HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thrw42A8N

154 karma · joined October 30, 2024

submissionscomments
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
Something that can be read 10k kilometers away from the school by people who never met the kid.
thrw42A8N··on Go and Java: Rethinking Type Safety for the Pragmatic Age
The actual point is so that the compiler can tell you that you forgot to check all possible cases. Typescript is really great for this.
thrw42A8N··on Y Combinator often backs startups that duplicate other YC companies, data shows
Yeah, back then Booking was hotels only, not people's apartments or couches.
thrw42A8N··on Cybertruck's Many Recalls
I get it's wrong in cars. But who the hell cares about games? So your game updates after a month with a fix. So what? It's not like you pay for the update.
thrw42A8N··on How to run multiple VPS on MacBook with Apple Silicon
Seems like it'd be much easier to use Docker...
thrw42A8N··on The meme-ification of the “Demon Core”
Obi Wan knew who is it. He said "It's your father's" when he handed it to him.
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
The current trend in education is to blend subjects and methods together and create cohesive interdisciplinary lessons practicing multiple skills at once. "ChatGPT lesson" is the 19th century way.
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
I know my paper was never in the national news.
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
The problem is that the school simply didn't teach them about the tool enough, and they taking something that should be just another lesson as disciplinary action.

Why do you expect children to know math only after months of tries, but understand the perils of AI after hearing one sentence regulation? That's not going to help the kids. You need to spend time practicing using the tool with them, showing them the pitfalls in practice, and only after enough time you can start rating them.

The school handed them a gun and they're Pikachu surprised a kid got shot, and now they're blaming it on the kid that had it in hands - but the school is to blame. And it's certainly not newsworthy, or where is the math exam results article?

thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
Yes, exactly right. If your tool caused you to plagiarize, it's your problem - you should've checked the output. You can't point to ChatGPT, it'd be like pointing to Word. You are the author and thus you are responsible.

Schools need to adapt. Explain why a tool is forbidden - it will improve efficiency of learning if the kids know what is the purpose. Use different more fun method to teach mind skills, and teach overcoming problems using various always evolving and changing hi-tech tools - instead of the rigid lesson/homework style of today. Teach them that change is constant and that they need to adapt. This is not something theoretical - there are state sponsored schools operating in this way where I live. It's great.

thrw42A8N··on Which power plant does my electricity come from?
Myself I'm not affected by this. It's used too much as a counter argument, it's not universally applicable - even in Germany. The price spikes were happening before the war too.
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
If that is the goal of a specific task, be explicit about that. From my personal experience, it's just what old teachers say because they can't deal with the new reality. The teachers who incorporated AI and other tech into their lessons are much more successful and better rated - by parents as well as children, and the final exams too.
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
How could it be the same if another person wrote it?

Situation A - a person uses a tool. They are the author.

Situation B - a person contracts another person. They are not the author. The other person might be using a tool, but it doesn't matter.

This is not a theoretical debate. This is how the current legal framework works, and if you expect someone to behave differently, you have to be explicit. Change the law if you want the default to be different. This is how it works now.

> This pedantry is useless. Ask any person if an essay produced by AI was written by the person writing the prompt and I think a majority will say “no”.

I'm an expert in the field. I don't need to ask mainstream people about their sci-fi influenced opinions, they don't matter to me nor to the law. This is how it works, it's not magic, it's not scifi, it's not a person, it can't be an author and thus it can't be plagiarized by the user, nor the user can violate the tool's copyright by using the output.

It's a tool that authors can use to create their works, and even if all they did is push a single button, they are the author. Compare this to me applying a filter on a blank canvas to produce an abstract art wallpaper in Photoshop - am I the author or is Photoshop? Let me tell you, don't try to steal my work. I did it, not Photoshop, that was just a tool that made it easier for me.

Same with ChatGPT - this morning I used it to write an architectural proposal. It's my proposal, there is no way I somehow "plagiarized" something. Doesn't matter that I pushed like 50 buttons in total; it's my work, I am the author.

--

And if schools don't actively teach children to use this technology, they should be reformed. If this school was in my city, I'd vote for the party that will cancel it - for the extremely serious offense of letting the children think it's wrong to use tools. At least they should explain that the goal is elsewhere and why a particular tool shouldn't be used for that task. It's not like children will just know, you know.

This is just like when teachers at my own school told us that Wikipedia is a bad source and we can't use it because it can't be trusted. That's total bullshit, just be honest - this assignment is supposed to test your writing skills, not tool usage skills.

thrw42A8N··on Which power plant does my electricity come from?
Gas is expensive because stable demand has been replaced by spikes based on renewable availability. I don't have any opportunity to get any renewable power - it's cold and there's no space for grid scale wind or solar.
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
How come they're not my words? I thought of sending them, not the keyboard. Same with ChatGPT, it doesn't do anything on its own - even if it could, it's a tool, not a person.
thrw42A8N··on Which power plant does my electricity come from?
This is how the energy grid operates everywhere, it's not some uniquely German mistake. Renewables require an incredibly huge grid investment - it's the same story they keep telling about external costs, only this time they don't want to hear it. I don't want to subsidize others' cheaper energy, I don't have any place to put my panels and batteries, I was happy with how it was before. But they would do anything to avoid the fees when they can.
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
Textbook has an author that you can copy. You can't copy output of an auto suggest, it's just yours.
thrw42A8N··on Elon Musk Highlights Boring Company's TBM Innovations
It's still the best, nobody used the time to outcompete them.
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
ChatGPT is not someone. It's a tool.
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
What if I first asked ChatGPT what should I say? And what's the difference from just copy pasting it?
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
Is what I wrote here mine or not? I used the autocorrect suggestions almost exclusively, wrote few letters only.
thrw42A8N··on Fusion power is getting closer
My city has a steam/hot water distribution network. No need to convert to electricity for quite a lot of residential energy usage.
thrw42A8N··on Straightforward steps to get the first paying customers for your SaaS
How to substitute lack of industry experience?
thrw42A8N··on School did nothing wrong when it punished student for using AI, court rules
What is unauthorized use of technology? Is the light I need to read not technology? Is using the internet to find more about a topic not technology? Where is the line that makes AI forbidden?
thrw42A8N··on Fusion power is getting closer
Yes, incredible idea. I really hope it works out.
thrw42A8N··on Fusion power is getting closer
Steam.

The actual problem is reaction vessel wall ablation.

thrw42A8N··on Dear sir, you have built a compiler (2022)
It's really not much. We use it to the full with code splitting and preloading, but it's not much. Not bundling is still not possible.
thrw42A8N··on 'Thirsty' ChatGPT uses four times more water than previously thought
Which makes you seem insincere.
thrw42A8N··on 'Thirsty' ChatGPT uses four times more water than previously thought
I am. That's amortized over millions of users and billions of invocations.

But who cares? I'd gladly pay for something to do in minutes what would've taken me hours. It doesn't need to be as efficient as my body in the same time frame.

thrw42A8N··on 'Thirsty' ChatGPT uses four times more water than previously thought
I really am not. I just drank 1 liter of water. ChatGPT consumed several orders of magnitude less doing much more than me. I also just heated up my meal, with meat and fries. ChatGPT didn't need that. All of that while walking around my apartment full of various "useless" stuff. ChatGPT doesn't care.
← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →