HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thwarted

5,732 karma · joined April 9, 2008

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/thwarted; my proof: https://keybase.io/thwarted/sigs/HrX9gbY0wIe5I3aaFU27h5F7kZJBGFm9fioZpUoRJfQ ]

I can be reached at hnthwarted (&) thwartedefforts (x) org

https://github.com/thwarted

#D5B390 #274e69 #FF9933 #7a8c96 #663399

submissionscomments
thwarted··on A free and open-source rootkit for Linux
LD_PRELOAD has nothing to do with the kernel, it's entirely resolved in user space; in this context, it would be used to replace libc functions.

> I think I would literally recompile libc to patch fopen/open/openat

That's literally the functionality that LD_PRELOAD provides without having to recompile libc.

thwarted··on Command-line Tools can be 235x Faster than your Hadoop Cluster (2014)
The most interesting part is that you can say you're doing/using something entirely independent of if you actually are. Sure, that's a lie, but so is only using something so you can say you're using it (sure, they admitted to you that was the reason, but that won't be the reason they put on LinkedIn).
thwarted··on Emoji Use in the Electronic Health Record is Increasing
> You're a grad student who's been reading page after page after page after page after page after page after page after page after page after page of lack and white text.

What an interesting way to describe reading a book. It's amazing that anyone can read an entire book, composed of hundreds of pages, without getting bored of the black text.

thwarted··on Dell admits consumers don't care about AI PCs
Is there a way to tell if people are seeking out the same video or or if they are watch it because it was suggested? Especially when 90% of the recommendations are repeats?

There isn't even an "I've watched this" or "don't suggest this video anymore" option. You can only say "I'm not interested" which I don't want to do because it will seems like it will downrank the entire channel.

Even if that is the case, I rarely watch the same video, so the recommendation engine should be able to pick that up.

thwarted··on Dell admits consumers don't care about AI PCs
YouTube could use AI to not recommend videos I've already watched, which is apparently a really hard problem.
thwarted··on Show HN: One clean, developer-focused page for every Unicode symbol
It's odd that searching for "section" finds U+2E39 (Top Half Section Sign) but not U+00A7 (Section Sign).

The directions for input on on each operating system are all the same, use an app? On Windows there's a key sequence based on the codepoint integer. It should tell you exactly what to type. The Linux one is especially odd "Use the Character Map app or a Compose key sequence, then paste into your app" because if there's a compose key sequence you don't need to paste it.

thwarted··on How did DOGE disrupt so much while saving so little?
My understanding of what you say is true, and NASA is a common example of high value cultural and economic outcomes for the pittance the US government budgets/allocates for it.

O'Rourke's take is an interesting read; it is commentary that is meant to be more humorous and entertaining than political, I think he excelled at that in the entirety of Parliament of Whores. It was published in 1991 in a different political climate. He does admit he's doing this for fun, that the takes he express are mostly uninformed about the nature of many of these government departments and programs, and takes a (traditional) conservative (high level, and ahem, naive) view of many government programs. For example, additional quotes from that PoW chapter:

> Training and employment is properly the concern of trainees and employers: $5.7 billion.

> Insurance companies should gladly pay for consumer and occupational health and safety: $1.5 billion.

> If unemployment insurance is really insurance, it ought to at least break even: $18.6 billion.

I shared this for the Circumcision Precept bit; the portions of the quote surrounding that were context.

thwarted··on How did DOGE disrupt so much while saving so little?
PJ O'Rourke had a line in his book "Parliament of Whores" when he, as a layman, ham-fistedly cuts a bunch of stuff from the federal budget, and then just subtracts 10% from it at the end. Probably not the originator, but a quote I think about often.

"Add it all together, and I've cut $282.8 billion, leaving a federal budget of $950.5 billion, to which I apply O'Rourke's Circumcision Precept: You can take 10 percent off the top of anything. This gives me another $95 billion in cuts for a grand total of $337.8 billion in budget liposuction."

Parliament of Whores, page 103.

thwarted··on Fabrice Bellard Releases MicroQuickJS
Except when it doesn't because of browser or platform differences/incompatibilities.
thwarted··on Indoor tanning makes youthful skin much older on a genetic level
A Google search for vitamin d results in ads, ahem "sponsored results", for 180 servings for $27, which is about $55 for a full year assuming it's one serving per day, which is the same decimal order of magnitude as $10 (but, I suppose, since we are on HN, is three or four orders of magnitude in binary)
thwarted··on Show HN: WalletWallet – create Apple passes from anything
> It won't scan cards with AI - you manually enter the barcode, which I think makes it less prone to error.

This is a very interesting sentence.

I interpret this sentence as saying that manually entering a barcode is less error prone than letting AI do it, that AI would have an unacceptable margin of error (and this is probably an accurate assessment).

But you don't need AI to find or read barcodes. Finding and reading barcodes is a reasonably mature technology that has existed long before AI.

Barcodes exist as a fast, machine readable data transfer format meant to avoid data entry errors by avoiding manual data entry, and yet you've implemented manual entry in order to avoid errors?

Now, if one of the constraints you've put on your implementation is that it work only in the browser and you don't want to have to download a large barcode scanning library to the browser, then it makes sense to implement manual entry. But that has nothing to do with AI.

That being said, there are some barcode reading apps that can be used to prompt for a scan from a web page, and you get the barcode payload back. I've used an app called "bineye" on Android (source on GitHub) that works like this. This helps avoid error prone manual entry and gets the full barcode payload (many barcodes store/encode more information than the human readable text printed next to them).

thwarted··on Capsudo: Rethinking sudo with object capabilities
What's missing in this writeup is if/how capsudod can be configured to drop/acquire capabilities (in the capabilities(7) sense, in a namespace sense, or using openbsd's pledge(2)) before executing the command. From looking at the code it seems to rely on filesystem permissions to access the capsudod socket; when in order to make mounting USB drives actually safe via this kind of permission proxying method, you'd want to only give it very limited access to operations, like only the ability to make the mount(2) syscall. I generally agree, this is sudo in a different format and with a daemon; perhaps that's better. And it's written in C, which doesn't speak to avoiding the classic C-related privilege escalation risks (although this is a small amount of code compared to sudo).
thwarted··on Most technical problems are people problems
And there's another group, grifters, who are neither living to work nor working to live. They are the parasites, and our current society rewards grifters by not putting them in check. Probably because so many want a piece of the grifting pie, in the same way many people see themselves as temporarily embarrassed millionaires.
thwarted··on CSS now has an if() conditional function
You need conditionals and loops. Recursion counts as looping.
thwarted··on Most technical problems are people problems
> Or you have a leader above who has no idea and goes with the quickest/cheapest option.

This leader is not going with the quickest or cheapest option. Doing so would probably be laudable. They are going with the claims made by someone that a certain way is going to be quicker or cheaper. It doesn't matter if it actually is, or ends up being, quicker or cheaper. One plan is classified as meeting the requirements while another plan is classified as being cheaper, the cheaper one will be chosen even though it doesn't meet the requirements.

thwarted··on CSS now has an if() conditional function
We can blame von Neumann (et al) and his infernal architecture, where memory stores both instructions and data.
thwarted··on I ignore the spotlight as a staff engineer
Sometimes achievements speak for themselves and provide the marketing for the actor. But that requires both the achievement to be extremely outsized, so as not to get lost in the noise, and very obviously the result of a singular actor. Only one person can step up to the plate and swing the bat.
thwarted··on AI has a deep understanding of how this code works
> When I open a PR without discussing it at all beforehand with anyone, I expect the default to be that it gets rejected.

TNG S2E8, "A Matter Of Honor" is about this topic. The submitter introduced risk on the maintainers (the risk being here largely eating up the maintainers time needlessly) by working in isolation and only presenting the finished work without any feedback or awareness from the rest of the participants.

thwarted··on 10 years of writing a blog nobody reads
The compose key on Linux makes deliberate use much easier (rather than automatic replacement which often triggers when I don't want it). There's a compose key utility for Windows, but has some minor annoyances like many input (mouse or keyboard) macro extender applications.
thwarted··on 10 years of writing a blog nobody reads
Emdashes are useful for an embedded appositive phrase, which a colon can't handle the same way.
thwarted··on A Remarkable Assertion from A16Z
That's almost more damning. The list was created by humans, who presumably read the books, but then couldn't be bothered to summarize the very books they read? Either the human is really lazy ("read" the book but can't be bothered to write a short summary) or really really lazy (didn't read the book but felt a summary was necessary). Either way, it makes this list less interesting, at the very least because it doesn't need to exist at all if someone can just ask an LLM "list and describe books that A16Z might think are valuable to read" and get the same quality output.
thwarted··on I don't care how well your "AI" works
"Automating agency" it's such a good way to describe what's happening. In the context of your last paragraph, if they succeed in creating AGI, they won't be able to exercise control over a robot army, because the robot army will have as much agency as humans do. So they will have created the very situation they currently find themselves in. Sans an economy.
thwarted··on WorldGen – Text to Immersive 3D Worlds
> they never go into buildings, the buildings all have similar size, the towns have similar layouts, there’s numerous visual inconsistencies, and the towns don’t really make sense

These AI generated towns sure do seem to have strict building and civic codes. Everything on a grid, height limits, equal spacing between all buildings. The local historical society really has a tight grip on neighborhood character.

From the article:

> It would also be sound, with different areas connected in such a way to allow characters to roam freely without getting stuck.

Very unrealistic.

One of the interesting things about mostly-open world game environments, like GTA or Cyberpunk, is the "designed" messiness and the limits that result in dead ends. You poke at someplace and end up at a locked door (a texture that looks like a door but you can't interact with) that says there's absolutely nothing interesting beyond where you're at. No chance to get stuck in a dead end is boring; when every path leads to something interesting, there's no "exploration".

thwarted··on CoMaps emerges as an Organic Maps fork
Presumably, "design" here is referring to the visual, graphic design.

> It is pretty interesting because it is true that design is better solo'd than committee'd.

This applies to all manner of "design", especially when it's at the edge/interface, which includes humans interfacing with a tool, but also with interfaces such as APIs. It's hard to maintain consistency and coherency and vision in the design of anything when it's committee'd and/or a free-for-all.

thwarted··on IBM Patented Euler's 200 Year Old Math Technique for 'AI Interpretability'
> IBM Slapped the Buzzwords 'AI Interpretability' on Generalized Continued Fractions and their Series Transformations and was awarded a Patent

A good portion of the perception and use around patents is the word "awarded", which implies that there was some evaluation, either objective or subjective, by an expert in the topic and that the invention met some high level of… something that made it worthy of being "awarded" for the "work" that it took to invent. Most parents are not evaluated like that today, and software patents specifically probably never have been.

thwarted··on End of Japanese community
What is the logic behind adding machine translation for content that already had a seemingly robust, enthusiastic, and motivated (volunteer?) community maintaining the translations? The "saves money" rationale to deploy LLM/MT automation doesn't make sense when its volunteers are contributing because they want to. This is kind of community and participation destruction wrought by the introduction of LLMs/MT has a serious impact because it undermines the people who are actually willing to do the work. It was presumably costing nothing (or very little) to have the community maintain this content, but the change has cost a significant amount of goodwill. If the Japanese SUMO community wanted to use MT, it should be their sole decision, baring any issues with their stewardship in general. This is someone else saying "look, with this great new automation, you don't need to spend time anymore doing «thing you want to do»". Huh? How does that make any sense to force on anyone?
thwarted··on Ask HN: My family business runs on a 1993-era text-based-UI (TUI). Anybody else?
Acquiring the skill to fly through such interfaces is equivalent to learning to play a musical instrument, where the desired attention (taking cues) and action (body/finger movement) becomes second nature. Such skill and interfaces are, unfortunately, not viewed as similarly valued as playing a musical instrument, and such visual presentation of the TUI is thought to be "difficult" to use, and they do take learning and effort to achieve that level of mastery. Meanwhile, the interface to traditional musical instruments, while there's been some changes and improvements, have stood the test of time and remain attractive to a lot people who want to make music. Many of the claimed "improvements" that GUI interfaces have over TUIs look in some cases, to me, like busy box toys created for toddlers (this is how I feel about the Windows Ribbon menu widgets). Once something becomes second nature, it's not "I'm putting my fingers in this position" it is "I want to play an A after this series of other notes".
thwarted··on Dating: A mysterious constellation of facts
Money (or access to money) is often a proxy for a certain kind of stability and access to leisure, two things that many people strive for.

But the joke wasn't about long term, successful relationships. The guy was interested in looking attractive. That could have any kind of relationship goal, from one night stands to marriage, or even meeting someone who could introduce them to even more people.

thwarted··on You already have a Git server
Exactly, it doesn't make sense other than that folks don't actually know how to do even the most basic thing with git (git init).
thwarted··on You already have a Git server
It doesn't matter. They are centralized on servers that are ssh accessible, creating it is effectively mkdir and git init.

It's not about how long the action takes, it's about how much the team responsible for that is loaded and can prioritize things. Every team needs more round tuits. Anyone who works in an IT support role knows this. The point is that they can self-service immediately and there is no actual dependency to start writing code and using revision control, but people will trot out any excuse.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →