HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thu2111

811 karma · joined November 14, 2019

submissionscomments
thu2111··on Rethinking the computer ‘desktop’ as a concept
On mobile there are ways to force quit apps. They just aren't front and centre, nor mandatory for users to understand, like it is on the desktop.

Too many apps abusing resources and affecting UI speed is a separate issue, and mobile OS's developed a lot of techniques and technologies to allow apps to work in the background without bothering the user, and without overloading the device's resources. It's a nice set of systems, really, and I would be happy if desktops worked the same way. Nobody would be taking force quit away from me, even if such a system were to be implemented.

thu2111··on What Oxford taught me about posh people
The book you cite doesn't seem to support your argument.

Firstly, you say they nationalized many industries but the book talks about individual companies. Nationalizing an industry means nationalizing every company within that industry.

Secondly, this does not appear to have been motivated by the failure of capitalism but rather the opposite. It was done in response to union strikes. Unions are usually understood as being against capitalism and free markets; they want to replace individuals "voting with their wallet" by collectively taking control from management via committees of (frequently communist leaning or outright communist) representatives of the workers.

Thirdly, it says quite clearly that as late as 1943 the War Department had done so few of these seizures that it amounted to "barely a dozen". By the end of the war they had seized around 60. That's a drop in the ocean of the US economy, which is why it's not well known.

So this example doesn't really seem to argue against the notion that the US won because of free market capitalism. The only places where they had to step in and become authoritarian (very briefly) were places where capitalism was breaking down thanks to communist agitation.

thu2111··on Rethinking the computer ‘desktop’ as a concept
Yeah but the semantic difference between "hide" and "quit" is a very technical one that doesn't need to exist. On mobile it doesn't happen, and we can thank Android for that, as they insisted from day one that multi-tasking APIs should not require the user to manually manage memory on the device. When Apple added multi-tasking to iOS later they copied the Android design more or less exactly. Browsers do something similar for browser tabs now.

However this was never brought to the desktop, largely because native desktop APIs are dead and none of the companies that fund them are interested in improving them. We get the web and if it sucks, well too bad.

thu2111··on Rethinking the computer ‘desktop’ as a concept
Yes, filesystem sync protocols like rsync do it at the FS level and if you want to go deeper than the FS level, you get into the realm of operational transform and other rather complex algorithms.

A very insightful comment up thread observes that filesystem-centric computing worked for as long as collaboration was very limited. Once apps needed to move beyond that to collaboration at a finer grained level it fell apart and apps started needing databases, and in particular, databases that could link data from different users together, implying a shared privacy domain.

Was this change inevitable? The long since exiled and forgotten Hans Reiser wrote about this problem a lot back in the day (he murdered his wife and obviously his ideas lost any traction at that point). His thesis predated a lot of the concerns about privacy and central control that we see today, but briefly, he argued a part of why this was happening was that filesystem technology was not good enough because it couldn't handle very small files and because POSIX had some unnecessary limitations. Due to this lack, apps were constantly forced to invent filesystem-within-a-file formats, e.g. OLE2 and OpenDoc were both centred around this concept, SQLite obviously is one too, ZIP yes, but really most file formats can be viewed as a collection of small files within a file.

The idea was, if you upgrade filesystem tech, you can radically change how apps are written.

The problem is that operating system tech on servers and desktops has been stagnant for years. Microsoft and Apple lost interest in their primary operating systems and the open source world has never really been interested in going beyond 1970s design ideas, largely because cloning and adding small elaborations to commercial designs is the way the community stays unified. Look at the mass hysteria that followed systemd, which is one of the only upgrades to the core UNIX OS design patterns in decades. Actually making changes to the core of POSIX isn't something that's going to come out of that community. It'll probably take some company that wants to innovate on the core ideas again.

thu2111··on Rethinking the computer ‘desktop’ as a concept
Ah, so this takes us into the question of what "native" means.

Some people use the word native to mean "the way apps were written in the 90s and on Apple platforms, still are written". It's short hand for manual memory management, full commitment to the operating system vendor's APIs, and so on.

Apps written that way have some big advantages for end users - consistency, low memory usage, and so on. But they suck for developers. Manual memory management sucks, having your app market share be limited to the operating system's market share sucks, often the vendor APIs suck.

Some people use the word "native" just to mean "uses the operating system specific APIs". The other aspects like being written in an AOT compiled manually memory managed language don't count. For those people Android apps written in Kotlin running on a JVM are native, but the other people, not so much.

thu2111··on In Mexico, cartels are hunting down police at their homes
I said decriminalized, rather than legalized.

I was thinking of Switzerland and Spitzplatz in the 1980s:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platzspitz_park

thu2111··on Improving ventilation will help curb SARS-CoV-2
For what it's worth, I agree with you w.r.t. tech firms. We can observe the unsatisfactory nature of their practices without concluding regulation is the answer.

As for the WHO, I wish I could simply ignore them as easily as I ignore what Facebook do. Facebook's power is limited to doing stuff on their platforms, more or less, and whoever they can influence via that. The WHO directly commands national governments who then command the rest of us. Dysfunction at that level filters down to the whole world.

thu2111··on Cloud Atlas 'astonishingly different' in US and UK editions, study finds (2016)
The most surprising thing about this is that academics write research papers on Cloud Atlas. Is that really a good use of research money?
thu2111··on Improving ventilation will help curb SARS-CoV-2
The CDC isn't run by doctors, it's run by public health officials. Very different.
thu2111··on Improving ventilation will help curb SARS-CoV-2
No, pretty much anything was banned or throttled including professors sharing graphs of data, or people re-sharing articles critical of the WHO or the COVID response. And it's still happening, by the way. That's not in the past.
thu2111··on Improving ventilation will help curb SARS-CoV-2
Not for lack of trying however. Bear in mind the big tech companies all adopted an explicit policy of, "information that disagrees with the WHO is forbidden" and proceeded to ban lots of qualified commentators for trying to present non WHO approved information. They did this with the full approval and encouragement of the WHO itself.

I'm slightly disturbed by the casualness of this thread actually. The WHO is not merely some random organisation, one of many providing information in an open environment. It commands the loyalty of many powerful people who just automatically assume it is correct, and as such has proven basically unkillable. Trump realised it was corrupted and tried to defund it, that lasted right up until Biden rolled everything back. Other countries have also been defunding it which is why the Gates Foundation is now such a large donor. How should society handle an organisation that is so clearly inadequate and even dangerous yet which commands blind adherence from the richest and most powerful people in the world, people who can and do seriously interfere with the flow of information?

thu2111··on In Mexico, cartels are hunting down police at their homes
Nearly all of them? This problem is not caused by some weird, out of line policy of the USA. Basically nowhere wants hard drugs on the streets. And some places that experimented with legalisation rolled it back or changed their approach. Where I live there are still quite a few places with junkie lights, remnants of a hands off approach some decades ago. It led to a central public park becoming completely taken over and turned into a shanty town by addicts. Eventually the approach changed to one of less tolerance, the addicts were moved into rehab or died, and the shanty town was forcibly cleared by police.

I see people on this thread acting as if Mexico's inability to control cartels is a problem exclusively created by America. But those cartels exist elsewhere and America is not the only market for illegal drugs. The issue is wider than that.

thu2111··on Molecular biology clues portray SARS-CoV-2 as a lab manipulation of RaTG13
It seems that the most common response to arguments in favour of a lab leak is always to attack the messenger. First "It's Trump so don't listen to him", then "Nicholas Wade is a racist so don't read him" and now "Ariel Fernandez is only writing a letter and someone anonymously complained about one of his papers once but they were never told what the complaint was actually about and the generic expressions of concerns never went anywhere". That's weak sauce.

I think most of us don't care who he is, only whether what they say is true. The claims in this article aren't actually new anyway, it was all covered in Wade's article already. So if it's wrong, let's hear why. That would certainly be interesting.

thu2111··on Molecular biology clues portray SARS-CoV-2 as a lab manipulation of RaTG13
The counterargument mounted by Wade and others is that the world has been searching for such a transmission path for the last year with far greater resources than normally allocated, as obviously, China would very much like to find such a path. However no such animal has been found. The lack of any discovery despite great effort is not itself proof, as you can't prove a negative, but it does seem suggestive.
thu2111··on What a Wuhan lab leak would mean
Given the massive levels of evidence destruction involved, that seems like quite a stretch.
thu2111··on What a Wuhan lab leak would mean
I don't think that's quite true. The grants and papers talk about what the goals were and the biosafety labels being used.
thu2111··on Y Combinator backed MMO metaverse game is a blatant scam
Sure, technology makes some things easier with time. But the needs for content to be optimized has not really gone away, and the issue was not necessarily overly complex 3D assets but that the very structure of what people wanted to build was difficult to optimize for. Many AAA games are set in indoor areas with no windows, because this limits how much you have to draw. In second life, almost everywhere the camera could see long distances either because you are outside or because you're inside in a room with windows. And that doesn't seem to have a really easy technological solution, although maybe Unreal's new nanite can do something about it by avoiding the need for custom LOD meshes.
thu2111··on Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of UFOs
Is that less sensationalist? It seems they're reporting exactly the same things just using different types of recorded data. Neither article attempts to speculate on what kind of object might be capable of causing such data, nor who might control it.
thu2111··on I quit my job to focus on SerenityOS full time
It doesn't. He says it brings in $2000/month and that this is not enough to sustain his family, but he hopes to increase it.

It's nice that he's able to indulge in this kind of hobby programming, but he must have an incredibly generous and understanding family. Clearly he can hold down programming jobs at major tech firms and could therefore give his family a much higher quality of life than $2k/month will bring, but chooses not to. Well, OK. I'd like to write an OS too, but my family has slightly higher expectations ...

thu2111··on I quit my job to focus on SerenityOS full time
Debuggers aren't quite as useful with C++ indeed. But that's a good reason to use C++ less. I diagnose issues drastically faster with a debugger all the time. Often I'll write a unit test that reveals a bug, but just looking at the code doesn't quite reveal where the bug is. But sticking a few breakpoints in the right places and examining the data structures directly makes it really obvious.

Eventually, I learned to write code that was so obviously correct and had such good error messages that I haven’t needed to use a debugger in a long time.

Nobody needs to use a debugger, just like nobody needs to use most tools. They're just very helpful when they work correctly and are used correctly.

thu2111··on Court rules climate change “duty of care” to future generations exists
European constitutions have a lot of bad stuff in them that's not thought out at all, especially around human rights. The US constitution limits itself to a very small number of matters that are (relatively) well defined, exactly to stop this kind of law making by judges. If it allows court rulings like this one then, the German constitution is not as well thought out, for the reasons well outlined above.
thu2111··on Y Combinator backed MMO metaverse game is a blatant scam
That's not necessarily the hard part. I mean, it's hard, but it's not the hard part.

We know this because what this game is trying to do is done already a long time ago. It's a description of the original vision for Second Life. In fact Second Life was explicitly an attempt to create "the metaverse", with all user-generated content. Linden Labs used to write about the challenges they faced in making that vision real so we have a good idea of where the challenges really lie, or at least did 10-15 years ago.

First problem: physics. LL sharded their world, which was indeed infinite. The problem is each shard required its own dedicated high end server, which made "land" extremely expensive. Amazingly, people bought it anyway, LL developed a small but extremely rich customer base who were willing to literally rent high end (what would be today) cloud VMs just to have a very small space to call their own online. For a brief period it was also trendy for companies to open up spaces in Second Life.

The reason land was so expensive was that physics (collision detection and movement, mostly) required the server to constantly iterate every object within the zone and the calculations scaled with number of objects. Shutting down physics when nobody was there also wasn't possible because the metaverse concept implied allowing arbitrary scripting, and scripts frequently expected the world to keep running even if nobody was there. The answer in SL to "if a tree falls and nobody is around to hear it, does it make a sound" was a resounding yes.

The second big problem they faced was that user generated 3D content was extremely un-optimized. The biggest complaint users had about SL was always performance. Eventually they gave up promising to improve it and came clean with the userbase: SL was slow and always would be because users kept making slow content. In particular SL was set mostly outdoors, and even when indoors, people loved doing things like creating semi-transparent windows. The ability for any object to change at any moment (users created content in-game) also implied they couldn't use all the "baking" techniques professional games use to optimize rendering. So the rendering algorithms had to be very primitive, and there was lots of overdraw, so SL really chugged even when drawing scenes that looked very basic compared to what high end games could do. And of course hobbyist metaverse users are not pro grade 3D artists so they tended to make a lot of ugly stuff anyway.

So syncing player data was certainly a sub-challenge, but compared to the difficulties posed by cost effective sharded physics and totally un-optimizable 3D scenes, it wasn't that big a deal.

thu2111··on Unreal Engine 5 enters Early Access
The video says that parts of the golem's armor are in fact megascans, iirc. But yes obviously some parts of it are manually modeled. I don't see why that's a problem - people have been making film quality assets for many years. The only thing that's new is it can run in real time now without a lot of work.
thu2111··on Unreal Engine 5 enters Early Access
Quixel Megascans are based on photogrammetry. So they're taking lots of photos of real world objects and generating the meshes from laser scans. They aren't built by hand.
thu2111··on Unreal Engine 5 enters Early Access
Yes but their demo is a 100GB download alone, it seems. That's just a demo. The capabilities of new hardware and engines to render worlds is massively outstripping the capabilities of distribution networks to get that data into people's homes. That's where the next challenge is. Xbox Live is already a long way from being able to deliver games quickly and it will only get worse.
thu2111··on Developers can't seem to agree on what command should get rid of a package
This is a symptom of the more general problem that CLI interfaces usually have very little attention paid to usability. It's not that developers can't agree on what command should get rid of a package, it's that they can't agree on whether a CLI is an interface meant for humans or programs. So you get completely unintuitive user interfaces that break all the time and never DWIM, and user guides so filled with explanations of all the persnickety behaviours in such a useless format, that you end up needing a separate tool (tldr) to augment them.

The tooling doesn't help. Many CLI flag parsing frameworks don't make it easy to give flags and commands aliases.

You could also view it another way: many small tools that could/should have GUIs don't, because so many developers no longer know how to do a GUI that doesn't involve running a web server.

thu2111··on Google is officially releasing Fuchsia OS, starting with a first-gen Nest Hub
I disagree, I think the state of this discussion thread is about what should be expected given what Fuchsia is and how the project is run.

Firstly, there is little technical discussion of Fuchsia here because there's actually very little to discuss. Fuchsia is, design wise, a pretty ordinary operating system differentiated from Linux mostly by using a microkernel. If you've ever looked at SEL4 then you've got the gist of what's going on here. I'm not aware of any obvious ways Zircon differs from any other microkernel design. Like all such systems it has an inter-component RPC layer (called FIDL) which if you've ever used the Android Binder will look familiar. And it's got a component system. In some ways these upper layers are reminiscent of COM and the whole OS has a bit of a Windows NT 3.1 architectural vibe. That's about all there is to say on the matter.

Fuschia is an oddly unambitious platform. Here's a representative quote from the docs:

"There is no concept of inter-package dependencies because transitive dependency closures have unbounded resolution time"

This statement is technically correct but practically incorrect: when users complain about dependency resolving package managers, they are complaining about out of date packages, broken dependency graphs, centralized repositories and other things. The fact that dependency resolution can be NP-complete in artificially constructed worst case scenarios never comes up because in the real world, dependency resolution takes a few seconds and the problems surface elsewhere. But they found an excuse to avoid doing anything hard or new in the world of software distribution, so they took it.

Elsewhere people promote its ABI stability compared to Linux. Maybe, but this is Google we're talking about. Constantly obsoleting stuff is literally built into their incentive structures, so we should double check that right?

https://fuchsia.dev/s/results?q=deprecated

120 results for deprecated already! Nobody even uses this OS yet and they already changed their mind about APIs all over the place.

The same lack of ambition is visible if we look at the Architectural Principles section of their site. Their principles are: "Secure, Updatable, Inclusive, Pragmatic". That's it. "Secure because capabilities" is a very old discussion with not much to add, and the rest is vague or just not that interesting.

Those principles brings us to the final reason the HN discussion is so lacking in technical depth.

The OP complains that the discussion here is all about politics and wonders in jest if there's a social justice forum where they might find technical discussion of the project. Amusingly the OP's wish is easily satisfied by the Fuschia website itself. Fuschia is by far and away the most ideologically biased operating system project you will have ever had the misfortune to encounter. It is something the world has never seen before, an entire operating system controlled by the hard left. Every single page in the docs has a giant banner across the top saying "Google is committed to advancing racial equity for Black communities". Note the demand for equity, not equal opportunity. Classical liberalism is dead here, tokenism is in. Of only 4 so-called architectural principles one of them is "Inclusive". They make a brave effort to pretend this is actually about technology by claiming that being just a microkernel+RPC is inclusive because they don't provide any language runtimes for the users (i.e. spinning missing features as a form of moral purity). Then it all falls apart and they go back to talking reducing harm and bias via language control - another tenet of hard left thinking.

So let's imagine we're looking for something better, fresher, bolder than Linux, macOS or Windows. We look at Fuschia. What we see is an extremely conservative OS design in which the most modern ideas in it pre-date Linux itself. We see an overwhelmingly political project, run by a company that has in the last year been systematically erasing from its platform crazy wack-jobs like, er, doctors and professors simply because they disagreed with the WHO. And we see that there's no discussion, anywhere, of any features that end users might actually care about.

That's why there's no discussion of technology in this thread.

thu2111··on Google is officially releasing Fuchsia OS, starting with a first-gen Nest Hub
- Fuchsia provides a stable binary interface (like Windows, but unlike Linux).

Does it?

Fuchsia is a brand new OS, at least from the perspective of the world. One reason my interest in it died quite early on, despite being an aficionado of new operating system designs my entire life, was finding stuff like this in the docs:

https://fuchsia.dev/fuchsia-src/development/components/v2/mi...

It's brand new and there are already migration guides for core parts of the design. Also:

https://fuchsia.dev/s/results?q=deprecated

That's a lot of deprecated stuff for a project that started with a blank slate.

thu2111··on EU bans Belarusian airlines from European skies
I used to agree. These days I don't. I find it very harsh and unsympathetic to use a strategy that can be summed up as, "we will make your life as shit as possible in the hope that despite having no access to military power you nonetheless start a civil war in which you will probably die without achieving anything, and if you don't, you just won a civil war so your whole country is destroyed and lots of people hate you for it".

If the west is serious about taking down foreign dictators it needs to man up and start assassinating them, either with hit squads or drone strikes. No pussyfooting around and hiding behind the hope that locals will get the blood on their hands so the foreign bureaucrats don't have to. And if the EU isn't willing to do that, then it should be trying to do what it can to make life better for the Belarusians, just like a doctor would try to help a sick patient even if they spent a lifetime smoking and thus in some way might have some culpability for it.

thu2111··on EU bans Belarusian airlines from European skies
That strategy has, I think, never worked in the history of dictatorships. It probably won't start working now.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →