HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thwarted

5,732 karma · joined April 9, 2008

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/thwarted; my proof: https://keybase.io/thwarted/sigs/HrX9gbY0wIe5I3aaFU27h5F7kZJBGFm9fioZpUoRJfQ ]

I can be reached at hnthwarted (&) thwartedefforts (x) org

https://github.com/thwarted

#D5B390 #274e69 #FF9933 #7a8c96 #663399

submissionscomments
thwarted··on Google changes its search box
When the default "search" results are AI, it's difficult, if not impossible, to "choose", since Google is pushing the AI so hard.
thwarted··on Making the news available at no cost is a victory
Sometimes a given presentation is called biased but it's not that the reporting is biased but that the actual event is or the source material is biased or lacking. "Dog bites man" is not biased against the dog if they don't or can't get the dog's take. And if they do get the dog's take and the dog wastes everyone's time by ranting/barking about cats and they don't print it, it's not the reporting that's biased, the dog squandered its chance to offer its perspective on the topic at hand.

Sometimes there is no "other side" or the other side offers meaningless contribution. The trend to present oneself as unbiased have often given platforms to voices that are not worthy of having a platform, for whatever reason, and someone needs to make a call, and they should be transparent about it. Are they not giving time because they choose to ignore legitimate and useful information or because giving someone a platform to rehash all the bogus reasons that the moon landing was faked again isn't worth it (to use an extreme example). Moon landing deniers can set up their own web site to push their faked moon landing agenda, they don't need to clutter up everyone else's content with their nonsense in the name of "unbiased reporting".

thwarted··on The Upper Middle Class Trap
Isn't a "centi-millionaire" someone who has $10,000? Exactly what order of magnitude of millionaire was this person?
thwarted··on Opus 4.7 knows the real Kelsey
Recognizing someone's "fist" and other patterns in their communication is part of traffic analysis.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_analysis

thwarted··on LinkedIn is scanning browser extensions
> Hundreds of job search extensions are in the scan list. LinkedIn knows which of its users are quietly looking for work before they've told their employer. … Extensions tied to political content, religious practice

Why are these even extensions to begin with? A legit job finding service can be a website, no extension required. If they are nefarious extensions that fake ad clicks or mine cryptocurrency, that they are job search, or political, or religious in name/nature only serves to get rubes to install them. This entire ecosystem is goofed up.

thwarted··on U.S. Debt Tops 100% of GDP
> To be serious, we need to talk about what cuts are to be made to SS/Medicare/Medicaid and the military. But no one wants to have that discussion

The military-industrialist complex is a socialist jobs program.

thwarted··on Drone pilot makes US rescind no-fly zones around unmarked, moving ICE vehicles
being specific is the essence of lawmaking and the whole difference between having a Congress and having a mom

~ P. J. O'Rourke, "Parliament of Whores"

thwarted··on My audio interface has SSH enabled by default
I think my favorite is wifi access points that support tftp to load a firmware image (with some kind of hardware switch to enable this state). These can be made effective unbrickable and it's really nice for experimenting.
thwarted··on 5x5 Pixel font for tiny screens
This reminded me of work to get the C64 to do 80 columns in software, using a 3x7 pixel grid (with one row and column used for spacing), some of which were part of commercial products.

https://www.pagetable.com/?p=901

> Creating a 4×8 character set that is both readable and looks good is not easy. There has to be a one-pixel gap between characters, so characters can effectively only be 3 pixels wide. For characters like “M” and “N”, this is a challenge.

thwarted··on GitHub CLI now collects pseudoanonymous telemetry
> Or you can look at the analytics, which tell you everything you need to know immediately, always up to date, with perfect precision.

Analytics do not tell you everything you need to know immediately. The analytics may say that no one is using a given feature, but they don't necessarily tell you why. Maybe they don't use it because they're not aware of it, marketing is presenting it wrong, or sales isn't selling against it. Maybe they've tried to use it and it doesn't work for them and they never tried it again. Maybe the call to action to bring them to it doesn't work or directs them wrong. Maybe it gets used by 1% of the users who happen to be power users. You might look at that 1% and conclude that it's not getting enough use to warrant supporting it or keeping it around.

thwarted··on AI-Assisted Cognition Endangers Human Development
Yes, this is why I mentioned comparative advantage.
thwarted··on AI-assisted cognition endangers human development?
The issue here is that the sister could have used ChatGPT herself, so why bother hiring the plumber. The plumber has provided less value than was expected. But make no mistake: the value the sister was looking for was to have someone else deal with it, and there's a price that the sister was willing to pay for the service of having someone else deal with it.

In the comments of this HN post, there is a dead comment from someone who posted an LLM's summary of another comment. It's dead because it offers very little/no value: that summary could be obtained directly from ChatGPT by anyone who wants a summary.

The sister offloaded plumbing to the plumber under the economic principle of comparative advantage. The plumber undermines the value they provide by outsourcing yet again. What value is provided by the middle man who does nothing but proxy the issue? Is the person who does this really a plumber? Is a plumber merely someone who has plumbing tools like wrenches and pipe tape?

That the plumber also wanted to outsource it is the concern: right now, the plumber is able to make money because of the difference between what is charged to deal with a problem and what it costs for them to deal with it. Knowledge and experience has become a commodity, which we probably can't do anything about, but along with that comes all the drawbacks (and advantages) of things, and humans, being comoditized.

thwarted··on We've raised $17M to build what comes after Git
"Where are we? Are we where we wanted to be?"

"I'm not sure. But at least we got here fast."

thwarted··on We've raised $17M to build what comes after Git
> or whatever GitHub and the like are called

GitHub is a social networking site that just so happens to have code hosting related features.

thwarted··on Slightly safer vibecoding by adopting old hacker habits
Oh, a separate GitHub account that has its own forks of the repos the agent is working on. Yeah, that's probably the most secure, isolated, and safest. The merge to the canonical repo then needs to go through a human, or at least separately controlled, process via a GitHub pull request.
thwarted··on Slightly safer vibecoding by adopting old hacker habits
Generally a good idea, but I'm not sure why you should even want to fork a git repo when a local clone should be sufficient. But this is probably a terminology mixup from the way github presents forks and clones.
thwarted··on The cult of vibe coding is dogfooding run amok
> WiB is different from Move Fast and Break Things and again different from YAGNI though.

Yes, which is why I listed all three.

It's not about if the vibe coding results in any of these strictly, it's that the vibe coder can claim that the low quality doesn't matter and cite any of these as support for why the low quality doesn't matter.

thwarted··on The cult of vibe coding is dogfooding run amok
> It shows that you can build a crazy popular & successful product while violating all the traditional rules about “good” code.

We already knew that. This is a matter of people who didn't know that or didn't want to acknowledge that thinking they now have proof that it doesn't matter for creating a crazy popular & successful product, as if it's a gotcha on those who advocate for good practices. When your goal is to create something successful that you can cash out, good practices and quality are/were never a concern. This is the basis for YAGNI, move-fast-and-break-things, and worse-is-better. We've know this since at least betamax-vs-VHS (although maybe the WiB VHS cultural knowledge is forgotten these days).

thwarted··on Claude wrote a full FreeBSD remote kernel RCE with root shell
> can we demon strait somehow a unpriv non root user

"demon strait". Was this speech to text? That might explain the punctuation and grammar.

thwarted··on AI overly affirms users asking for personal advice
The upvotes ultimately train the bots, reenforcing the content posted. Even the most passive form of interaction has been co-opted for AI.
thwarted··on Moving from GitHub to Codeberg, for lazy people
If you have ssh access to the remote machine to set up a git remote, you can login to the remote machine and commit the changes that you forgot to commit.
thwarted··on GitHub appears to be struggling with measly three nines availability
Charging for self-hosted runners is like a corkage fee but you still need to open the bottle yourself.
thwarted··on Ask HN: AI productivity gains – do you fire devs or build better products?
> it happens when they give Claude too much autonomy. It works better when you tell it what to do, rather than letting it decide. That can be at a pretty high level, though. Basically reduce the problem to a set of well-established subproblems that it’s familiar with. Same as you’d do with a junior developer, really.

Equating "junior developers" and "coding LLMs" is pretty lame. You handhold a junior developers so, eventually, you don't have to handhold anymore. The junior developer is expected to learn enough, and be trusted enough, to operate more autonomously. "Junior developers" don't exist solely to do your bidding. It may be valuable to recognize similarities between a first junior developer interaction and a first LLM interaction, but when every LLM interaction requires it to be handheld, the value of the iterative nature of having a junior developer work along side you is not at all equivalent.

thwarted··on A rogue AI led to a serious security incident at Meta
This feels like a rediscovering/rewording of Kernighan's Law:

"Debugging is twice as hard as writing the code in the first place. Therefore, if you write the code as cleverly as possible, you are, by definition, not smart enough to debug it." ~ Brian Kernighan

thwarted··on Have a fucking website
> I tried to teach her to code a few months back and it was hilarious. We started with "First download VS Code". We never made it to another step.

This has been a serious regression in the industry for a while: popular operating systems (I'm looking at you, Windows) don't encourage and are not set up for their users to program or even do the bare minimum of random automation unless it's embedded in an application and meant for automating just that application (excel macros).

You are encouraged and directed to install and use "apps" which are either a one-size-fits-all lowest common denominator or a tries-do-everything dog's breakfast frustration.

The Commodore 64 turned on instantly and said "READY." and effectively gave you a blank canvas to poke (no pun intended) at. It was BASIC, but it was a real (if simple and limited) programming language and you could get immediate feedback and satisfaction from playing with it to learn what it could do. The syntax of BASIC is simple, the stdlib is comprehensive and unopinionated. There was nothing to download to get started to try to get that initial dopamine hit and to start to realize the true power of what computers can do and what you could make them do.

If you want a better chance at getting someone excited about programming, there are much better places to start than VSCode. pico8, scratch, even the browser's developer toolbar is more accessible than VSCode.

thwarted··on Have a fucking website
I read comments such as:

>> I don't get it. LLMs are supposed to have 100% bridged this gap from "normie" to "DIY website." What's missing?

as less sincere and more facetious, calling out that every single "AI" company is massively overhyping their capabilities and use-cases. You did the same thing in a more detailed fashion, enumerating all the constraints that AI can't address, and others that speak to the reasons that small businesses don't have websites independently of the tooling/services that are ostensibly able too make it easier or remove barriers.

thwarted··on //go:fix inline and the source-level inliner
I'm no longer sure what you're saying. You asked why they didn't go with dedicated syntax, I listed two advantageous aspects of the chosen syntax. We know it's an overloaded comment: that's literally one of the advantages.
thwarted··on //go:fix inline and the source-level inliner
//go:xyz is dedicated syntax that is compatible with both the language spec and other toolchains that don't know about it.
thwarted··on Willingness to look stupid
Popularity and reputation are not the exact same thing. Reputation is about trust and predictability, while popularity is about awareness of the person and/or their reputation.

But your points largely stands. However, reputation is one of many tools that can be used to assess the worthiness of giving some work attention, but should be given a relatively low weight compared to other tools. Giving reputation a low, but non-zero weight allows bad actors to be rightfully put in their place and allows someone the ability and chance to "clean up" their reputation with effort.

thwarted··on Dijkstra's Crisis: The End of Algol and Beginning of Software Engineering (2010) [pdf]
This is such a common position in just about every professional industry, codified legally or as personal belief, that it barely qualifies to be called out as unique to Dijkstra.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →