HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

theluketaylor

2,182 karma · joined February 10, 2015

submissionscomments
theluketaylor··on EVs Are Essential Grid-Scale Storage
Most cars use NCA or NMC chemistry which has 500ish cycles. Grid storage will soon use LFP which is cheaper to begin with and has 5000+ cycles. It has a lower density than other chemistries and very poor cold weather performance, making it less ideal for vehicles (though Tesla is using it in the standard range model 3 now). Those downsides don't matter for grid storage and really change the economics of charge/discharge.
theluketaylor··on Do heat pumps work in cold climates?
There are plenty of insulation firms that specialize in insulating old homes without ruining the finishes. Typically you cut a small plug, either from the outside or inside depending on the construction method and mechanically force (typically blow) cellulose fibres into the wall cavity. You need one plug per stud bay, but repairing those is a pretty simple job compared with tearing down all the finishes.

Air sealing is tougher, but techniques like aerobarrier where an aerosolized polymer is sprayed throughout the home while it's under positive pressure has made air sealing fairly simple. Stuff like that can plug up to multiple inch gaps

theluketaylor··on In Lebanon, solar power is booming
Drain heat recovery is quite common here in Canada and mandatory in a few jurisdictions for new builds.

https://www.homedepot.ca/en/home/categories/building-materia...

As for the hot humid bathroom air, that also exists in the form of ERV (energy recovery ventilators). For well sealed houses you route all the exhaust and intake for the home to one place where there is a heat exchanger to minimize the losses from getting fresh air into the house.

theluketaylor··on Mercedes is the first automaker to offer Level 3 self-driving in the US
The big difference is MB is taking liability in the event of a collision and he car won’t simply hand control back to the driver. This is much more advanced than any L2 system and the fact MB is taking liability is a whole different ballpark.
theluketaylor··on Autonomous trucking upstart Embark has gone from $5B+ to basically worthless
I've heard it said the single best thing that could be done for airline safety is getting rid of pilots since most crashes are the result of pilot error. Then ask yourself if you would get on a plane without anyone flying it.

Driving is one of the most dangerous activities people undertake on a regular basis, yet we are all numb to the risk since it's just normal. Changing a major variable in the risk profile of driving by introducing autonomous cars is a big deal since the failure modes are so foreign.

I think the autonomous vehicle resources should be more focused in the short term in making "uncrashable" cars as we're a long way off from true autonomy. Systems like automatic emergency braking that live in the background and act when the driver is making a serious error to prevent or dramatically reduce the impact of an event the car is certain will occur.

theluketaylor··on RISC-V: The Last ISA?
> Now that RISC has decidedly won out over CISC

Has it? The modern "RISC" designs out there in the wild include a lot of pretty specialized instructions.

I would agree load/store has won over instructions with memory side effects common to many CISC setups. Keeping side effects to a minimum to improve out of order and speculative execution has been a key goal of most modern ISAs, but keeping instruction count to a bare minimum has not. CPUs have landed in a space between RISC and CISC where simplified and reduced instruction count is certainly a goal, but the ISA will happily toss in a specialized instruction where significant speedup can be achieved.

theluketaylor··on The United States’ Unamendable Constitution
I could easily be mistaken. I think it's currently a weird grey area where the UK government has said they will continue to respect it, but there is nothing binding them to that decision.
theluketaylor··on Tesla's Model Y tops new car registrations in Europe in September
Depends of what it takes to be a "US auto manufacturer". Ford has had strong sales for decades throughout europe and is routinely the biggest volume seller in the UK. Nearly all those cars were designed and manufactured in Europe and until the Focus none of the popular european models were available for sale in the US. Is is a US manufacturer doing well in Europe when it's an entirely european effort to design and build? Even if it's on the american branding?

This is likely the first time a car designed, engineered, and manufactured in the US tops european sales figures. Tesla is expanding manufacturing to China and Germany and the actual vehicles for sale in europe right now were manufactured in China, but the cars are the same as built in Fresno or Texas, but I think the point stands.

theluketaylor··on The United States’ Unamendable Constitution
The US has the most expansive free speech laws in the entire world. Perhaps 'extremist' is a bit hyperbolic, but it's certainly true US free speech laws go far beyond any others.

Reporters Without Borders maintains a press freedom index. Their justification is detailed here: https://rsf.org/en/index

Canada ranks 19, the US 42

theluketaylor··on The United States’ Unamendable Constitution
For a long time now I have tried to sum up the differences between the US and Canada in our founding principals. Canada's is "Peace, Order, and Good Government". Contrast that against the "Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness" and the fundamental differences in our approaches to government make a lot more sense.

We're much more like the UK than the US in the function of government and the construction of laws, though Parliamentary Sovereignty is expressly subject to judicial review in Canada, something the UK is going to have to grapple with over the next decade now that they are no longer subject to the European Court of Human Rights.

The government can't just override the charter as they please using the language in the Guarantee. The charter allows for things like hate speech laws, but they have to fall under "reasonable limits", something the Supreme Court of Canada rules on all the time, nearly always in favour of citizens compared to the government. A recent example being medically assist death, where the Supreme Court ruled bans on assisted death violated the Charter.

The US is a free speech extremist country, but since even the US Supreme Court has ruled there are limits on speech (like threats) this isn't a night and day difference between our countries in my view. The US allows far more speech than Canada does, yet we rank higher on the press freedom index.

The thing that really lets the Charter down is section 33, the 'notwithstanding clause'. It allows the federal and provincial governments to pass laws overriding certain rights for a period of 5 years. The charter itself would likely never have come into being without it, but it does take some of the teeth away.

theluketaylor··on The United States’ Unamendable Constitution
> Ruth Badger Ginsburg

Ruth Badger Ginsburg should be a Supreme Court Justice on a kids show filled with animals who makes landmark decisions the real Ruth Bader Ginsburg would have proud of.

Your own link contains my very point: the Charter of Rights and Freedoms is a modern piece of human rights legislation. RBG specifically calls out the Charter, not the Canadian constitution as a whole.

The Charter is like the US Bill of Rights, a small section of a larger document dealing specifically with civil rights. The rest of the Canadian constitution is a messy bit of parliamentary wrangling from across 2 centuries delegating the country of Canada into existence and separating it from the UK.

theluketaylor··on The United States’ Unamendable Constitution
As a Canadian I'd be surprised to learn our constitution was considered top notch by legal scholars.

The amendment process is very onerous. 7/10 provinces haven't ever really agreed on the colour of the sky, let alone something as important as new constitutional rules. It took some very special backroom wrangling to pass it in the first place and I don't see a path to amending it during my lifetime. Meech Lake came close and very nearly broke the country.

The notwithstanding clause was necessary to get it passed at all, but really takes some of the teeth out of the charter of rights and freedoms. When parties hold majority control of the House of Commons or a provincial legislature a lot of what keeps their power in check is mostly norms it turns out. One of the few actual laws that would really impede them is the charter, but portions of it can be ignored.

Overall I'm very happy we have the 1982 Constitution Act, but I certainly wouldn't offer it up as a blueprint if someone came asking for assistance in drafting a constitution. The Charter itself as a portion of the larger constitution (minus the notwithstanding clause) is a very special piece of law that deserves some recognition internationally, but as a whole it wasn't even 10 years before the real issues were exposed with the whole document.

theluketaylor··on Oslo Looks to Become World’s First Capital City with All-Electric Public Transit
Trolly buses make so much sense to me with modern range extending batteries massively reducing the cost and complexity of hanging the gantries and wires. You can skip all the messy intersections and complex areas and just handle the long, simple stretches. I would much rather see cities embrace overhead wires in low cost runs compared with huge battery busses that need tons of recharging infrastructure. It also helps solve the climate conditioning issues in extreme weather locations, since both heating and cooling power coming from overhead wires solves range issues that arise from pure battery solutions. Cold winters and trying to keep a bus warm are range killers.

I also want to see a battery range extended approach taken to electrifying existing rail routes that rely on diesel. The vast majority of the cost comes from a relatively small part of the total distance of the track run, from things like bridges too low for gantries and nearby structures impeding on the space required for the safe use of wiring. If batteries on the locomotive or electric multiple units can power the train for short distances the cost of electrifying the line can be slashed to a fraction of needing to power every inch of the run. Europe has electrified a huge portion of their rail network, but it's pretty rare here in north america and keeping the costs under control could make electrifying large chunks of the network feasible, especially east of the Mississippi.

theluketaylor··on Towing with My Ford Lightning EV Pickup Was a Total Disaster
Ford has a patent out on a removable bed box that contains a range extender. Looks like it's not just a defensive patent either; they have been spotted testing something very similar. With a big battery capable of providing extra juice when climbing long hills or accelerating they should be able to put a fairly small engine in and always run it at peak efficiency.

Especially if they can be rented from a dealer it would really takes care of the casual truck user's needs. I have a buddy who daily drives his F-150 to work and then a couple times a year tows a big camper long distance for family vacations. His daily needs could easily be electric and he could rent an extender for 3 or 4 weeks a year to tow with. It would still slash his annual fuel consumption and as biodiesel or other synthetic fuel becomes available/reasonably practical even with a big truck his carbon emissions would be very low (it does help the grid here in Ontario is extremely clean already)

theluketaylor··on Towing with My Ford Lightning EV Pickup Was a Total Disaster
EV towing is likely is toughest use case for personal transportation, but it's worth noting Hoovie has the small battery Lightning and towed at well over 70 mph. Slowing down even a little would have resulted in a different experience since aerodynamic drag is the biggest range killer.

That's not to say the issues he raises are not real, they absolutely are. Towing with an EV is painful since most charging locations don't have pull-through stalls and the range hit with a trailer is no joke. ICE vehicles are so inefficient to begin with and refuelling so quick and simple people don't typically notice how big a hit towing is. Batteries just don't have much energy in the compared to fuel, so reducing the efficiency has very apparent impacts.

theluketaylor··on ArriveCan’s $54M price tag ‘outrageous,’ tech leaders say
We need our own version of 18F to build technology patterns and in house expertise so that government is less reliant on outsourcing. With more in house work when government does outsource there would be a much better yardstick to determine requirements and measure success.
theluketaylor··on Ask HN: Why are expert practitioners often so bad at teaching beginners?
Sports is a good place to look for models since the hiring and firing of coaching staff is reported right alongside the other narratives during a season.

It's rare for the best coaches to have been the elite practitioners of a sport. What's very common is for someone who struggled to even break into the elite league or had a very short career there goes on to work through the coaching ranks and become an elite coach.

I have always thought it's due to mid-tier players needing to really focus on every lesson they get, studying every drill, obsessing over every piece of advice they get. Elite players just absorb the drills and lessons into who they are and forget it was ever taught to them in the first place. When the learning comes hard the player will understand the complete process to come to understanding. They will also see the elite players around them apply the lesson and improve, so they know the lesson works. Being worse at doing the skill can ultimately make you better at teaching it because you are forced to understand the skill more deeply.

Being a replacement-level player doesn't automatically make you great coaching material though, that's where the filtering starts to find great teachers and communicators. As many others have commented, teaching is a skill unto itself, one not everyone has.

theluketaylor··on Homemade Heat Pump Manifesto (2009)
I think they can recover up to 60-70% of the heat in the drain water. Not bad for totally passive. The installs I have seen are on the main drain for the whole house and located right next to the hot water heater. For it to really work you need a hot water tank, but I have seen some small tanks combined with tankless.
theluketaylor··on Charging cars at home at night is not the way to go: study
Hardly 99%. With a 260 mile-range car I only need to plug in about once a week. People who drive more obviously need to plug in more often, but it's a pretty rare person who would absolutely need to charge every single day. EVs are not for every single use case yet (like long distance towing) and that's okay. They will handle more use cases with each passing year. We certainly don't have nearly enough slow charging points yet, but it doesn't need to be anywhere near 100% coverage before many people who don't have dedicated parking can use an EV with minimal to no disruption.

Battery swapping isn't more efficient or cheaper. You still have to build out massive charging infrastructure all over the place to charge all the swapped batteries, plus you need staff, locations, and equipment to do the swapping, and storage space for the batteries while they wait to be placed back in a car. Plus every manufacturer has to use the exact same battery physical and electrical specs, eliminating all possible innovation in packaging. No one is saying it isn't possible, it just doesn't actually make sense at scale.

I recognize having a private driveway and garage is a luxury, which is why I'm highly supportive of laws requiring multi-unit dwellings to add charging and offering tax breaks for both landlords and tenants to get them installed. Also highly in favour of tax breaks for employers to offer charging in their lots. I also think municipalities should be upgrading the existing streetlight wiring to offer charging alongside street parking.

theluketaylor··on Homemade Heat Pump Manifesto (2009)
Modern setups are really good about managing frost buildup and can be more efficient than resistive heat down to -20C. Waste heat from the compressor is often used for the defrost.
theluketaylor··on Homemade Heat Pump Manifesto (2009)
drain water heat recovery is already a thing. It's code for new builds in British Columbia, Canada.

It's only expensive due to the amount of copper. The actual install has no moving parts and is completely passive.

https://www.nrcan.gc.ca/energy/products/categories/water-hea...

theluketaylor··on Charging cars at home at night is not the way to go: study
fast charging isn't need for day-to-day life. The vast majority of cars spend most of their time stationary and slow AC chargers are going to just become more and more common at all parking spots. Never having to stop during normal driving for gas since you start every day with a full 'tank' is a complete game changer.
theluketaylor··on Charging cars at home at night is not the way to go: study
I believe the EU trucking downtime rules actually line up pretty nicely. Building trucks with enough range to maximize the driver time and then charge during the refresh period works out just about right.
theluketaylor··on Charging cars at home at night is not the way to go: study
Way more complex than that. Different packs have very different voltage and current delivery characteristics. A bunch of motor management depends on the battery pack characteristics, including things like regen braking.

Charge times are already under 20 minutes for the best cars and will likely continue to come down. Swappable batteries would be a massively expensive undertaking that would hugely limit innovation in battery and car packaging for a pretty minimal gain.

I’ve taken my model 3 on plenty of road trips and haven’t once thought it would be better with battery swapping.

theluketaylor··on Charging cars at home at night is not the way to go: study
I’d happily let the utility decide when to charge the car for best pricing and load usage so long as I can override it when I need from time to time at prevailing price. I’d also be happy to sell power back to the grid if I can set the price floor threshold since batteries do have cycle limits.
theluketaylor··on Charging cars at home at night is not the way to go: study
I live in a cold climate and it would take only take more than 50% of charge to keep the house warm overnight with an air source heat pump. Since I rarely use more then 10% of range per day driving this would easily work for me. With an LFP battery car the cycle usage wouldn’t even be a big deal.

It’s not impossible.

theluketaylor··on California's Highway 1 reopens in Moss Landing after shelter-in-place lifted
The biggest barrier has been patents and availability. A number of patents expired this year, so I'm expecting a lot of new players and locations to get into LFP production very quickly.

LFP for home or grid storage is a nearly no-brainer compared to other chemistries since it's so much more stable and has much better aging and cycle characteristics. The slight loss of power density doesn't matter for stationary installations.

theluketaylor··on Dwell House – 540 sq ft prefab home that you can add to your backyard
It does seem to include pulling the utils and a slab foundation, so that's a lot less out to lunch. Still very high end pricing.
theluketaylor··on Dwell House – 540 sq ft prefab home that you can add to your backyard
It does seem to be a mostly turnkey price, including a (I'm guessing) slab foundation and running sewer, water, and electrical, and placing the structure, so that price is a lot less crazy.

The other thing they have working against them is cost per sq ft goes up with smaller builds since you still need expensive spaces kitchen and bathroom and they can only shrink so far.

In most high cost of living places where building ADUs makes the most financial sense I'd be surprised if you could do something like this start to finish for much less than 400k between permits, variances, drawings, groundwork, utilities, construction and finishes. The foundation and utils alone could be 100k+.

theluketaylor··on Volkswagen targets $70.1B to $75.1B valuation in planned Porsche IPO
It’s non-voting shares. It’s free money without any risk of losing control.

The Volkswagen corporate structure is really confusing due to complex financial maneuvering by the Porsche/Piech family over the past 20 years. 30% of Volkswagen AG is owned by Porsche SE (a holding company under the control of the Porsche/Piech family, not the car maker), but those shares are more than 50% of the voting shares. Volkswagen AG contain Porsche AG (the car maker).

Porsche has been a money printing machine for quite a while, so why not cash in with an IPO when there is 0 risk of losing control?

← PreviousPage 9 of 22Next →