HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thenoblesunfish

1,116 karma · joined April 13, 2020

submissionscomments
thenoblesunfish··on Ask HN: What was your "oh shit" moment with GenAI?
When a junior engineer first sent me something that looked good until I realized it had been vibed, and thus their understanding of what they were doing was too shallow to answer questions and improve on it. That was a doc, but it happens with everything. "Oh shit", I say, as everyone is aggressively encouraged to work this way.
thenoblesunfish··on Domain expertise has always been the real moat
A terrible example, because chess is very, very simple - deterministic, rules fully specified in a few pages. We're talking about how you operate in a "games" which, among other complexities, involve the economy and human social dynamics. Billions of other agents. Find a plumber and try to beat them when someone calls you with a clogged toilet. Find a teacher and try to beat them when a student is repeatedly acting out.
thenoblesunfish··on Domain expertise has always been the real moat
True that AI lets you get information fast an efficiently. But it might just make you feel like you understand, even if you don't have the kind of hard won domain intuition that this article is talking about. I certainly often get delusions of grandeur when I learn a lot of something and haven't yet suffered with it in practice.
thenoblesunfish··on I'm Tired of Talking to AI
Perhaps part of the issue is that people feel compelled to respond, even though they don't have anything to say. Maybe people think if they burn some tokens for you that's somehow a more polite way to ignore you and hope you go away?
thenoblesunfish··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
To make sure this opinion is here:

The fact that they get to make this announcement is probably the biggest upside. Their base loves it. It makes people think they are doing something. There is an asymmetry in that if they quietly roll this back or it's blocked in court, it will generate only a tiny fraction of the publicity.

Probably not too controversial here to say that the economy wants these immigrants so good bet they'll keep getting hired.

It's a cruel strategy, but I think it's fair to say that it's far from certain it'll be a consistent one.

Don't let them troll you too much, stay strong.

thenoblesunfish··on Google Chrome silently installs a 4 GB AI model on your device without consent
It's annoyingly huge, but is this worse than that? It's software - it does stuff and takes up space. If it takes up more space than you think the stuff is worth, then complain it's bloated, sure, but I am not sure why "silently" is being thrown around.
thenoblesunfish··on Talking to strangers at the gym
It's true but then again, for most things, the correct answer is somewhere there, amongst the BS, so if you have a good BS detector and want some ideas, you could do worse. You can't outsource the part where you see for yourself if stuff works, and form your own opinions.
thenoblesunfish··on Talking to strangers at the gym
Charming! Reminded me of "Naive. Super" by Erlend Loe, which I loved.
thenoblesunfish··on Composition Shouldn't be this Hard
Maybe this unfairly off topic, but in reading the intro, my thought was not that things become brittle and hard to change because of the inelegance of the abstractions, but because of the banal dynamics of work. Mostly, people act quickly towards short term goals, without full understanding. They accept technical debt, they pass things between people, and the numbers to avoid making things kinda gross just never work out.
thenoblesunfish··on The effects of caffeine consumption do not decay with a ~5 hour half-life
Very interesting! An aside and fishing lazily: I am one of those people where caffeine has a very strong and long lasting effect. I don't have caffeine after about 9am or it affects my sleep that night. I love drinking coffee, and fortunately for me it seems like decaf got way better and widely available recently. Did something happen there?
thenoblesunfish··on Restoring the first recording of computer music (2018)
"This audio is embedded from SoundCloud and requires cookies to function. To view this content, please enable analytics and marketing cookies using the cookies opt-in at the bottom of your screen." - lame!
thenoblesunfish··on Emacs and Vim in the Age of AI
I still use Vim a lot, even though for work I use a fork of VSCode, like most people. Why? Because it's something I feel I can understand - it's simple and runs everywhere. It's the world of shells and text files. The work setup is a huge GUI with dozens of extensions, and now a whole other layer of non deterministic AI stuff. Useful, but it's a different kind of tool, one which relies on constant support from a large system.
thenoblesunfish··on I'm reluctant to verify my identity or age for any online services
People don't like these checks. Ok. But. Parents worry about their kids being exposed to porn and social media. They want someone to do something about it. That political force is real, and someone is going to take advantage of it. What tools can they ask for if not these checks everyone agrees they hate? That's what I hope for in these types of comment threads.
thenoblesunfish··on Cognitive Debt: When Velocity Exceeds Comprehension
Just to make sure it's somewhere in these comments: the fundamental issue is people trying to measure something they don't understand. That is not new. The article gives an interesting exploration of how things break down in a new way when people focus too much on metrics instead of (IMO) the more robust approach of getting people who care to try to make something that feels quality. We're building crap, yes, but I blame the people who spend their time measuring "velocity" like it's a well defined term, not the coding tools being used to play the game.
thenoblesunfish··on The Age Verification Trap: Verifying age undermines everyone's data protection
I was hoping for more on "... The only way to prove that you checked is to keep the data indefinitely." What do the laws say on this? What data is this? I would have assumed that just like a bouncer can check my ID and hand it back to me, a digital system can verify my identity and not hold onto everything (e.g. the actual photo of my ID).
thenoblesunfish··on I want to wash my car. The car wash is 50 meters away. Should I walk or drive?
Okay, funny. What does it prove? Is this a more general issue? How would you make the model better?
thenoblesunfish··on “Nothing” is the secret to structuring your work
I personally find the same approach very effective. It forces me to know where to look for things, and to document things because I cannot hold onto the fiction of being able to hold it all in mind.

But the real advice here is "think about what you're doing". Any system, whether it's "clear your workspace" or "arrange absolutely everything so its visible" probably works, because you're acting deliberately.

thenoblesunfish··on RFC 3092 – Etymology of “Foo” (2001)
This location in Switzerland reminded me of some placeholder Python code.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foo_Pass

thenoblesunfish··on Product and design are the new bottlenecks
From my team's PoV, I reject the premise. The non-eng people can scale their ambitions and asks even faster than AI has accelerated the engineers' work. In fact, they always have a bunch of stuff that ends up below the line, they always would have wanted to go bigger and faster.
thenoblesunfish··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
He doesn't get into why he didn't switch to Apple. Kind of a middle ground - it's still got the maddening things about being from a corporate behemoth, but it's closer to Unix and you can run your audio software there. (I would be using Linux instead of Apple yesterday if it weren't for a single music program I can't live without).
thenoblesunfish··on Ask HN: How can we solve the loneliness epidemic?
Be a part of (IRL) groups.
thenoblesunfish··on Stop Doom Scrolling, Start Doom Coding: Build via the terminal from your phone
I think the commonly used platforms, ISPs, etc. make this just annoying enough that most people really don't know how easy this should be.
thenoblesunfish··on Stop Doom Scrolling, Start Doom Coding: Build via the terminal from your phone
Is being able to SSH into your home machine that easy these days? I never had a strong enough reason to spend more than a few minutes trying, but I always suspected that my ISP would make this harder for me than I would hope.
thenoblesunfish··on Try to take my position: The best promotion advice I ever got
Good advice, in general. But there is a risk here, which is that you're encouraging people to do something which isn't their job.

Are you sure you don't want this person working on the things they are supposed to be working on?

Further, even if it all goes well, you're encouraging someone to do a more stressful job and not (yet) compensating them. Given the fact that you can't practically promote everyone you want, this risks your senior-with-junior-title feeling taken advantage of and prone to look for their title elsewhere.

thenoblesunfish··on Toys with the highest play-time and lowest clean-up-time
This article is aimed at younger kids, before normal Lego is appropriate. I like Duplo more than magnatiles - slightly harder to clean up I suppose, but that's because they hold together better than magnatiles, which create quite fragile structures.
thenoblesunfish··on If you don't design your career, someone else will (2014)
Comments like this make me feel very lucky to have the job and manager I have! If the situation is as adversarial as the one you're describing, are you perhaps missing out on the fact that when people trust and genuinely support each other it's not zero sum? That you and your manager are actually on a team (assuming you're in a big company), basically at the same level in terms of power and influence?
thenoblesunfish··on Jonathan Blow has spent the past decade designing 1,400 puzzles
People do the New York Times crossword every day for years..
thenoblesunfish··on Jonathan Blow has spent the past decade designing 1,400 puzzles
These guys are more like artists than engineers, right? I don't care if my favorite band only releases one album a decade, if it's good.
thenoblesunfish··on Fran Sans – font inspired by San Francisco light rail displays
Fun! Would love a "style 4" where you see the thin lines e.g. within the solid squares.
thenoblesunfish··on Things that aren't doing the thing
There is an extreme where you procrastinate on the real work, yes. But half the things on the list are not procrastination, but preparation. If you skip those you hit the other extreme where you are so focused on doing the thing, you waste your time because you don't know the background or context.
← PreviousPage 2 of 17Next →