9,258 karma · joined August 18, 2007
Of various creative arts, I am most familiar with music, so will use some musical examples, but I suspect this more or less applies to anything.
You could train an AI (or a person) on a bunch of Bach cantatas, and likely the trainee could start churning out similar music. More cantatas of a Bach style.
You could train an AI (or a person) on a bunch of 1980s pop music, and likely the trainee could start churning out similar music. More pop music of a 1980s style.
How likely is it, though, that you could train an AI (or a person) on music up through the 1970s, and (assume granting access to the requisite instruments) the trainee could develop the 1980s pop music sound?
Or training on all music up through the 1940s, how likely is it that the trainee could develop the Miles Davis / Gil Evans "cool jazz" subgenre?
Or for that matter, being trained on music up through circa 1900, how likely is it that the trainee could develop jazz as a whole? Or rock & roll?
I suppose in the "infinite monkeys" sort of scenario, maybe so, and, at that, AI may well have an advantage. If it just churned through all possible combinations of musical constructs, surely it would eventually develop jazz. But would this really constitute creativity? Or just randomness? Would the AI realize that it made something special in finally arriving at jazz? I don't think Miles just randomly recorded "Birth of the Cool".
Of course, it is the "more variations of the same" sort of creativity that most humans exhibit. It is rare that someone develops something significantly new, and even then, it is often multiple people playing off each other. I think one difference is, humans can realize there's something interesting down a particular path, and start trying to develop it on purpose. Can AI do that?
Perhaps what's missing is less creativity and moreso "taste"? But I think it all works together. Is creativity without taste just randomly trying things? But for an AI, you still need a human in the loop to say, "stop, that one there"? I'm not entirely convinced what AI is doing is truly "creative", but even if it mimics creativity well, it seems to me it is still lacking taste, and therein its attempt at creativity hits a wall.
I suppose it reasonable also to imagine that as soon as I hit the "add comment" button, a new AI model will come out that has mastered taste...
Otherwise, their website suggests you can specify a particular project via the memo line of a check:
It need not be all-or-nothing. I've been improving my diet for 10 years, as I started to learn more about nutrition.
Instead of a Crustable sandwich, get some turkey at the deli counter and some prepackaged whole wheat bread. Still processed, but better. Maybe after a while, move to getting bread from some whole food bakery or something. If you don't have time or money to jump all in, start taking steps.
https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-statement-boeing-airworthin...
https://www.faa.gov/other_visit/aviation_industry/designees_...
It is typical for aerospace companies to have in-house "FAA delegates" who function in the stead of direct FAA reviewers, and it looks like all that is going on here is the FAA is allowing Boeing to go back to using their own internal delegates (every other week!).
What would Claude do?
By ELIZA, are they referring to the classic ELIZA? I am not aware of anything new and current with the same name?
If the old ELIZA succeeded 23% of the time, in the context of the other numbers ... that seems ... odd.
If you have an LLM that was trained on (say) everything on the internet except for programming, and then trained it on the Python.org online documentation, would that be enough for it to start programming Python? I've not tried, but I get the impression that it needs to see lots and lots of examples first.
If tomorrow, all LLMs ceased to exist, humans would carry on just fine, and likely build LLMs all over again, next time even better.
I wonder how much better humans would be at generating code given the same abundance of clearly-written design documentation?
But I've wondered the same thing. On some level, the coding superpowers allegedly wrought by LLMs seem reminiscent of proficient use of macros. But most programmers don't use them, and most programming languages don't support them.
Sure it exists. Not everywhere, not for all software, but it does exist.
I imagine there's a big difference in using AI for building, say, an online forum vs. building a flight control system, both in terms of what the AI theoretically can do, and in terms of what we maybe should or should not be letting the AI do.
I can understand becoming reliant on a technology -- I expect most programmers today would be pretty lost with punch cards or line editors -- but LLM coding seems too new for true reliance to have formed yet...?
I am bemused / irked / saddened by the state of nutritional science research. I am convinced that the classic "food pyramid" that was pushed for years was a bad idea, but now guidance on what to eat seems to have split into various warring factions.
Some say that we should severely limit or even avoid meat. Their words look correct on the surface, but I notice their science seems based on "meat" pretty generically. There doesn't seem to be any accounting for eating high end grass fed beef from an organic market vs. low-end beef from a gas station. Does it really make no difference?
Another faction recommends eating meat freely, with no distinction as to type or quality. Another insists on the highest grade meat but then also discourages dairy. Another recommends high quality meat and no vegetables.
I would think that it would be, by now, more straightforward to determine what really makes most sense to eat. I guess (nearly?) everyone seems to agree that adequate water is good and too much sugar isn't.
(Not disagreeing, but most of these comments -- on both sides -- are pretty vague.)