HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

three_seagrass

1,367 karma · joined February 5, 2020

submissionscomments
three_seagrass··on Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Netflix
Yes. Also true in NYC if you don't want to come to SV.
three_seagrass··on The case for why Google should be regulated as a public utility
Obligatory FYI: DuckDuckGo is pretty much Bing search. If you're trying to support newer competitors in the search engine space, try Qwant or YaCy.
three_seagrass··on The case for why Google should be regulated as a public utility
Despite the EU ruling, Google Shopping is essentially search ads with pictures. And despite being in search results, retail companies have more platforms than ever before to sell through, such as Amazon, Ebay, Instagram/Facebook, and others.
three_seagrass··on The case for why Google should be regulated as a public utility
On-brand keywords are defensive plays, and should not be paid for unless others are targeting them as well.

It's possible that the competition stopped advertising against ebay searches as online shoppers migrated to Amazon.

three_seagrass··on The case for why Google should be regulated as a public utility
HN threads are not 1:1 conversations.

Threads start and branch on different topics, which are varying degrees related to the main post.

Kind of like how you have now switched the discussion to Alan Sokal. That doesn't mean you are making some tactical shift as part of a larger strategy.

three_seagrass··on Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify drivers as employees
There's a difference between believing in start up hype and looking at the evidence on the ground. It's an even larger leap in claiming it's decades away while the technology is in testing right now.
three_seagrass··on Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify drivers as employees
Maybe help me understand how having a phone means you're present in a conversation? There have been class action lawsuits filed by uber and lyft drivers.
three_seagrass··on Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify drivers as employees
How is California enforcing it's laws a repeat of a medallion licensing system?
three_seagrass··on Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify drivers as employees
Apparently not obeying those pesky government laws.
three_seagrass··on Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify drivers as employees
Exploitation isn't limited to quid pro quo or antitrust corruption.

It's easy to sit from a seat of having a salaried ~40 hour week job with health benefits and safety standards, which were fought for from past generations, and then scoff when similar people are trying to fight for the same.

three_seagrass··on Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify drivers as employees
Waymo started publicly testing level 4 cars last year, and reportedly has 600 cars testing level 5. It isn't decades away anymore.
three_seagrass··on Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify drivers as employees
The difference being the employers have buying power for all their employees and can keep costs down, as opposed to individual buyers on the exchanges.

The problem with switching healthcare in America is that any new system that doesn't allow Americans to think, "I've got mine, you can worry about you" is difficult. Whether that's forced exchanges where everyone pays the same or universal healthcare (where everyone pays the same).

three_seagrass··on Uber and Lyft ordered by California judge to classify drivers as employees
You're right. Health insurance was originally fought for by the unions, which was why they are historically provided by employers in the US. Other nations underwent similar demands from their people, but it ended up being tied to government provision, not corporation.

With employee unions being neutered in the past century, and exponential privatized healthcare cost increases, you start to see broad swaths of employees go without insurance in the US, while other countries nationalized their healthcare to keep costs down and continue providing it to their people.

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
In the U.S. at least, grocery stores are not monopolies. Neither is Facebook.

Both have competitors who can supply fungible services to the market, some of which are typically very close, sometimes "just a click away".

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
Because Facebook is not an ISP nor a FedEx. They do not provide a service that ships information.

Now, you can muddy the semantics by saying, "Isn't every website an information shipper?" and even then the answer is still no, that still does not make them a common carrier.

There are what people want Facebook to be, which is some system supporting of their own political views, but the bad faith arguments to project Facebook into being an ISP are not sound.

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
The point of the this example:

>"I'm not saying all black men are criminals, but on average, they go to prison more."

Is that the underlying causation behind this 'fact' is that there is systemic bias against black men from law enforcement and the rest of society.

This is why we have diversity programs.

James Damore's argument is that diversity programs are moot because he says there is no systemic bias against women. Just as if a racist were arguing against diversity programs because they say there is no systemic bias against black men, because really, on average black men "just go to prison more".

Whether or not it's the average or the individual is a red herring. The point is Damore misrepresents data to argue against systemic bias - data which is inherently culpable to the same systemic bias he is arguing against.

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
Considering 'the arguments therin' to be scientific is considering the memo to be scientific, which it's not.

When they're not conservative opinion pieces, they're cherry picked articles, even going to far as to misrepresent the data they support.

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Alt-right

By suing Google for discrimination against white conservative men, Damore fits this fairly well. That, and the alt-right podcasts he went on.

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
Common carrier laws prevent that. The same reason FedEx can't open your box and halt your shipment of UPS swag.

And no, Facebook is a website and app(s), not a common carrier.

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
I appreciate the measured response, thanks.

Nobody is claiming that Damore said it applies to all women, in fact, he hides his argument behind an appeal to averages. He says that no individual women is less capable than men, but on average, women are. The same way that a racist would say, "I'm not saying all black men are criminals, but on average, they go to prison more."

This is what I was referring to about weak-wording earlier. Damore claims that he's pro-diversity, then makes anti-diversity arguments. He gives the tone of a peer reviewed paper, but really it's a word doc with cherry picked citations. He claims that it's not all women, just distributed averages (so the typical woman) on a whole.

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
That's why 'alt right' wasn't being used as a synonym for Neo-Nazis - that's your own straw man to laugh at.
three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
They're referring to James Damore being alt-right.

Kind of like how he soon after sued Google for discrimination for being "white male conservative" (which has not aged well).

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
What's amazing is that people, to this day, take a personal weakly-worded memo as scientific fact.
three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
IIRC there is no case law on this, though if you know of any I'd appreciate sharing it.
three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
No, by that reason they should not be protected classes, as race, sex, sexual orientation, etc should be. Same with religion.

Also, why did you just create a throwaway just to make that comment?

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
Yes, more than once, hence the comment about how it's weakly worded. Did you?
three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
Political ideology is a choice, and as such, not protected by the civil rights act of 1964.

You can wish you were a victim of persecution for your political choice, but it is still your choice, and as such, people can also choose to not employ or serve you for your decision.

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
The Epic Games store and Fortnite is precisely the counterexample to anyone saying there's a single store on Android devices.

Whatever sweetheart deal Epic worked out with Google in the end doesn't discredit that they successfully sold hundreds of thousands of copies outside of the the Google Play store.

This argument also intentionally ignores the existence of the Amazon app store on Android.

three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
Sounds like the James Damore event for Facebook.
three_seagrass··on Facebook Fired Employee Who Collected Evidence of Potential Political Bias
First, only Apple devices have the issue of limited store access, which is a tangential antitrust problem unto itself.

Second, despite the claims of the president, the white house does not have the power to block TikTok or Bytedance from the public. The president can only block armed forces from installing apps on their owned devices.

← PreviousPage 9 of 22Next →