HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

thwarted

5,732 karma · joined April 9, 2008

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/thwarted; my proof: https://keybase.io/thwarted/sigs/HrX9gbY0wIe5I3aaFU27h5F7kZJBGFm9fioZpUoRJfQ ]

I can be reached at hnthwarted (&) thwartedefforts (x) org

https://github.com/thwarted

#D5B390 #274e69 #FF9933 #7a8c96 #663399

submissionscomments
thwarted··on You already have a Git server
Not even "offline", just "using git".
thwarted··on You already have a Git server
They don't have a reason. There's no policy that keeps them from doing this. Sure, the whole point is to ultimately have the code in a common place where backups and code review can happen, but if it's a matter of starting something sooner because it takes a few days for the request to flow through to get things set up, they are not constrained by that AT ALL. They can create a git repo with git init immediately, start working, and once the repo is set up in the common area, git push all their work into it. Rather than train people on this, we spend time trying to hasten the common area repo setup time and put additional unneeded burden on the team responsible for that.
thwarted··on You already have a Git server
Yes. I've been subject to claims that a single person can't start a project unless and until an official, centralized repo is setup for them. I've responded with "git init is all that is necessary to get started", but they wouldn't hear it.
thwarted··on Neural audio codecs: how to get audio into LLMs
No, I'm saying that it is more meaningful to use what is directly derived rather than what is an indirect assumption. There is already issues with people erroneously considering whatever LLMs output as truth, the last thing anyone needs is an LLM claiming someone like Idris Elba is a white Briton because of his accent. We don't need automated phrenology machines, and that's what "determined your race from your voice" is pretty close to.
thwarted··on Neural audio codecs: how to get audio into LLMs
If it did, it responded based on the accent it picked up on not race, because race and accent are orthogonal, correlation does not imply causation.
thwarted··on The scariest "user support" email I've received
Unless you're on Windows, there's one in /bin or /usr/bin, you don't even need to go find one.
thwarted··on FSF announces Librephone project
Every banking phone app I've used auto-logouts after being idle or unused for a bit, and my primary bank's app requires 2fa using an app that exists on the same device -- a second factor that secures nothing. They probably are not explicitly considering the phone more secure than a computer, but rather a good 80% of this is security theater or a checkbox on some baseline security checklist that was implemented without really understanding what the implications, for usability and security, were going to be.
thwarted··on FSF announces Librephone project
> But it does highlight the poor security of desktop browsers where they are only trusted to do anything when a phone app approves it.

Does it? The browser doesn't do anything, the person sitting at the computer where the browser is running is what performs the actions. The reauthentication and 2fa is meant to authenticate and authorize the user, not the browser.

The attack vector of someone else using your phone using an app that doesn't require (re)authentication is independent of the browser or the app itself being trusted. That your bank doesn't periodically require some kind of re-authentication for their app is a security hole, but because the device could fall into the wrong hands, not because the code/app/browser used to access it isn't trusted.

thwarted··on FSF announces Librephone project
This isn't the browser not being trusted, it's access to the device the browser runs on. Forcing logout when idle, and authenticating again, is good in general to avoid leaving something accessible when walking away from it, even if it's a home computer that is otherwise "secured".
thwarted··on CRISPR-like tools that finally can edit mitochondria DNA
This reminded me of the 1995 The Outer Limits episode "The New Breed".
thwarted··on HTTP3 Explained
Because one thing it tries to optimize for is avoiding TLS session negotiation.
thwarted··on A story about bypassing air Canada's in-flight network restrictions
The way you describe this system is exactly how I'd describe a system I worked on in the early 90s at PW (before it was PWC).
thwarted··on Instant Checkout and the Agentic Commerce Protocol
I got spam sales email yesterday touting that exact thing. Paying for product placement in conversations with chatbots, claiming it's "not an ad".
thwarted··on Everything that's wrong with Google Search in one image
I wonder how much this can end up contributing to the Kleenex-ification of a brand or a term. You search for firefox and random other browsers come up. Now browsers in general are associated with the firefox term. Of course, when it comes down to it, there isn't much difference between browsers anyway, the UI is different but they all need to work with the same websites, and people have been using specific application names in place of the type of data/work ("Excel file" being used to refer to a CSV).
thwarted··on Go has added Valgrind support
Because "constant time" here means algorithms that are O(1), rather than O(n). This isn't about wall-clock execution time, it's about avoiding the number of operations performed being based on attributes of the input.
thwarted··on Gemini in Chrome
An infinite number of people at an infinite number of computers will eventually be served the content they desire.
thwarted··on Gemini in Chrome
We're too lazy to browse now, that we need machines to do it?
thwarted··on The old SF tech scene is dead. What it's morphing into is more sinister
Oops, missed a word in the last sentence:

> Those who don't see the value are not taking risk management seriously.

thwarted··on The old SF tech scene is dead. What it's morphing into is more sinister
> 99.99% of the time security guards are just standing around not doing anything or patrolling. They’re still needed even though they technically don’t do anything because there’s no way to predict when and where a breach will occur.

Security guards, like system administrators who keep the lights on and don't directly contribute to revenue, are insurance, something you pay for that you hope you never have to use. Those who don't see the value are taking risk management seriously.

thwarted··on The old SF tech scene is dead. What it's morphing into is more sinister
The tech scene in SF and the Bay Area at large was taking its last breath in 2015. When I arrived in SF in 2007, it was, in retrospect, already on its way out. But you could still walk down Mission in SOMA and overhear people talking about Apache configuration, witness technical team meetings in Yerba Buena Gardens, or run into the same people from another company's engineering team at the rotating schedule of bespoke coffee places (if the online camera someone setup across the alley from Blue Bottle indicated it was to busy, Special Xtra was the closer alternative). In 2015, South Park was waning as a startup office Mecca. Overhearing technical discussions and interviews at coffee shops and bars was replaced with overhearing discussions about pitch decks and VC meetings.

By 2015, the industry was fully infected with finance bros drawn to "easy VC money". This when we got non-viable startups like juicero, flower delivery, or one that would pick up your mail and scan it. Companies like WeWork and Uber being tech companies because they have an "app" made everyone think all you needed was an app to be a tech company, and having an app was defacto required to get VC investment.

The trends have always been evident from the billboards you'd see in the city and along 101. They have become more homogeneous with AI content more recently, but the blockchain/Bitcoin cycle was pretty homogeneous too.

I don't know that's there more far-right. But there is less of the free-spirit hippy branding (which was riding on 60s and 70s nostalgia anyway). Mention going to Burning Man and people say "Really?" rather than "Cool". The people who got rich over a decade ago got older.

The advertising/billboards do reflect/are the zeitgeist. There are conversations about working at an AI startup or how their pitch is based on AI at the coffee shop I frequent, which is outside SOMA/FiDi (and in view of the GGB). I don't think it's more sinister, SF still feels like California, at least in terms of the coastal relaxed attitude and hope if not in terms of being a big tech draw. Thanks to COVID, coming to the Bay Area to work in tech isn't required, or expected, anymore, which makes all the narrowly focused billboards seem odd: who are they advertising to other than other AI startups?

thwarted··on Will AI be the basis of many future industrial fortunes, or a net loser?
That's an advertisement that's working, and not what I was referring to. There are a lot of ads that don't hammer anything about the brand or product into your head, either because they are not memorable, don't communicate their subject matter well, or are placed/appear where they aren't effective.
thwarted··on Will AI be the basis of many future industrial fortunes, or a net loser?
> Unfortunately, like most adverts which are memorable, I have absolutely no idea what it was selling.

A friend of mine liked to point out that if you couldn't remember what the brand was or what was being sold, then it wasn't effective advertising. It failed at the one thing it needed to do/be.

And there's a lot of ineffective advertising. Either people don't notice it or they don't remember it. Massive amounts of money are poured into creating ads and getting ad space, much of which does very little in the getting you to buy sense.

By this measure, advertising is generally very inefficient. Large input for small output. The traditional way to make this more efficient is to increase the value of the output: things like movement of digital billboards (even just rotating through a series of ads) to draw the eye and overcome lack of noticing it among miles of billboards. There's another way: decrease the cost of the input. If I can get the same output—people don't see the ads (bad placement) or people don't remember the product/brand (bad stickiness)—by not using human creatives and using genAI to make my ads, I've improved efficiency.

Unfortunately, this doesn't make advertising more effective or more efficient as an industry and does flood the market with slop, but that's not any individual's goal.

The people who are creating ads that don't work, despite getting paid, are in Bullshit Jobs (in the David Graeber sense). Replacing bullshit jobs with genAI, where the output doesn't seem to really matter anyway. It would be great if people/companies didn't commission or pay to place ads that don't work, but since they do, they might as well spend the least amount possible on creating the content. The value of the input then approaches the (low) value of the output. No one is going to remember the ad anyway, it impacts no buying decision, why bother spending to make it good?

thwarted··on If my kids excel, will they move away?
The conservative movement today is heavily influenced by religious positions.
thwarted··on ‘Overworked, underpaid’ humans train Google’s AI
Jeez, the reading comprehension in the other replies is really bad. The "Why would you…" sentence is meant to support the observation that many experts are holding out and have no need to be involved with this training, not meant to ask why people like to get paid.
thwarted··on Why our website looks like an operating system
Platform for Privacy Preferences Project (P3P) has existed for over 20 years and no one wanted to implement it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P3P

thwarted··on Nuclear: Desktop music player focused on streaming from free sources
Tragedy of the Commons Ruins Everything Around Me.
thwarted··on Andrew Ng says bottleneck in AI startups isn't coding – it's product management
> Things that used to take six engineers three months to build, "my friends and I, we'll just build on a weekend," Ng said.

There's that word "just".

There is no way Andrew Ng—Stanford professor and cofounder and former head of Google Brain who is 49 years old with a net worth of $100m and has written 200 research papers—is calling up his friends to come over and vibe code on the weekend. Does he entice them with pizza and beer? And at the end of the weekend they lean back, look at the AI's handiwork, and slap each other on the back, congratulating themselves on not taking three months to produce this thing they are going to ignore? (Or does Andrew Ng and his buddies have a new startup's worth of code every Monday for the last couple of years?)

I mean, if that was my situation I'd like to think I'd spend time coding, but herding a bunch of other millionaires to get together and think they're competing, John Henry style, with actual, dedicated engineers doing it "the old way" seems unlikely.

thwarted··on Do the simplest thing that could possibly work
> then the source of the problem is in unclean separation of concerns and tight coupling

Sometimes the problem is in the edges—the way the separate concerns interact—not in the nodes. This may arise, for example, where the need for an operation/interaction between components doesn't need to be idempotent because the need for it to be never came up.

thwarted··on Some thoughts on LLMs and software development
It's meant to contrast/correct the claim that

"LLMs produce either truth or they produce hallucinations."

Claims worded like that give the impression that if we can just reduce/eliminate the hallucinations, all that will remain will be the truth.

But that's not the case. What is the case is that all the output is the same thing, hallucination, and that some of those hallucinations just so happen to reflect reality (or expectations) so appears to embody truth.

It's like rolling a die and wanting one to come up, and when it does saying "the die knew what I wanted".

An infinite number of monkeys typing on an infinite number of typewriters will eventually produce the script for Hamlet.

That doesn't mean the monkeys know about Shakespeare, or Hamlet, or even words, or even what they are doing being chained to typewriters.

We've found a way to optimize the infinite typing monkeys to output something that passes for Hamlet much sooner than infinity.

thwarted··on Rendering a game in real time with AI
> lay out the skeleton of a game and tell an AI to do the rest, give it pointers and occasional original art to work into the system, and ship a completed playable game in days

"But, think of the indie game designer!" is getting to be quite the take.

We have a machine that produces slop and the selling point is how fast it produces it? And how more people should be using it to spend less time on creative aspects? Would the world be a better place if GRRM "finished" his most well-known work sooner rather than never?

Something about the phrase "tell an AI to do the rest, give it pointers" reminds me of "The Sorcerer's Apprentice" from Fantasia. Not in the surface level dire-warning about laziness, automation, and losing control that story is telling but in that Mickey didn't spend any time thinking about what he was doing and the Wizard's disappointment at the end.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →