HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thetruthseeker1

208 karma · joined December 3, 2014

submissionscomments
thetruthseeker1··on Google CEO Sundar Pichai Brings in Less Egotistical Leadership
Sure, just to play the devil's advocate here (I support for giving feedback in constructive manner when possible), sometimes giving a feedback in a constructive manner is simply inefficient and some manager may not have time to do it every time they think something isn't perfect.

Hello X, while I think you have done these three features A, B, C well....blah blah, you could do E in a better way by doing 1,2,3. This superfluity can add up, making some people get straight to the point.

thetruthseeker1··on The Most Important Thing: Decline in poverty, illiteracy and disease
Again, the positive side of this is, 50 years back the resources of China and India could only support may be 1/5th of their current population. However with green revolution, white revolution, cheaper energy sources living has been sustainable. I will agree that US is not relatively as rich compared to other nations as it was once before, but that is not the point Kristof is making, he is talking about how most people in the world are making the cut to reach a basic std of living (which I think is more important than some rich countries slightly backsliding?).
thetruthseeker1··on The Benefits of a Quiet Ego
Interesting. I want to make a point that questions the premise of the article. What is wrong if people dont have a quiet ego? What is wrong with the fact that humility is mentioned 43% less. Why is that automatically bad( I am not saying it is good either)? Values of a society change over period of time, many things that were acceptable behavior in the 1900s are not acceptable anymore. In the early 1900s black people were disenfranchised, there were no laws to protect same sex partners. I am sure many of you will agree that you dont miss those laws.

Again why do we want to demonize or characterize not having a quiet ego as less superior to having a quiet ego. I do think that if the non-quiet ego is bombastic and misleads people by stating not true statements, that can be a problem.

thetruthseeker1··on Google Is 2B Lines of Code, All in One Place
Can you solve all the problems in ext4 that NTFS claims to solve? No you cant. I am not saying either of the systems is perfect nor either of them is horrible. They are perfect for the use cases they are designed for. If somebody had a file system structure that was unusual(say lots of small files) to NTFS, I think it was his mistake in treating it as a black box.
thetruthseeker1··on Why Is Europe Failing to Create More $1B Startups?
India has 7, 1 less than Europe, that is very interesting from many accounts. GDP of Europe ~20 Trillion $. GDP of India is 2 Trillion $ - I wish there were more studies like this, but not just at the billion $ evaluation, but say 100 million $ evaluation, I think reaching the mark of 1 B$ also requires significant amount of luck(in addition to great execution), a smaller number like 100 M$ may be a more consistent measure
thetruthseeker1··on Computer Sciences Courses That Don't Exist, but Should
I am a software engineer, I have a grad school degree in CS with many years of experience in the industry. One thing I often noticed was many people break some key computer science concepts while on the goal to achieve some minor usability improvements or some other minor goal such as code reuse.

There was one instance where in a multiprocess environment, one of the engineers wrote some library to access a database table and read its contents. In the process he/she maintained a cache of it in memory. Then somebody else decided to use that convenience library/methods in a different process and so on.., essentially cache coherence problems were left unsolved and when I brought this to the attention of people they shrugged it off saying when they see a problem they might handle it - which may be fine, but seemed like some key computer science concepts were overlooked in the goal to achieve software reuse (here reuse of existing accessor/cache code to the database)

I have seen design choices that cause race conditions or non-determinstic behavior, following some patterns or cargo cult programming because something is an industry trend etc.

thetruthseeker1··on The 21-year-old building India's largest hotel network
I guess there are a host of problems that could be solved in India in a better way since it is still developing.
thetruthseeker1··on The Internet of Way Too Many Things
I want to bring an alternate viewpoint into the discussion. For some a product like Leeo may sound superfluous and may not seem to justify the added value it provides for the rise in cost(99$+). (Note there is some added value however trivial it may be). For others they may say no to a product like https://nest.com/ or this https://on.google.com/hub/ based on their financial flexibility and their lifestyle (which you may see as 'obviously' needed).

I do think in this case, the best judge is the free market. If any product maker provides added value at a price point where there will be enough buyers and they see profit, their business will run successfully, else it will fail like any other business. How can my opinion decide what is a good product, it is the market that should decide it!

There are lot of independent products that solve mostly one problem - cars for eg:

Every product design does not have to solve multiple problems, it is just that the users need to feel that it justifies its cost based on the value it provides.

thetruthseeker1··on St. Petersburg paradox
Also, there is another point I want to make, lot of readers assume that they can only play it once. I dont think that is a constraint at all. If that is a constraint, problem is simplified. If you were to play only once you have less than 1/(amount) chance of seeing your investment or more.

If you invested 1024$ (10 successive head rolls), you have less than 1/1024 chance of seeing it back.

Of course, you start from 2$ and not 0$ (I have simplified a few things to drive the point).

thetruthseeker1··on St. Petersburg paradox
If you were paying 50$ to play this game, you would have to play around 2^50 (each time paying 50$) times to even break even! I think the article is a good illustration of how expected value can't be really used as the only parameter.
thetruthseeker1··on WordSafety – Check a name for unwanted meanings in foreign languages
It will be great if the program checks for phonetically similar words as well, currently, looks like it doesn't. Bhat (India), pronounced like 'butt' is not flagged.
thetruthseeker1··on How to get gmail.com banned (2011)
I love mailinator!

However tricking site scrappers may not work perfectly if the site scrappers maintained a list of websites in their "whitelist". Say if I am scrapping mailinator.com for domain names, if I see gmail.com or yahoo.com, I might just not put them in my database because they are in my whitelist.

thetruthseeker1··on Web Design: The First 100 Years (2014)
One common counter argument that people make is that users are lazy when you say they don't want to learn something new(lets ignore the physically challenged for now). But that argument is so fallacious I think.

What users actually mean is- for the delta value this new feature provides, it is not worth their time to learn to do this the new way. Everybody has to make judicious choice on where they choose to spend their time. And in that vein I dont think the users are being lazy in saying that it is not really efficient if they have to spend significant amount of time learning something new in what they perceive to be of little added value.

EDIT: BTW I do think that people are happy to relearn something if they perceive it to provide a "significant" added value. Hypothetically speaking if I had to relearn driving and this "new way of driving" took me from NY to DC in an HR for the same cost, I would try to learn that in a heartbeat. But I dont want to learn a new way of driving if it reduces my drive time by only 15 min.

I also think software/CS needs a school of thought that discourages significant change/variation in UX design. But unfortunately most people are incentivsed for change.

thetruthseeker1··on Hackers Remotely Attack a Jeep on the Highway
Research can be done to drive a point without making that into a drama. you can demonstrate the science without the hollywood so to speak. I think what was done here could have been demonstrated without the risk that was taken. I think the risk that was taken was poor judgement.
thetruthseeker1··on Potato paradox
A better or more shocking way to understand how the numbers interplay is, to reframe this like this. Imagine a vegetable mystical-vegetable, that had 99.9% water and weighed 100 lbs. If I dehydrated it such that it now has 99% water, what would be its weight? Yes, its 10 lbs.
thetruthseeker1··on How Much Does an Experienced Programmer Use Google?
I can't agree with this article more. It's like the author read my mind. I have programmed in perl, C, C++ in linux, VC++ & COM, python, JAVA, JS, VB, assembly language, Prolog, Lex, Yacc. I am sure I missed a few in this list. I think of problems in abstractions and when I think of syntax/semantics its almost a vague haze a mix of libraries of various languages. Dont get me wrong, once I start programming in a particular language, I am in the "zone" so to speak. But I think I need Google too often.
thetruthseeker1··on Who Do You Trust?
Indian women sell hair to Chinese, who productizie it and sell to Koreans, who further refine it and eventually sell it African American women == worst experience? I think this sentence is soaked in prejudice.

Most global supply chains, some for super luxurious products have these three countries involved... I dont know how that automagically qualifies for a horrible experience

thetruthseeker1··on Blow to Internet.org as Indian Internet Companies Begin to Withdraw
This is not a black and white scenario as you have characterized or how Mark Z has characterized.

As more and more people come out of poverty, they will be able to access basic services such as water, electricity and data plans. There is no reason why data plans is the only service among the three services that needs to be free. If it is free, it is the government that should provide it rather than private corporations whose single interest is profit.

Now, people who are super poor may not be able to pay for electricity let alone will access free internet.

Either way, FB and bunch of other companies want to profit out of the people who are uninformed and these people may end up buying only services and products from those limited free websites that they get from free internet.

It also looks like the telecom services might take advantage of this and partner with some companies provide selective access to some websites and the biggest losers of this kind of partnership could be companies that dont have enough capital to pay each of the telecom providers to be in their "basic package"

thetruthseeker1··on The Best Entrepreneur I Know
No, I wouldn't consider that alone a great enterprise. It should be determined based on some objective and measurable criteria. Everybody who develops an app is not a great entrepreneur, and everybody who is nice alone is not a great entrepreneur
thetruthseeker1··on The Best Entrepreneur I Know
I read the Article. Dennis seems like a nice guy- rather a great guy! But I do think that this article does not particularly embody a spirit of entrepreneurship. Dont get me wrong, Dennis does not embody any negaative spirit, everything positive. It is fitting for MLK day. However, just because it makes us feel warm and fuzzy, it shouldn't be characterized to embody any particular quality that we choose to say it does. It embodies great human spirit, but, rationally thinking, is not fitting example of entrepreneur.
thetruthseeker1··on Immigration is about talent, not costs
Is that not true when Pepsi goes to India and sells its product there. The profit is distributed only to share holders of Pepsi, and the Indian beverage companies stand to lose. If Pepsi had not been so "greedy", Indian beverage companies would make some money and probably cause a more better distribution of wealth?

Is Amazon guilty of using drones/machines for its 70 Billion$ business where as Target employs 5 times as many people for an equivalent revenue?

← PreviousPage 4 of 4