HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thedevil

1,844 karma · joined May 5, 2015

submissionscomments
thedevil··on Ontario announces that it will begin a basic income trial in 2016
_ak:

"Nobody shall be able to force you to spend your money in a way that prescribes a very specific kind of lifestyle."

But they're not spending their money, they're spending other people's money.

ak, If your version of basic income is about taking money from one group and letting another group blow it on alcohol and cigarettes, then it's obviously a bad idea.

thedevil··on Ontario announces that it will begin a basic income trial in 2016
While I can appreciate the optimism, I think it's important that we get this right (which might or might not be my idea).

Think about all the payday loan places. They're everywhere. Think about all the credit card debt (among other excess debts). Note that a lot of people with credit card debt make much more than any basic income would be. Think about how much the poor (who do not have luxury of wasting money) spend on cars, cigarettes, and TVs. With all these things in your head, do you still think that people will manage the money well if you just hand them money? Will they handle money that they didn't work for better than they handle the money they did work for?

Sure, some of it will go to good purposes. Why not make most of it go towards good purposes?

And to be clear, I'm not just trying to blame the poor - good money management is psychologically hard.

thedevil··on Ontario announces that it will begin a basic income trial in 2016
This exactly. It's not like they buy TVs instead of paying rent. Of course very few are that stupid. The problem is that they charge up their cards and blow their safety buffer on the TV/car/etc.
thedevil··on Ontario announces that it will begin a basic income trial in 2016
I'm not promoting any central planning. That certainly would be a disaster. The reason I suggest a voucher and food stamps is because they give the individuals the flexibility to apply them to their situation.

Edit: Also, it's definitely not just my parents. Look around you, there's payday loans on every corner. My parents only took a couple payday loans that I knew about. Their money-management issues are a drop in the ocean of similar problems.

thedevil··on Ontario announces that it will begin a basic income trial in 2016
1) A housing voucher would cover analogous issues in the US.

2) Being poor in a poor country is very different from being poor in a rich country.

3) I don't know the details of the program, but it likely involved different amounts of accountability and social influences than a basic income.

thedevil··on Ontario announces that it will begin a basic income trial in 2016
This basic income idea has been popping up a lot lately. And there's some merit to it, but there's some major problems too.

The biggest problem I see is giving people cash. Why not instead give each adult a voucher for housing (just barely adequate for cheap housing) and each person $5/day food stamps (or something similar), regardless of income.

Everyone gets a lower stress level this way. The risk of being homeless or hungry go to near zero. It doesn't matter if you're unemployable, or starting a business, or between jobs. You know you're going to be okay.

While giving people cash seems to have the same effect, it doesn't. At least here in the US, money problems are (mostly) a money-management problem. Many people use any cash they get to pay for whatever seems the most pressing at the moment - whether it's rent or a big screen TV. People buy the TV when they have money and rent isn't due yet, then have a little unexpected expense and can't pay rent. The stress level hurts them, hurts their families, causes increased expenses (e.g. payday loan).

My parents were like this, in six-figure-income years and in dead-broke years. It hurt us quite a bit. And "loaning" them money NEVER helped - they'd pay the mortgage today and then buy the TV when the next payday came in. And there's LOTS of people like this, which is why there's a payday loan on every corner.

Now, we've taken care of my mom by covering her housing and utilities directly. And her stress level is down a lot. It works great. This would have also helped me a lot when I was a student. And it means more startups - since all startups would be "ramen profitable" by default. And in the US, we could fund this with about a 10% tax (probably less if we took some funds out of SS, disability, section 8, etc.).

thedevil··on In San Francisco and Rooting for a Tech Slowdown
When I lived in SF, the categorical hate towards tech workers (I was not a tech worker back then) was nothing like "mainstream". It was just a few extremists, a few protesters I might see in the news. I didn't actually know anyone like that. Journalists made it sound like a bigger thing than it was.

It's been over 3 years though. Has the anti-tech-worker hate really gone mainstream or are journalists continuing to inflate it?

thedevil··on Silicon Valley Has Not Saved Us from a Productivity Slowdown
I'm not confused, I was just disregarding advertising in my comment because I assumed it only captured a tiny portion of the value. According to my first Google result, total US internet ad spending was about $60B last year (~$15/month), so my assumption was pretty reasonable.

The $106B is closer to $30 than $50 (I rounded up). So the combined ad spending and the 106B estimate together is about $50 per month per person.

It's actually more complicated than that - companies like Comcast also capture a (disproportionate) share of the value created. But even when you add it all together, it's still a big underestimate of the value created.

thedevil··on Silicon Valley Has Not Saved Us from a Productivity Slowdown
Google and Facebook have combined annual revenue around 80B, or around $20/month/person in the US. And the $50 was rounding up.

We're still underestimating value. Dramatically.

thedevil··on Silicon Valley Has Not Saved Us from a Productivity Slowdown
And here's an idea to explain the mismatch. Not sure if it's right, but it might explain why the numbers make no sense:

newspaper -> hacker news, google news: GDP drops, but life is better.

stereo + CDs -> mp3 player: GDP drops, but life is better

GPS -> Google maps, GDP drops, but life is better.

snail mail -> gmail, text, GDP drops, but life is better.

thedevil··on Silicon Valley Has Not Saved Us from a Productivity Slowdown
I definitely think we're nowhere near where we could be.

I just meant to say that the article's claim that slow productivity growth is "real" doesn't make any sense.

We definitely could be doing much better though.

thedevil··on Silicon Valley Has Not Saved Us from a Productivity Slowdown
"they valued free Internet services at ... less than 1 percent of G.D.P."

So Pandora, Facebook, Hacker News, YouTube, Google, Wikipedia, gmail, google maps, Reddit... all of these together are worth less than $50/month? Would any of you give up all the free parts of the internet for $50/month?

And look back 30 years: everything has gotten so much better. Rotary dial landlines have been replaced with smartphones. Houses are better and bigger. Cars are better, more comfortable, safer. Children's toys, strollers, playgrounds are so much safer and more convenient. Music has changed from a few CDs to thousands of songs carried around in almost every pocket. The numbers don't seem to make any sense to me.

Marc Andreessen is onto something. The economic numbers don't make any sense when you compare them to reality.

thedevil··on Be careful before you sign a non-compete agreement
Some employers will not hire you if you have a non-compete that might impact your work for them. It's never been an issue for me, I've only read stories online. But I have been asked while applying for a job whether I have any non-competes.

It's a risk for you. Even if unlikely, there's a non-zero chance that it could screw up your career and hurt you badly. That risk has very real value attached to it. Just like insurance and out-of-money options have real value to them.

thedevil··on Be careful before you sign a non-compete agreement
I've noticed the same trend in using non-competes on low-level grunts. Every job I've taken in the last decade required one. Only one of those jobs had a legitimate competitive reason for it.
thedevil··on The end of the establishment?
Scott Adams, maker of Dilbert, wrote something similar. He was calling it the "second American revolution". He threw out some radical, somewhat silly, but interesting ideas about it.

http://blog.dilbert.com/post/138023808851/the-second-america...

thedevil··on People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads
On that note, does anyone know anything about the impact of internet use in drug addiction (and crime)? I have a very speculative hypothesis that internet (social networks, porn, etc) might work as a super-crack, competing with (and crowding out) other addictions because it's cheap, abundant, and instant.
thedevil··on People in Silicon Valley Don’t Click on Ads
"Silicon Valley people don’t click on ads... Similarly, they appear not to be commenting or liking posts as frequently"

The most successful drug dealers don't use their own stuff, I hear.

Edit: I think I sounded a little snarky here. To be clear, I'm a huge fan of silicon valley. But I thought the analogy was humorous and thought provoking so I thought I'd share.

thedevil··on Against Generations (2015)
Born in 82 myself. If we're going to define people by generations, I wish we got broken into our own group.

I think there was a HUGE cultural shift that makes lumping us with Millenials insane. Social network usage is different, political views are different, use of language is different (e.g. YOLO).

thedevil··on The Fine Bros abandon attempt to license reaction videos after criticism
I don't follow the YouTube world at all, but I still keep hearing things like this. I'm surprised YouTube doesn't punish or at least stop people who make false claims.

I have an idea I'm exploring that would involve making YouTube videos and that (and other things I've heard) would make me hesitant to follow through on the idea.

thedevil··on Ask HN: What should we fund at YC Research?
1. Intersection analysis: Get traffic patterns with smart phones. Get traffic accidents and latency statistics by different intersection designs. Determine which intersections are most ripe for improvement. Give free access to departments of transportation. Traffic is a huge problem for society and self-driving cars are realistically a long way off from a total rollout.

2. Programming humans: When you train a neural network, you give it as carefully chosen data labeled as clearly as possible. When you train humans, they listen to a teacher and hope to collect 5-6 useful examples of a concept per hour somewhere in the thousands of words spoken by the teacher. What if you turbo charge that? One related experiment I'm considering is collecting thousands of images of different body language cues and making an app to train my brain (and that of other social handicaps like myself) to read body language more effectively.

thedevil··on Why Shitty Products Survive and Thrive
I wouldn't recommend most of these ideas to Microsoft.

For example, I've done work where I've needed a recalc based on an updated csv so your suggestion would have broken Excel for some of my use cases. There's plenty of changes to recalc rules I would have liked, but I'm not sure any of them were unambiguously good ideas.

Also, scripting in spreadsheets is bad practice (besides maybe formatting or simple data fetching and even those are questionable). It's not what spreadsheets are for.

thedevil··on Why Shitty Products Survive and Thrive
For the 14 years during which I used excel daily, the first 4 items you listed didn't affect me and the last two never mattered. I used text-to-columns to very nicely parse pipe-delimited files. The leading zeros issue I bumped into several times and was a minor irritation to fix.
thedevil··on Why Shitty Products Survive and Thrive
It was very well made. It's easy to use and yet but also has great features and shortcuts for power users. There's lots of genius little features not available elsewhere, like grouping columns or formulas over columns or rows (e.g. sum(A:A)). I often abused it with 50mb spreadsheets (a bad practice fyi) and it could often take it. The version I used rarely crashed.

For most software I use, I see lots of things that need improvement. With Excel, I can only think of a few. (If anyone from Microsoft is reading this, please add matchifs, it's desperately needed).

thedevil··on Why Shitty Products Survive and Thrive
In a past life, I made (very expensive) spreadsheets for a living. And though I don't like most Microsoft products, I'm pretty sure that Excel was built by God himself (or at least He was the lead dev or the PM).
thedevil··on The Automation Paradox
This is a great insight: "In nearly every corner of the economy there is an infinite amount of work that needs to be done"

I agree with you but i can understand how people can think differently. They are basing their ideas on what they see in front of them. And they don't see how it worked out before and they don't see all the additional work that can be done. I think it takes an imagination to understand that new jobs will form.

thedevil··on The Rails Doctrine
"Ruby included a hanging rope in the welcome kit" is very poor wording.

There's advantages and disadvantages to flexibility. I personally think there's tradeoffs that need to be balanced. But even if we accept the assumption that more flexibility is always a good thing, the wording is still poor.

That wording vividly and convincingly explained the exact reason why too much flexibility is a bad thing, rather than the good side of it.

If the author happens to read my comment, I recommend a rewrite saying something about trusting developers or maximizing their power instead of giving them a tool to metaphorically kill themselves.

thedevil··on Hire Literally Anyone
I'm a self-taught career changer and work for a team that has several new developers transferred from other departments.

It works out surprisingly well. The 2-3 experienced devs and myself do the harder development parts and the new developers are actually quite valuable as they contribute plenty to the code but also often explain some of the business considerations from other departments.

thedevil··on Running costs for running a web app
Anyone here have any thoughts on AppEngine vs Heroku?

I use AppEngine for my experimental projects because I can get a simple data model and some handlers running in minutes and a (supposedly automatically scalable) useful backend up in less than a day, and at very low cost. (Virtually free if I use an *.appspot.com domain).

You do get lockin issues but don't you also get lockin from Heroku? Is there big advantages to Heroku that make it worth it?

thedevil··on North Korea's computer operating system mirrors its political one
My first thought exactly.
thedevil··on DOJ defers payments to local police agencies through asset forfeiture program
I thought that was funny wording too.

I wonder if the person whose money was "forfeited" finds the sharing to be equitable.

← PreviousPage 8 of 10Next →