HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thetruthseeker1

208 karma · joined December 3, 2014

submissionscomments
thetruthseeker1··on Malcolm Gladwell got us wrong: here’s what got oversimplified
The author agrees with Gladwell that to become pretty "good" at anything you will need to work hard at it(10K hrs). But the theme of the book is 'outliers', and Gladwell over simplifies saying that all it takes to be an outlier is 10000 hrs of work - which is not the case apparently, some people achieved this without as much effort and it is likely some people require a lot more effort than 10K hrs to be "as" good and considering that, it is not really clear what the outlier benchmark cutoff hrs is.

The underlying message which Gladwell conveys that to be outlier at anything, all you need is 10,000 hrs of work does not seem to hold true for all individuals in all fields.

thetruthseeker1··on A Pointless Cancer ‘Moonshot’
I am not cynical about humans living longer etc as this article seems to claim. However I am cynical about the approach of calling everything a moonshot. For Moonshot, there were clearly measure-able goals before you were able to land on moon in say 10 yrs. Now in Cancer research or any research is not executed in the same paradigm as planning a voyage to moon.

Yeah my point maybe a minor one, but I dislike the dumbing down of things or appealing to past glory.

thetruthseeker1··on Solar is now cheaper than some coal, says India energy minister
I do think ambitious & driven Indians can do very well in a global market place. I think the stiff competition in resources have made the cream of India very competitive at a global level and we see things like Indian at Microsoft CEO position. But I dont buy your argument that Indians are outdoing the west yet(not saying it can't be done), but there have been more American CEO's in the fortune 500 than Indian CEOs.
thetruthseeker1··on Solar is now cheaper than some coal, says India energy minister
In general I understand the principle of the argument, that the government is not as driven as private sector because there is strong incentive structures in private companies. But with some good management decent incentive structures in govt, it can also work. Case in point, the some of the Indian banks which were nationalized, the Indian railways(the largest rail network in the world), and in many Indian States govt. diary companies have worked decently well as well.
thetruthseeker1··on Congratulations You’ve Been Fired
This article talks about how companies over inflate the value of the work tech workers are providing almost to the extent of feeling like being in a cult - which was something I was thinking all along but didn't want to say out of fear of being called a kill joy.

While in many successful tech companies this might not be to the same degree, I bet the scale is tipped towards the direction of cult like indoctrination. My guess is the part of the problem is in many technology companies that are not seeing huge profits, there are no true metrics to measure the value of your work - so they can get away making bold corny claims

thetruthseeker1··on Why Anti-Authoritarians Are Diagnosed as Mentally Ill (2012)
I am an immigrant in America. I have had problems with my bosses(American) when I challenged some of their decisions at work. When I challenged their decision in every quantifiable metric, they could not defend it in any way and relented, but then I heard from HR about not following orders in general.

I think in American culture there is lot of emphasis on command hierarchy( may be military influenced?) and who wears the pants so to speak, compared to my home country in the east, and I think that may have something to do with it.

But I can attest to the the repulsiveness I feel to subtle authoritarianism where orders are sneaked in along with regular conversation.

thetruthseeker1··on Study: Immigrants Founded 51% of U.S. Billion-Dollar Startups
No matter how you feel about the whole legal immigration thing, If it is true that immigrants who form significantly less than 51% of the working population found 51% of the startups there is an interesting insight statistically speaking (This is not normal, but good)

May be there needs to be a distinction between the kind of immigrants who go on to found startups vs the one who come to take low paying jobs. May be create different visa category for each. Encourage one discourage another(limiting it), but that doesn't mean that every person who comes under 1st category starts a company or everybody who comes under the second category doesn't start a company.

I see it as math, maximize one function and minimize the other.

thetruthseeker1··on Illegal Math
Even though the contents of iPhone is encrypted, the government agencies have been able to get that out of iCloud with the help of Apple in the past. So it is not entirely true that the whole encrypted content is off limits in all cases. May be that is all that is needed. And may be we shouldn't need to do anything more which I think is a valid argument. However, lets also not paint the ones who request such a feature as "morons"
thetruthseeker1··on In the Age of Google DeepMind, Do the Young Go Prodigies of Asia Have a Future?
Or in the 1990s in the age of DeepBlue (IBM super computer), do young chess prodigies of countries that formed the former USSR have a future?
thetruthseeker1··on Young Saudis See Cushy Jobs Vanish Along with Nation’s Oil Wealth
I find the argument really odd. For eg: India's borders were drawn by the British in 1947. Is the British responsible for the staggering growth rate of India or any success attributed to India since.

Same thing with Saudi: US or any other country did what they did, I am sure taking into account their interests.

Since both India and Saudi Arabia are sovereign nations, it is their actions that have either propped them up or otherwise.

thetruthseeker1··on Young Saudis See Cushy Jobs Vanish Along with Nation’s Oil Wealth
Not sure why I got down voted for this! I hope I am not down voted just because people disagree with my view point? I thought the guidelines clearly said that you only down vote when I say something that does not add value to the discussion. If Saudi's borders were drawn by England, how did US make Saudi by that definition. I still stand my ground that there is some kind of a we(US and England) are better than you (Saudi Arabia ) tone here.

Occidental Capital is a private enterprise it looks like, a private enterprise is not a nation. A private enterprise can relocate, it can shut down, it can spin off, it can undergo merger and a complete metamorphosis to a degree that it has no resemblance to the original company (unlike a nation). If occidental capital funded the initial setup of Saudi Aramco, it does not mean US nor UK did it!

thetruthseeker1··on FBI Director Comments on San Bernardino Matter
Sounds extremely straight forward and sincere(many bad decisions are also taken with utmost sincerity) but I would think it would be a bad idea to provide FBI this ability.

For one, it is forever weakening the security and privacy of your iphone. Bad guys who want to evade the policy officers will do it anyway with encryption systems/software available from any of the non US territories.

Considering that FBI can get significant meta data from telecom providers(who called whom etc), I think this requirement that FBI has gives little gain in security as the upside and comes with a significant downside[ huge loss in privacy].

thetruthseeker1··on Young Saudis See Cushy Jobs Vanish Along with Nation’s Oil Wealth
This reeks of condescension. I don't believe US made Saudi Arabia, but I do think Saudi Arabia benefited from US and US from Saudi. The partnership was a good one for both probably, but America through it ingeniousness and also through circumstances ended up being the country with highest GDP. Now Saudi has capital and resources, it is upto it on how it uses it, it is interesting article from NYtimes that talks about the challenges Saudis face, but I dont believe that "Saudi" or any country for that matter is destined for failure.
thetruthseeker1··on A Message to Our Customers
Are iphone hard disks (and the files within it) and cloud content encrypted based on this single private key that is stored in the secure enclave on iphone?
thetruthseeker1··on A Message to Our Customers
I dont know if there can be a practical solution based on what you said. If an FBI agent could do it, he could lose that methodology due to him getting hacked or he could do that on purpose with malicious intent( theoretically speaking).
thetruthseeker1··on India bans discriminatory pricing based on source/destination/app/content
Note in the USA, Verizon does not ding uses of their data cap if they use Verizon's video content Go90, however it does if the users use YouTube. It is interesting that in India the net neutrality has been taken to a much higher degree than in the US itself. But I don't think what India did is a bad thing in the long run(even though the acceleration of people moving to use Internet for first time will get hurt a little bit in the short term)
thetruthseeker1··on UC Berkeley profs lambast new “black box” network monitoring hardware
The title of the article wasn't very worrying to me, so I read the whole article, and I was trying to figure what in this article is actually a cause for concern. I actually didnt find any "significant" cause of concern.

I have worked in the area of computer networking for many years. My guess is, one of the things the black box product is doing is typically looking for TCP or IP traffic patterns(packet flow patterns) that indicate say command control type of malware, or other malwares, that don't have much resemblance to packet flow signature of user browsing activity.

Also, this blackbox won't be able to decode HTTPs anyway. So may not be a privacy concern for most people?

thetruthseeker1··on Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team
I dont agree with the way the title is worded: as if to indicate that it is wrong in principle to build a stadium for NFL team. I think this is a case of a bad business deal or contract. The NFL clearly had a better contract here. If the deal was worded such that St. Louis Ram's teams were obligated to play there for X years or something else that guarantees cash flow, probably the city wouldn't have had such a loss. It is just poor deal making.
thetruthseeker1··on Why Shitty Products Survive and Thrive
It reminds me of the GoT dialogue " Chaos is a ladder, my friend" : What I mean is the products that are 'shitty' and are thriving is because probably each one of them were created to solve a problem where absolutely nothing like that product existed before and the original product founders were sharp enough to notice a market and business opportunity. This shitty product was so good when it came out, it changed the way ppl did business and led to its mass adoption with little marketing. The other better products that came later on, however usable they are, are probably providing marginal ( as per the product users) value over the previous product hence lower adoption rate and requires huge marketing $. That is why if you notice a new market/business opportunity it is most lucrative path.
thetruthseeker1··on People can read their manager's mind
Yeah, I have seen this. I think the reason being, evaluation is not objective or quantitative. I think it needs to be. If people game the system, then you have to tweak redefine those criteria over iterations to get it right.
thetruthseeker1··on Facebook is misleading Indians with its full-page ads about Free Basics
I agree with jholman and Sreemani here. I dont see the pharma analogy, because rest of the 20% of the internet users are not forced to pay for something (Even though there may or may not be questions about anti-competitiveness, but that is not what we are arguing here...its net neutrality). If they dont like Reliance agreement with FB, they can switch carriers.

In the US an analogy that I can think of is obamacare, where everybody was forced to pay a certain amount of money as TAX so that the whole country is insured.... I dont see the same argument here.

thetruthseeker1··on Facebook is misleading Indians with its full-page ads about Free Basics
I think your argument makes no sense. I am all for helping people etc, but just because Facebook is rich by your definition, the poor people are not entitled to its money. FB will do what is needed to promote its self interest and in that process some (supposedly poor) people get some amount of free internet, its not such an evil thing, though, if it turns to be an evil thing in the long run, it could be regulated in the future. I see arguments about net neutraility though, but I dont understand/see the solution, if FB cancels this, there is no free wikipedia to the masses (which is horrible).
thetruthseeker1··on John McCain wants to outlaw encryption that the US government can't crack
I am not sure how this can be implemented effectively in a globalized world! Lets say we take John McCain's advice and corporations give america a back door to read encrypted data, what would other countries do? Would they make laws forcing corporations to give back-doors on the encrypted data as well? Eventually, one of these countries could sell that information to unscrupulous hackers?

Also, such a mechanism will only catch unwitting gmail like app using terrorists (assuming google co-operates with USA). I would guess vast majority of terrorists will still encrypt the data themselves without relying on underlying app to do so?

thetruthseeker1··on Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org
I kind of agree with Zaidf, in countries like India it might not come as quickly as you think. But I think FB and Indian Govt should be given a chance to iterate over this plan, see what works and what doesn't and then regulate again. Iterate and regulate...
thetruthseeker1··on Opposition to Facebook's new internet.org
The article gives one point of view. The argument seem to imply that, this free internet is worse than no internet at all. I am not sure I buy into that yet. What I do think will be great is if the Govt of India and internet.org can quickly iterate over this plan, see what is working and what is not working and come up with regulations.

Mr. Mahesh made a comment about something that Comcast wanted to do was outlawed - which is essentially regulations. I think if India can quickly iterate and regulate with this new internet.org, that might be the solution to the problem.

thetruthseeker1··on Large Companies Game H-1B Visa Program
Lets assume that your plan works first year and there is almost zero gaming the system. Companies like BoA or Wells Fargo, the ones who are clients of TCS/Wipro etc, what do you think they will do to account for the change in landscape (and still keep their profits high), there will be lobbying in foreign countries, and, they may make it easier for BoA or Wells Fargo to setup offices in India and move some less important divisions there if not the most important divsions? Here its hard to predict whether common sense solutions will solve the problem, because you dont know what the Nash equilibrium solution here is or you dont know how other rational actors will adapt to this rule.

So the govt will have to go back and forth to get this right, the energy is better utilized in the big ticket job items that have costed america millions of jobs (not a few 10 thousands like in this one).... see my other comment on this topic.

thetruthseeker1··on Large Companies Game H-1B Visa Program
Lets look at this problem. 20K visas are gamed every year. Lets assume polices in place made them unable to game the system, we might have save as much as 8OK jobs say here in the USA (assuming 3 jobs from India are also moved back to US in addition to the one in US). But people who know economics say that is not a big deal or the source of American economic woes, it is the decimation of manufacturing and millions of jobs having gone to China + Korea + Indonesia + India +...rest of the world. It is globalization.

So why is this not talked about? The reason being: unlike H1B visas they are not easily quantified in terms of number of "human jobs" even though they are a factor of magnitude larger I would reckon. However, they can be measured by trade deficit that America builds up( because the money goes to that country) and you are right about which country America has the highest trade deficit with US (worth millions of jobs in USA).

So H1B visa is really a small fry, but delicious fry and easy catch and an easy problem to describe and easy to vilify.

Also, if the H1B visas were completely eliminated, its not like those jobs may stay in the US forever, companies may find alternate strategies to get less " important " work done by foreigners.

thetruthseeker1··on Google CEO Sundar Pichai Brings in Less Egotistical Leadership
I disagree. Was Yahoo search innovative? Google search came later and just did the search in a better way, but people still called Google search innovative!

Yahoo search did make money with banner advertisements, and when that was doing well people called Yahoo search innovative. Innovation is used like a buzz word. Truly anything new, even if it is poorer than the previous product is innovation, it may not sell, but it is innovation!

thetruthseeker1··on Google CEO Sundar Pichai Brings in Less Egotistical Leadership
I want to down vote this comment, looks like I can't. Sometimes success of a product also depends on being in the right place at right time. It is not binary
thetruthseeker1··on Google CEO Sundar Pichai Brings in Less Egotistical Leadership
Being Egotistical shouldn't be conflated with being an Egotistical Asshole. Ego if used in the right way can be a powerful force for the better. America's moonshot was a collective ego of an entire nation that led them to achieve it.

I watched an interview by Charlie Rose of Google's operation guy called Lazlo, I thought it was a great interview. He said having intellectual humility is important (does not mean less ego), which is the curiosity to learn or accept if you were wrong. Ego I am not convinced is such a harmful thing, and lets not say it is harmful just because many software engineers being introverts have a confirmation bias against it.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →