HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thedz

1,600 karma · joined July 19, 2009

submissionscomments
thedz··on The Decline of ‘Big Soda’ (2015)
(2015)
thedz··on Unlearning Unhelpful Behaviors in a Code Review Culture
> I disagree with "most", but this is absolutely often an issue. Often people take criticism of their code as criticism of themselves and their abilities, which is always counterproductive.

I think it's easy to fall into "this comment is a value judgement on my skill/person, and not my code" if code review feedback is targeted at the person and not the code.

Hence the discouraged "why did you do this" form vs the more helpful "this might be better because" format.

thedz··on Unlearning Unhelpful Behaviors in a Code Review Culture
Something that's been on my mind is the value of code reviews as a line-by-line exercise, vs the value of a code review as a round table.

I find line by line reviews useful for small PRs of limited scope (bug fixes, etc), but find it a difficult space to talk about things like approach, architecture, etc.

For the latter, I've found round tables where the dev in question have the time and space to explain their reasoning in a synchronous real-time manner to be valuable.

thedz··on Unlearning Unhelpful Behaviors in a Code Review Culture
I agree with refactoring along the way, but I think it's important to clearly state the _purpose_ of a branch or pull request, and to make sure that refacors don't wildly blow out the scope of the PR. I've been on the receiving end of too many PRs that refactor a bunch of things all at once because "well I was in there" to feel good about unchecked scope creep in PRs.
thedz··on Unlearning Unhelpful Behaviors in a Code Review Culture
I don't expect a team that is fearful of code reviews to be the best work they can do. IMO this isn't about offense, it's about removing barriers and wariness around code reviews.

(But as you side, that goes both ways, to both the reviewers and reviewed)

thedz··on A letter about Google AMP
1. H2 2018

2. Relies on a "web standard" that Google is pushing and is implementing in Chrome (and so far, I think, only confirmed to be in Chrome)

thedz··on As of today, no US passenger airlines operate the Boeing 747
Those airports already exist for other flights, and you don't need to negotiate track and land space for the path between cities. So I could see a heavily trafficked air route being (1) more logistically expedient (2) politically viable
thedz··on “Variables” in CSS are harmful (2008)
This is an article from 2008.

I'd take most arguments in this with a grain of salt, as it predates much of the progress that CSS (and things like Sass/Less/PostCSS) have made over the past decade.

thedz··on NextDoor Says Users Who Share Posts with Reporters Could Be Kicked Off the Site
If they only report hispanics or other non-whites walking around as "not belonging", then yes, skin tone is playing a part.
thedz··on 150 days of living and coding in a van
Different people have different work styles - some prefer the focus.

Fun fact: Antirez worked on Redis solely on a MacBook Air 11"

http://oldblog.antirez.com/post/apple-mba11-my-sole-computer...

thedz··on Show HN: Uncap: Map Caps Lock to Escape on Windows, Linux and Mac
Mapping caps lock to escape is nice, but IMO the really useful move is to map caps lock to BOTH escape and control. I use it (via Karabiner Elements on OS X), and it's great:

Caps lock pressed AND released in isolation within 250ms is escape.

Caps lock pressed in conjunction with another key is control.

The way it seems to do it is to trigger key events on key_up rather than key_down, meaning "escape" is triggered when you release caps lock, not when you press it. This can feel a little strange in some edge cases, but in normal usage, I don't notice it at all.

This has essentially saved my MacBook Pro touchbar as a dev machine, since I absolutely loathe the touchbar escape key, but didn't want to lose caps lock as control.

thedz··on A new kind of map: it’s about time
> Imo when it comes to that there is a huge difference between men and women, or perhaps more accurately people who are highly skilled in map-reading vs people who aren't.

If the second part is more accurate, why did you even bother mentioning the first? If it's correlation you don't even 100% believe in, leave it out.

thedz··on At liberal tech companies, those who disagree on politics say they’re isolated
> Now I've got total control over the speech of anyone around me. I can shut down anyone, making any statement on any topic. I need only declare that I feel hurt, scared, or angered by that statement - and such inarguable declarations have absolute unappealable power to silence.

If someone, in your place of business, says "what you just said was hurtful and offensive", then yes, I think maybe you shouldn't say it. Or at least take pause and consider why what you said may be hurtful.

None of that prevents your ability to say what you want outside the office.

thedz··on At liberal tech companies, those who disagree on politics say they’re isolated
IMO, part of the problem is that some "conservative" viewpoints nowadays are directly attacking or undermining how your coworkers might live. And in many cases, so much so that their views go from "well, that sucks but I can still live my life" to "if your views were enacted, my way of life would be destroyed".
thedz··on Mastodon is big in Japan, and the reason why is uncomfortable
> She didn't flinch and just went on about her business like nothing had happened, and he was thinking what a fuss/embarrassment etc that would have caused if it happened in a hotel in the US -- when it's just an adult being naked with another adult present. It's not like everybody hasn't seen genitals before or it's a big deal.

I'd caution against using a single situational anecdote and drawing conclusions about an entire culture. For one, it's highly likely that many maids in the U.S. (especially at a dedicated guesthouse or bathhouse) would also have a more minimized reaction to guest nudity and privacy. The experienced ones have seen some shit.

thedz··on James Damore is (almost certainly) not a victim of a free-speech violation
The ol' freedom of speech but not freedom from consequences bit
thedz··on I'm not a Woman in Tech
I'd urge folks in this thread to remember to treat this post as only speaking for Maria, and not as political capital for your personal POV about Women in Tech, because, well, that's the entire point of her post.

Not everyone is going to agree on the best way to foster diversity and inclusiveness, and that's fine.

thedz··on Another Ransomware Outbreak Is Going Global
yes, that's exactly what he said:

> You need read-only, airgapped backups before you can consider yourself safe.

thedz··on Mice fed a time-restricted, high-fat diet show reduced metabolic disease (2012)
> I don't think anyone is arguing that calories don't matter

Ahem:

> Carb restriction is key. You can literally eat until your stomach hurts all day long and lose weight.

thedz··on Mice fed a time-restricted, high-fat diet show reduced metabolic disease (2012)
I don't disagree with what you wrote -- I acknowledged in my post that certain foods satiate better than others.

But too often, in the swing towards "think about more than just calories!" I see folks completely ignore calories. It's much, much harder to over eat on some foods than others, true, but IMO I find people espousing "you can eat as much as you want all the time!" to be equally damaging.

Set a target caloric amount. Eat towards that. Fat/protein heavy foods make that easier to maintain.

thedz··on Mice fed a time-restricted, high-fat diet show reduced metabolic disease (2012)
Yes! To reiterate: the backlash against calorie counting into not taking calories into account at all is just as damaging.

Certain foods help satiate better than others at lesser calories -- which is why some people find that eating 1500 calories of high fat and protein foods to be much easier to live with than eating 1500 carb heavy calories.

IMO, that's one of the big draw of keto. It's not that you can magically eat 5000 calories of cheese and meat and lose weight. It's that you can eat a caloric amount at a deficit and still feel energetic and full and like you didn't miss out on anything.

thedz··on Mice fed a time-restricted, high-fat diet show reduced metabolic disease (2012)
> Caloric restriction is bs. Carb restriction is key. You can literally eat until your stomach hurts all day long and lose weight.

While I agree that for many people, restricting carbs is a far easier method of eating healthy while still feeling fully sated, stating that you can "literally eat until your stomach hurts" is false, misleading, and potentially destructive.

5000 calories of cream cheese or other caloric dense foods is, still, at the end of the day, 5000 calories. Caloric restriction isn't the only way to diet or eat healthy, but ignoring overall caloric intake (even rough estimates) while only focusing on "what" you eat is one of the biggest pitfalls I see.

thedz··on Apple acquires sleep tracking company Beddit
I read this as "BBEdit" at first and thought wow, they pivoted to sleep tracking?
thedz··on Bad Character: If Chinese Were Phonetic
For context, to forestall some knee jerk reactions I'm seeing:

1. This essay is part of a series, where guest authors are explicitly asked to "uninvent" something. So there's a level of built-in hot take to this.

2. The author is Ted Chiang, writer of Story of Your Life (and the work that the movie Arrival was based on). He's explored how language affects how we think before (Story of Your Life/Arrival is explicitly about this). So this kind of falls in line with that.

Anyway, I think this is a fascinating thought experiment to work through. What would China be like with a phonetic system? What would change? How much of the culture is derived from the method of language and how much from other factors?

thedz··on Bad Character: If Chinese Were Phonetic
> I've seen this sentiment a lot in Chinese-Americans that are not educated in linguistics, along with other self-loathing sentiments.

FWIW, I think Ted Chiang (author of Story of Your Life that Arrival was based on) knows a decent amount on linguistics.

At this point, Chinese characters aren't going to go anyhere. But I think it's an interesting thought experiment to puzzle through.

thedz··on What’s the Matter with Covert Action?
A similar thing is true of the latest well-reviewed open world game, Horizon Zero Dawn. The game's devs said that a majority of the world is "procedurally generated", but that their process still allowed artists go to in and fine tune spaces.
thedz··on Uber has a law firm investigating me – Susan Fowler
The title of this submission is a strict paraphrasing (despite being in quotes) of an already short tweet, which is pretty meh.

The full tweet is: "Uber names/blames me for account deletes, and has a different law firm -not Holders - investigating me. I have hired"

"Uber names/blames me for account deletes" is a pretty bold claim, and doesn't feel like a routine investigation.

thedz··on Uber has a law firm investigating me – Susan Fowler
> IOW, I'm not going to run in circles over a seven word tweet that could mean about anything.

It's not a 7 word tweet. Full text of linked tweet:

"Uber names/blames me for account deletes, and has a different law firm -not Holders - investigating me. I have hired"

The "names/blames for account deletes" is kinda weird. In either case, the title of this submission is a strict paraphrasing (despite being in quotes) of an already short tweet, which is pretty meh.

thedz··on How to Self-Publish a Novel in 2017
> When a fiction writer comes up with a plot, or even a turn of phrase that blows my mind, that's one of the best things about reading. Like "how did he think up all this?!"

Typically the answer is: hard work and iteration, and many times not by himself. I think you're partially falling for the fallacy of the singular author completing a perfect work with unflinching vision. IMO this is incredibly rare.

Take, for example, Harper Lee and To Kill a Mockingbird. It's an amazing book. It's a novel that might at once feel effortless and also an unaltered vision of the author. But it's actually the result of years of editing (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harper_Lee):

> Ms. Hohoff was impressed. "[T]he spark of the true writer flashed in every line", she would later recount in a corporate history of Lippincott.[16] But as Ms. Hohoff saw it, the manuscript was by no means fit for publication. It was, as she described it, "more a series of anecdotes than a fully conceived novel".[16] During the next couple of years, she led Lee from one draft to the next until the book finally achieved its finished form and was retitled To Kill a Mockingbird.

Everything from the narrative structure to the title to characterization is refined, over and over again.

The goal with feedback and subsequent editing isn't the dilution of an author's vision, it's the opposite. It concentrates and clarifies the vision with each successive pass.

thedz··on How to Self-Publish a Novel in 2017
IMO, this is an artistic fallacy that needs to die. Responding and adjusting to feedback doesn't undermine the integrity of a work or weaken its authenticity. Cycles of feedback and iteration are common to all work in every medium.

Obviously, you can take responding to feedback too far, but the idea of the artist-in-a-tower-birthing-a-fully-grown-work-whole is an inaccurate idea at best, and a damaging assumption at worst.

Like King says, ignore the outliers. But if no one understands a plot twist, or everyone dislikes something you really like, maybe take another swing at it. Iterate a little more. Creative output is the art of refinement as much as anything else.

(Good editors can also often help substitute for peer feedback)

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →