HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thetruthseeker1

208 karma · joined December 3, 2014

submissionscomments
thetruthseeker1··on Git Magic
I really liked the analogies the author used to demistify git usecases. I also agree that it probably doesn’t make sense to use other version control systems if cost and learning (which can also be modeled as cost for the company) are not factors.

For eg, if there is some quick project you need to do, and people in your team have been using say CVS, and there is not much wiggle room in the deadline, getting your team to use Git may not be the most smartest choice - I think that is what most people mean there when they talk about ‘tiny’ projects.

I will say that even if you are not truly starting from scratch, migrating to git has advantages more often, but I am wary of trivialising the people who think there is a cost associated to ( move to )a distributed system like git.

thetruthseeker1··on India Wants to Give Half a Billion People Free Health Care
They say Proof is in the pudding.

I am wary of applauding before seeing how well this is implemented. India is known to come up with lot of big programs that make good rhetoric, but not all of them are implemented with equal amount of vigor or commitment.

I am sure part of the motivation may be to help next election cycle which is coming soon.

thetruthseeker1··on How I review code
I don’t know how much time he spends code reviewing. But if at the end of the day he wants anybody to get the complete context of what the change entails by looking at the PR... I would think the code review process is more elaborate and time consuming than many companies can afford.
thetruthseeker1··on India’s IT industry laid off more than 56k employees this year
One thing I was hoping to get answered is, what is the revenue growth or dip these companies have seen. I think that may give a better context to this story. Job loss headlines alone sounds like doom and gloom, but that may or may not be the case depending on how the money is flowing...
thetruthseeker1··on macOS High Sierra: Anyone can login as “root” with empty password
I think the responsible way to handle it is, you inform Apple in a closed way. Once they come up with a fix, if you think they didn’t come up with a fix soon enough, make that information public then on how long it took Apple to turn this around. Disclosing every vulnerability to the internet and setting their ass on fire is not a good way to solve this IMO.
thetruthseeker1··on macOS High Sierra: Anyone can login as “root” with empty password
Closed disclosure is responsible disclosure. Moving past the terminology, I am an Apple user as well, I am pretty satisfied with how quickly Apple resolves issues.

Now if every person started disclosing vulnerabilities via twitter without giving the company turn around time to resolve the issue based on their dissatisfaction with Apple based on standards they came up with personally, I don’t think it is nice or fair.

thetruthseeker1··on The Western Elite from a Chinese Perspective
I thought it was a good/enjoyable article and it shed light on many things for me.

Reading some of the comments below, and having known some Chinese people ( I am not east asian) I want to point out that it seems like many people missed the intention/ tone of the author. I think his intention was not to brag as some people have misunderstood, but to provide context to how he got to where he got to.

His communication style is different compared to the western style of communication. There is no single coherent message he is trying to drive purposefully or tacitly, but my guess is he was hoping you learn whatever you can from his experience and his way of thought.

Sure the article title could have had the words ‘random’ and ‘musings’ in the same sentence..... meh!

thetruthseeker1··on India's Indira canteen: The best meal you can buy for 13 cents
For people dismissing it as vote bank politics... I want to say policy is more complicated.

If the govt reduces taxes for people in low income range is that vote bank politics?

If government provides free education to the poor is that vote bank politics?

Both the above items are aimed at a certain segment.

If you think the answer to above questions is Yes, then in that case every body has vote bank politics, and discussing whether it’s vote bank politics is of little use (I am not even sure if it is a bad thing).

I think a better question to ask is whether it is good policy. I don’t see any argument indicating it is bad policy. Seems like it is helping a certain section of the society at little cost to the rest.

thetruthseeker1··on Leonardo Da Vinci Painting Sells for $450.3M, Shattering Auction Records
I wonder if its a person or a corporation/org that bought the painting. Number of people who may buy such a painting is probably only a handful.
thetruthseeker1··on Bakhshali manuscript: oldest recorded use of the zero symbol
Did you read my other comment about why Fibonacci promoted the decimal number system? Because, at least he thought in his qualitative assessment that the Decimal number system was better and he brought in its adoption in the roman world (Feel free to look it up).

All I was trying to say was the article is very superficial and does not capture the "real value" zero eventually provided.

thetruthseeker1··on Bakhshali manuscript: oldest recorded use of the zero symbol
I think this article fails to capture the importance of zero. While the idea of zero itself isn't staggeringly mind blowing, the real greatness with zero came in with development of decimal/ Hindu (positional) numerical system and zero indicating nothing in a position which led to simplicity in doing arithmetic.

For example can you think of the rules to multiply XVIV with XXV or can you quickly calculate what the result of that will be without translating to a decimal number system ? Exactly!

With the use of zero and the the development of rules for decimal arithmetic (Brahmagupta), the hindu numeral system became superior to the roman numeral system and thus led to its wide adoption (The decimal number system was promoted by Fibonacci in the west and some people consider that to be his greatest achievement).

thetruthseeker1··on Ask a Female Engineer: Thoughts on the Google Memo
But that wouldn't appease the public who wanted him fired? If the public( let's say women's group) aren't appeased and they boycott google, it affects google ?

It is possible that google gave an offer to James D to be silent along with the pink slip, which he might have turned down?

thetruthseeker1··on Ask a Female Engineer: Thoughts on the Google Memo
I for one believe James Damore wasn't fired for his views on women, but Google fired him because he was a PR problem and that could affect their business/financial bottom line. Google probably understands the user base and decided they would rather not displease women (bigger group) compared to conservatives.

My analysis adds up to what James Damore had to say as to what happened in a WSJ article. He said his memo didn't bother many people until it was leaked, and the google HR got many complaints from the outside world.

I think the google management fired him not because of his view, nor were they worried that he questioned google's purported wasteful spending on diversity programs (which for Google is drop in the bucket if it is effective...if it is not effective I dont think they care, it makes them look good).

But google fired James because they thought he was bad for business (consumer base).

thetruthseeker1··on U.R. Rao has died
Thanks swatkat for a good gist. I found it odd that the nytimes mentioned a yoga study which I would guess was not among his super critical contributions and the purpose of which may have a fun study/angle to it like Alan Shepard playing golf on moon.
thetruthseeker1··on I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
Hi Peter,

Thanks for offering to do this. According to new USCISs rules , if you are on H1b and you were let go, you can be in the US two months to find a new job and have your H1 transferred.

What happens if you stay say slightly over 2 months and find a job later? In what ways can you run into trouble ?

thetruthseeker1··on Seattle’s higher minimum wage is actually working fine
My take away has been that it is not clear beyond doubt that higher minimum wage is better in the long run. If both the studies had agreed that it is better, yes, it makes sense to enthusiastically adopt it. However if studies have results that dont match, then I think there is a reason for caution.

As far as what I understand, only Seattle adopted higher minimum wage, now many people with that minimum wage can get services (may be not directly, but in the supply chain) from other states which don't have the minimum wage which can give the impression that their life has improved. However, if the whole country adopts it, the parameters of that might be different.

I hope somebody sheds a light on wage dilution as well. If somebody was incentivized to learn a skill that pays them 20$ an hour, will that incentive still be there?

thetruthseeker1··on How some people stay motivated at work when they don’t love their jobs
Presumably for this author, when he came of age to work, he didnt need to support his parents or his brothers, so he had the luxury to look for true meaning in his work and had enough balance in his checking account that quitting wasn't an unreasonable choice when he didnt find what he was looking for. I would think he is not alone, and many people around the world who come from upper middle class families are in the same boat if they dont have anybody else depending on them and if they can't find meaning in their job.
thetruthseeker1··on WSJ Ends Google Users' Free Ride, Then Fades in Search Results
Yes, thank you!
thetruthseeker1··on WSJ Ends Google Users' Free Ride, Then Fades in Search Results
This is free market capitalism that Rupert Murdoch's company Fox News promotes.

Google News fundamentally improved the online content publication system by making it cheaper to its consumers.

Earlier, there were too many news companies whose content didn't necessarily have an edge over some other news agency's and they charged money (which worked in an age where no internet existed), and google has fundamentally squeezed some of them including WSJ.

If the differentiating quality was present, more people might have been willing to pay for WSJ.

When Harrison Ford made cars, lots of businesses who built business around the inefficient means of transport (i.e the horse) like providing fodder for horses, and blacksmiths who were building horse shoes or the ones building horse carts got squeezed.

Same here. Internet and google has removed an inefficiency in the news system. They need to adapt and provide a differentiating quality, else they will perish - The principle of free market capitalism.

If WSJ needs google to behave a certain way so that it can make more money, that is not free market capitalism.

thetruthseeker1··on A critique of trends in tech
If people had a choice to live in a country where it is hard to start "meaningful" companies vs living in a country where it is so easy to start companies that you can even start stupid companies, I would think most people here will choose #2.

Now regarding degrading conditions and pay, that was not what I was commenting about....

Also, one thing to remember is small 'stupid' companies (like juicer) will be "taken care off" by free market economics. Over a period of years, if it does well, then it is fair game. Else it might go bust. It is unlikely that is not the outcome here.

thetruthseeker1··on A critique of trends in tech
I understand the point the author is trying to make, but I do want to point out, that if you lived in another country unlike USA, it would be hard to even come up with a product like the quip or the juicer (however useless you may think it is). You would have funding barriers, you may find it hard to find people who have the engineering skill set to come up with a product that works the way it does etc, or worse you may not even have a local market for your product initially.
thetruthseeker1··on India Is Winning Its War on Human Waste
Part of the problem is also because of lack of education. Unlike in the west, literacy rate is not as high, hence they miss out on the knowledge and awareness that can come from being able to read. But, India is making progress even on that front, so eventually I think both these improvements will complement one another nicely and things may be much different 10 years down the line.

I am originally from India(now I live in US) and my grandfather who was a doctor in India back then in the 1950s would advise people who often fell ill to eat healthy and eat apple. People would ask him what Apple was and to describe it so that they can buy it in the market. My dad who also turned out to be a doctor said he didnt meet any patients who didnt know what Apple was...so yes, things change...but they take time.

thetruthseeker1··on Intellectual Humility increases tolerance, improves decision-making
The one thing I would have liked to see in this article would have been the benefits and downsides of both qualities. Intellectual Egotism, and Intellectual Modesty. That would have been a balanced approach.

There are people who know that they are intellectually modest that read this article, and it may reinforce their belief that being intellectually modest is the one true path! There are people who know that they are intellectually arrogant and may feel that they are destined for hell by reading this article. There are some advantages to being an egotist as well and disadvantages being modest.

The other subtle incoherence I wanted to point out is, at some point the author claims intellectually modest people are in both classes of people, conservative and liberals. But he does say that republicans by and far are more likely to not accept a person who has "flip flopped" [may or may not be for good reasons] than a democrat. So assuming most conservative people are republicans, and most liberal people are democrats there is some intellectual quality that differentiates their bases. This probably needed more analysis in my opinion.

thetruthseeker1··on The threat from within
Any idea that can't be tested or challenged at any point of time, I am worried about such an idea. No idea is fundamentally true or absolutely right in all contexts.

I am a liberal and a progressive, but there are many progressive ideas that have failed and thanks to that.

thetruthseeker1··on The threat from within
Not sure why I got down voted. What I am saying here is - from the university point of view, if universities are worried that the platform is used for spreading fears via nonintellectual arguments, they can create a framework to mitigate such problems... I dont know why I got downvoted, please attempt to understand the point I am making here before down voting me.

I dont think universities should shut down the other side, but they can create a framework for communicating ideas .... one way OXFORD does it is via debating (which you can find on youtube).

thetruthseeker1··on The threat from within
I agree with this article 100%. If universities are worried about "ignorant" people spreading misinformation (if they give a podium to people who they think are un-intellectual), what the university could do is have a framework on how such ideas or all ideas are communicated. With some rules and fact checking guidelines in place, it is possible to hear the opposing (or what is viewed as un-intellectual view point ) with proper analysis.
thetruthseeker1··on Reflecting on one very, very strange year at Uber
I think part of the problem is giving too much power to middle management in tech, which I think is unnecessary and many companies like google have tried to obviate this problem.
thetruthseeker1··on Time to Take a Stand
I hope I am not downvoted because I have a different view.

I think Trump is a show man to some degree. He has said in the past he wanted to be in Hollywood. This is important to understand what drives him.

I think what Trump is doing is a part of a show, to tell his voters he is credible. But I think his long term policies will not be this drastic even if they are. I think the tech community should work with him to do the right thing, dissenting with him is not the right way at this point in time. It is too early to decide that you are against Trump ( as a Tech community).

thetruthseeker1··on Air India Taking Advantage of Tailwinds
I dont think there is any greater lesson or theme here about lost chance of BRICS of anything. I think the world is ever changing and there is always newer opportunities that show up to capitalize from.

India is a big country/ship and is harder to steer quickly. In the last 25 yrs, India's GDP growth rate has not fallen much below 4% (averaging more than 6%). India is achieving near 100% literacy rate below a certain age demographic, it has a good space program, there is good encouragement for education and free enterprise, I reckon India is doing many things right.

thetruthseeker1··on How the Arab World Came Apart
I don't think we should say let's pay for the invasion with their oil, it's probably more accurate to say let's take their oil or steal it because when you say 'pay' it implies Iraqis asked for invasion(which they didn't) and you are talking of oil as payment.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →