HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thinkingemote

10,531 karma · joined May 21, 2017

submissionscomments
thinkingemote··on Douglas Adams and the exterminated Doctor Who adventure
Adams is a good example of a story with a message. A message with a story is more like today's TV sci-fi.

The way the message is being told has changed because the message is incredibly important.

thinkingemote··on Douglas Adams and the exterminated Doctor Who adventure
One thing with some modern sci-fi shows is that it's more of a message with a disguise of a story rather than a story with a disguised message.

The writers justify the change by saying (correctly) that the message is important and that right now is the most important time to say the message. The message became more important than the vehicle that it travelled in so poor story writing is acceptable.

It's like Christian rock music, it's okay and if you are Christian you might enjoy it both for the message and the music but if you just want good music you are likely not going to enjoy it as much as regular "secular" rock.

But there's also rock music that everyone can enjoys which contains (not sure the word to describe it) non obvious but religious-adjacent themes.

thinkingemote··on This Code Is CRAP (2011)
(2011)
thinkingemote··on Show HN: Bodily Oddities
It's very common for people to get the pressure on eye thing by the way there's a wiki page somewhere.
thinkingemote··on The revolt of the reader
You can adapt the output if you care to do so. Almost all do not care to do so.

They just don't care to put the slightest attempt because they have a blindness to the problem. They are not doing it to intentionally mislead people.

thinkingemote··on UK residents warned to stock up on food due to El Niño
"UK residents urged to stop panic buying food and toilet roll": bbc.co.uk 05-09-26
thinkingemote··on The shrinking landscape of linguistic diversity in the age of LLMs
I like watching and listening to YouTube videos. Recently my ears have switched into a mode where I'm evaluating if the human speaker is reading LLM copy as they would normally read from a script / teleprompter anyhow.

Often they are not but sometimes I detect that they are and it's very sad to see.

thinkingemote··on Meet the People Taking over Hacker News (2014)
Discussion at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7493856
thinkingemote··on I Became the Scapegoat in the Jason Arday Affair
Similar to when GitHub removed their meritocracy rug - it's fundamentally about a view of the world and less about the action. Most universities have signed up to a charter [1] that says that "racism is an everyday facet" of life and needs to be fought against by concrete actions. These universities get official ratings from bronze, silver or gold based on how they do. This current issue is less about the facts and more about a view of the world that's being challenged. People on one side are viewing the world and explaining things through one lens and others are viewing it through another. One problem in this discourse is that on one side they don't know how and why academic institutions operate and the other side sees criticism as justification for and reinforcement of their world view.

The basis for conflict resolution is to encourage people to see their opponents as human similar to themselves and to put themselves in the others shoes to acknowledge common grounds for agreement. It's possible an official inquiry by those experienced in conflict resolution may help this.

[1] https://advance-he.ac.uk/membership/equality-charters/race-e...

thinkingemote··on Berd
I actually like the design. It's the product of a human and it's fun. It also feels like it's playing with jokes about brain-rot aesthetic so communicates a contemporary and young point of view. It's cool.

The thing it's selling doesn't appeal to me in the slightest but they have tried and have some human ideas in the webdesign. Cool design if cringe product

thinkingemote··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
I think we will see a hidden motivation behind this as ultimately so the output can have an author, the author can be attributed and finally the output will be copyrighted and so the LLM has more value.

Everyone who invests in AI companies wants to see the value of their investment increase.

I'd give it about 3-5 years until an AI company claims copyright over code their LLM produces. This is a crucial step in that path.

thinkingemote··on Guiding Ships with Moire Patterns (2018)
When I first joined the university I went to a guided tour of the library. The librarian said that this was the most important tour of my entire stay. She said that the key for finding knowledge was not about the answers but the questions.

It's about finding the questions to ask. About learning to learn. The tour guided us through actually using the library and how to learn the library which is a way to find the questions first and then find the answers afterwards. The librarian then outlined their role in helping the student in how to learn, and how to use the various facilities too.

Learning the question is something that is most fundamental to learning but is kind of overlooked.

A good knowledge system should probe initial enquiries to identify what the users actual desires, gaps and questions are. No one wants a sycophantic doctor, they want one that can ask probing detailed questions to learn whats really going on.

thinkingemote··on Stowaway – Take the window seat on any plane or satellite overhead
Not working for me on firefox on linux.

Console shows

THREE.WebGLRenderer: Context Lost. index-DMul8aia.js:3819:24355 Object { error: undefined } Stowaway failed to start

It also made firefox actually hard crash to desktop!

thinkingemote··on Illinois just told every operating system to start reporting your kid's age
Age verification is human verification at the time when the internet is getting very smart and dangerous bots. At least that's my optimistic view of this kind of paradigm shift!
thinkingemote··on Wikipedia article "Ship of Theseus" has changed entirely since its inception
The talk page has an interesting section about this, subtitled "Article of Theseus" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Ship_of_Theseus#h-Article...
thinkingemote··on Show HN: ssh ssh.place
> what in the training process causes

Read some early pre-mass-adoption LLM papers by the key scientists and researchers. The style is very similar...

thinkingemote··on 1,741 "informed" consents with one click? GDPR complaint filed
A surprising number of sites that have consents do not actually do anything apart from set a flag.

They are not actually connected to disabling analytics, just connected to the banner itself.

It seems like no data privacy activists or automated scans actually look at whether the consents really work or not, just whether they have them!

thinkingemote··on Document-borne AI worms can self-propagate through Copilot for Word
It can be anything no matter how unsubtle or bizarre. Students are not going to scan the output to check if its correct because they 1) cannot evaluate correctness and 2) are lazy in checking as evidenced by them pasting the prompt without checking it in the first place.
thinkingemote··on An Uncomplicated Man – A review of The Odyssey, directed by Christopher Nolan
"The Odyssey is The Hero's Journey without a hero" - a quote about this adaptation referencing Campbell's The Hero with a Thousand Faces.

I'm wondering if today films (the main form of story telling) also do not quite follow the apparently universal and archetypical story structure outlined by Campbell. Maybe these story structures are not actually universal across all cultures or maybe it's a sign of the culture that tells the stories. Wrt this movie, I think it does kind of fit in with a few of the structures but I've not seen any deeper analysis.

thinkingemote··on Codeberg Bans Cryptocurrency Projects
Indeed we see legislation (from all sides of politics and nations) saying there is no distinction, that all services and websites are now publishers.

It was ever thus except when we remember.

thinkingemote··on Codeberg Bans Cryptocurrency Projects
A side effect of platform vs publisher.

They are voluntarily choosing to be a publisher. Publishers are responsible for the actions that the users do on their platform.

States are happier with and want more publishers as it's easier to censor, add surveillance and control them than neutral platforms.

The few past times when Cloudfare censored politically was interesting as they quickly made apologies because they want to be seen more as a neutral platform than a service that nation states can control.

It's why modern internet legislation across all parties and across all nations is geared towards changing platforms into publishers.

And it's why the services that we would have seen to be independent and neutral in the past are choosing this new paradigm.

thinkingemote··on The Voice of Google
There was no mention of this on hacker news (at least I cant find anything via the search at the bottom) but the story of Thomas Kurian's office break in / sit in was in 2024 so not that long ago: https://www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/ryldympec

"Google employees arrested following protest over Israel ties at executive’s office. The employees were arrested during a sit-in at the office of Google Cloud CEO Thomas Kurian in California, during a day of company-wide protests by Google employees at offices across the US in protest of Google’s Project Nimbus deal with Israel"

thinkingemote··on Sealed tomb filled with paintings and inscriptions discovered in Egypt
Nothing remains here - only walls.

Most of these tombs have already, since ancient times, been looted and desecrated and most things inside including any human remains have long since been removed. It looks like this tomb is also in this category as all that remains of note are on the walls which cannot be easily removed.

I seem to recall a story that even at the time when they were building pyramids in ancient Egypt that they had a problem with looters of the older tombs.

Additionally: The use of the word "Sealed" in the title is not present in the text and I propose is click bait for attention and an emotional reaction. Looks like that strategy still works.

thinkingemote··on Scalable Detection of Adversarial Synthetic Slop and Coordinated Media Abuse
"Synthetic Slop" is a new term for me, I quite like it, more accurate than "AI Slop"

Allegedly these techniques are being used by Google on YouTube to delete slop videos.

thinkingemote··on Young adults are poor despite every metric which suggests otherwise
You might want to qualify this with start to buy a house and get a mortgage and then pay off when older than 20s-30s.

I think some people in the comments are thinking you are saying they could outright buy a house straight out of school! (Which in a way might be a symptom explained in the article!

thinkingemote··on Ask HN: Add flag for AI-generated articles
Most articles that people want on HN are about LLMs and most of those are written by LLMs. The submissions are always horrible to read and usually have no gems to inspire, so if relevant I will at most skim it but the comments on HN about the submission is where the real jewels are likely to be.

If you can easily detect the pattern of LLM writing here's something for you to look at: I was reading some pre-consumer-LLM papers by AI researchers and founders and the way these are written are incredibly similar to existing LLM prose!

thinkingemote··on I think I have LLM burnout
We employees need to remember that most software projects fail. So the work we produce should have lower value than we give it.

We also need to be motivated to stay in our jobs.

Most developers like their projects and value their work. But the chances are that it's for nothing.

Many developers know they work on bad products (gambling industry, military, surveillance, whatever) and so it's here that they focus on their technologies, tools and frameworks rather than the work they produce.

"Agentic engineering" for example.

Id be curious to see what and how Googlers are doing with their 20% time.

thinkingemote··on Organic Maps
CoMaps is a fork/spin-off of Organic Maps, which in turn is a fork of Maps.ME
thinkingemote··on An entire Herculaneum scroll has been read for the first time
Although advocating to have less empathy generally isnt considered good there are ancient and modern schools of thought that explicitly says that empathy can be bad.

To understand the enemy is to some extent to start to love the enemy and that's bad because the enemy is bad. The idea is that you can only have empathy for certain people.

Worth also pointing out that there's also a more modern but uncommon idea that empathy towards someone or a group may weaken and shutter their own "truth" or identity stories but this is for the moment only heard in radical academia not on the street.

Generally there's also a large amount of people who don't know what "empathy" means with the ever present confusion of it with "sympathy", endorsement and alignment.

thinkingemote··on Why Switzerland has 25 gbit internet and America doesn't
Agreed. It's telling that the ads for speed upgrades all seem to focus on families: when all are uploading and streaming maybe at the same time. The marketeers know that 1 individuals and couples are not the target market and 2 they want everyone to be using as much as possible.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →