HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

theschwa

1,527 karma · joined June 9, 2008

submissionscomments
theschwa··on Oculus sunsets Go, will add easier Quest app distribution
Focusing their product line like this is a great move. I hope that they do more to hone in on overall usability for the average user, and continue to expand beyond gamers as their core persona. Focusing on standalone VR, hand tracking, and hopefully more social and productivity apps like Facebook Horizon will be the best way to grow.
theschwa··on Coronavirus and Credibility
This is likely the case, but can you site some sources?
theschwa··on Machine Learning on Encrypted Data Without Decrypting It
The person who runs the model won’t be able to infer anything. The result of the model is itself encrypted, and would need to be decrypted using the original encryption key.
theschwa··on Half-Life: Alyx
You can't easily know where your elbows are correctly. In games where they try to fake it, it feels dysphoric to have the elbows in the wrong place.
theschwa··on Why Enterprise Software Sucks
The truth is though, if you make user focused B2B software, it likely won't do well.

I worked on a product recently where we built a new stripped down mobile version of our enterprise software that was extremely easy to use for the average user, but had minimal functionality for management. Our manager users have never been big adopters of our mobile software, because they spend most of their time looking at large reports that don't work well on mobile, so we figured this was a safe strategy, at least for the initial launch.

However, we saw extremely low adoption, because managers would try the app, see that the minimal amount of features for them, and then they wouldn't recommend it for the rest of our users. We refocused to adding features for management, and we started to see much larger adoption by the average user.

Selling user focused software to the someone who isn't the main user will always be an uphill battle. The companies that have had the most success are those like Slack that are able to get into the organization without the buyers approval first.

theschwa··on Filecoin: A Decentralized Storage Network [pdf]
I haven't had a chance to dig into this paper yet, but for a similar system Swarm [0], there is a system of insurance and escrow on file chunks, and a system of verifying the hash of piece of the file to see if they still have its contents.

[0] http://swarm-gateways.net/bzz:/theswarm.eth/

theschwa··on Filecoin: A Decentralized Storage Network [pdf]
What's the problem with them being on random machines? I believe the purpose of Filecoin and other projects like Swarm is to incentives people to store the files long term and in some cases verify that those files are still being held.
theschwa··on Filecoin: A Decentralized Storage Network [pdf]
I believe that's what projects like Filecoin and Swarm are trying to solve. How do you incentivise long term storage of these files.
theschwa··on Oculus CEO Brendan Iribe Steps Down
I'm a bit of a VR enthusiast, and I'm not a gamer, so I think I can answer some of these. >- Outside of car games, space sims, or any other game where the main character is mostly sitting down, does VR work well?

Very well. The thing I hate most, as a non-gamer, is having to learn all of the confusing controls. I really like that VR games take away most of the complication and allow you to do what feels natural. Probably for the same reasons a lot of people like the Wii. I've been having a lot of fun in games like Vanishing Realms:a first person dungeon crawling RPG http://store.steampowered.com/app/322770/ , The Unspoken: where you have magic battles in a New York like setting http://www.insomniacgames.com/games/the-unspoken/ , and a bunch of the puzzle type games.

>- Apart from games what other applications are there at the moment?

Not enough in my opinion, but I've spent the last week using Oculus Medium to make 3D models, and using Quill to make VR paintings. This is actually the area I'm most interested in, and I know that some companies are working behind closed doors at the moment to make more creative tools as well as business and social type tools.

-Anyone try replacing their monitor with a VR headset? How'd that go?

I do this frequently for consuming movies, but the resolution isn't at a point where I'd recommend it for long periods of time if you're doing text editing. I still occasionally browse and listen to music with the screen set to a gigantic size, but it hasn't replaced my monitors.

- Anyone try combining a VR headset plus a kinect? Seems like a natural combination.

Several companies and individuals are. This guy has been involved in the VR scene for many years and has some interesting experiments using several kinects to do mixed reality work http://doc-ok.org/?p=965

theschwa··on Oculus CEO Brendan Iribe Steps Down
I'm rather surprised that amongst the speculation in the comments, no one is really considering that maybe Iribe's comments are true. Maybe he really did miss being more involved in the product and engineering part of the job.

The company has grown up very quickly, and I have to imagine at this point as CEO, he was spending most of his time in high level business talks and not doing what he loves and what he's best at.

theschwa··on Crypto 101 – Introductory course on cryptography
There seems to be a lot of comments asking about the quality of this piece. I read through this the last time it was posted to HN, and I just have to say that this is the perfect balance of having enough detail to understand how things work, but not so much that it's overwhelming. That's a really difficult balance when it comes to crypto, so major props to the author. Fantastic work.
theschwa··on Did anyone notice 12-bit jpeg?
I believe that's to support HDR.
theschwa··on Origami Studio – Design Prototyping
Invision is great for prototyping a general work flow, how the user moves from screen to screen, but it's not designed around building individual interactions. You upload a bunch of screenshots and create clickable areas that link to another screenshots with some basic transitions. Origami is designed around building out individual interactions and transitions.
theschwa··on Origami Studio – Design Prototyping
I've generally seen tools like Balsamiq and Invision used for the app flow and tools like Framer and Origami used for micro-interactions. I would, however, like to see something that blends the two well, but maybe that just doesn't fit with enough people's use cases.
theschwa··on Origami Studio – Design Prototyping
That's fantastic. I can't imagine how much work has gone into this project. I'm excited to see what this does for the adoption of Origami. Are there any personal stories from the process you're able to share?
theschwa··on Origami Studio – Design Prototyping
I'm really curious how this was built. Quartz Composer got a lot of things right, but it's showing it's age. Was this rebuilt from the ground up?
theschwa··on Daydream – Google VR
To be fair, the new phones are supposed to have MUCH higher accuracy in tracking which is necessary to make it feel like you're actually THERE (what's generally referred to in VR as "presence").

The Samsung phones work around this by putting extra sensors in the VR headset itself.

theschwa··on [dead]
> Among milliennials and those coming of age behind them, the race is on to see who can be more righteous and aggrieved — who can replace the boring old civil rights generation with a spikier brand.

> When I was growing up in the ’60s and early ’70s, conservatives were the enforcers of conformity.

This article just sounds like every other time someone complains about the generation that came after them. I'm sure to her, the conservatives seemed like the ones enforcing conformity in the 60's and 70's, but the view on the right at the time was the left was the one enforcing conformity.

theschwa··on Why GitHub Finally Abandoned Its Bossless Workplace
Just for some clarification on the VR side, the Vive is a partnership product between them and HTC. Valve did the R&D, and HTC did the manufacturing, adnd Valve helped Oculus get things off the ground as well. I'm not a gamer, so I can't speak to that world, but they are doing truly innovative things in VR.
theschwa··on Dolphin 5.0 Release
Why is this emulator so well organized and polished compared to some other emulator projects? They do such great technical write ups, but I'd love to see one about how they manage the project.
theschwa··on Introducing Algolia Places
How does this compare with Google's places autocomplete?
theschwa··on Oculus Rift Exclusives on the HTC Vive – Proof of Concept
First off, I want to reiterate that I'm most excited about the lighthouse tracking system, it fits well with projects where I'd like to apply tracking, but my main objection is to your comment that it's an objectively superior design. All designs have pros and cons. Also, I realize I'm nit picking, but there's a couple inaccuracies in what you've said:

I'm not sure where you're getting the significantly more processing power; particularly if you're comparing to lighthouse. General image processing can add latency, but they've constrained the tracking problem, and it currently doesn't heavily utilize the CPU [1] . You can perform similar tracking cheaply with an ASIC like castAR does [2]. Lighthouse still has to perform sensor fusion with different time stamps for the tracker locations as I previously mentioned, which can also be processor intensive. I haven't done or seen any CPU usage comparisons between the two, but I believe they'd be comparable.

You are limited by the resolution of the camera, but you can still get subpixel accuracy when tracking. With lighthouse, you don't exactly get infinite resolution either, but I do think lighthouse takes the cake here. Once again though, it's the IMU that ultimately determines the accuracy.

Lighthouse being untethered is one of the more exciting things to me as it lends itself well to doing tracking in large event spaces.

The limiting factor for lighthouse isn't whether the laser is in range, but whether the LEDs are in range. In between each laser sweep, the IR LEDs flash, so that the tracking points know when to start timing [3]. I believe they've improved the distance of this flash in the consumer Vive, but they will still limit the distance.

Adding base stations does help improve accuracy, just as it does with constellation, but it won't improve precision. It only helps prevent issues with occlusion. However, adding more base stations won't improve the precision of the tracking device's location.

I believe the current lighthouse systems are still technically limited to two base stations, because of how they are time multiplexed. They're planning on frequency multiplexing which should allow this to grow without having to connect the base stations.

Also, lighthouse is susceptible to IR interference in ways that constellation isn't. They both utilize IR for their tracking, but since each tracker in the constellation system flashes a pattern, it's able to eliminate environmental IR. Lighthouse doesn't have a direct way to prevent IR interference that I'm aware of other than accounting for potential errors in their pose estimation.

Lighthouse also has moving parts, so there's a chance for mechanical failure. The motors are manufactured by Nidec [4] who are one of the largest manufacturers of hard drive motors, so they should be very high quality, but it is a potential point of failure.

Lastly, your statement "while this might be possible with the rift, the experience is likely not going to be as good as the Vive, and may be quite poor at times," seems to be entirely speculation. There are several tests with both single and multiple cameras that have performed room scale tracking exceptionally well. [5] [6] [7]

These are both great technologies that have their own strengths and weaknesses. I don't think there's one objective winner here. That being said, I'm looking forward to the updates to lighthouse that they've been talking about to make lighthouse viable for large event spaces, and I could even see a day where other IOT objects utilize lighthouse for tracking in ways that wouldn't be possible with constellation.

[1] http://uploadvr.com/oculus-cv1-positional-camera-efficient/ [2] http://www.theamphour.com/transcript-of-episode-147-absorpti... [3] http://www.pcper.com/reviews/General-Tech/SteamVR-HTC-Vive-d... [4] http://www.nidec.com/en-Global/product/news/2016/news0108-01... [5] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_HlXzELHgo [6] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cXrJu-zOzm4 [7] http://uploadvr.com/room-scale-possible-testing-the-standing...

theschwa··on Oculus Rift Exclusives on the HTC Vive – Proof of Concept
First off, I'm a huge fan of the lighthouse tracking system, and I'm looking forward to them opening it so I can use it in other projects. I do think it has some elegance to it.

That being said, it's not necessarily "superior in design". Because it uses a sweeping laser, it can't know where every tracking point is at the same time. It can't even measure each axis at the same time. The laser sweeps top to bottom and then side to side. For each tracking point, it records it's position in one axis at one point in time and the next axis at another point in time. If the tracking point has moved in between sweeps (which is likely), then you have two separate position measurements from two separate times that have to be combined with data from the IMUS to determine exact location. The Rift doesn't have this issue. The Rift records the location of all visible tracking points at the same time using an infrared camera.

It's important to keep in mind that Vive's lighthouse tracking system and Rift's constellation system only use the lasers and cameras to do drift correction. Most of the tracking is done by their IMUs (accelerators and gyroscopes), so the actual results you perceive will be very similar.

theschwa··on Lytro announces light field VR video camera
There seem to be a lot of questions on what a light field is. Lytro just put up a great blog post that gives a good introduction to them http://blog.lytro.com/post/132599659620/what-is-light-field
theschwa··on Lytro announces light field VR video camera
You're spot on. Holograms, as in the images like on a credit card, do actually record light fields.
theschwa··on Lytro announces light field VR video camera
Actually, he was right with his first guess. This isn't about capturing film with a heightmap like RGBd cameras do, it's about capturing all light that goes through a volume of space from all angles. If you can fulyl capture all light that enters a volume of space, you can accurately recreate a view from any point in that space. So, in VR I can move my head around, both by turning my head around and moving forward, backward and side to side and accurately see any view.

This does also allow adding CG elements, but it's real strength is being able to capture enough of the light coming through so that you can almost 'teleport' to where the video was recorded.

theschwa··on Google in Kansas City: A Tale of Two-Speed America
I had a beautiful spacious apartment in midtown for $800 with all utilities included. I now rent a two story three bedroom house in midtown for $1300 not including utilities. Overall, it's extremely affordable, and there are single bedroom options that aren't as big as those places for even less.

Not all of these are listed on sites like Craigslist, so it helps to reach out to some property management places.

theschwa··on Prospecting on the Playa: 19 Tips to Network and Generate Leads at Burning Man
I hope this is a joke, but just in case anyone thinks this is a good idea, remember that this violates one of the ten principles:

Decommodification In order to preserve the spirit of gifting, our community seeks to create social environments that are unmediated by commercial sponsorships, transactions, or advertising. We stand ready to protect our culture from such exploitation. We resist the substitution of consumption for participatory experience.

theschwa··on How I Hacked Amazon’s $5 WiFi Button
I'm not sure what you mean by this comment. This is pretty much the definition of hacking something together.
theschwa··on I Tried VR and It Was Just OK
Not only is this based on "early versions of the tech", but no one has even released a consumer product yet. These are are all developer prototypes. Even the Samsung Gear VR is still an "innovator edition".
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →