thaanpaa··on GPT-4 vision prompt injection
In other words, a probability-based text generator does not behave like a sentient being. That's hardly an attack; isn't it more of a misunderstanding of the technology?
thaanpaa··on Lawmakers shift gears on TikTok ban
I.e. people who actually use the app are wrong, and you must be right.
thaanpaa··on Lawmakers shift gears on TikTok ban
My TikTok is filled with electrical engineering, various forms of activism, and so on. I've never seen anything like what you describe, and I've used it a lot. When I first started using it, I noticed a lot of dancing and singing (by very talented people), but those types of videos disappeared quite quickly.
thaanpaa··on Lawmakers shift gears on TikTok ban
Everyone seems to believe that all the apps spy on users (such as tracking your location, etc.), but I don't believe the platforms actually permit this unless the user expressly grants the app permission. However, just having a huge database of videos, viewing patterns, and social connections to analyze can be absurdly valuable, but I don't see all of that becoming illegal anytime soon.
thaanpaa··on Unity Overhauls Controversial Price Hike After Game Developers Revolt
Yes, a one-size-fits-all game engine will undoubtedly be extremely complicated. However, depending on your project, you will most likely only require a subset of its features.

One could also argue that if people base their creative decisions on the game engine, that's not always a good thing.

thaanpaa··on Unity Overhauls Controversial Price Hike After Game Developers Revolt
The lack of interest in developing a custom game engine today surprises me. It should go without saying that using a tool like Unity can help you get going quickly, but when it doesn't exactly fit your original game idea, it can and does often turn into an uphill battle. Directly utilising the SDKs without the use of middleware grants the most freedom, and technologies like DirectX were actually designed to simplify life to begin with.
thaanpaa··on The Pinouts Book: Pinout functions for 130 commonly used components
I suppose it's me. When I'm working on something on the bench, I don't like having to Google the pinouts. A well-curated printed book would be ideal. But, yeah, I can see how that might be very niche.
thaanpaa··on Apple iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro Max
The App Store is the real issue. Apple's antipathy towards developers is perplexing. The number of stories I've heard about companies having problems due to some interpretation of their policies is ridiculous. There are even horror stories about businesses going bankrupt simply because Apple decided they were in violation of something and banned them from the App Store entirely. I mean, no game company wants to spend millions on a game only to have all of their games pulled because one of them was too similar to someone else's game or something (according to some Apple reviewer with way too much power!).
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →