HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

throwawayhhakdl

121 karma · joined October 28, 2019

submissionscomments
throwawayhhakdl··on Heart doctors 'held back stent death data'
I’m not a medical expert but your hand waving of stents feels off to me. Yes, it’s not surprising that stents can be dangerous, but the alternative is open heart surgery. Which sounds pretty damn risky too.

Is the choice really that simple?

throwawayhhakdl··on Indian police open case against hundreds in Kashmir for using VPN
https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/an-important-distinction

Patriotism is love for one’s country. Nationalism is the belief that one’s country (and often ethnic subset) is supreme (and more deserving of prosperity), speaking generally.

throwawayhhakdl··on Facebook asks for a moat of regulations it already meets
Time spent isn’t the same as addiction though. The grossness of Facebook is not that people spend too much time on it (though they may), but what content they see, how they are encouraged to engage with it, and the effect it has on people’s world views and psychological health.

The addiction component would be the constant concern with either how you are perceived on the platform or outrage with what others are saying.

I see precisely nothing they’ve done to increase the well being of people who are constantly tilted by the dumbest political garbage.

throwawayhhakdl··on SpaceX launches more Starlink satellites, misses booster landing
So all you need to do is change the policy determining billions of dollars of infrastructure and profits with powerful entrenched interests? Where do I sign up?
throwawayhhakdl··on Jeff Bezos Commits $10B to Address Climate Change
Project Vesta claims it would need $250B / year to sequester all the carbon we emit... https://projectvesta.org/
throwawayhhakdl··on Screens Are Bad for Young Brains
I don’t have any kids, but I can’t figure out what people are actually complaining about here. Most comments seem to be referring to breast feeding in the hospital in the few days post birth. Is it just hospital culture we’re upset with? My understanding was that breast milk is generally pretty important to do as it helps transmit antibodies and the like. But, having some formula is fine too.

I see older cases about nestle misleading women in developing markets to suggest formula was better, which led to deaths. However this seems to be due to nutritional deficiencies which I, perhaps naively, would assume they have figured out by now.

throwawayhhakdl··on Texas medical masks manufacturer is caught in coronavirus’s supply chain panic
The important bit is that they’re not “practically” effective.

You need to wear them properly. You need to change them regularly. You need to practice effective hygiene like not touching your face.

If the government distributed masks that could be effective to everyone, it’s unlikely they would have a noticeable effect

throwawayhhakdl··on Astronomers want public funds for intelligent life search
> High risk with the highest reward

I don’t understand people who think this way. Let’s imagine there is definitely an alien and we find it. Assume it follows a similar tech trajectory as humans.

If we find it in the millions of years of pre-civilization we got nothing. Probably don’t even notice it. If we get it the thousands of years before communication tech, we also get squat. If we get it in the couple hundred years between comm tech and the present, we maybe can do something? If we go beyond the present either they have killed themselves, or they’re inconceivably more advanced than us and the idea that we found them before they found us is kind of laughable. The probability that we’re the first civilization to have “found” them is laughable.

By all means, space and communication tech is interesting. Go make it. If finding aliens would have some philosophical value to you, go look for them. But to think that they’re likely to change society seems weird.

throwawayhhakdl··on Developer salary spreadsheet compiled from tweets
A person in Nigeria isn’t a minority, unless they’re not ethnically Nigerian.
throwawayhhakdl··on Self-driving cars turned out to be harder than expected
A lot of people are incredibad at driving in snow. I would not be surprised at all if self driving cars vastly reduce the accidents attributable to snow on the road. Some of that might be due to the car deciding something is too dangerous to attempt, and frankly that seems fine to me. If your problem is “the car can’t handle x condition”, there’s really no issue so long as that’s because the car refuses to try, rather than trying and failing with non trivial probability
throwawayhhakdl··on Facebook reverses on paid influencers after Bloomberg memes
Agreed. Democracy doesn’t work when you can send different messages to different people, and pretend that your platform is specialized to each case. Big data targeting helps them do this, but even regional targeting is probably fine.

I should know if you’re telling ____ he can have X before I vote for you to represent me.

That being said, so many people are adverse to critical thinking (on both sides of the American political split) that this feels like a non issue to begin with. So whatever.

throwawayhhakdl··on Why do incompetent managers get promoted?
Often not. This is a really under looked at part of business. Sales is an excellent example. Most sales cultures are super super competitive. The natural inclination is to promote the best salespeople to be sales managers. But sales talent is a poor proxy for management talent, so you usually don’t get the best results (and your best sales people stop selling!). Resolving this is not easy, because it conflicts with people’s sense of fairness and how we think of career growth. You also need to do a lot of work if you want to figure out what a good management skill proxy is instead.
throwawayhhakdl··on The outsize influence of middle-school friends
I’m curious if any non movers would like to chime in here, because tempting as it is, I wouldn’t be surprised if this mentality was common among HN readers regardless of childhood stability.

Moving sucked, but i hadn’t until now considered it traumatic. I’ve always chalked up these feelings to being smarter than average and more self monitoring. Alternatively, being comfortable with losing relationships because I’m sure I can make new ones

throwawayhhakdl··on The outsize influence of middle-school friends
I had a male friend with a mother that did that. As a child I didn’t recognize it, but as it was explained to me in adulthood, the reason he played guitar, got quarterback lessons, and started to hang out in groups with cooler kids (or at least larger and larger groups of kids) was because his mother was orchestrating the whole thing to make him more popular.

I’m pretty sure that put enormous pressure on him and filled him with anxieties. Last I heard he dropped out of undergrad, and his sisters all look like they have eating disorders.

I wouldn’t try to touch my kid’s social status with a ten foot pole, aside from perhaps ensuring they have at least an average level of wealth relative to their peers. If anything popularity needs to be downplayed

throwawayhhakdl··on The outsize influence of middle-school friends
That’s interesting. I switched ~4 times in the first 5 grades. I’ve never really considered whether it affected me much, but have been highly self aware that I don’t really care about letting go of people. I have a vivid memory of yearbook signing in high school, and just getting tired of it, and when people wanted me to write a personalized message, I just said... eh, and declined to do so.

I wouldn’t have thought this was disruptive, but I also recall manually learning how social behaviors work in 11-12th grade and had always assumed I was just a bit of an aspie

throwawayhhakdl··on Burnoutindex.org
I like this conceptually, but I don’t think I trust it to be... a reliable opinion.

I got 1.5 / 6. Apparently this means I’m at HIGH risk, which strikes me as pretty stupid. What are other people getting?

(I am comfortable and pretty darn sure I’m not burnt out at all, answering several of these as “Never”)

throwawayhhakdl··on Facebook Dating launch blocked in Europe after it fails to show privacy workings
The harm of not allowing Facebook dating while it fails to meet privacy regulations is that people have to use alternative dating services that do meet privacy regulations.

Social harm: nothing.

The implication that any government ban is bad, because fascists, is silly. The concept that some bans have net negative consequences is fine, but there is nothing to suggest that is the case here.

throwawayhhakdl··on No person who was born blind has ever been diagnosed with schizophrenia
No that’s not correct.

I mean if we’re evaluating the claim that no blind people got schizophrenia then sure. But the claim is that blind people don’t get schizophrenia, which is different. The population for this claim is not “all the humans alive” but rather “all potential humans” (which is not possible to sample).

throwawayhhakdl··on No person who was born blind has ever been diagnosed with schizophrenia
Except we don’t have perfect information. Schizophrenia is misdiagnosed fairly frequently. I couldn’t find stats on undiagnosed schizophrenia, or schizophrenia diagnosed without visual hallucinations (which is probably the more relevant metric)
throwawayhhakdl··on Apple engineer killed in Tesla crash had previously complained about autopilot
There’s no moral problem with increasing the price when it becomes a better product.

There arguably is a moral problem selling a product with optional safety features that cost extra.

If tesla invented immortality fields within their vehicles, I have no doubt they would jack up the price, and that would be fine, because it’s now a much better car. To think otherwise would be silly.

throwawayhhakdl··on No person who was born blind has ever been diagnosed with schizophrenia
I don’t know if I believe that 3 / 10,000 people are born blind, in addition to the arithmetic errors
throwawayhhakdl··on Airbus unveils 'blended wing body' plane design after secret flight tests
I don’t think that was his point. He is saying you can neither assume that this fee is enough to offset the carbon, nor that Ryanair will spend it appropriately. Just because it says carbon offset doesn’t mean all of the carbon is offset.

If the true price were actually that low, it would be easy to solve.

throwawayhhakdl··on What does happiness at work mean?
I disagree entirely. Office politics were rampant in companies I’ve seen that had little to no advancement. Because the only way to go up was effectively at the expense of someone else leaving, or someone else not get promoted too.

Environments where your success doesn’t mean someone else loses are extremely positive.

throwawayhhakdl··on Turing-NLG: A 17B-parameter language model
1) How close do you think the technology is to answering -this- question?

Four days!

2) How long in years?

Three years!

throwawayhhakdl··on The Disneyfication of a University
I find your anecdote silly (no offense intended), but do agree with the general point. Especially in tech, you can have a drastically higher impact donating some tech time than manual labor time.
throwawayhhakdl··on The Disneyfication of a University
I’ve been on the other side of the table where these decisions are made. It’s rarely malicious. It’s more so trying to emulate companies they think of as successful. Many business leaders believe that market cap == goodness of management, and so they copy companies they know to be large. Culture is part of it. And culture can make a really positive difference, but not when it’s force fed as shown here. The part about only GW being able to do this stuff struck a painful chord with me.

The two big things that determine whether these things suck or rock is basically the amount of money the company invests into its own employees and the amount of growth opportunities. Both of those are (optional) second order effects of the company being wealthy and successful most of the time.

throwawayhhakdl··on [dead]
Society has plenty of trust functions. If you can’t rely on them, it’s not unreasonable to think that your blockchain evidence won’t help you either.

Suppose you post your finding generally, then I see it, and post it to the blockchain timestamped as my own. Then you say, “hey, I was first”. The blockchain is bad here because it’s incomplete.

If we mandate that only the blockchain can determine truth, then, if I really want to own that claim, I can hit you with a wrench until I have the private key, and now I am the owner of truth.

Trustless societies suck. We should be trying to increase social trust.

throwawayhhakdl··on When did Americans lose their British accents?
Yep. 7 years in Boston and the only time I have ever heard a “Boston” accent unironically was at Fenway Park.
throwawayhhakdl··on A moon landing in 2024? NASA says it'll happen
The problem with this approach is that you don’t get anything for the added risk. We could decide to keep trying. That is, build a rocket, put people on it, send it up, and repeat until one reaches the moon without exploding. That might get us to the moon faster, but it doesn’t improve our knowledge base much faster than carefully managed testing with carefully managed risks.

If we get to the moon while taking a big chance, that doesn’t mean we get to cross off the things that could have gone wrong, but didn’t, as solved.

throwawayhhakdl··on A moon landing in 2024? NASA says it'll happen
I don’t think that’s the right way to phrase it. Complicated things are probably written down somewhere, but it’s just not practical to assimilate the knowledge without having been involved in its creation.

The loss of this kind of thinking isn’t so much a failure of people to write documentation, but a natural consequence of things being hard.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →