HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

the_grue

144 karma · joined February 22, 2018

submissionscomments
the_grue··on Google Plans to Launch Censored Search Engine in China, Leaked Documents Reveal
Is it a coincidence that USA was the largest economy on Earth? I don't think so. On the contrary, I think it became the most powerful country on Earth due to the free competition of talent and ideas, which is impossible without free speech.

Besides, Internet, being as wide open to anonymity as it is, simply never would never have been developed in a country like China, it would be deemed too dangerous. They may compete these days in electronics, but it doesn't mean they can compete in everything. Totalitarian society is always rotten in one way or another, and it manifests in all its output, including business, science, technology and culture. I'm saying this as a person born in the USSR.

the_grue··on Google Plans to Launch Censored Search Engine in China, Leaked Documents Reveal
How precisely does the fact that these countries exist 'require' complying with local legislation? Google is free to host their servers in other countries, which are free from censorship laws. It's not like Google needs to be present in that market to survive.

In a bigger context, the Internet business, and Google in particular, is a product of a free, liberal society. It couldn't have existed without freedom. Thus freedom is linked with success. So, as long as Google is innovative, it has that inherent advantage over its Chinese competitors.

the_grue··on Firefox 61.0 Released
Same here :/
the_grue··on The Stuxnet worm may be the most sophisticated software ever written
Do you happen to remember what was the crazy guy's nationality?
the_grue··on Java SE 8 business users must buy a licence from Jan 2019 to receive updates
That can change.
the_grue··on Java SE 8 business users must buy a licence from Jan 2019 to receive updates
You are drawing conclusions based on arbitrary facts. GCJ has always been going against the grain both politically and technologically, no wonder it ended up where it did. There are strong efforts and weak efforts. The fact that many projects fail doesn't mean that it's a bad idea for this specific project to be maintained by a community.

And no, "community" doesn't necessarily mean unaffiliated developers, they can be affiliated, like I have already stated many times, and still collectively considered a community. Open source can be a collaborative effort by major players or it can be a hopeless attempt to catch up with such. For the last 15 years or even more, it has been a common practice to commoditize technologies that are widely used across the industry. Java fully fits the above description, so maintaining it by a strong community effort would be a natural fit. Actually, from what I know, it almost works like that right now, we just need to take the licensing power from Oracle's greedy hands and keep the process the same as it is.

the_grue··on Java SE 8 business users must buy a licence from Jan 2019 to receive updates
> or you can buy RHEL

Or use CentOS. Oh wait, that's exactly what tens or hundreds of thousands of small businesses did and keep doing even today. Besides, that's not even a good comparison - Red Hat Linux was and is mainly about packaging other vendors' software, as opposed to Java, which is a monolithic piece of software developed as a single project.

> Google maintains an in-house OpenJDK

Didn't know that. How can they do that while keeping compatibility with Oracle's OpenJDK? Well, this information just reinforces my point, actually. Google is already in position to ditch Oracle as an upstream and unite with other parties to build a new foundation for open-source Java.

> Google is hardly famous for its long term commitment to stable APIs and old versions of software

Nobody likes to use other people's buggy code. I think you are mixing up two different things. Google does iterate their own software at a fast pace, but that doesn't mean it doesn't want the underlying infrastructure to be as stable as possible.

the_grue··on Java SE 8 business users must buy a licence from Jan 2019 to receive updates
> For starters none of those projects has parity with Java's JIT and GC implementations.

Aren't you forgetting about Linux, Firefox and Mesa graphics library to name a few? You seem to imply that all open source is amateur's work by definition, which is obviously wrong, as many large-profile, complex open-source projects are maintained by professional developers, employed by powerful companies to work for the benefit of the whole industry. Besides, it's one thing to develop GC from scratch and another to maintain an existing one and backport fixes.

> Those that kind of do, are sponsored by corporations not much different from Oracle, other than some geek love.

There is nothing wrong in being sponsored by corporations, especially if it's a collaboration between several players, as opposed to a single one. The problems only start when these corporations overtake the maintenance completely and then start leveraging it against the users.

> Oracle was the company that rescued Java

Pah'lease! Rescued... Oracle just bought Sun's intellectual property and trademarks in hopes of monetizing them later. Guess what, later is now! The only reason Java was in trouble during Sun's time in the first place is because of Sun's proprietary attitude under the pretense of safeguarding the Java standard and preventing fragmentation. It's that attitude that first caused the Java development to stall when Sun ran out of steam and now it has brought us to the spot where the project maintainer is denying us security patches.

the_grue··on Java SE 8 business users must buy a licence from Jan 2019 to receive updates
This is not about enterprise support. It's about security fixes and bugfixes. If you're a business, you will have to pay for these fixes or roll with their 6-months release cycle. Selling security fixes is quite unprecedented for a project of this scale. Furthermore, it emphasizes Oracle's power over its users, and let's not forget that these users are sometimes as big or bigger as Oracle itself (IBM and Google to name a couple). So they could potentially organize and take over stewardship of the project to ensure that no drastic changes of this sort will ever happen again. I don't see any reason not to. As far as I can tell, the reason Oracle is the sole maintainer of Java is mainly historical (Sun legacy) and because no one felt an urge to do anything about it before. I'm sure it's going to change now.
the_grue··on Java SE 8 business users must buy a licence from Jan 2019 to receive updates
I don't see how OpenJDK is different from other big open source community-managed projects. If Oracle is not willing to maintain an up-to-date version of the JDK, there are a lot of businesses big and small, as well as individuals, who will be interested in creating a governing body to oversee bugfixing in old releases, potentially even taking over stewardship altogether (which is probably a good idea, given Oracle's dubious reputation and this boundary hostile move).
the_grue··on Java SE 8 business users must buy a licence from Jan 2019 to receive updates
Yes, 2017 was a typo, thank you. 2014 is 8 years after 2006.
the_grue··on Java SE 8 business users must buy a licence from Jan 2019 to receive updates
Okay, replying to myself after a couple of quick Google searches.

The situation is quite complex. A big part of the industry seems to be stuck at Java 8 right now due to several reasons. One of them is the momentum Java 8 gained when it was released in 2017, 8 years after Java 7. It was a strong release, bringing much-awaited features to the aging Java ecosystem. Subsequent released didn't come anywhere close to that.

Another big reason is the uncertainty of the upgrade path. Java 9 was released comparatively short time afterwards, and it is set to expire... last month. [1] Unsurprisingly, many customers chose to stay with a stabilized, thoroughly tested version of Java 8, rather than switch to a bleeding edge (in Java terms, at least), untested Java 9 with a very short time fuse on it. Finally, Java 10, which has been released recently, is also due to expire very shortly - in fall 2018.

So overall this looks like a very aggressive monetization move on Oracle's part, intended to extract $$ from customers who value stability of their platform. It goes completely against the long-established tradition of stability in the Java ecosystem, which is one of the reasons many of the customers chose it, in the first place. I expect a massive migration towards OpenJDK and a backlash in the community, which will ultimately push Oracle aside.

[1] http://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/eol-135779.html

the_grue··on Java SE 8 business users must buy a licence from Jan 2019 to receive updates
I'm confused. Is this a cost-cutting move intended to push the industry towards Java 9? If a business is able to switch to Java SE 9, will they still be eligible to receive free upgrades?
the_grue··on Dependency injection on Android with dagger-android and Kotlin
Yeah, I tried that, but the simple examples didn't do enough for my purposes, I had to take it further and was never able to get too far.
the_grue··on Dependency injection on Android with dagger-android and Kotlin
I tried to learn Dagger for a recent project in a similar setting (Dagger+Android+Kotlin). Spent some 8 hours, couldn't make it work and gave up. I suppose, as with most systems, one needs to build up a list of recipes for solving common problems. But with Dagger I found that notoriously hard for some reason. Perhaps because it tends to fail silently at runtime or with non-descriptive errors.
the_grue··on Dark side of ergonomics in Rust
That sounds like a natural fit for Rust's lifetime-tracking mechanism. The compiler can automatically drop all initialized objects upon exception. In fact, I'm reasonably sure it does just that for panic handling.
the_grue··on Why Jewish History Is So Hard to Write
As soon as we hand history over to a good-willing person, even if they are a great artist, the matters quickly get foggy. This particular attempt at simplification of history has at least one significant flaw. It picked a plot line of different peoples fighting for land because they consider it holy and sticks to it, even though it's historically incorrect. Specifically, it is only fully correct for Jews, since, according to the Bible, the land of Israel was promised to Abraham and his descendants by God. Everyone else were and are primarily fighting for other reasons. For Muslims, Israel has never been a particularly important place - only the Jerusalem Mosque is somewhat important (not as important as Mecca and Medina), even though it is only thought to be mentioned in Quran as "the farthest Mosque". Now while Christians did call it a Holy land, I believe the real reason they were attracted to it was because of its association with Jesus.

So yeah, while Nina Parley is a terrific artist, be warned that this particular work of art distorts the truth, whether on purpose or not. The real story is that the Jews have a much stronger religious claim to the land than anyone else. Even more importantly, Israel is their only homeland, as opposed to everyone else who fought (and, arguably, still fights) for it.

the_grue··on Study shows salaries of young women 8% higher than men in peer group (2010)
Not necessarily. It can point to different distribution of priorities between sexes. E.g. if women prefer to dedicate their energy to family and house, while men prefer to work more, it makes sense that men would earn more. If we quit assuming we all want the same thing and actually ask people what they want, we may actually learn something. There are studies that do ask this kind of questions and get interesting answers, and my complaint is that this study is not actually one of those, it only appears to be that on the surface.
the_grue··on Study shows salaries of young women 8% higher than men in peer group (2010)
If even PhD's can't be expected to adhere to basic standards of intellectual honesty and critical thinking, then how can we ever expect the general society to grow up and realize the value of these things? How can we, the enlightened few (I say this half-seriously, of course, because obviously I am not without fault myself), ever expect to be able to lead a logical conversation with most normal folks we encounter in our daily lives, even with our parents, spouses and children? Seriously, most of us will never be able to choose their spouse from that tiny minority that understands honest and logical discussion. They will have to settle for something less. Most of us will have children who will never understand what we understand, simply because the school, the society and even our spouses will teach them to act based on emotions and false values. Basically, we are doomed to be eternally dissatisfied with the way our lives turn out to be!

I have to admit, conversations about critical thought in society invariably make me depressed.

the_grue··on Study shows salaries of young women 8% higher than men in peer group (2010)
Exactly. The word "peers" in the title implies comparison between people with a similar background (education, industry, etc). But it seems the actual study just compares the average salary of all single, young, childless women vs the average salary of all single, young, childless men across the economy.
the_grue··on Uber will not re-apply for self-driving car permit in California
> It's an unpopular opinion, but I believe the pedestrian caused this situation by putting themselves in a dangerous situation

Interesting! What reasons do you have to think this is an unpopular opinion? To me, it sounds like an obvious conclusion.

the_grue··on Firefox 59 released
They are already maintaining FF 52 LTS (actually, in Mozilla terminology it's called ESR) They should've calculated this in advance and made FF 56 LTS. They could still do it now if they wanted...
the_grue··on Firefox 59 released
Well, he's upset. After all, when you support a project for years, you convince your friends to switch, participate in the community, maybe write some extensions, and then it removes one of the main reasons you have ever been using it, you get upset. It's understandable... I used to have strong feelings about it as well. You say that Mozilla didn't kill their extensions lightly, etc. But still they didn't think to make 56 a LTS release to allow us a breathing space of at least a year of security updates until we decide what to do next. Going 4 releases back for someone who's used to be on the bleeding edge is quite daunting.
the_grue··on Firefox 59 released
I don't have an example handy, but when FF 57 was first released, I actually took the effort to check what are the prospects of extensions I use in future FF versions. I found at least one extension which required a feature that FF developers refused to fix because it would expose APIs they didn't want to expose, end of story. So it's not just a matter of "scratching your own itch", a lot of it is politics.
the_grue··on Firefox 59 released
For me it's EdgeWise, Session Manager, DownThemAll, Status-4-Evar.
the_grue··on Firefox 59 released
After I gave up on Classic Theme Restorer, 4 most useful addons remain: EdgeWise, Session Manager, DownThemAll, Status-4-Evar.
the_grue··on Firefox 59 released
I don't know why you are being downvoted. I have the same problem. I'm still stuck with Firefox 56 and no upgrade path in sight. I wish Mozilla declared FF 56 a LTS release for those of us who value their addons more than performance benefits of Quantum. Right now I'm still using an out-of-date release that doesn't receive critical security updates, and I have to choose between either downgrading 4 releases down to FF 52 (bad) or upgrading beyond FF 57 and losing addons that I came to rely on (unacceptable).
the_grue··on Rust needs to run, and be easy to use, on every platform
> I like Rust a lot actually, but kernel modules aren't a good use case for it.

If we're talking about kernel modules in general, I'd have to disagree. I think it's a perfect language for kernel, as long it's all written in Rust. I only wanted to point out the practical impossibility of integration with existing infrastructure, such as Linux kernel, which is written entirely in C.

the_grue··on Rust needs to run, and be easy to use, on every platform
Heh, but it doesn't do anything, does it? Because to do anything, it needs to interoperate with native datastructures and functions. There you go...
the_grue··on Rust needs to run, and be easy to use, on every platform
I'm a big fan of Rust, used it for several projects already, loved it. Too bad much of the systems programming is currently tied to C/C++ infrastructure. There is only so far you can get with FFI. Most likely not far enough to write a Linux kernel driver and many other things, unfortunately. Here's hoping the situation changes now that Rust is attracting so much attention.
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →