HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thelettere

324 karma · joined April 29, 2012

soen.substack.com
submissionscomments
thelettere··on G.K. Chesterton: The fallacy of success (1909)
It's from "In Praise of Idleness"
thelettere··on Cancer vaccine begins Phase I clinical trials
There are several citations in those posts, and a bazillion in the book I posted below.

Your attitude is all wrong though, and that is what needs fixing, above and beyond your knowledge. You ask straw man questions - you know I'm talking about added sugar. As for oil, why don't you look at the label of any processed food and then do some research on how these oils are produced? You'd discover how much worse americans health has gotten as these processed oils have largely replaced butter and animal fat as sources of lipids.

Also you do not appear familiar with how nutritional studies work and the difficulties of establishing causation. You cannot simply lock someone in a room and force them to only eat certain foods, and it is really really expensive to do longitudinal studies. We really know next to nothing based on controlled experiments on chronic conditions simply because of their limitations - but you combine the correlationary studies with evolutionary theory (especially natural selection) and studies in medical anthropology (as cited in those links) and you have as clear-cut a case as you can get in nutrition.

Groups that don't eat processed crap get cancer and the metabolic syndrome in ridiculously high numbers. Groups that don't eat processed crap don't get these diseases.

Groups that don't eat processed crap, but then suddenly are introduced to sugar and flour find their chronic health conditions going to the shithole. There is not example that I know of the contrary.

That's all the proof I need.

thelettere··on Academia.edu, The Social Networking Platform For Researchers, Raises $11 Million
You can do that with google scholar

http://scholar.google.com/scholar_alerts?view_op=list_alerts...

thelettere··on Academia.edu, The Social Networking Platform For Researchers, Raises $11 Million
Still kind of shitty - you have to log in to view or download anything. Google scholar is much more useful and open.
thelettere··on Cancer vaccine begins Phase I clinical trials
More on Jobs:

http://www.bulletproofexec.com/low-carb-paleo-diets-vs-cance...

Best Cancer Book:

http://www.amazon.com/Anticancer-New-Way-Life-ebook/dp/B002Y...

thelettere··on Cancer vaccine begins Phase I clinical trials
Two good referenced articles:

http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/2008/07/cancer-among-i...

http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/2008/07/cancer-in-othe...

As far as what they're consuming - sugar, processed oils and processed grains are the most widespread aspects of the industrialized diet, and therefore the best suspects. Try finding a processed "food" product without either sugar or an industrialized oil.

Jobs only started experimenting with weird diets after he became an adult. Also, while industrialized crap is likely the primary culprit, other things contribute - sedentary lifestyle and lacking basic necessary nutrients (Jobs experimental diets are like nothing I've ever heard of any non-industrial tribe or society eat).

thelettere··on Cancer vaccine begins Phase I clinical trials
There already is a cancer vaccine. It's called "Don't eat industrialized crap".

Cancer is virtually non-existent in tradition non-industrial tribes and societies. And yes many in those culture do grow just about as old as we do.

thelettere··on Show HN: Send Your Favorite Articles to the Future
I love your design, but in Firefox for me the middle section under "it's as easy as" is not loading, and the "start using timecapsule" button is covering a phrase starting "Do..." at the bottom of the screen.
thelettere··on The New Science of Mind
That hope and the relationship make up a much larger percentage of what causes change than technique is not my personal opinion. It's the result of a trans-theoretical analysis that was done a few years ago.

I don't recall the name of the study, but it's described in detail in "The Heart and Soul of Change".

thelettere··on The New Science of Mind
The only therapies you can study scientifically (making sure everyone receives the same treatment in the treatment group), are therapies with manuals. However, only about 3% of all therapies have such manuals (CBT being one of them).

Most therapists highly individualize their approach - just because they have the same name doesn't mean they're actually doing anything similar. So claims of "empirical" proof of psychoanalysis is nonsense. The nature of what psychoanalysis is precludes that.

thelettere··on The New Science of Mind
For a long time it was thought that mind and brain were not synonymous.

I do not argue it either way though - my point was that Kandel's claim that mental illnesses are fundamentally biological, that people are not at all responsible and that our brains "control our actions" is not supported by his examples or the evidence.

thelettere··on The New Science of Mind
“Psychotherapy is an undefined technique applied to unspecified problems with unpredictable outcome. For this technique we recommend rigorous training.” -Horowitz

All therapy is "black magic" in the sense that no-one quite understands exactly how it works. CBT gets props because it's one of the few therapies that has a manual and can actually be studied scientifically.

I'm sorry but I prefer to speak with a therapist who doesn't have to consult a manual for every response he/she makes. Therapy is ultimately a human relationship, and just as messy and unpredictable as any other relationship - and subject to all the contingencies thereofe.

Just because something cannot be studied scientifically does not mean it is not effective. Evidence for the limited long term effectiveness (high relapse rates, ect) of shallow and manualized interventions like CBT is growing by the day. Compare that with more messy therapies that dig deeper (like psychodynamic) whose outcomes actually improve the longer the subjects are tracked.

The vast majority of the effectiveness of therapy is due to hope (placebo effect) and the relationship. Focusing on the "technique" is distracting and leads to a view of therapy as something that is done to you, as opposed to something that is done with you. Lasting change comes from taking personal responsibility, not from having special "scientific" techniques done to you.

That para-professionals with 2 weeks of training have outcomes as good or sometimes better than those with Ph.d's in clinical psychology is all one needs to know when deciding whether or not to categorize psychotherapy as a science.

thelettere··on The New Science of Mind
"Mental illnesses are disorders of the brain that disrupt a person’s thinking, feeling, moods, and ability to relate to others. Just as diabetes is a disorder of the pancreas, mental illnesses are brain disorders... [They] are not a result of personal weakness, lack of character, or poor upbringing."

That's from a 2000 pamphlet written by the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill. Kandal's claim that this is new is BS - it's an old idea, and one not demonstrated by the research he cites. It's simply more evidence that mental illnesses are mediated by biological processes - something we've known for years.

The claim that mental illnesses are "caused" by biology is just as false now as it was then, and these experiments make no suggestion in either direction.

Clearly, neither study permits inferences about cause. Again, just because biological processes are involved does not mean that it is triggered by it. This is the same idea that's been pushed by over-zealous neuro-scientists for years. It's based on the belief that if we just drill down far enough in biology and genetics, we will explain most of the variance in behaviors.

If you don't cherry-pick the evidence, the whole picture suggests the same story that we've known for quite a while - but some in the psych/mental illness field aren't satisfied with it because the truth doesn't fit with their cravings for prestige - with our cultural obsession with the biological being more "real" than the social. Not to mention the financial aspects - one of the reasons we know so little about the social etiology of mental illness is because there's so little funding available for it.

The evidence suggests that environmental factors are just as involved - and in many cases is the primary cause, which plays on biological vulnerabilities that determine how the illness is expressed and through which it becomes self-perpetuating, not only for the individual, but on down through the family through cultural transmission and epigenetics.

Why does this even matter though? Because our perceptions of mental illness influences its outcome - how we view mental illness determines in large part what it is and how it expresses itself. If we believe it's fundamentally a fixed genetic and biological disorder that the individual themselves is helpless to do anything about, then through the nocebo effect it becomes a self fulfilling prophesy. That is one reason why outcomes for schizophrenia are better in sub-saharan Africa than they are in the US.

Sources

On Epigenetics: Masterpasqua, F. (2009). Psychology and epigenetics. Review of General Psychology, 13(3), 194. http://pzacad.pitzer.edu/~dmoore/2009_Masterpasqua_Psych&Epi...

On Biological and Environmental Etiology: Bentall, R. (2009). Doctoring the mind: Is our current treatment of mental illness really any good?. NYU Press. http://www.power2u.org/downloads/Richard-Bentall-Broken-Brai...

Scheid, T. L., & Brown, T. N. (Eds.). (2009). A handbook for the study of mental health: social contexts, theories, and systems. Cambridge University Press.http://hmid.basijmed.ir/public/hmid/books/mental%20health/A_.... 104 to end of chapter provides a good overview)

Whitaker, R. (2011). Anatomy of an epidemic: Magic bullets, psychiatric drugs, and the astonishing rise of mental illness in America. Random House Digital, Inc..

On social Expectancy: Burns, J. K. The Social Determinants of Schizophrenia: An African Journey in Social Epidemiology. Public Health Reviews, 34(2). http://www.publichealthreviews.eu/upload/pdf_files/12/00_Bur...

Whittaker, R., Kemp, S., & House, A. (2007). Illness perceptions and outcome in mild head injury: a longitudinal study. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 78(6), 644-646 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2077969/

thelettere··on Show HN: Mixest, my summer project that crawls the web for new indie music
I love this. There's a particular song that I absolutely can't get enough of, but it isn't labeled correctly (says "Track 4 by New Artist"). I've "loved" it but do you have any suggestions for finding out what it is?
← PreviousPage 5 of 5