HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thisrod

1,056 karma · joined February 27, 2009

submissionscomments
thisrod··on Earthquake in Melbourne, Australia (9.15 AM 22nd Sep 21, AEST)
Australia is really stable. The edges of the Australian plate are in New Zealand and Java, which aren't. But tectonic plates are big, and we're in the middle.
thisrod··on The Matrix was a metaphor for transgender identity, director confirms (2020)
If it's true that transgender people didn't think about this until the directors came out, the metaphor can't have been a very good one. That's likely more the fault of the studio than the directors.

A point of comparison is Harry Potter. Rowling is still coy about it—as you would be, given the money at stake. But every gay or lesbian reader, and lots of straight ones beside, immediately see what inspired lycanthropy. Not to mention the adolescent protagonist who moves out of his suburban closet to discover a hidden world at the back of a strange pub, where power comes from the point of a spark-shooting wand, and his latent talent for riding broomsticks makes him the most popular boy in his boarding school.

With Rowling's sense for wordplay, she must have been aware of that interpretation, even if it wasn't entirely deliberate. But it isn't just words: the whole structure of magical Britain, and the muggle world's surprising failure to notice things that are sitting in plain sight, are strikingly familiar to gay and lesbian readers who were around when the books were written.

thisrod··on Tortured phrases: A dubious writing style emerging in science
Authorship is the metric that scientists get paid for, so of course it has been thoroughly corrupted.

Fake papers and plagiarism are the most blatant form of corruption. They tend to come from certain, let's say, large countries with less developed scientific cultures. Those countries need to put an end to it, because the rest of us keep having to work harder to suppress the racist impressions that we're bound to form of colleagues who look and sound like the cheats.

In more traditional scientific countries, the corruption is more subtle. Today, many groups publish every paper with half a dozen authors, and no indication of what each of them contributed. This enables the professors who run those groups to manipulate authorship more or less as they please, and have total control over who gets to have a career in science. It turns out that absolute power corrupts senior scientists as absolutely as it does other people.

No doubt there are more clever ways to game the system, that I haven't noticed. As long as million dollar grants and first-world citizenship keep being doled out for something as contrived as scientific paper authorship, corruption is inevitable.

thisrod··on Tortured phrases: A dubious writing style emerging in science
> Is there any way the authors could have kept your definition, and somehow credited you, even anonymously?

It's not uncommon for the acknowledgements section of a paper to thank an anonymous reviewer for, e.g., suggesting the authors further investigate a detail that turned out to be important. But in this case, where the authors couldn't write their own explanation of a technical term, maybe it's a bit premature for them to be writing technical papers.

thisrod··on How Bell’s Theorem proved ‘spooky action at a distance’ is real
> You really need to read the link above

I don't like claims to authority, but maybe you should read the papers I've published about Bell inequalities too? :-p

It sounds like you're saying that, in principle, physical processes are all reversible. (Although that is often thermodynamically impossible in practice.) You're also saying that it's impossible in principle for someone to learn the result of a measurement in the morning, then unlearn it when the measurement is reversed during the afternoon. I don't see how there could be a self-consistent interpretation of quantum measurement where both those things are true.

thisrod··on How Bell’s Theorem proved ‘spooky action at a distance’ is real
I agree with this. But it's worth pointing out that lots of good physicists don't. It's a statement of the Everett/relative state/many worlds interpretation, which is simply too weird for many people to accept. That's why there are about a dozen other interpretations of quantum measurement theory, which are all weird in other ways that I can't accept.

The weird part is precisely this: "you can get back to a state where you can no longer tell what the outcome of the 'measurement' was." In other words, at lunchtime you believed that a horizontally polarised photon hit your nose at 10am in morning, and you were right. Now it's dinner time, you don't believe that, and you would be wrong if you did. If the Everett interpretation doesn't pose a massive challenge to your ideas about reality and human identity, you haven't understood it. There are physics professors who picture photons choosing which way to go at a beam splitter, then transmitting the news backwards in time, because that seems more plausible to them.

Of course, interpretations are not science. Everyone agrees how an experiment would go: any attempt to reverse the interaction of the photon with your nose and brain would fail, because thermodynamics. From a purely scientific viewpoint, it simply doesn't matter how many other yous are superposed in parallel universes, because their existence or lack of it has no consequences that (any of?) you can observe. But scientists are as fascinated by this as everyone else is.

thisrod··on A Burner Identity Protects Your Inbox, Phone, and Credit Cards
I use Abine Blur for this, and I think it's a great idea. I have two concerns, though.

First, I have to place a lot of trust in Abine. They get to see everything! It would be nice if the EFF or FSF audited these services.

Also, it would be nice if each part of the privacy respecting web supported the other parts. Blur supports Google and Apple browsers on smart phones, but doesn't (officially) support Firefox.

thisrod··on Nanofiber membrane makes seawater drinkable in minutes
> Then there is a 100m column and a 95m column forcing the water through the membrane

In that scenario, why do you think it helps to put the membrane 100m deep, instead of 5m deep?

thisrod··on Nanofiber membrane makes seawater drinkable in minutes
> the oceans own water pressure, pushes water through the membrane and up into the tank on the beach

Unfortunately, that's not how pressure works. There's a 100m column of water above the salt side of the membrane, but there's also a 100m column of water in the pipe on the fresh side. Those columns generate an enormous pressure, but it's pushing from both sides, which doesn't help you get water through the membrane.

thisrod··on Nanofiber membrane makes seawater drinkable in minutes
Every desalination process uses a lot of energy, too! However fancy a membrane they're using, they need to force the salt water through it, and push hard enough to beat the osmotic pressure.

This is a reversible process, as you can get the energy back by using the osmotic pressure to drive a piston. A desalination process that used a lot less energy would let you build a perpetual motion machine, and is seriously against the laws of physics.

thisrod··on Neal Stephenson – Announcing Termination Shock
Going by the title, I think I can guess the proposed solution to global warming. Anyone else thinking along those lines?
thisrod··on Encrypted Chat An0m was a FBI honeypot Used to take down global criminal network
For the past few years, Australian police have been loudly whinging to journalists about their inability to tap encrypted messaging apps, and demanding parliament give them all kinds of Orwellian powers to force developers to add back doors. This puts a whole new light on that! Let's hope it was reverse psychology directed at the crooks, and they'll stop it from now on.
thisrod··on America has a drinking problem
> Distilled alcohol is recent—it became widespread in China in the 13th century

Go Ghengis!

That's quite interesting. Lots of Mongol rulers drank themselves to death. The timing had world historic consequences: they tended to cark it just after they nuked the entire muslim world from horseback, and just before they moved on to Europe. Maybe the invention of distilled spirits was the key to European domination.

thisrod··on Finite Difference Computing with PDEs: A Modern Software Approach [pdf]
There must be lots of textbooks that approach finite difference formulae from an applied perspective. This one is free of charge, but is there anything else remarkable about it?

The cost of a second-hand mathematics textbook is immaterial compared to the cost of the time I spend learning its contents. A text that lets me learn the same material in half the time is worth a lot: within reason, cost is no object for serious physics and maths books.

thisrod··on India’s second wave
> Using "official" numbers alone

Those are corroborated by sentinel cases in Australia. The rate has risen to the point where quarantine is struggling to cope, and the doctors' union has suggested a complete ban on flights from India.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-04-21/nt-covid-active-cases...

thisrod··on Book review on the history of modern Singapore
This is indeed a problem, but there is a very simple and effective solution that Australians call "youth wages".
thisrod··on Bertrand Russell Is the Pope (2010)
In the version I heard, Russel says: "I am one, the pope is one, therefore the pope and I are one." I doubt he ever said that, but it sounds like him.
thisrod··on Academic “ghost-writing”: the cheating scandal no one will discuss (2020)
That says more about the ruling class from which presidents are selected than it says about universities. No doubt the management of AT&T said similar things about Bell Labs, even after they invented the transistor.
thisrod··on GitHub, fuck your name change
Here's Australia taking the piss out of woke:

https://iview.abc.net.au/show/why-are-you-like-this

I don't know if iView works overseas, but I think the show is on Netflix too.

thisrod··on Cracks emerged in digital contact tracing system days before five-day lockdown
To put it in context: the lockdown cost a billion dollars, and Australia and New Zealand are going through this about once a fortnight. Could NASA please send out the space shuttle software team, and build us a reliable public health information system?
thisrod··on Git's list of banned C functions
I teach first-years in Australia, where boys from private schools call me "sir". When I'm feeling mean, I tell them to drop and give me ten pushups.
thisrod··on A Dishonest, Indifferent, and Toxic Culture
Doesn't a 15 year ban on publishing in ACM journals speak for itself, in any language?
thisrod··on Changes to sharing and viewing news on Facebook in Australia
I think both sides are in the wrong here. One of them is Mark Zuckerberg and the other is the Morrison government, for a start. But not only because of that.

The Murdoch family's claim ... I mean, Australia's ... is ridiculous. Facebook are totally within their rights to stop using Australian content and not pay for it. If the law is so sloppily worded that it arguably defines the Health Department website as news, well, it wasn't Facebook who drafted it.

On the other hand, this does stuff around a lot of innocent bystanders, and Facebook could easily have given a month's notice that they were going to do it. Which is, ironically, one of the things that the law would require them to do. What ever else Facebook might have demonstrated by their irresponsible reaction, they have shown that this law isn't all wrong, rather some parts of it are urgently necessary.

thisrod··on The imminent stable-version apocalypse
> 128 bits ought to be enough for any IP address, right?

Here's something I find really amusing. In the late 90s, when IPv6 was being introduced, the joke was that 128 bits would suffice until we all had massively parallel wrist watches. Which would never happen, certainly not in our lifetimes.

The iPhone was released in 2007.

thisrod··on What I Learned in Avalanche School (2019)
> such courses might be more successful at extending students’ mobility in avalanche terrain

That's the point.

It's very easy to travel through the snow without exposing yourself to any avalanche risk: just stay away from snow that's steep enough to avalanche. If you're going "hiking on skis", that's all you need to know.

It's not quite so easy if you want to go climbing, but it isn't that hard. If an avalanche sweeps you off the mountain, your immediate problem is falling off a mountain. Being caught in an avalanche is a comparatively minor issue. So you're going to be conservative: if any kind of subtle analysis is called for, you stay in the hut, and wait until the snow is obviously stable. In climbing season, that will happen soon enough.

What's tricky is going skiing. In winter, either you're willing to take some calculated risks with avalanches, or you'll be limited to pretty boring skiing. People don't do avalanche courses to be safe (you can do that without a course). They do them to take more risks, skiing in less obviously safe conditions, and get away with it. Which is all good, provided that you're honest about what you're doing.

Maybe a good comparison is a pilot getting an instrument rating. The safest option will always be to stay on the ground in bad weather. The reason they'd get the rating is to travel reliably, but less safely, by flying through bad weather when the rewards justify the risks.

thisrod··on Meshtastic: Open-source, off-grid, hiking, climbing, GPS mesh communicator
> I’ve been told that many have been abused and are not treated as urgent any more

There is an old type of PLB and a new type. That was a problem for the old type, in principle. In practice, the search coordination centres got pretty good at triage. Going down Route 66 at 70 mph, unlikely to be a real emergency; halfway up Mt McKinley, scramble the chopper. Accidental activations are far more common than abusive ones.

The new type broadcasts its serial number, and everyone is required to register an emergency contact person when they buy their PLB. If the beacon is activated, the contact person gets a call from search and rescue, asking what the beacon user is up to.

thisrod··on I tried to report scientific misconduct. How did it go?
Since I read Seeing Like a State, I've started to think "charlatan" whenever I hear the word "science". As in "scientific forestry", "climate science" (scientists who study Earth's climate call themselves meteorologists), "scientific racism". Is "computer science" an exception? I'm not game to speculate.

Which actual scientists describe themselves that way? We're physicists, geologists, botanists, psychologists or whatever. When someone says they're a scientist, it suggests that they're not part of any actual scientific discipline, but making a false appeal to authority.

thisrod··on FDA approves first monthly injectable to treat HIV infection
I was about to reply: because no one ever recovers from HIV infection. Then I realised it isn't true. People being treated for HIV are not contagious, so they "recover" in the epidemiological sense the moment they start treatment. The only way that can happen is if a lot of people have HIV but don't know it.
thisrod··on Heatwaves may mean Sydney is too hot for people to live in 'within decades'
Quick question (and don't look it up). One government spends 35% of GDP, another spends 37%. Which is Australia, and which the USA? That's a normal year: COVID stimulus sent both off the charts, of course.

The difference is that Australians are, for the most part, paying the bills as they come due.

thisrod··on A Nepali team has made the first winter ascent of K2
> There’s been a repeated surge after wars wrap up

What are you referring to? The Second World War seems like the obvious case. I think there were two things at play there. European climbers returned to the Himalayas, and resumed where they left off in 1939; perhaps the war delayed the ascent of Everest instead of causing it. Also, nylon! Ropes that don't break—and that don't break falling lead climbers—were a huge enabling technology for rock climbing.

← PreviousPage 2 of 19Next →